Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Zanatdy · 03/03/2024 07:23

Yup I know how you feel. I’ve had to pay a fair bit back. Posters saying their heart bleeds, well it’s annoying when you’ve worked really hard to get promotions etc and your extra money is eaten by the tax man etc. Frustrating for me too as I’m the only earner in my household as a single parent, whereas a couple earning just shy of 100k would receive the child benefit. I can’t even afford to buy a house in the South East so I’m far from well off. If I was you OP yes cut your hours or put some into your pension.

Beautiful3 · 03/03/2024 07:21

Personally I'd just reduce my hours and become part time. You'll have more time with your child, and pay less tax.

laclochette · 03/03/2024 07:19

@KidsDr Well said! We are definitely moving from an income- to an asset-based society. And as you say, no amount of hard work can get you from the income-reliant underclass to the asset-reliant upper class, unless you are exceptionally fortunate and successful eg found a very successful business and sell it; work in the upper echelons of finance...

Vettrianofan · 03/03/2024 07:16

DH earns no where near £50k so I do agree OP. We get a sizeable amount of UC, CB for four DC, and Scottish Child Payment for three of four DC. And I have my tuition fees paid for by SAAS to do a part time degree via the OU because I am not in paid employment.

laclochette · 03/03/2024 07:16

Oh and to all those heart bleeds people - the average full time salary is now about £39k.

So while £50k is obviously above that, it's not much above that. For our tax system to treat it as a "high" earner salary, where so much is taken away, is really crazy.

It's really just a bit above average, and as I said in an earlier post, if it had been increased in line with inflation, it would now be £67k.

KidsDr · 03/03/2024 07:13

It's so sad and pathetic that the asset owning class have convinced hard working people to bicker and squabble over their relative incomes.

Doing more productive work should always pay. Right now, if you earn around £50k, it doesn't. It's irrelevant that you are luckier or more privileged than someone earning less, if work doesn't pay then people choose not to do it.

Noone benefits from this. People doing less productive work harms the economy. It reduces productivity, reduces cash circulation, and reduces the tax take.

The choice not to reward productive work is driven by the ideology of the asset owning class, who dominate our politics. That's the real class divide in our country.

A professional on £100k has more in common with a self employed cleaner on £12k than either has with the likes of Sunak or Rees-Mogg. And the likes of Sunak and Rees-Mogg prefer to keep it that way, forever. Which they can do, because as well as possessing dramatically more wealth than even the very best paid professionals not belonging to the asset owning class, they also have easy access to power and influence.

If you earn a pittance it is at least theoretically possible to earn more, or for your children to earn more by entering a well paid profession, trade or through good enterprise. It's still not fair that many hard working, valuable people have such low incomes and that social mobility between income stratifications is still so poor. But there is virtually zero social mobility that will allow you to enter the same world that Sunak occupies. It's not a position you can get to through merit or hard work - I'd go so far as to say many in the asset owning class demonstrably lack merit or a hard work ethic.

Galliano · 03/03/2024 07:08

leafybrew · 03/03/2024 06:18

But surely if you're on that sort of higher salary you'll be smart enough to work it all out? You may want the bonus money now - all of it without being taxed - but it doesn't work like that. This page is very useful But no doubt you know all this. Plus all the people coming on this thread to say how dreadful it is to earn more than £100k - don't you do all this as well?

https://taxscouts.com/high-earner-tax-returns/60-tax-what-to-do-if-you-just-started-earning-over-100000/#:~:text=Over%20this%2C%20you%20pay%20tax,over%20this%20%C2%A3100%2C000%20threshold.

Not a massively helpful article given it has the wrong threshold for taper in it.
Noone has said it’s terrible to earn a high salary.
It’s completely possible to both believe in progressive taxation and feel that the current system is poorly designed with cliff edges that have a punitive impact and act as a disincentive to career progression/ full time hours.

Yourethebeerthief · 03/03/2024 06:35

leafybrew · 03/03/2024 06:18

But surely if you're on that sort of higher salary you'll be smart enough to work it all out? You may want the bonus money now - all of it without being taxed - but it doesn't work like that. This page is very useful But no doubt you know all this. Plus all the people coming on this thread to say how dreadful it is to earn more than £100k - don't you do all this as well?

https://taxscouts.com/high-earner-tax-returns/60-tax-what-to-do-if-you-just-started-earning-over-100000/#:~:text=Over%20this%2C%20you%20pay%20tax,over%20this%20%C2%A3100%2C000%20threshold.

