Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
DoodleDoo37 · 05/03/2024 20:19

JessS1990 · 05/03/2024 19:55

I guess you don't want any graduate teachers.

Last time I looked Teachers started on between 23k - 29k - got paid during their training and can earn overtime in many different forms. Progression can also be achieved - becoming Head of a Department or even Head Teacher which bring greater monetary rewards. Starting salaries for Solicitors outside London are 28k and go higher depending on the practice you begin with - Barristers start on 20k in London and less than that outside London - graduate trainee accountants start at 23k also which is less than the minimum wage!!!! It's often a long hard slog to the £125k's of the world...... and those which achieve it - make many sacrifices along the way- including working through a tax change limit!

JessS1990 · 05/03/2024 19:55

DoodleDoo37 · 05/03/2024 19:54

For all the criticism of the minimum wage being so low - the UK is actually 6th highest in the world - so it's not as low as people think. And why should someone who has worked hard in school and Uni and incurred the costs I highlighted not be rewarded for that and the particular skill set they have attained. Otherwise we are in a race to the bottom - where mediocrity is the name of the game. Why should I as a solicitor wind up over 200k worse off by going to Uni (as per the example I gave earlier) - if I'm only going to earn 55k - when I can simply become a cleaner and earn 33k (also as per my example earlier) - also minimum wage usually goes up each year - private sector pay rises are not guaranteed..... or how about this - we raise the minimum wage and then the companies pass on those costs to us consumers and we face ever increasing inflation and all that goes with that - challenges for people to feed their kids - and higher interest rates so higher mortgages...... and the expense that that brings. There is no perfect solution - but at the end of the day people have to be rewarded for the efforts they have put into their education and the sacrifices they have made.... in terms of time and money.

I guess you don't want any graduate teachers.

DoodleDoo37 · 05/03/2024 19:54

JessS1990 · 05/03/2024 19:23

If the minimum wage was higher, businesses might not be able to pay as many people 125k and that would apparently be a bad thing.

For all the criticism of the minimum wage being so low - the UK is actually 6th highest in the world - so it's not as low as people think. And why should someone who has worked hard in school and Uni and incurred the costs I highlighted not be rewarded for that and the particular skill set they have attained. Otherwise we are in a race to the bottom - where mediocrity is the name of the game. Why should I as a solicitor wind up over 200k worse off by going to Uni (as per the example I gave earlier) - if I'm only going to earn 55k - when I can simply become a cleaner and earn 33k (also as per my example earlier) - also minimum wage usually goes up each year - private sector pay rises are not guaranteed..... or how about this - we raise the minimum wage and then the companies pass on those costs to us consumers and we face ever increasing inflation and all that goes with that - challenges for people to feed their kids - and higher interest rates so higher mortgages...... and the expense that that brings. There is no perfect solution - but at the end of the day people have to be rewarded for the efforts they have put into their education and the sacrifices they have made.... in terms of time and money.

JessS1990 · 05/03/2024 19:23

OldPerson · 05/03/2024 16:08

Remind me again. Why are all the tax payers wanting to support you, when you can damn well support yourself???? Welfare and benefits used to be for the needy. And if minimum wage was higher, and with universal credit, that would probably make Child Benefit payments the most stupid welfare payment of them all. Why pay benefits to someone regardless of what they can afford? It's certainly not to pay them to spend more time at home.

If the minimum wage was higher, businesses might not be able to pay as many people 125k and that would apparently be a bad thing.

Chrisaldridge · 05/03/2024 17:19

@hydriotaphia and others who are periodically suggesting this, it’s a long thread and the OP knows this. Elsewhere in the thread you will also see one of the points of controversy is that some people think this is outrageous behaviour and the OP should be maxing out her tax contributions as a public service.

BIossomtoes · 05/03/2024 16:22

NoCloudsAllowed · 05/03/2024 16:10

Arguably, means testing child benefit costs as much in administration as it would cost to just pay it to everyone.

It wouldn’t if there wasn’t the option to claim it then pay it back. The admin costs would be minimal if it was just based on taxable income.

hydriotaphia · 05/03/2024 16:16

If you can afford it, you could pay into your pension to bring your adjusted net income back under £50k. This should allow you to keep the child benefit. https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-charge

You will need to calculate how much to pay into your pension - you can add on the government's 25% uplift https://www.gov.uk/tax-on-your-private-pension/pension-tax-relief. For example if you earned £60,000 you would only need to pay in £8,001 to your pension to bring your adjusted net income to under £49,999.

