Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
whatkatydid2014 · 06/03/2024 10:12

Astonetogo · 02/03/2024 21:14

See, this is part of why our public services are so crap, people earning plenty are dodging paying tax by sticking it in their pensions and hanging onto benefits they don’t need 🙄

Edited

While I see what you are saying if you had a payrise of £6k, 2 kids and the choice of:

  1. putting an extra 3k into your pension & taking ~3 weeks of unpaid parental leave in school break OR
  2. getting £3.5k cash but losing 60% of your child benefit AND paying £1k+ in childcare fees beyond what you’d spend at home with kids for the 3 weeks so ultimately being about £100/month better off in cash terms now and worse off overalll if pension considered

What would you do?

Why would anyone be surprised someone in this bracket might rather work part time, take unpaid leave &/or plough into their pensions to facilitate early retirement rather than end up with about 20% or whatever they earn between 50&60k available to them to spend.

It’s the exact same scenario as people not wanting to work more hours as they’d be worse off not getting a certain level of universal credit because the taper is so steep

Vod · 06/03/2024 10:07

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 09:56

Yes. Happy now? Any thought about how the system could be made fairer for single parents or are you just going to keep posting aggressive comments on my posts?

The time when you could've called anyone else aggressive without being snorted at evaporated with your FFS.

Still though, I'm glad we're getting constructive now. Better that you're grown up about some of it than none at all, don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good etc. The quickest way to address the system that could be done today would be to raise the threshold in line with inflation to alleviate the 50-60k bottleneck. I agree with you that for single parents, longer term structural changes are needed, and I'd also include in that two parent households that will always be one income due to one parent being unable to work due to disability or being a carer. If the earnings cap on child benefit continues to exist, which it doesn't have to, single parents should be exempted. There is also the discrimination in relation to personal allowances to address. There is some potential for abuse of the system, but then that's the case with UC as well.

updownleftrightstart · 06/03/2024 10:06

JessS1990 · 06/03/2024 09:46

Oh, so you aren't actually worse off if you earn more. I'm sure we were told people were.

If you are already at the point of getting no benefits (except child benefit), then given tax/pension/NI etc is never going to be 100% you'll always be better off earning more and I'm not sure how people can argue otherwise.
But if you're looking at the difference between maybe someone on 28k who gets UC, 85% of childcare paid, etc then I can see how someone on 50k who gets none of that would be worse off once they've paid for everything that the person on 28k gets help towards.
Also once you get to the 100k mark and lose 30 hours free childcare you'll most likely be substantially worse off than keeping your wage under 100k.
Both those situations are really unfair but completely different to the 50k+ situation mentioned here

Charcol · 06/03/2024 10:01

lets see if anything comes out of the budget today to help.

But in summary, you have to look long term...and strive to make as much as poss. as childcare will not always be an issue for all your life.

but if in the short term you feel to spend more time at home. dont feel guilty. just do it

whatkatydid2014 · 06/03/2024 09:59

Mmmm19 · 02/03/2024 21:10

i believe child benefit is simply gross not net adjusted which takes into account pension (tax free childcare is net adjusted at the 100k threshold!)

It’s based on taxable income and you can adjust for pension & charitable contributions when you do your tax return.

NeedtostopusingMNsomuch · 06/03/2024 09:59

Harry12345 · 06/03/2024 08:49

Can you tell me what the benefit of putting it into your pension is apart from having more in pension pot?

As others have said, massive tax savings if you contribute via salary sacrifice. Earners over 100k avoid the 100-125 60% effective tax rate due to the loss of the personal allowance. You can take out 25% of your pension tax free at 57. Also the power of compound interest if you start contributing early

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 09:56

Vod · 06/03/2024 09:52

People talking nonsense is part of life yes, they're not mutually exclusive. So to clarify, would a single parent pointing out unfairnesses in the tax system be able to do so without you FFSing because they haven't 'come to terms' with it and that's reserved only for those with partners?

Yes. Happy now? Any thought about how the system could be made fairer for single parents or are you just going to keep posting aggressive comments on my posts?

SUPerSaver721 · 06/03/2024 09:53

WingsofRain · 02/03/2024 21:24

I’ve worked hard all my life and currently get £12k a year. I’ll swap for your £70k+ if you like.
Or even the £50k, actually. 👍🏻

You clearly dont work full time for 12k a year.. Get a full time job and you will earn alot more.

Vod · 06/03/2024 09:52

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 09:47

It’s not nonsense. It’s life. 🤷‍♀️

However the way the system treats single parents goes beyond unfair, it’s illogical and ridiculous too.

People talking nonsense is part of life yes, they're not mutually exclusive. So to clarify, would a single parent pointing out unfairnesses in the tax system be able to do so without you FFSing because they haven't 'come to terms' with it and that's reserved only for those with partners?