Speaking for myself, thankfully my husband is good with this sort of thing. I earn well (when working- currently only just returned to work after having a child and will have to stop again for a while when we have a second) but my earning potential is shy of £50K when working full capacity.

We are both self employed. One person earning over £50K is a new development for us so we're only now having to look at these things.

I work with languages and have never been good at maths so I'm reading up on it all now- Mumsnet discussions about these sorts of things are invaluable to me and I come away with a better understanding than from researching on my own or reading useless .gov sites. Just because someone is skilled in a specific field and can earn well in their industry doesn't mean they are good with numbers. I think a lot of people can relate to that! I was the first in my family to go to university, the first to earn what I earn, the first to work as a sole trader and have to navigate all that entails. My parents don't have a clue.

Like I say, thankfully my husband is good with these sorts of things and we'll discuss it when he returns from working away. In the meantime I'm just trying to understand it all better myself so that we can chat when he's back.

leafybrew · 03/03/2024 06:18

But surely if you're on that sort of higher salary you'll be smart enough to work it all out? You may want the bonus money now - all of it without being taxed - but it doesn't work like that. This page is very useful But no doubt you know all this. Plus all the people coming on this thread to say how dreadful it is to earn more than £100k - don't you do all this as well?

https://taxscouts.com/high-earner-tax-returns/60-tax-what-to-do-if-you-just-started-earning-over-100000/#:~:text=Over%20this%2C%20you%20pay%20tax,over%20this%20%C2%A3100%2C000%20threshold.

60% tax? What to do if you just started earning over £100,000 – TaxScouts

If you’ve just started earning over £100k, you’ll realise you’re not paying tax at a marginal rate of 60%. Here’s how to lower it.

https://taxscouts.com/high-earner-tax-returns/60-tax-what-to-do-if-you-just-started-earning-over-100000#:~:text=Over%20this%2C%20you%20pay%20tax,over%20this%20%C2%A3100%2C000%20threshold.

Yourethebeerthief · 03/03/2024 06:17

@blueshoes

And it avoids ridiculous tax cliff edges arising due to means testing. It cuts out the complexities of claiming for NI credits and paying it back - I know some people get caught out by this

Can you explain what you mean? I have 4 years of not full years on my NI contributions (university) that I can buy back. I find all of this stupidly complicated so currently need to work out if that's worthwhile to do.

Past two years I have credits as I stopped working to look after my son. Do I have to pay something back here too?

We are now in a situation of my husband earning £60K and I'm trying to understand what we do about child benefit as well. Stopping it altogether seems simplest.

It's incredibly unfair that if one person earns nothing and the other earns £50K you are charged. But both people earn £49,999 you don't. What kind of nonsense is that?

Dorisbonson · 03/03/2024 05:32

There was a UK Treasury Select Committee House of Commons report mentioned in the times yesterday that said the cliff edge at 50k was having a negative economic impact on the UK and also the cliff edge at 100k is having a similar impact on economic growth, this was based on their interrogation of Bank of England economists.

It's clearly not popular to reduce taxes for those people impacted but might actually benefit the rest of the UK overall if the cliff edges were smoother out.

Noicant · 03/03/2024 04:42

I don’t think people understand what most people have to do to earn those wages. Studying while working and often also whilst raising a family (a few of those in my family, you literally have zero time to do anything else). Or being available way beyond contracted hours, going home doing dinner and bathtime and then opening up your laptop again to keep going.

There are some very able people who are paid very well because they have niche valuable skills and don’t have to work mad hours to achieve that but most on 60k plus aren’t getting it for free.

The cliff edge is truly horrible if you are putting the hours in and seeing little benefit for it.

dopamineexplosion · 03/03/2024 04:31

And sorry, I should just point out that I wasn't the person who mentioned earning £12,000 initially. Just thought I'd explain my own situation so that people understand that you can be working full time and not earning anywhere near minimum wage.

Sloelydoesit · 03/03/2024 04:27

entropynow · 03/03/2024 00:08

Just as I'm so done with "high earners are all sooo hardworking and contribute so much more to society than all you lazy, envious povvos..."

