Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
leafybrew · 03/03/2024 10:03

@whistleblower99 - hmmm? So you're not commenting on this thread whilst sitting on your arse?

Get out in the world and be more productive - leading by example is always best.

laclochette · 03/03/2024 10:02

Highly recommend this article by tax expert Dan Neidle too.

https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2023/09/24/70percent/

"If I was a Tory Chancellor, I wouldn’t abolish inheritance tax. I’d fix the ridiculous marginal rates that mean there are hundreds of thousands of 30-somethings paying more than 70% tax on every additional £ they earn.

"This is complicated, unfair and a disincentive to work; it could also plausibly be holding back growth. Any government serious about fixing the tax system should start here..."

"And if your reaction to this is “I don’t care about people earning £50k or £100k a year”, then you should.

"It’s more people than you’d think. After the recent surge of inflation, something like 23% of taxpayers earn £50,000 and 6% earn £100,000.

"But that’s a snapshot, and also not quite the right measure. A better question is: what proportion of households will at some point have someone in a position to accept a promotion, or work more hours, and break the £50k or £100k barrier? I’m not aware of any figures on this, but I expect the answer is a large percentage, perhaps even a majority.

"There’s an obvious impact on all of us if plumbers, doctors, IT contractors etc are turning away work/hours to avoid hitting £50k/£100k."

Cutting 70%+ marginal rates should be a Tory priority

If I was a Tory Chancellor, I wouldn’t abolish inheritance tax. I’d fix the ridiculous marginal rates that mean there are hundreds of thousands of 30-somethings paying more than 70%

https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2023/09/24/70percent

SodOffbacktoaibu · 03/03/2024 09:57

Alcyoneus · 03/03/2024 09:52

You probably already do. Vote for people who put soundbites like these.

The bit missing is how to achieve this utopia.

Edited

I haven't heard any politician speak in these terms. Rutger Bregman is pretty good at challenging them. He has some interesting ideas.

We've already said we need an overhaul of the tax system.

Alcyoneus · 03/03/2024 09:52

SodOffbacktoaibu · 03/03/2024 09:46

You can. I share it! Flowers

I'll vote for you... @KidsDr for PM 😉

You probably already do. Vote for people who put soundbites like these.

The bit missing is how to achieve this utopia.

Alcyoneus · 03/03/2024 09:50

You are not wrong OP. Taxation is why productivity is low as people are loathed to put too much effort in for so little return.

But the less you earn, the less tax you pay. Unfortunately proponents go high tax would rather stay poor as long as everyone else is too. Crabs in a bucket.

SodOffbacktoaibu · 03/03/2024 09:46

KidsDr · 03/03/2024 09:38

Get you completely and I completely agree.

If I was to imagine my perfect society, everyone would live in a reasonably minimum level of comfort. We would have strong communities and would feel proud and appreciated for our roles within them. Pride and a sense of community would motivate people to work, not poverty. People choosing to undertake a higher amount of work (which includes the time spent on gaining skills / experience), or more unpleasant, dangerous, risky or responsible work would earn more to compensate them. As much unpleasant work would be automated as possible, and the profits resulting from automation would be a public asset. Individual asset based wealth would diminish instead of accumulate over time. We wouldn't need giant assets many multiples of our annual income merely to live in comfort and security (housing crisis). All children raised in my perfect society would be cherished and encouraged to thrive.

I haven't quite worked out the fine detail of how to make my vision happen yet 😅but I can dream right?

You can. I share it! Flowers

I'll vote for you... @KidsDr for PM 😉

Newusernameforthiss · 03/03/2024 09:41

YANBU, scroll down and look at this chart. The system is so broken 🫠https://www.contractorcalculator.co.uk/marginal_tax_rates_explained.aspx

Enjoy more time with them now, it sounds like you've thought about this really sensibly, it's not you, it's the system!

Marginal tax rates explained - how much tax you really pay revealed!

You pay very different marginal tax rates depending on your earnings and business/personal circumstances.

https://www.contractorcalculator.co.uk/marginal_tax_rates_explained.aspx

MidnightPatrol · 03/03/2024 09:39

The high cost of living combined with the freezing of tax thresholds is becoming a disincentive IMO.