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 09:47

Vod · 06/03/2024 09:44

Glad you're not trying to apply that 'life's unfair' nonsense to at least some of the people affected by this policy.

It’s not nonsense. It’s life. 🤷‍♀️

However the way the system treats single parents goes beyond unfair, it’s illogical and ridiculous too.

AmaryllisChorus · 06/03/2024 09:47

Honestly, I'd just reframe my thinking if I was you, and say to myself: I earn 50k part time, get loads of child benefits and a 3k bonus. Lucky me.

While I do have a LOT of sympathy for middle class 'wealthy' earners who can barely make ends meet on two salaries with London house prices etc, I don't really have much sympathy for people despairing at having their bonuses taxed when I know so many people working 12 hour night shifts on minimum wage, helping the dying, the sick, the demented, children in trauma, with no bonus in sight.

JessS1990 · 06/03/2024 09:46

updownleftrightstart · 06/03/2024 09:44

If my salary was 50k exactly, after my company pension payments, and adding on child benefit, I'd be taking home £3118.
If I was on 65k, I'd not get any child benefit but would still take home £3742 (after pension contributions).
That's £624 a month extra so there is obviously a point.
Of course if you're paying a lot in childcare, especially if that's for a higher than average number of children, it might be worth dropping hours to save childcare costs. But for your average person it is absolutely worth it.
If I was to be on 78k, I'd be taking home £1250 a month more than if I was on 50k, even taking into account losing child benefit.

Oh, so you aren't actually worse off if you earn more. I'm sure we were told people were.

Vod · 06/03/2024 09:44

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 09:29

Heaven forbid any of us actually want a fairer and more efficient tax system that doesn't structurally discriminate against single parents.

Single parents have my every sympathy, they get an incredibly raw deal. There are a number of ways that could be addressed - raise the threshold for child benefit, higher personal allowance are just two. The issue is how you identify them in a way that isn’t an invitation to abuse.

Glad you're not trying to apply that 'life's unfair' nonsense to at least some of the people affected by this policy.

updownleftrightstart · 06/03/2024 09:44

If my salary was 50k exactly, after my company pension payments, and adding on child benefit, I'd be taking home £3118.
If I was on 65k, I'd not get any child benefit but would still take home £3742 (after pension contributions).
That's £624 a month extra so there is obviously a point.
Of course if you're paying a lot in childcare, especially if that's for a higher than average number of children, it might be worth dropping hours to save childcare costs. But for your average person it is absolutely worth it.
If I was to be on 78k, I'd be taking home £1250 a month more than if I was on 50k, even taking into account losing child benefit.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 06/03/2024 09:39

I hate the assumption that the amount you earn signifies how hard you work. Some of the easiest jobs I’ve had have paid well.

Also while it can be good financial sense to put more in your pension be aware of the annual allowance threshold.

Whatstheword21 · 06/03/2024 09:37

I feel this! I genuinely don’t know what to do as I’ve negotiated a nice pay rise BUT I lose out on child benefit, get taxed 40% and lose most of my bonus as a result so what is the actual
Point! I fear I’d be seen negatively if I dropped my hours as it’s such a male dominated industry and to be honest, I’d really struggle to do my role on less hours. My husband doesn’t bring home half of what I do but works full time too so it just feels like we’re slogging away to get the minimum when I have friends on less then my husband and I but their benefits top them up to practically be in line with our take home 🤦‍♀️

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 09:29

Heaven forbid any of us actually want a fairer and more efficient tax system that doesn't structurally discriminate against single parents.

Single parents have my every sympathy, they get an incredibly raw deal. There are a number of ways that could be addressed - raise the threshold for child benefit, higher personal allowance are just two. The issue is how you identify them in a way that isn’t an invitation to abuse.

Vod · 06/03/2024 09:24

MidnightPatrol · 06/03/2024 08:50

‘lifes unfair’

Brilliant.

Good thing you aren’t a government economist.

Maybe you are actually! That would make a lot of sense actually.

