Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
567839Y · 06/03/2024 13:00

Pensions can also be a bit if a rip off. Pay all the money into a pension you might never see. And if you do see it it could easily fall through the floor the month before you retire. Meanwhile someone somewhere made money off your money.

it’s very tricky to decide what to do.

final salary pension - def worth it

YouJustDoYou · 06/03/2024 12:41

We wouldn't mind the stupendous amounts of tax we pay, IF it actually went on continuing a successful society and economy. It's a shitshow no matter who is leading. We're looking to leave for greener shores and taking our tax money with us to better spend in a better country than this shit hole.

Vod · 06/03/2024 12:35

Yes, the NHS pension scheme and tax systems having intersected to discourage senior doctors from working more is another corker. A leading candidate in a competitive field!

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 12:21

samarrange · 06/03/2024 12:11

True. Nobody took any notice until they noticed that senior doctors (perhaps the only class of people making six figures who everyone likes) were walking away from the NHS in droves because they were losing money by working.

That’s because they were doing what’s widely recommended here and stuffing their pension then they reached the lifetime limit and that particular wheeze no longer worked.

Chris002 · 06/03/2024 12:19

Maybe the government should look at changing the child benefit system again
Perhaps tie it In with universal credit so you only get it if your total household income is on or under the threshold for uc.
At the same they could encourage employers of higher income bracket earners to come up with incentives to help with child care costs nursery etc

samarrange · 06/03/2024 12:11

khakifingers · 06/03/2024 08:54

Unless you maxed out on your lifetime allowance without noticing as happened to a few people when the impact of the lifetime allowance hadn't been fully analysed. I understand they will pay 55% tax on that. Not that anyone cares much for the overprivileged few.

True. Nobody took any notice until they noticed that senior doctors (perhaps the only class of people making six figures who everyone likes) were walking away from the NHS in droves because they were losing money by working.

RedCircleLine · 06/03/2024 12:08

I keep reading about the UK's "productivity problems" and have to admit here that I'm a part of it.

I earn about 90k full-time.

But I'm in Scotland, so I pay thousands of £s more in taxes vs. my English family members. (No, i didn't benefit from free university, but I do get free prescriptions and eye tests.)

I have a very responsible, senior, stressful role. I also have small DC (and a husband that more than pulls his weight at home, works part time, and his job has been impacted worse by taking the sick days/drop offs and pickups etc).

I'm about to go into my annual performance review chat in 2 week's time and my C-level line manager is going to ask my career plan to get to the next grade.

I need to formulate a narrative which is a more polite version of:
"I'm good at my job. My customers love me, my colleagues ask to work with me, you know it already. But I can't handle the stress that comes with being at the "next level up". And even if I did want the extra responsibility, why would I, it's not worth the net pay increase. Can I go 4 days a week instead?"

I've crunched the numbers - by the time I factor in the loss of child benefit, the tax/NI cliff at 43k-50k, extra Scottish rate of income tax at £75k, and then potentially the whammy at a new potential salary of 100k... I'm not even convinced that my last promotion was worth it vs. the responsibility and stress, never mind my supposed next one. I'd rather look at ways to reduce my work level because just automatically doing more more more more... i'm not seeing the reward being proportionate in future.

This is the first year I've started to think like this - i've just adjusted my pension contributions to start reducing my income to offset the tax pressures further; I've always paid into my pension but now it's the first year I've done it as a direct result of the tax situation making it nonsensicle not to salary sacrifice down as much as possible.

Before I became a stressed, frazzled mess of a mother, i was head down for years thinking hard work pays off. In my case, it mostly has, don't get me wrong.. but I can now see why others are saying F this and stepping back. That's not a workforce productivity problem, that's a "workers choosing to opt out of the craziness if they have a choice" problem.

I know i'm in a privileged position to talk like this. But until someone does something about the relative levels of tax, NI, and net income cliffs that exist in the UK tax system, more people are going to start to think like me. And that's scary, because we should be incentivising people that working harder/more = rewards more. At the moment, it doesn't feel like that.

entropynow · 06/03/2024 11:58

cremebrulait · 06/03/2024 11:51

Its really sad that the system is so broken that people would prefer to work less and get a government hand out. No no. I'm not faulting OP. I'm faulting the system. There shouldn't be this point where you fall off a cliff. You cut back and get more money being paid into tax contributions by everyone else. It's fair to nobody.

But apparently people on over 50k are OK to complain about taxes? They also want a handout...

cremebrulait · 06/03/2024 11:51

Its really sad that the system is so broken that people would prefer to work less and get a government hand out. No no. I'm not faulting OP. I'm faulting the system. There shouldn't be this point where you fall off a cliff. You cut back and get more money being paid into tax contributions by everyone else. It's fair to nobody.