High Income Child Benefit Charge

High Income Child Benefit Charge - check if you're affected, how and when to pay this tax charge, opt out and restart Child Benefit payments.

https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-charge

NoCloudsAllowed · 05/03/2024 16:10

OldPerson · 05/03/2024 16:08

Remind me again. Why are all the tax payers wanting to support you, when you can damn well support yourself???? Welfare and benefits used to be for the needy. And if minimum wage was higher, and with universal credit, that would probably make Child Benefit payments the most stupid welfare payment of them all. Why pay benefits to someone regardless of what they can afford? It's certainly not to pay them to spend more time at home.

Arguably, means testing child benefit costs as much in administration as it would cost to just pay it to everyone.

OldPerson · 05/03/2024 16:08

Remind me again. Why are all the tax payers wanting to support you, when you can damn well support yourself???? Welfare and benefits used to be for the needy. And if minimum wage was higher, and with universal credit, that would probably make Child Benefit payments the most stupid welfare payment of them all. Why pay benefits to someone regardless of what they can afford? It's certainly not to pay them to spend more time at home.

Stephjea · 05/03/2024 14:49

JessS1990 · 02/03/2024 21:35

Untrue.
The Prime Minister for example pays a lower proportion of his income in tax than teachers and nurses. Helpfully he has published that information for us all to understand the ludicrousness of the tax system.

@JessS1990 services aren't paid for in proportions. Someone paying £50k in tax is putting in more than someone paying £20k, irrespective of what proportion that is of their salary.

All the current system achieves is getting the middle and working class echelons of society fighting against eachother whilst the truly wealthy are laughing all the way to the bank.

At every step there are incentives for all to earn less as they will be "better off". What does this do? Keep everyone earning less and no-one working their way up.

The truly wealthy will be entitled to all the "freebies" because they don't fit into any salary bracket. They are generally not salaried.

Vod · 05/03/2024 14:45

cardibach · 05/03/2024 14:28

Na. Semi retired now. Teaching isn’t a doable job any more so I took my pension and do a bit of supply.

Well, I can't blame anyone for getting out of that sector! I know people who've done the same. Would've been interesting to see if you felt that way if it were actually going to apply to you though, rather than being of an age cohort who were able to take full universal child benefit for granted. The 50k threshold is hitting more teachers who are in higher leadership positions now, which I'm not sure was generally foreseen when universal CB ended in 2013. I can't be arsed trying to dig out the pay scale from back then, but obviously salaries were lower.

cardibach · 05/03/2024 14:28

Vod · 05/03/2024 11:17

Well, given that we've still failed to curb inflation and the child benefit thresholds remain frozen at 2013 rates meaning it's lower in real terms every year, perhaps you'll get chance to find out.

The stuff about who works harder is totally stupid though, I agree with you there.

Na. Semi retired now. Teaching isn’t a doable job any more so I took my pension and do a bit of supply.

DoodleDoo37 · 05/03/2024 14:05

JessS1990 · 05/03/2024 06:48

Just to keep it factually accurate. It is not possible to go to uni to study to be a lawyer.
One can study a law degree, after which one would either have to take SQE or Bar exams, which means a year or two more of studying.

Splitting hairs but I meant you go to University with the intention of becoming a lawyer / solicitor - so three years studying for your primary degree - I was only referring to 3 years as when you get a training contract you are usually paid - while you progress on your further exams - but yes from a free time perspective it does mean giving up a further two years of your life - but you are being paid at least.

Biddie191 · 05/03/2024 13:53

Apologies, not read the whole thread, so this may be a 'cancel the cheque' comment......
One thing to watch out for if you reduce your hours, is it will reduce your pension. Where I work it's not just about how much you earn, but also about the hours you work, so although I've been here 21 years, because I went part time for a few years when the children were young, I only have 17 years pensionable service, so have 'lost' 4 years. This is especially galling, as for a few years of that I was actually working full time the majority of the time but it was classed as overtime, as not on my contract (but still paid as time, not T1.5 or anything). SO when I retire, I will get less to live on.

However, if you can afford to do it, the time at home is definitely worth it - looking back one of my biggest regrets is not spending more time at home with the children when they were little.

Crikeyalmighty · 05/03/2024 13:52

@TruckerMother ah you have answered me on the EU thing

BIossomtoes · 05/03/2024 13:51

WithACatLikeTread · 05/03/2024 13:40

@BIossomtoes As much as I sympathise with the fact that you had to/have to wait longer for your state pension please bear in mind what people in their 30's might or might not get. Be grateful. Suspect I might be dead before I get mine.

Be grateful? For something I paid tax (higher rate for over 20 years) and NI for a total of nearly 50 years with the promise I’d get a pension at the end of it? That’s longer than you’ve been alive and you have the brass necked nerve to tell me to be grateful?

