Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
KidsDr · 03/03/2024 09:14

SodOffbacktoaibu · 03/03/2024 09:03

I hate this glib idea that anyone who is a high earner works super hard and we're all capable of getting there if we just put the effort in, and that high earners contribute more and take less out.

That is fundamentally the Tory position to justify keeping wealth and not distributing it more equally.

Plenty of people earning minimum wage or just low earnings work very hard for it. Many of them are highly educated. However, even if they're not we need bin men, posties, hospital porters, admin, teaching assistants, charity workers etc. I don't want people doing those important jobs to be living in poverty.

The system is not always fair but you can't keep giving people benefits when they're earning more than double the average. Taxation needs an overhaul, and our childcare is ludicrously expensive in this country. Let's hope we get this after the election.

They definitely need to do something about single parents. We are massively disadvantaged, not only in child benefit.

But these threads and the ones about private schools always keenly show inequality on Mumsnet. It's like another world when I read what some mnetters think is normal and they're entitled to. Life isn't fair. But we could try and make it fairer. People complaining when their joint household income is 70k+ have no idea.

It's true that there isn't a great relationship between hard work / merit / value to society and income.

But that doesn't alter the reality that it is dysfunctional and perverse to disincentivise anyone, in any income bracket, from doing productive work.

A cleaner on minimum wage gains nothing by a professional on a higher wage choosing to work less, earn less and pay less tax because of poor incentives created by a perverse system of benefits and tax. In fact, everybody loses.

And the (majority of) the political elite are not in this game "on the same team" as high earners. Their wealth is created from assets and investments, which are minimally taxed, and produce nothing for society (and in fact may be hugely damaging to society).

High earners who vote Tory are just as misled as low earners who vote Tory. They are not the party for people who earn their income through productive work. People who work for a living, however much they earn, should consider themselves on the same team Vs the asset-owning class who do not rely on productive work for their income.

NotARealWookiie · 03/03/2024 09:13

You aren’t being unreasonable.

You’ll get lots of “my heart bleeds” type comments though, these are from people who would clearly be happy to do £25ks work and give it all to the tax man 🙄

caringcarer · 03/03/2024 09:12

Mmmm19 · 02/03/2024 21:09

I’ve just had a big jump in salary from 45 to 70ish k and feel the same. Had worked hard passing professional exams and going extra mile whilst still trying to be a good mum and we feel stretched to max at home. I also have huge student debts. Partner also works very hard but earns less. It will have pushed me to 55k this tax year So will need to repay some child benefit and I’m wondering why I didn’t think to reduce my hours - especially as my nursery fees have jumped massively from 54/day 2 years ago to 74/day now. As a staunch labour supporter I get it’s probably hypocritical- I do support high taxation but not cliff edges like this. Honestly finding it hard to work the long unpaid hours and wondering why bother

Edited

It's not too late to pay £5k into your pension before April 5th.

Vod · 03/03/2024 09:11

rainydays03 · 03/03/2024 09:08

I think the tone of your message came across that way but fair enough if you weren’t - you see it on here all the time, it’s like people prefer it if somebody isn’t in a high paid job and they are on benefits!

Anyway, the point of the post wasn’t that she didn’t want to earn over £50k at all, it was that she is almost penalised in other ways for doing so in the forms of taxes and childcare etc which is absolutely true.

Additionally, the poster's comparison to an NMW job was silly, because that's clearly not one of the options OP is picking from. She's talking about whether there's any point her working 4 days a week instead of reducing her hours a bit more.

rainydays03 · 03/03/2024 09:08

Got2getout · 02/03/2024 23:47

I’m not bashing OP for having a good career; I’m disagreeing with the idea that there is “no point in earning over £50k”. I think it’s absolutely fine for OP to have a well paid job. I think it is silly to think that there is no benefit to having such a salary.

I think the tone of your message came across that way but fair enough if you weren’t - you see it on here all the time, it’s like people prefer it if somebody isn’t in a high paid job and they are on benefits!

Anyway, the point of the post wasn’t that she didn’t want to earn over £50k at all, it was that she is almost penalised in other ways for doing so in the forms of taxes and childcare etc which is absolutely true.