Vod · 06/03/2024 11:48

JessS1990 · 06/03/2024 10:14

Surely the value to society of parents spending more time with their children is far greater than the loss of tax income?

I think if you want to make that argument, fine. But if we're to have policy on that basis, the government should be clear about it and also explain why marginal tax rates are to be used to encourage it at certain income levels and not others.

There should also be honesty about the potential impact on others of people in that cohort working less. This clearly isn't happening at the moment. Some of the contributions on this thread make it clear that not everyone has actually clocked that the way our tax system functions and intersects with other entitlements could be the reason their dentist won't work an extra afternoon, the local plumber doesn't do Friday jobs, they can't recruit for a particular vacancy at work etc.

Vod · 06/03/2024 11:41

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 10:30

The time when you could've called anyone else aggressive without being snorted at evaporated with your FFS.

Difference is it wasn’t directed at a single poster. However you continue with the personal attacks, people will draw their own conclusions.

If the earnings cap on child benefit continues to exist, which it doesn't have to, single parents should be exempted. There is also the discrimination in relation to personal allowances to address.

That’s exactly what I said. But identifying genuine single parents and preventing abuse would be a huge problem. You only have to look at the gymnastics people already go through to “beat the system” to see how many single parents would miraculously spring up like mushrooms. I wish I knew what the answer was.

Likewise, if you continue your attempts to tone police after your previous contributions, people will draw their own conclusions. Glass houses etc.

It is true that preventing abuse is a problem, but that's true of the whole tax and top up benefits systems. It's a problem today. There are single parents now who have both a UC claim and are affected by the child benefit threshold, and we still run those parallel systems.

whatkatydid2014 · 06/03/2024 11:39

JessS1990 · 06/03/2024 10:14

Surely the value to society of parents spending more time with their children is far greater than the loss of tax income?

It’s possible it is & will doubtless in part depend what you do for work. For us as a family though I feel like there is a significant benefit for kids to get time off over the holidays with one of us when we just chill and potter at home. Usually my husband takes Easter and I take time in the summer and then we do half terms individually too with a family break at Christmas and a summer holiday. It takes us down to kids only having a couple of holiday weeks a year in paid childcare and lets us have the odd day off alone as well.

The point I was making is it’s unrealistic to expect people to act against their own/their families best interest.

Pretty much everyone I know with children who earns 50-60k puts into pension &/or dropped hours temporarily. It’s because overall they are actually financially better off that way &/or because the relatively small gain they would get doesn’t feel worth it vs chance to spend more time with kids. It might be that there is an impact to career. I haven’t seen that myself but then I always had rather limited ambition.

Feelingstrange2 · 06/03/2024 11:27

@Harry12345

Another benefit of my pension scheme is if I die before 75 I can leave it outside of my estate and it doesn't take any of my IHT banding.

Whilst I hope that reason never applies, if it does Im.giving it 45/45/10 to our kids and then husband (as my husband has a decent employer pension provision), and they will be able to use it including the option of keeping it as a pension pot for themselves.

MarvellousMonsters · 06/03/2024 11:25

Aside from this being a huge first world problem, yes. Rethink your life, and priorities. Do you need to earn over £50k? What do you benefit by working full time? And whilst you're working full time and losing so much to tax etc, you're paying someone else to raise your family.

The concept of 'enough' is one that's too often ignored. If you can reduce your hours/income to £50k you have enough to live on without hardship, and are spending time with your children and not working so many hours that you're exhausted, this is surely optimal? What's the point of working 5 days a week and hardly seeing your children?

Money isn't everything, as long as you have enough

BezMills · 06/03/2024 11:16

I'm generally sympathetic, nobody enjoys paying tax (well if there is such a person I haven't met them).
Taxes are basically a subscription for civilisation, that's how I look at it. I don't sweat it too much (similar income as you)
If you want lower or zero taxes, there are countries that are like that (generally with lower or zero public services and higher personal costs due to that). You can vote and even campaign to turn the UK into a low tax or zero tax country, also fine. And you can let off steam online about taxes (cf this thread) - that's also completely fine.

CountryCob · 06/03/2024 11:15

If you get to £100k it’s no child benefit or tax free childcare either…

Redpaisley · 06/03/2024 11:08

Exasperateddonut · 02/03/2024 21:15

Not really. High earners pay WAY more tax at every turn. They spend more - more VAT. They employ more services - paying NI and tax. They don’t use public services - schools/medical care.

Yes but some people are paying a lot towards that tax pool while people earning decent but near threshold avoid that extra tax and also claim child benefits.

