Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 10:31

It’s unintended consequences. But let’s face it, it’s something that affects a small number of people for a limited period, just like the WASPI women. It’s intensely irritating during the period you’re affected and you forget all about it as soon as you’re not.

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 10:24

TerroristToddler · 04/03/2024 10:17

And whilst not a tax, when you hit this bracket (£100k) you also lose:

  • "tax free childcare" scheme, so not £1 of the childcare payments you pay are tax-free
  • Important to note also that this scheme replaced the old Childcare Voucher scheme (same principle - a small portion of money you pay for childcare is tax-free) which doesn't/didn't have the £100K limit applied, so newer parents are disadvantaged in comparison to parents who had kids a bit earlier (pre-2018/9 I think) when childcare voucher scheme was still around.
  • No entitlement to 30hours free childcare (or any of the new 15 hours free for under 2s/9month olds etc.).

Removal of these schemes actually results in taking home LESS than if you were on a lower salary.

All these are removed at a cliff edge - no tapering down like you see for child benefit. If you earn £100K you are no longer entitled to any of it at all..... and you also lose your tax personal allowance at the same time. And yet we wonder why so many GPs and other professionals are opting to work part-time and refuse to take on more hours!

I'm not sure how much longer the government can have their heads in the sand on this one, as more and more people are being impacted by it.

How have we managed to create a tax system whereby the top 5% pay 100% tax on 25% of their earnings, if they have a couple of preschoolers.

Of all the groups to excessively penalise, seems a strange one.

TerroristToddler · 04/03/2024 10:17

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 09:34

You pay 60% tax on income between £100-125k, due to the removal of the personal allowance.

And whilst not a tax, when you hit this bracket (£100k) you also lose:

  • "tax free childcare" scheme, so not £1 of the childcare payments you pay are tax-free
  • Important to note also that this scheme replaced the old Childcare Voucher scheme (same principle - a small portion of money you pay for childcare is tax-free) which doesn't/didn't have the £100K limit applied, so newer parents are disadvantaged in comparison to parents who had kids a bit earlier (pre-2018/9 I think) when childcare voucher scheme was still around.
  • No entitlement to 30hours free childcare (or any of the new 15 hours free for under 2s/9month olds etc.).

Removal of these schemes actually results in taking home LESS than if you were on a lower salary.

All these are removed at a cliff edge - no tapering down like you see for child benefit. If you earn £100K you are no longer entitled to any of it at all..... and you also lose your tax personal allowance at the same time. And yet we wonder why so many GPs and other professionals are opting to work part-time and refuse to take on more hours!

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 04/03/2024 10:09

Agreeable · 04/03/2024 09:30

So basically you're happy to work less and take the child benefits, which I would say aligns with a lot of peoples views.

Then they moan when tax and national insurance are increased by govt.

I agree the system is screwed and it shouldn't be that way but that doesn't mean you have to do it yourself.

Yes pretty much! I understand it’s not for the ‘greater good’ but if theres no financial benefit for my family or I, why on earth would I choose to put my children in breakfast/after school club & nursery 5 days per week? When I could work 3 days for similar overall finances, or 3 days over 4 and be able to pick my children up at 3:15 rather than half 5/6?

OP posts:
MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 09:34

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 08:42

The poster I responded to reckoned she was paying 60% tax, plus NI and losing child benefit. Nobody pays 60% tax alone. It’s also completely misleading to rebrand loss of a benefit as a tax.

You pay 60% tax on income between £100-125k, due to the removal of the personal allowance.

Agreeable · 04/03/2024 09:30

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:43

Just posted this summary in reply to another poster regarding going back full time. For the extra stress I’m not sure its worth it while the kids are young!

If I go back full time 40hours per week at £78k, I’d take home £47 k per year overall.
Working just 24 hours a week at 60% equivalent and staying below 50k means £36k with child benefit.

£11k is a massive difference but after the additional childcare for three kids for 2 days per week and traveling costs it would mean financially we’d not be much better off and children would be home less.

So basically you're happy to work less and take the child benefits, which I would say aligns with a lot of peoples views.

Then they moan when tax and national insurance are increased by govt.