ChristmasLightsAndSparkles · 03/03/2024 09:06

VampireWeekday · 03/03/2024 00:06

It used to be, didn't it?

I've realised from this thread, actually, that I'm an idiot and I'm completely fucked for next year. I started a part time job because I didn't think I'd get a full time one, and ended up with an overlap. Because of how it's paid, it will all be paid in the next tax year. Feel like crying! I've worked my arse off this year and will end up significantly worse off. what even is the point.

The system makes no sense. Why is there such a random cut off point, and why is it SO harsh? There is no way that someone earning 50k is so much better off than someone on 48k, that it would make sense to charge them double the tax. How is someone on 50k comparable to someone on 110k. It would make way more sense to have it as 25% at 50k, 30% at 60k, 35% at 70k, and so on.

Don't panic @VampireWeekday- I think you've misunderstood how the 50k 'cliff edge' works.

It isn't that income tax doubles on your whole salary. We already do tax in bands: you pay the tax at that band level only for the parts of your income that falls in that band.

If you earn £52k, you still pay nothing on your first £12,570, then you pay 20% on the next £37,700 income, and then you pay 40% on income above that (above £50,271).

So on £49k income you get £38k take home pay and at £51k you get £39,383 take home pay.

The reason people call it a cliff edge is that child benefit tapers off. You pay back 1% of your child benefit for each £100 you earn over £50k. And that means that the marginal rate of tax - which is the percentage tax you pay on the last £1 you earn - gets really high. You're still going to end up better off, but just not by as much as you would expect. If you add in extra student loan repayments, you can reach the point where for every £100 extra you earn, you're only £30 better off. That's 70% marginal tax... but of course over your whole income you're paying a much lower percentage (because most of your income is taxed at 20%, and some no tax at all).

BUT, if getting that extra £100 pre-tax income costs you anything (extra childcare, extra commuting) then you may be worse off (since you only get £30 of it). If you have to work extra hours for it, you might decide you're not enough better off to make up for having less time with your family.

So don't panic - you're unlikely to end up significantly worse off next year because of your jobs overlapping. You might just not get to keep as much of the extra as you expected.

If you say what your earnings are in each job, when you get them, and what it's meant for you in terms of extra costs someone on here can help you figure out what it means for you.

And well done for getting the full time job!

SodOffbacktoaibu · 03/03/2024 09:03

I hate this glib idea that anyone who is a high earner works super hard and we're all capable of getting there if we just put the effort in, and that high earners contribute more and take less out.

That is fundamentally the Tory position to justify keeping wealth and not distributing it more equally.

Plenty of people earning minimum wage or just low earnings work very hard for it. Many of them are highly educated. However, even if they're not we need bin men, posties, hospital porters, admin, teaching assistants, charity workers etc. I don't want people doing those important jobs to be living in poverty.

The system is not always fair but you can't keep giving people benefits when they're earning more than double the average. Taxation needs an overhaul, and our childcare is ludicrously expensive in this country. Let's hope we get this after the election.

They definitely need to do something about single parents. We are massively disadvantaged, not only in child benefit.

But these threads and the ones about private schools always keenly show inequality on Mumsnet. It's like another world when I read what some mnetters think is normal and they're entitled to. Life isn't fair. But we could try and make it fairer. People complaining when their joint household income is 70k+ have no idea.

Vod · 03/03/2024 09:02

BIossomtoes · 03/03/2024 08:56

She doesn’t provide any services. She’s got three kids, that’s using all the tax she pays.

Nope, you're conflating whether someone provides services with whether they're a net contributor. They're not at all the same thing. If a person is eg a care worker with 4 DC, they're not likely to be a net contributor but that doesn't mean they aren't providing services that would be missed by someone if they chose to reduce their hours.

Jovacknockowitch · 03/03/2024 09:02

Scarletttulips · 03/03/2024 08:26

This boils my piss. I earn £34 000 in the voluntary sector. I have two degrees, work very hard at what I do

Then play the game and get a better paid job, with 2 degrees you should be contributing more tax to help those less fortunate.

😂😂

Mumsanetta · 03/03/2024 09:01

KidsDr · 03/03/2024 08:41

You are viewing this as a high earner Vs low earner issue, but it isn't.