Child benefits should be for those near minimum wage, below national average salaries, not for someone earning 50k.

If we go by your logic, child free should have their taxes lowered because they never use public childcare and schools.

BezMills · 06/03/2024 10:45

If you don't want to pay higher rate tax, (fair), just wham it into a salary sacrifice pension, or if that's not available, get a SIPP and do that (make sure and claim the higher rate tax relief via your SA Tax Return)

Helensburghmiddleagedmum · 06/03/2024 10:41

I help out at a mental health hub and although there are some people who are very much in need of benefits and totally deserve them there are also (from what I see) quite a lot of people who have spent their lives milking the system, not working, living off benefits. From what I see, in comparison to me and my husband who have always worked, and not been very well off but not poorly enough off to claim universal credit or any other benefit other than child benefit when the children were younger, the benefits system is, in my opinion, extremely generous, and those who are able to claim additional benefits because of their mental health issues which may or not be genuinely severe, have a very good standard of living with a relatively large disposable income (in comparison to me) which they spend on eating out, takeaways, holidays, clothes. I know here on MN it is frowned upon mentioning benefits, and I am not bashing people who are in genuine need of benefits, but there is the elephant in the room which is that there are a lot of people who don't really need benefits who are able to claim benefits, and not work, and have a very nice life.

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 10:30

The time when you could've called anyone else aggressive without being snorted at evaporated with your FFS.

Difference is it wasn’t directed at a single poster. However you continue with the personal attacks, people will draw their own conclusions.

If the earnings cap on child benefit continues to exist, which it doesn't have to, single parents should be exempted. There is also the discrimination in relation to personal allowances to address.

That’s exactly what I said. But identifying genuine single parents and preventing abuse would be a huge problem. You only have to look at the gymnastics people already go through to “beat the system” to see how many single parents would miraculously spring up like mushrooms. I wish I knew what the answer was.

Chris002 · 06/03/2024 10:20

YABU - that's a nice bonus - you get to pay off some of your student loan.
That's great if you get to keep 30% of it then perhaps you could pay off some more of it. Lots of people would love to have a £9k bonus !
Why do you get child benefit if you have to pay it back ?

nearlyemptynes · 06/03/2024 10:19

I get what you are saying OP my husband's earnings are over the threshold and we are now in the third year of paying back child benefit. We also are supporting our eldest son through university. I work in the public sector so do not earn over the threshold. Why should we be penalised for my husbands earnings when a couple where both earn just below the threshold would receive CB? I see friends who receive CB having multiple foreign holidays, driving new cars and telling their children they can't afford to support them through uni. We choose to priotitize our children, others don't. However, this is a first world problem and we should be grateful we have these choices to make.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/03/2024 10:15

missmollygreen · 02/03/2024 21:10

My heart bleeds

No worries let’s have everyone who would earn over 50k cap their hours to make sure they stay below and see the impact it has on your life

JessS1990 · 06/03/2024 10:14

whatkatydid2014 · 06/03/2024 10:12

While I see what you are saying if you had a payrise of £6k, 2 kids and the choice of:

  1. putting an extra 3k into your pension & taking ~3 weeks of unpaid parental leave in school break OR
  2. getting £3.5k cash but losing 60% of your child benefit AND paying £1k+ in childcare fees beyond what you’d spend at home with kids for the 3 weeks so ultimately being about £100/month better off in cash terms now and worse off overalll if pension considered

What would you do?

Why would anyone be surprised someone in this bracket might rather work part time, take unpaid leave &/or plough into their pensions to facilitate early retirement rather than end up with about 20% or whatever they earn between 50&60k available to them to spend.

It’s the exact same scenario as people not wanting to work more hours as they’d be worse off not getting a certain level of universal credit because the taper is so steep

Surely the value to society of parents spending more time with their children is far greater than the loss of tax income?

fleurneige · 06/03/2024 10:13

Not read the whole thread, I have to admit. But you have to look long-term on this. If you work very part-time, what will be your chances, eventually, when children are at upper school, and leave home- to go back to a senior job. In many jobs, if you don't keep up when children are young, you totally lose your place on the ladder forever, as skills, technology, etc, keep moving forwards.

This has really long-term implications for your post mother career, and eventually, your pension. So many women react as you do- and it is too late by the time they realise they have lost all realistic chances of a great career post motherhood, and a decent pension eventually.

When I went back to work, it almost cost me to work, as I had to have a full time nanny due to working hours, meetings, occasional travel off site or even abroad. The cost was crippling. But I stayed on the ladder and even went up a bit, and when the time came, I was ready to break that glass ceiling and get a really decent salary. And at 59, my pension forecast is really good.