I agree the system is screwed and it shouldn't be that way but that doesn't mean you have to do it yourself.

Groundhoghcg · 04/03/2024 09:28

OP's problem is the cost of childcare.

Alainlechat · 04/03/2024 08:54

I disagree. The marginal rate is a disincentive to work, increases pension contributions around that mark so actually reducing tax collection. It's collected through paye but it's not a tax charge?

It disincentivises the earner in the same way we hear all the time on here about people not upping their part time hours due to the loss of benefits.

Over 50k I took home 31p for every pound earned. Collected through paye by HMRC.

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 08:42

Alainlechat · 04/03/2024 08:33

The marginal tax rate in the Uk can easily be more than the top rate of 45%. I was paying a marginal rate of 69% between 50 and 60k due to the loss of child benefit.

Depending on the circumstances over 100k there are similar if not worse marginal rates.

The poster I responded to reckoned she was paying 60% tax, plus NI and losing child benefit. Nobody pays 60% tax alone. It’s also completely misleading to rebrand loss of a benefit as a tax.

Alainlechat · 04/03/2024 08:33

The marginal tax rate in the Uk can easily be more than the top rate of 45%. I was paying a marginal rate of 69% between 50 and 60k due to the loss of child benefit.

Depending on the circumstances over 100k there are similar if not worse marginal rates.

bombastix · 04/03/2024 07:43

@TempestTost - I don't disagree that subsidy of wages has to end. The current arrangements are mad. Part time work being subsidized by government policy also has to end. These are policies we can't afford long term.

I am all for certain laws being reviewed like anti union provisions, zero hours and policies like EMA being reintroduced.

But the idea the UK government should be subsidizing wages and facilitating part time working arrangements is mad. It shouldn't. Socialism for employers. A hot mess. And very expensive, and discentivizes work.

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 07:36

Where are you paying 60% tax @FreeZor? It’s not in the UK where the top rate’s 45%. I’d also query how it can possibly be that a family with three people with disabilities could pay more in tax than they take out. There are numerous non means tested benefits available to people with disabilities, why aren’t you claiming them?

Then there’s this

But that means 75-80% of people earn less than £50k!

Well, we know that. In many cases it's because they are pensioners, or students.

You do know that only working people are included in those stats? No statistician, no matter how amateur, is going to skew their results by including the non working population. And you have the bare faced audacity to call others economically illiterate.

WithACatLikeTread · 04/03/2024 06:52

FreeZor · 04/03/2024 00:47

I have been considering for some time cutting my hours as the marginal benefit in net income decreases the more hours I work. I had sat on the fence about this for many reasons (including that I've happily paid a lot more in tax than I ever used in services, as I think that is reasonable on a higher income).

However, with the ever rising taxes, the enormous discrimination in the tax system against single parents (almost all women, so what a surprise), and then finding that the services I was supposedly paying for do not exist when my disabled children need them: state education is a joke and has treated them appallingly due to their disabilities, absolutely vile behaviour from their school. The NHS may as well not exist and I've had to fund all of their treatments and operations privately, etc. I have had enough. I am not a cow and will no longer be milked.

Then I've been reading this thread and the disgustingly ungrateful comments about people like me, who worked 80-90 hour weeks all through our 20s and early 30s before having children, took exams that most posters here wouldn't have a hope in hell of passing, then are told we are "privileged" and "lucky" to pay 91% taxes and anyone could do what I have done. And I did all this while disabled myself. You know what? Fuck them.

This thread has tipped the balance for me, when I'd been trying to make a decision for a while. I shall be cutting to part time, so goodbye to another chunk of the tax revenue funding all of these ungrateful people outraged at the people who fund what they take for granted. I shall hugely decrease the extent to which I do so now and will spend some more time with my children instead.

And this is happening across the economy. Carry on with the bile though, and enjoy getting increasingly poorer as a result. 😘

Yeah right.

TempestTost · 04/03/2024 01:23

bombastix · 03/03/2024 16:38

Btw you can see this same narrative about "why should rich people get state pensions" etc coming along the same lines.