The combination of higher rate tax + student loan has meant many ‘higher earners’ have been stung with a 50%+ tax rate on earnings of £50k for years now. Plus the loss of child benefit and basic pension contributions… and you can be a couple of hundred quid better off a month for a £10k salary increase.

I agree, what’s the point and why isn’t the government addressing something so clearly punitive / a disincentive to work.

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/03/2024 09:39

Vod · 03/03/2024 09:29

Although not for child benefit. Which acts as even more of a disincentive to work for OP.

You're right. That £15.90 a week is more than enough to cover all costs for another child. I'm sure there will be a stampede.

KidsDr · 03/03/2024 09:38

SodOffbacktoaibu · 03/03/2024 09:23

@KidsDr You make a very good point and I agree, taxation needs to change. I know what you mean about disincentives. I just find some comments here galling. I hate the "I earn 70/80/100k because I work harder and I'm cleverer" attitude and that others could do the same if only they were less lazy. That's just untrue.

Get you completely and I completely agree.

If I was to imagine my perfect society, everyone would live in a reasonably minimum level of comfort. We would have strong communities and would feel proud and appreciated for our roles within them. Pride and a sense of community would motivate people to work, not poverty. People choosing to undertake a higher amount of work (which includes the time spent on gaining skills / experience), or more unpleasant, dangerous, risky or responsible work would earn more to compensate them. As much unpleasant work would be automated as possible, and the profits resulting from automation would be a public asset. Individual asset based wealth would diminish instead of accumulate over time. We wouldn't need giant assets many multiples of our annual income merely to live in comfort and security (housing crisis). All children raised in my perfect society would be cherished and encouraged to thrive.

I haven't quite worked out the fine detail of how to make my vision happen yet 😅but I can dream right?

whistleblower99 · 03/03/2024 09:37

You can predict this thread. Women tearing down women for being successful and daring to earn slightly over the average wage. Privilege 🤣

If people were less bitter (it’s the same ones) and the spent less of their time on their arses on mumsnet. They maybe more productive to society. Instead of spending day in day out being bitter and angry at other women for earning slightly above average.

The problems with this country; all in one thread.

Loloj · 03/03/2024 09:36

Some people are bashing you on here for complaining but can understand where you are coming from. I am earning around a similar level but I opted into a salary sacrifice scheme for a company car so it brings me back down to £50k. Before that I put extra into pension. It’s all very well people making statements like “my heart bleeds” but it is annoying when you work hard over the years but each small incremental pay rise seems be worth less and less.

It’s a big jump in tax when you get into 40% territory and it’s hasn’t increased in line with inflation so more and more people are falling into this bracket purely because of incremental pay rises (which are not even in line with inflation) and paying more tax as a result.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 03/03/2024 09:35

I get where you are coming from OP. It's also daft that you could have a household income of 2 x £49,999 with both working and this is not going to impact child benefit but having one person working and earning over £50k does.

WithACatLikeTread · 03/03/2024 09:33

Vod · 03/03/2024 09:29

Although not for child benefit. Which acts as even more of a disincentive to work for OP.

Child benefit is included in benefit caps so they do penalise having lots of kids and not working.

Vod · 03/03/2024 09:29

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/03/2024 09:28

There is a 2 child limit so it wouldn't make any difference.

Although not for child benefit. Which acts as even more of a disincentive to work for OP.

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/03/2024 09:28

ThinWomansBrain · 02/03/2024 22:48

just stay home, have more kids, claim benefits, feel proud of yourself

There is a 2 child limit so it wouldn't make any difference.

Got2getout · 03/03/2024 09:27

rainydays03 · 03/03/2024 09:08

I think the tone of your message came across that way but fair enough if you weren’t - you see it on here all the time, it’s like people prefer it if somebody isn’t in a high paid job and they are on benefits!

Anyway, the point of the post wasn’t that she didn’t want to earn over £50k at all, it was that she is almost penalised in other ways for doing so in the forms of taxes and childcare etc which is absolutely true.