Of course people shouldn't make rude remarks... But the OP hasn't. She hasn't told lower earners not to have children. I know that people do sometimes say this and you're quite right it's very unreasonable. However, you have literally projected these remarks onto OP to justify your position of being rude and unreasonable about her choice to have children. This way of debating doesn't elevate anyone!

At the end of the day, if working longer/harder doesn't yield sufficient rewards for the OP, she won't do it. Therefore she will be less productive, and pay less tax. You will not benefit from this. Lower earners will not benefit from this. People on benefits won't benefit from this. The salary she chooses not to earn won't be diverted into your salary. Society as a whole is damaged by perverse disincentives to productive work, even if they only affect relatively high earners (actually, the same problem can crop up for low earners too at the intersection between benefits and minimum wage).

Edited

Very well said.

KidsDr · 03/03/2024 09:01

BIossomtoes · 03/03/2024 09:00

Way to miss the point. 🙄

What was your point?

BIossomtoes · 03/03/2024 09:00

KidsDr · 03/03/2024 08:59

Yes, and her three children will also earn and pay tax when they are adults. The education and health services they use are not an investment in the OP, but in her children themselves, for them to become productive individuals in the future. They aren't receiving anything more than each and everyone of us born and raised in this country has received. You are attempting to count their costs against the OP without counting their contributions.

Edited

Way to miss the point. 🙄

KidsDr · 03/03/2024 08:59

BIossomtoes · 03/03/2024 08:56

She doesn’t provide any services. She’s got three kids, that’s using all the tax she pays.

Yes, and her three children will also earn and pay tax when they are adults. The education and health services they use are not an investment in the OP, but in her children themselves, for them to become productive individuals in the future. They aren't receiving anything more than each and everyone of us born and raised in this country has received. You are attempting to count their costs against the OP without counting their contributions.

BIossomtoes · 03/03/2024 08:56

Vod · 03/03/2024 08:20

That's exactly what OP is considering, since she mentions in her OP that she may reduce her hours.

Which, if Hunt doesn't fix this with the Budget on Wednesday, is a good idea for her. Bit unfortunate for the Exchequer though, and for any of us who might need whatever services it is that she provides. Hence the wider problem. The 50-60k marginal tax rates serve as a disincentive for parents to work, and they need addressing asap.

She doesn’t provide any services. She’s got three kids, that’s using all the tax she pays.

Vod · 03/03/2024 08:55

KidsDr · 03/03/2024 08:41

You are viewing this as a high earner Vs low earner issue, but it isn't.

Of course people shouldn't make rude remarks... But the OP hasn't. She hasn't told lower earners not to have children. I know that people do sometimes say this and you're quite right it's very unreasonable. However, you have literally projected these remarks onto OP to justify your position of being rude and unreasonable about her choice to have children. This way of debating doesn't elevate anyone!

At the end of the day, if working longer/harder doesn't yield sufficient rewards for the OP, she won't do it. Therefore she will be less productive, and pay less tax. You will not benefit from this. Lower earners will not benefit from this. People on benefits won't benefit from this. The salary she chooses not to earn won't be diverted into your salary. Society as a whole is damaged by perverse disincentives to productive work, even if they only affect relatively high earners (actually, the same problem can crop up for low earners too at the intersection between benefits and minimum wage).

Edited

All of this.

The heart bleeds people are the equivalent of the ones complaining that people on UC won't do more hours, on the benefits threads. In both cases, they're failing to see the wood for the trees. People respond to incentives, and unfortunately we have a system that sprinkes a lot of disincentives to work, both for high and low earners. We need to fix that for all our sakes, regardless of anyone's subjective view about who's taking the piss.

Fairygoblin · 03/03/2024 08:50

ohpumpkinseeds · 03/03/2024 08:20

It's one of those things isn't it - I was earning over that when I had my first child so I've never claimed child benefit, and therefore never had it to "lose". With any means tested benefit there's going to be a sore spot where you "lose" it. But actually, it means you don't "need" it and that's a good thing surely?

Yes exactly this! People complained when everyone got it and wanted it means tested and now that it is means tested they complain about the cut off point!

Tailfeather · 03/03/2024 08:42

LucyLaundry · 02/03/2024 21:14

Happy to swap?