It is very effective because it amounts to "you pay in and get nothing, others pay nothing and get benefits". Because that is the financial reality.

What you want to do is incentivise higher rate taxpayers to be more productive. You want them to earn more to contribute to public services and the welfare state. If you drift towards an American system where public services are really only for the poorest then there is no buy in from those who earn the most. And you need them to pay up!

I think that to some extent you can argue this both ways.

If we take out people who are really unable to work for whatever reason, if we notionally took away all state benefits and tax advantages from working people, what we'd see is a situation in which employers would have to pay the real value of people's work in order to get workers.

Would that be better for workers? I don't know, but I think in some way it creates a more honest set of choices about things like, should I work more, or spend more time caring for kids when they are young. In reality whatever benefits the state gives to encourage both parents in o work, that choice will still present itself at some point, like the OPs case. And maybe its's better to leave it to the parents to make that calculation which will be about not just the money but also the kids and quality if life for the family, rather than having the state try and push what it thinks is best which will always be about the money.

More importantly I think it's much better if employers are on the hook for the real costs of workers.

I di think some kinds of benefits are probably worthwhile - the idea that it is logical for society as a whole to contribute to caring for kids is perhaps a good example of that kind of thing.

But I'm just not sure that creating solidarity by having the state administer universal monetary benefits to the population at large is ever going to get away from creating weird artificiality. And in any case at a certain income level people must realize that while they may be receiving the benefit but they are also paying for it, for themselves and others as well.

FreeZor · 04/03/2024 00:47

I have been considering for some time cutting my hours as the marginal benefit in net income decreases the more hours I work. I had sat on the fence about this for many reasons (including that I've happily paid a lot more in tax than I ever used in services, as I think that is reasonable on a higher income).

However, with the ever rising taxes, the enormous discrimination in the tax system against single parents (almost all women, so what a surprise), and then finding that the services I was supposedly paying for do not exist when my disabled children need them: state education is a joke and has treated them appallingly due to their disabilities, absolutely vile behaviour from their school. The NHS may as well not exist and I've had to fund all of their treatments and operations privately, etc. I have had enough. I am not a cow and will no longer be milked.

Then I've been reading this thread and the disgustingly ungrateful comments about people like me, who worked 80-90 hour weeks all through our 20s and early 30s before having children, took exams that most posters here wouldn't have a hope in hell of passing, then are told we are "privileged" and "lucky" to pay 91% taxes and anyone could do what I have done. And I did all this while disabled myself. You know what? Fuck them.

This thread has tipped the balance for me, when I'd been trying to make a decision for a while. I shall be cutting to part time, so goodbye to another chunk of the tax revenue funding all of these ungrateful people outraged at the people who fund what they take for granted. I shall hugely decrease the extent to which I do so now and will spend some more time with my children instead.

And this is happening across the economy. Carry on with the bile though, and enjoy getting increasingly poorer as a result. 😘

FreeZor · 04/03/2024 00:26

winterplumage · 04/03/2024 00:11

Yes, it does sound frustrating and if your motivation for working is the extra money then it's natural not to feel motivated when you're not seeing higher returns for the additional hours.

However, the comments (not the OP) pretending people with lower pay don't work as hard (or harder in some cases) or couldn't manage to do the same job are offensive and unacceptable. Yes — some well-paid jobs involve astrophysics phds, but many are civil service or managerial or a multitude of other jobs that most of us could do given the circumstances, opportunities and experience, so, even if the OP's job is highly skilled and difficult, it's not ok to generalise.

But as I've pointed out, many have achieved such things from difficult circumstances. Why do these bitter people not go and seek the opportunities and do the hard work to get the experience if they believe they are sufficiently skilled to do it? Or, if they do not have the skills or are too lazy to do it then they should be grateful to those that do and therefore subsidise their lives through tax, or at least shut the hell up with their "tiny violin" sarcastic bullshit, or their woe is me excuses.

I'm sure all such comments really make the higher earners here even more inclined to sacrifice yet more time with their children to go out and work harder so they can hand over the vast majority of their additional earnings from this extra work to fund such people even more.