I can see that the OP feels penalised for crossing the threshold. My issue was with the idea that there was “no point”. OP has a couple of options and each of these have pros and cons. Only the OP can decide which option suits them best based on their circumstances and priorities. They can reduce hours and enjoy more family time, or they can stay as they are and have a greater chance of career development, more pension etc. The key thing is that OP has options. They can choose what to do, because there are positives and negatives to either option. So there is a point.

I’ve no objections whatsoever to OP earning at that level, or any other, working more, or less. Yes the system is long overdue a complete overhaul, yes it is frustrating that part-time working can ruin career prospects, yes childcare is a substantial expense which puts pressure on families. But as crap and unfair as the system is, you’re still better off being a middle earner than a low one, even if only for the luxury of having options.

Vod · 03/03/2024 09:27

rainydays03 · 03/03/2024 09:23

Exactly! Granted it doesn’t make any sense that to earn just a little bit over £50k (not sure exactly
on the figures) would make you worse off
financially than if you earned a little bit under but such if life i guess.

Some posters just can’t bear the thought that someone on a better salary may still have real,
validated concerns like everyone else 🤷‍♀️

Yes, so much of the discussion on any of the perverse incentives boils down to posters saying those people should just work anyway and not consider what they get out of it, because I want them to. It's precisely the same on threads where people are horrified that UC recipients don't work more for the sake of working rather than for any tangible benefit. It's absolutely idiotic.

SodOffbacktoaibu · 03/03/2024 09:23

@KidsDr You make a very good point and I agree, taxation needs to change. I know what you mean about disincentives. I just find some comments here galling. I hate the "I earn 70/80/100k because I work harder and I'm cleverer" attitude and that others could do the same if only they were less lazy. That's just untrue.

rainydays03 · 03/03/2024 09:23

Vod · 03/03/2024 09:11

Additionally, the poster's comparison to an NMW job was silly, because that's clearly not one of the options OP is picking from. She's talking about whether there's any point her working 4 days a week instead of reducing her hours a bit more.

Exactly! Granted it doesn’t make any sense that to earn just a little bit over £50k (not sure exactly
on the figures) would make you worse off
financially than if you earned a little bit under but such if life i guess.

Some posters just can’t bear the thought that someone on a better salary may still have real,
validated concerns like everyone else 🤷‍♀️

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/03/2024 09:23

BotDranning · 02/03/2024 21:50

You have no idea. The jealousy in this post is palpable. If YOU want more do something to go earn it. Its funking irritating to work hard, earn a good salary then get half of it taken to pay for those that don't.

It's even more irritating to work just as hard and earn nowhere near that level.

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 03/03/2024 09:19

WouldURatherWinkieOrFinger · 02/03/2024 21:11

Voted YABU because you proved your title to be wrong in the OP. There isn’t no point to it. It is rubbish but you’re still better off than if you actually earned under £50k. But yes, putting more into pension is a good idea.

Exactly. And taxation is what runs the country. My bonus took me into that bracket so I lost 52% of it to tax and NI. But I still kept 48% of it!
You can't please some people.

midgetastic · 03/03/2024 09:19

I don't believe that you give everything over. 50k to the tax man

I dont believe your take home is the same as someone earning a penny less than 50K even taking into account child benefit

That's just hyperbole

So you earn more when you get a higher salary but if you don't think it's worth it go get a lower paid job

Pludoniyum · 03/03/2024 09:19

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/03/2024 09:17

I didn't realise there were private A&E departments for life threatening emergencies and you get to them by ringing private emergency services. Are the sirens and flashing lights the same when you earn more or is it a classier sound?

Besides which plenty of high earners do still use public services. Our household income is circa 180k and we don't do private medical care or private education.

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/03/2024 09:17

Exasperateddonut · 02/03/2024 21:15

Not really. High earners pay WAY more tax at every turn. They spend more - more VAT. They employ more services - paying NI and tax. They don’t use public services - schools/medical care.

I didn't realise there were private A&E departments for life threatening emergencies and you get to them by ringing private emergency services. Are the sirens and flashing lights the same when you earn more or is it a classier sound?

Swipe left for the next trending thread