It's so inconvenient when people point out godawful policy and act accordingly instead of just being sucking it up and behaving in a way that suits the ideological bent of the person who doesn't want it tackled, isn't it! Heaven forbid any of us actually want a fairer and more efficient tax system that doesn't structurally discriminate against single parents.

boredybored · 06/03/2024 09:21

Yep ! Dh gets a huge bonus at Xmas and to give away half of it stings .. but ce la vie ! 💃

Zwicky · 06/03/2024 09:12

It’s part of the governments job to incentivise work, and particularly to incentivise skilled work. There is no point moralising that people should be thrilled to hand over 60% of their income after a certain point, or that they should be joyous that they are actually worse off than they were before their pay rise or bonus or overtime due to government policy. The reality is people make choices that make them, as individuals, and their nuclear family better off (which can mean financially or work/life balance). If you say to someone “pay for this qualification, study on your own time after work, sacrifice your cash and free time, take on extra responsibility at work, and at the end of it you will not be even slightly better off except for the rosy glow of paying more tax” then a lot of people will decide to stay exactly where they are. The idea that everyone who “works hard” is entitled to the same salary is disingenuous. A care assistant on a ward will “work hard” but they do not work harder than the band 5 nurse, who has sacrificed earnings to get her degree qualification and has more knowledge and more responsibility AND is working hard, and in turn the band 5 nurse does not work harder than the matron who has a leadership/management role, higher levels of clinical skills, additional qualifications, additional experience and a high level of responsibility AND is working hard. There are definitely jobs that are dossier than others and some low wage jobs do have an enormous physical and emotional toll but we are not in a situation where swathes of the country are bringing home £70-100k for spinning about on office chairs from 10 until 4 with a 2 hour lunch break to sip their expensive coffees in. Generally these earners have high levels of education and qualifications (which they will have paid for), are “clever”, are skilled, are knowledgeable and work long hours. Everyone knows a buffoon who has somehow blagged their way into senior management and everyone knows really bright hard working people who never seem to catch a break but that isn’t an argument for dismantling the relationship between skills/knowledge/qualifications/responsibility/hours and pay. It is an argument towards improving adult education and helping people for whom the “normal” life path isn’t A-level -> degree -> postgrad qualification -> professional qualification -> higher rate tax payer.
There are too many “cliff edges” in government policy, Tax thresholds, stamp duty, CB, free childcare, VAT rates, VAT thresholds, UC threshold’s etc that disincentivise anyone on the border, which is millions of people.
l’m on under £50k, but I tip over with unsocial hours payments and overtime and I works a second job which is taxed entirely at 40%. Everything over £49.9k goes into my private pension. I’m a bit 🙄 that people think I’m a scummy tax dodger because I’m contributing to my own pension.

Minimum wage is over £20k for a standard 37.5 week. Earning £12k a year for “working hard” is not normal. Not sure if I’ve missed the drip feed.

OP - as someone for whom the gas pedal disappeared and had to be built again from scratch my advice would be higher earnings plus higher pension contributions.

TinyTeachr · 06/03/2024 09:12

As many other have said - pension!!!

I have 4DC. I am part time and I work out my hours very carefully as I could very easily earn more (my boss wants me in more ideally) but then I take home very little of it as I'm just over £50K on my 3 days. With 3 under school age you can imagine it's definitelt not worth working an extra day.

Welcome2thecircus · 06/03/2024 09:07

Understand where you're coming from OP, more money but more outgoings puts you in the same position.

It's a balancing act. I plan to return to work but yes nursery x2, plus afterschool club 😬

You work super hard, have paid student loans, don't see the kids, and then break even. It's defo a decision if it's worth it.

For me personally yes but I don't claim. Maybe consider contracting. So you can earn what you need to and then take small breaks, giving you some time with kids too.

They won't be tiny forever, and childcare will reduce. Keep grafting hun x

MidnightPatrol · 06/03/2024 09:05

Twiglets1 · 06/03/2024 09:00

You won’t always be getting child benefit so limiting your career advancement because of concerns about repaying benefits does seem a little shortsighted.

Paying 40% tax isn’t great and I do understand people’s feelings about that. But we all want good public services don’t we? They cost a lot of money.

Well, you might be getting it for 20+ years, depending on then age of your children.

They aren't just paying 40% tax - they might be paying more like a 70-80% rate.

fromdownwest · 06/03/2024 09:01

Harry12345 · 06/03/2024 08:49

Can you tell me what the benefit of putting it into your pension is apart from having more in pension pot?

20% uplift on the contribution on day 1, with a further 20% claimed back for higher rate taxpayers.

This grows in a tax-free (primarily) environment, whilst invested, compounding the gross roll-up over time. You can then take 25% of that contribution out tax-free, and the rest of the compounded grossed-up sum, taxable at your highest marginal rate.

Down side is the lack of flexibility and age to access, whereas an ISA does not suffer these downsides, you do forgo the grossing up of any payments.

MikeRafone · 06/03/2024 09:00

You have a lot of choices open to you, choice to drop work to 3 days from 4 and spend more time with your dc, choices to put into your pension and retire earlier

for may others working just as hard as you and juggling just the same, they don't have those choices as they earn much less, but still pay the same price for supermarket food, fuel and products. £70 a day here for childcare and going up in April by 10%