FreeZor · 04/03/2024 00:20

No, the benefits poor people receive are often paid for out of the NIC they paid in- many benefits are contribution based on what you have paid in.

Business and employers pay in NIC as well which funds out of work or furlough or low pay benefits as well for poor people.

In addition, poor people also pay taxes that then fund their benefits when they fall below the threshold.

Most of what high earners pay in taxes goes toward public services which they benefit from as much as any poor person- pensions for the elderly, NHS, police, fire service, roads/infrastructure, schools, utilities, transport, etc.

So many economically illiterate posts on here. Over 50% of the population don't pay anything close to covering their own costs. The asset wealthy pay very little as a percentage and higher earners on PAYE/ in the professions are being taxed to obliteration with some of the highest marginal tax rates in the world, which in many countries would be illegal because those with higher incomes pay less as a percentage.

These people have been subsidising everyone else for years and have been milked to the extent that they are cutting their hours and declining promotions. Economic studies have demonstrated this. This makes everyone poorer and means lower overall tax revenues. And meanwhile they are being excluded from accessing what should be universal services like childcare, despite them funding it for everyone else.

If you want the decent public services as you see in many countries e.g. elsewhere in Europe, the difference is that their low and middle income earners pay far higher tax rates. There is no other way to fund it: it's mathematically impossible.

Meanwhile the wealthy (clue: these people mostly aren't employees as they do not have to work for money - although some exceptions like our Prime Minister choose to do so on a short-term basis as a stepping stone to further his network and business opportunities) also should pay a lot more. But that won't fix the problem because even if they did, due to their numbers it wouldn't raise enough.

Perhaps study some economics and maths and look at the data before making such foolish and demonstrably false comments in future.

winterplumage · 04/03/2024 00:11

Yes, it does sound frustrating and if your motivation for working is the extra money then it's natural not to feel motivated when you're not seeing higher returns for the additional hours.

However, the comments (not the OP) pretending people with lower pay don't work as hard (or harder in some cases) or couldn't manage to do the same job are offensive and unacceptable. Yes — some well-paid jobs involve astrophysics phds, but many are civil service or managerial or a multitude of other jobs that most of us could do given the circumstances, opportunities and experience, so, even if the OP's job is highly skilled and difficult, it's not ok to generalise.

FreeZor · 04/03/2024 00:10

bombastix · 02/03/2024 23:38

God the husband earned it! Give over with women claiming on what her husband earns. It's not 1950. The OP started out talking about she was affected in terms of her earnings.

And this!! I agree, it's pathetic. 🙄

FreeZor · 04/03/2024 00:03

But that means 75-80% of people earn less than £50k!

Well, we know that. In many cases it's because they are pensioners, or students. But in many cases it's because they choose to work part time and let the rest of us "top them up". Or not work at all, but still expect to be able to access all services paid for by taxpayers. Then have a go at the people funding them when they object to marginal tax rates of 70- over 100%.

No wonder more higher earners are leaving the UK every year.

FreeZor · 03/03/2024 23:58

T0E · 02/03/2024 22:15

But... what do you do? What qualifications do you have? Why not apply for a better paid job?

Not everyone is given the same life opportunities, some people have issues with learning or caring responsibilities. They didn't go to good schools and have happy families that encouraged them.

And as for this deterministic nonsense, I can't even...

My childhood was appalling and abusive. My school was one of the worst in the country.

Always these excuses from people to justifiy their hatred of people who have studied and worked extremely long hours to establish well-paid careers, many of whom are from equally hard or even harder circumstances than them. Instead it is bite the hand that feeds you, you should be bloody grateful to work for 9% of what you earn! And no gratitude whatsoever to the people who are funding everything for everyone else, over 50% of whom don't even cover their own costs to society in services.

And people wonder why UK productivity is so low.

FreeZor · 03/03/2024 23:50

I think the poster you were quoting is misplacing their anger. But you're bang out of order to suggest that earnings are directly linked to work ethic. You think that Rishi Sunak or Boris fucking Johnson work harder than a single mother with two SEND kids who can't be in two places at once and has lost her career? Or someone with a disability that has impacted their earnings potential? Or someone with caring responsibilities? Or any number of other circumstances that mean people are stuck in low wage jobs.

God, will people stop this?

I am a lone parent. I am disabled. I have two disabled children. I earn over £100k and get hammered by this tax cliff-edge. And no, it won't go away when they're older because they can't do holiday clubs or group childcare so I have to pay private nannies and will continue to have to do so at least until they finish primary school, meaning a childcare bill as high as most people have for children in nursery. Housing costs where I need to live for work are £2,500 per month for a modest family home. Therefore, we are broke after housing and childcare. And yet if I increase my earnings to fund what they need, I will be taxed 91% on it (60% income tax, 2% NI, 9% student loan, 20% loss of "tax free" childcare).

A single parent with two children has to earn over £150k to be left with the same net income as a couple both earning the average UK salary of £37k, after tax and childcare.

It should be obvious this is ridiculously discriminatory and unfair to individuals, but also that it is damaging to the economy. And clearly I'm not going to sacrifice even more time ans energy and health on working more/ taking on more stressful roles and getting even less time with my children to keep 9% of the extra money I earn.

VampireWeekday · 03/03/2024 19:37

ChristmasLightsAndSparkles · 03/03/2024 09:06

Don't panic @VampireWeekday- I think you've misunderstood how the 50k 'cliff edge' works.

It isn't that income tax doubles on your whole salary. We already do tax in bands: you pay the tax at that band level only for the parts of your income that falls in that band.

If you earn £52k, you still pay nothing on your first £12,570, then you pay 20% on the next £37,700 income, and then you pay 40% on income above that (above £50,271).

So on £49k income you get £38k take home pay and at £51k you get £39,383 take home pay.

The reason people call it a cliff edge is that child benefit tapers off. You pay back 1% of your child benefit for each £100 you earn over £50k. And that means that the marginal rate of tax - which is the percentage tax you pay on the last £1 you earn - gets really high. You're still going to end up better off, but just not by as much as you would expect. If you add in extra student loan repayments, you can reach the point where for every £100 extra you earn, you're only £30 better off. That's 70% marginal tax... but of course over your whole income you're paying a much lower percentage (because most of your income is taxed at 20%, and some no tax at all).

BUT, if getting that extra £100 pre-tax income costs you anything (extra childcare, extra commuting) then you may be worse off (since you only get £30 of it). If you have to work extra hours for it, you might decide you're not enough better off to make up for having less time with your family.

So don't panic - you're unlikely to end up significantly worse off next year because of your jobs overlapping. You might just not get to keep as much of the extra as you expected.

If you say what your earnings are in each job, when you get them, and what it's meant for you in terms of extra costs someone on here can help you figure out what it means for you.

And well done for getting the full time job!

Edited

Thank you SO much for taking the time to write this, I really was panicking - you're right, I'd completely misunderstood, I stayed up until 1am googling it and still didn't find anything that explained it all as clearly as you just did. Seriously, thank you!

In my case I'll earn just above the threshold, which is annoying in terms of the child benefit but as you say I won't actually be worse off, which is what I was worrying about. I won't keep as much salary as I would have liked but in my particular case I'm just happy to have a steady income, so I'm not too upset - it's more than I would ever normally earn so it won't make a huge difference to my expectations that I can't keep it all.

Now I understand the system properly I actually am not convinced that the system is so unfair - it doesn't seem to be true that there's no point earning over 50k, you still have more money, it's just that you have to work harder or more hours for less extra on top. But having an entire take home salary of 80% (excluding loan repayments) up to 50k doesn't seem that bad.

Katemax82 · 03/03/2024 19:17

missmollygreen · 02/03/2024 21:10

My heart bleeds

The sentiment of a lot of people who don't earn what some consider a high wage buts it's not really

noctilucentcloud · 03/03/2024 19:05

laclochette · 03/03/2024 19:01

@Poniesandpigs@Tevion1213 Yup, more than 1/5 people - nearly 1/4 actually - earn over £50k so it's not really a "high" salary, thanks to rampant inflation.

Edited

But that means 75-80% of people earn less than £50k!

Swipe left for the next trending thread