I don’t want (faux) sympathy. I used it as an example of how the system has done a number of different sectors of society an injustice and how, as soon as it stops affecting you personally, you stop caring about it.

Crikeyalmighty · 05/03/2024 13:50

@TruckerMother I agree about the robbing b*** bit totally- having lived in Copenhagen though for 20 months, to get a great quality of life they pay around 44% tax and there is only a very low free tax allowance too- the upside is wages are about 30% higher, good childcare is peanuts , masses of good social housing, no NI, no council tax and pensions are way higher. They do pay a small amount into a scheme that is for periods of unemployment etc .

Unless you have an EU passport or happy to go to Eire- it's not that simple to actually move now to the EU if retired- unless you keep a uk place and do the 90 days rule. Most country's require uk citizens to have either work to go to, a heftyish income and not work plus private health or a ton of cash in the bank- its variations on all of these depending where you go. A real Brexit bonus of course!!

I do disagree about child benefit- I think it should be across the board and not relevant to tax either. High earners and even middling earners pay a ton of tax, aren't claiming top ups of this that and the other, and get no other benefits whatsoever and often don't use state education either. In many country's it's an across the board benefit.

TruckerMother · 05/03/2024 13:50

Morph22010 · 05/03/2024 13:36

Plus you are no longer able to retire to the eu since brexit

I will follow my father who retired to rural Montenegro where he isnt taxed again on his pension. The cost of living there is low ie: his property tax on 4 bed with land is 69 Euro per year. Cost of living is a fraction of here. To apply for temporary residency you need buy property, start a business and have provable savings of 4K annually and can eventually apply for permanency.
It may change if they ever join the EU but all indications are that this is unlikely.

WithACatLikeTread · 05/03/2024 13:40

@BIossomtoes As much as I sympathise with the fact that you had to/have to wait longer for your state pension please bear in mind what people in their 30's might or might not get. Be grateful. Suspect I might be dead before I get mine.

Vod · 05/03/2024 13:37

WithACatLikeTread · 05/03/2024 13:32

I am not convinced. There would be a lot more "why did you have another kid" etc. OP has been treated more lenient because she is a high earner but cutting hours to get benefits.

You're not actually disagreeing with me then, as I didn't say how many posts there'd be. Only that people would wade in moralising, which is the same point you make here, and that it would be a different set of posters doing the entitled, cut your cloth, shouldn't have had another kid routine.

Morph22010 · 05/03/2024 13:36

BIossomtoes · 05/03/2024 13:33

Good luck with that. Where are you going? Your state pension will be frozen at the level it is when you leave.

Plus you are no longer able to retire to the eu since brexit

BIossomtoes · 05/03/2024 13:33

TruckerMother · 05/03/2024 13:21

As someone with 4 kids (with big gaps) who has only ever worked part time and still only just scrapes above minimum wage after 21 years NHS work, getting Child benefit was sometimes a godsend. IMO it should only be for low income families and this has been a long time coming.
I admire women who sacrifice so much to climb the career ladder and become high earners/main breadwinners, my daughter is one of them, and if you do it then AIM FOR THE STARS regardless. I dont think UABU, i think our goverment are robbing B* compared to other countries, and needs completely reforming.
I for one will be retiring abroad on my measly state and NHS pension and will be far better off.

Good luck with that. Where are you going? Your state pension will be frozen at the level it is when you leave.

WithACatLikeTread · 05/03/2024 13:32

Vod · 05/03/2024 09:27

You'd get a load of moralising there too, just from a different set of posters. The insistence on centering their own sympathies rather than acknowledging that people respond to incentives would be identical.

I am not convinced. There would be a lot more "why did you have another kid" etc. OP has been treated more lenient because she is a high earner but cutting hours to get benefits.

TruckerMother · 05/03/2024 13:21

As someone with 4 kids (with big gaps) who has only ever worked part time and still only just scrapes above minimum wage after 21 years NHS work, getting Child benefit was sometimes a godsend. IMO it should only be for low income families and this has been a long time coming.
I admire women who sacrifice so much to climb the career ladder and become high earners/main breadwinners, my daughter is one of them, and if you do it then AIM FOR THE STARS regardless. I dont think UABU, i think our goverment are robbing B* compared to other countries, and needs completely reforming.
I for one will be retiring abroad on my measly state and NHS pension and will be far better off.

SuperMaria · 05/03/2024 13:18

Not bad with money but 3x maternity leave, 3x nursery fees, mortgage to pay....

Well, cut your cloth like pp suggested