Some people really don't know their own privilege.

Not privilege. Probably has worked, and bow works really hard for it.

Tailfeather · 03/03/2024 08:41

missmollygreen · 02/03/2024 21:10

My heart bleeds

🙄

KidsDr · 03/03/2024 08:41

WithACatLikeTread · 03/03/2024 08:30

I am not sure why people on disability should be grateful to you high earners. Isn't being disabled hard enough that they also lose their pride too?

I think OP should have known how expensive childcare was and suck it up. You chose three. If you can tell a low earner not to have children if you can't afford them I am certainly saying it to you.

You are viewing this as a high earner Vs low earner issue, but it isn't.

Of course people shouldn't make rude remarks... But the OP hasn't. She hasn't told lower earners not to have children. I know that people do sometimes say this and you're quite right it's very unreasonable. However, you have literally projected these remarks onto OP to justify your position of being rude and unreasonable about her choice to have children. This way of debating doesn't elevate anyone!

At the end of the day, if working longer/harder doesn't yield sufficient rewards for the OP, she won't do it. Therefore she will be less productive, and pay less tax. You will not benefit from this. Lower earners will not benefit from this. People on benefits won't benefit from this. The salary she chooses not to earn won't be diverted into your salary. Society as a whole is damaged by perverse disincentives to productive work, even if they only affect relatively high earners (actually, the same problem can crop up for low earners too at the intersection between benefits and minimum wage).

Countrylife2002 · 03/03/2024 08:39

Either you give back through your actual work (and earn less), or you earn more and give back through tax. I do agree that the CB rates are unfair as regards single earner and double earners though, it should be based on total household income.

Wonderfulstuff · 03/03/2024 08:39

Pension, GAYE or Cycle to Work would all be useful - go treat yourself to a whizzy electric bike! :)

HMW1906 · 03/03/2024 08:33

Yourethebeerthief · 03/03/2024 06:17

@blueshoes

And it avoids ridiculous tax cliff edges arising due to means testing. It cuts out the complexities of claiming for NI credits and paying it back - I know some people get caught out by this

Can you explain what you mean? I have 4 years of not full years on my NI contributions (university) that I can buy back. I find all of this stupidly complicated so currently need to work out if that's worthwhile to do.

Past two years I have credits as I stopped working to look after my son. Do I have to pay something back here too?

We are now in a situation of my husband earning £60K and I'm trying to understand what we do about child benefit as well. Stopping it altogether seems simplest.

It's incredibly unfair that if one person earns nothing and the other earns £50K you are charged. But both people earn £49,999 you don't. What kind of nonsense is that?

If earning over 60k you need to stop child benefit asap if you’re still receiving it, you will need to pay back if you have been receiving it whilst he’s been earning over £60k. I know someone who ended up owing a couple of thousand as they didn’t realise the cut offs. But even though you won’t be receiving the child benefit money you still get the ‘credits’ for it for your NI so make sure it’s in your name if you’re not working so that you get the credits from it. You need to phone them asap and get it sorted.

Countrylife2002 · 03/03/2024 08:32

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 03/03/2024 08:26

For people that work hard and don't see the reward? Yet you can not work and be given house / money / child benefit etc....

Lots of us work hard and don’t see the reward - as our salaries are not as high. Your salary is not representative of how hard you work or even of your educational achievements. Many of us work in the voluntary sector and give back this way but we are on lower salaries as a result. I work hard and am highly educated. Also a better paid job is not necessarily a ‘better job’.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 03/03/2024 08:32

Exasperateddonut · 02/03/2024 21:13

Fill up your pension. Find out about any salary sacrifice your company does.

All those ‘my heart bleeds’ types…. Remember that well paid jobs are needed in society. Not everyone has the skills to be a CEO. The higher you get the longer you’re usually out between jobs/contracts as it’s a very different market. These people are paid well for a reason. More risk, more responsibility, more flexibility required. Envy is a sad thing.

Also, isn’t this what we want for women, to have middle class money problems instead of always been the low or no earners? Don’t ask for social mobility then kick people down for moving upwards!

Countrylife2002 · 03/03/2024 08:31

missmollygreen · 02/03/2024 21:10

My heart bleeds

Yup

Swipe left for the next trending thread