They don't necessarily work any harder, or earn those huge salaries : they just get paid more. Usually for pushing money around or pointless 'service industry' non-jobs.

I know people with fistfuls of educational and professional qualifications who work like dogs and will never pay higher rate tax. Rather be friends with them than with a "the only real success is loadsamoney" type, thanks.

Edited

Don't work harder? Pointless jobs?

If they were so pointless then the salary wouldn't be paid. I'm 25 years into my career. You come and do my worthless job

The £2k plus I pay in income tax alone every month supports other people. I don't complain. I don't want a hand clap either. But at least don't slag us off. It's PAYE, we aren't hiding behind a ltd company.

dopamineexplosion · 03/03/2024 04:14

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 02/03/2024 23:11

So never worked full time then, v v young? if you're 23 or older, and currently working 35 hours a week, your annual salary must be at least £18,964

Many people who are self-employed work full time for much less than the minimum wage. They are often forced to do this because they are disabled and may have been denied the benefits they are entitled to by the inherent dishonesty of the benefits system. Before I became too ill to work at all I often worked 16-23 hours a day, sometimes for weeks at a time for only around £700 a month because it was the only kind of work I could access. At my benefits hearing they quoted me as saying something I never said (basically reporting that my most disabling condition had miraculously cleared up which of course it hadn't) which lost me about 50% of the points I was supposed to receive. This is sadly a very common experience. So despite the fact that I excelled academically at school and university and have worked harder than almost anyone I know I have struggled to make £12,000 a year. Again, this isn't uncommon.

letstrythatagain · 03/03/2024 03:56

LucyLaundry · 02/03/2024 21:14

Happy to swap?

Some people really don't know their own privilege.

Love these sort of narrow minded responses. Why don't you try and get yourself through the same level of qualifications that takes you into the higher level of earning instead of sitting around being jealous of the success of other people?

PupInAPram · 03/03/2024 03:14

World's tiniest violin.

user1492757084 · 03/03/2024 01:58

It's fair enough that you start paying off your student loan.

I always think that paying that off should be tax deductable.

blueshoes · 03/03/2024 01:35

BungleandGeorge · 03/03/2024 00:33

Because when you factor in the high admin costs of the ridiculously complex system it’s probably cheaper to make it universal.

True.

And it avoids ridiculous tax cliff edges arising due to means testing. It cuts out the complexities of claiming for NI credits and paying it back - I know some people get caught out by this.

It also makes higher rate tax payers feel like they are getting something back for all the taxes they pay which is no small thing because they feel valued as a part of society and not just taken for granted as a tax money tree.

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 03/03/2024 01:13

trekking1 · 03/03/2024 01:01

Well why are you having a third child then. There is a simple solution to this - don't have kids you can't afford

Excuse me? where have I said I can’t afford the three children I’ve planned for?! I can 100% afford them and that’s not my point of the thread….

OP posts:
SevenSeasOfRhye · 03/03/2024 01:09

I've also found that the 40% tax rate means pay jumps at senior levels tend to be bigger

Certainly true where I work. The last sub £100k pay band starts at around £80k and the next one starts at around £120k.

trekking1 · 03/03/2024 01:01

Well why are you having a third child then. There is a simple solution to this - don't have kids you can't afford

Futb0l · 03/03/2024 00:58

The "cliff edge" of losing CB hurts. But once you are through it its worth it. longer term, earning more = student loan paid off sooner, more into pensions. I've also found that the 40% tax rate means pay jumps at senior levels tend to be bigger so that any pay rise accompanying a promotion is worth it in terms of pounds in your pocket.

bonzaitree · 03/03/2024 00:56

I think you should definitely keep working at your career hard and as much as possible irrespective of earnings.

You’re the main earner so it’s really important that your career progresses.

As other posters have said, sadly going part time indicates you don’t want to progress. And aren’t willing to work hard enough or at all. Your children aren’t going to care if you change their nappies a couple more times a day- frankly they won’t remember. They will care if you can afford to pay their uni and house deposit however. Plus you should advance your career for YOU.

Mumwithbaggage · 03/03/2024 00:53

Child benefit aside, my dd1 (29, no kids yet, higher tax payer) got a 20% bonus last year. So much of it went in tax or student loan! This year her 9% bonus will likely go the same way. At least she gets bonuses - wisely, none of my children have chosen to follow me into teaching 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread