Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 13:51

You've said having children is a choice and parents don't have a gun to their head.

I do not understand why it is reasonable for a parent earning <£100k to get childcare support, while parents earning >£100k get nothing.

As has often been repeated on these pages - this meaning someone earning £99k is better off than someone earning £140k if they have two children. And - they will still be spending 80% of their income on childcare.

You are not giving a rational answer to exclude these people from accessing this benefit other than how you feel about it emotionally. You comment on these threads about this issue frequently and there are gaping holes in your argument, so you cannot be surprised people are challenging your view.

Vod · 04/03/2024 13:48

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 10:31

It’s unintended consequences. But let’s face it, it’s something that affects a small number of people for a limited period, just like the WASPI women. It’s intensely irritating during the period you’re affected and you forget all about it as soon as you’re not.

This particular bottleneck is. But you miss out two important parts of the picture.

The first is that because of inflation and fiscal drag, the numbers are going to increase if nothing is done. That means more people facing a situation that can be an incentive to work and earn less, which is a problem in a society with our worker shortage and tax base.

The second is that it's only one of a number. Taken in isolation, a specific example such as the one OP faces, someone who doesn't take more hours at work to avoid going over the FSM threshold or the 30 hours free childcare threshold won't affect a lot of people no. But we have lots of these, sprinkled across the income spectrum. It's a potentially substantial problem, and it does no good to focus on only a single one in isolation. We need tax and benefits systems that address this.

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 13:39

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 13:35

So what do you propose then, no help for anyone with children at all because ‘they haven’t had a gun to their head’?

Allow children to grow up in poverty, women pushed out of the workforce, an even further decreasing birth rate (We went from 1.55 to 1.49 just last year).

And as for the introduction of pension ages being random - incredibly annoying yes, but as is the case on student loans (no time for parents to save), the sudden inability to afford housing due to inflation of asset values etc. I have a friend who took a loan out to afford to go back to work with 2 under 3 - and now the free hours have been introduced for example.

I think it’s odd you think your issue should have been managed better and be treated with more empathy… but this? These women ‘didn’t have a gun to their head’. More empathy for others situations required here I think.

You’re just being utterly ridiculous now. I don’t believe in subsidising the child care of people earning £100k+. I do think people on low incomes should have subsidised childcare. I do believe single parents are unfairly treated. I really can’t make it any plainer than that so please stop with the “So you think …” when I’ve said nothing of the sort.

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 13:35

So what do you propose then, no help for anyone with children at all because ‘they haven’t had a gun to their head’?

Allow children to grow up in poverty, women pushed out of the workforce, an even further decreasing birth rate (We went from 1.55 to 1.49 just last year).

And as for the introduction of pension ages being random - incredibly annoying yes, but as is the case on student loans (no time for parents to save), the sudden inability to afford housing due to inflation of asset values etc. I have a friend who took a loan out to afford to go back to work with 2 under 3 - and now the free hours have been introduced for example.

I think it’s odd you think your issue should have been managed better and be treated with more empathy… but this? These women ‘didn’t have a gun to their head’. More empathy for others situations required here I think.

Larasbra · 04/03/2024 13:21

missmollygreen · 02/03/2024 21:10

My heart bleeds

Give it a rest

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 13:18

Of course it’s a choice. Nobody holds a gun to people’s heads to force them to have children.

It's funny that you on the one hand think it's unfair for women to not be able to retire at 60 supported by the state potentially for 30+ years

I don’t think that. Equalisation of state pension age was the right and proper thing to do. The issue is that all the women affected by two changes in 15 years should have been treated more fairly. The random nature of the process was bizarre - a whole bunch of women of similar age had vastly different retirement ages - I missed out on three months’ pension by seven hours!

Morph22010 · 04/03/2024 13:15

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 07:36

Where are you paying 60% tax @FreeZor? It’s not in the UK where the top rate’s 45%. I’d also query how it can possibly be that a family with three people with disabilities could pay more in tax than they take out. There are numerous non means tested benefits available to people with disabilities, why aren’t you claiming them?

Then there’s this

But that means 75-80% of people earn less than £50k!

Well, we know that. In many cases it's because they are pensioners, or students.

You do know that only working people are included in those stats? No statistician, no matter how amateur, is going to skew their results by including the non working population. And you have the bare faced audacity to call others economically illiterate.

There is an effective tax rate of 60% when someone goes over £100k, actual tax rate is 40% but they also lose £1 of person allowance for every £2 above £100k, the tax due on each £1 over £100,000 works out to 60% until full personal allowance is lost

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 12:59

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 12:34

Why is use of schools, hospitals, pensions, other public services universal - but not pre-school childcare?

Because preschool childcare is a choice.

To be a net contributor, you need to earn >£50k anyway.

That depends, doesn’t it? If you’re a childless, healthy person of working age you’ll be a net contributor at a lower salary point.

Preschool childcare isn't 'a choice' for the vast majority.

For people to afford to pay their bills, have a home etc, you need two wages in this day and age.

It's funny that you on the one hand think it's unfair for women to not be able to retire at 60 supported by the state potentially for 30+ years... but simultaneously don't want people with children to have any state support wile they are young, as that's 'a choice'.

We need to invest in the future of the country, not just endlessly funnelling money into the pockets of pensioners.

justteanbiscuits · 04/03/2024 12:48

No one is forcing you to work the hours you work. If it is financially better to work less hours, work less hours.

before returning to work after mat leave I did a spreadsheet and worked out the optimum hours. Working 3 x 9 hour days is worked best, financially, so that is what I did.

So, the answer is, work less hours!

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 12:34

Why is use of schools, hospitals, pensions, other public services universal - but not pre-school childcare?

Because preschool childcare is a choice.

To be a net contributor, you need to earn >£50k anyway.

That depends, doesn’t it? If you’re a childless, healthy person of working age you’ll be a net contributor at a lower salary point.

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 12:26

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 12:16

Single parents earning half the income of a dual household shouldn't be ineligible for a benefit, when a household with twice the annual income is.

I couldn’t agree more. Just as I disagree with the rest of your points. Having children is expensive and I see no reason why we should subsidise the top 1% of the population in the case of £100k+ salaries.

A) The top 1% earn over about £180k a year. To earn over £100k is now about 4% of earners

B) To be a net contributor, you need to earn >£50k anyway. So those people not receiving child benefit, tax free childcare etc are actually the people funding all of this. They are not being subsidised by anyone, quite the opposite.

'Why should we subsidise X' is a very dangerous line of thinking IMO. If you stop people being able to use the welfare state, access the benefits they're funding, you are going to find those people might lose interest in funding it.

Why is use of schools, hospitals, pensions, other public services universal - but not pre-school childcare?

Think about it.

justteanbiscuits · 04/03/2024 12:24

You still get the 30% left over though, right? Which is more than without the bonus?!

WithACatLikeTread · 04/03/2024 12:23

Chocolateorange11 · 04/03/2024 12:01

If someone was working less hours and utilising tax credit / universal credit top ups because their family is better off, I wonder what response they’d get?

You don't need to wonder. Lots of posts about that.

Jux · 04/03/2024 12:19

Youneed to re-examine why you're following your current career path. If it's solely because you can earn lots of money, well, this is just an inconvenience and you'll getire in the end,

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 12:16

Single parents earning half the income of a dual household shouldn't be ineligible for a benefit, when a household with twice the annual income is.

I couldn’t agree more. Just as I disagree with the rest of your points. Having children is expensive and I see no reason why we should subsidise the top 1% of the population in the case of £100k+ salaries.

Scarletttulips · 04/03/2024 12:11

If someone was working less hours and utilising tax credit / universal credit top ups because their family is better off, I wonder what response they’d get?

the bus drivers did this in the 90’s

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 12:09

Total crabs in the bucket mentality @blossomtoes

Parents working full time should not be attracting 70-80% tax rates on levels of income like £50k because of a terribly designed policy of child benefit removal.

Single parents earning half the income of a dual household shouldn't be ineligible for a benefit, when a household with twice the annual income is.

Partners of high earners shouldn't be forced to stop working because of the removal of childcare support.

The cliff edge removal of childcare support means that those earning the highest incomes, they still might have to spend their entire salary on childcare costs. A loss equivalent to tens of thousands of income - privately funding what is one of the most expensive childcare systems on the planet.

The UK needs to work for everyone that lives here, and that involves creating tax policy (and child support initiatives) for people at all income levels.

If the middle classes are struggling to afford a family, the country is in big trouble. The gap between parents in apparently well-paid jobs and those with government support is getting increasingly small.

Chocolateorange11 · 04/03/2024 12:01

If someone was working less hours and utilising tax credit / universal credit top ups because their family is better off, I wonder what response they’d get?

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 12:00

I don’t need to do any research. It’s patently obvious what the situation is with mortgages and childcare. We have an adult child currently in the trenches. They recognise that it’s a temporary situation and they’ll be much better off when the youngest starts school. My sympathy is with families who have to deal with the same issue on much lower incomes.

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 11:55

The situation for WASPI women who weren't properly aware of pension changes is unfortunate but in no way equivalent to this.

I mean - the people with this childcare cliff edge issue / child benefit issues won't be getting a state pension until they're 70s (if, to be frank, at all). We are all being stung by the rise in pension eligibility.

You are frequently on these threads objecting to progressive policies for families, I suggest you do a little research into the cost of a mortgage and childcare for two at 2024 rates - we have some of the most expensive childcare in the world.

It is a failure of the state if it is unaffordable people to have children - let alone people who technically are very high earners.

It should be shouted from the rooftops, high inflation will bring more and more into child benefit and childcare benefit removal thresholds in the coming term.

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 11:39

'It doesn't impact many people' isn't a reason to accept a 100%+ tax rate on people

That’s what the WASPI women whose pensions were reduced twice said. It got us precisely nowhere. High earners with preschool age children are far more unlikely Tory voters than a bunch of women over 60. They don’t give a shit, there aren’t enough votes in it to make any difference.

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 11:34

It's not a minuscule percentage of those paying high levels of tax, and incentivising this group to pay less tax / cut hours / reduce their career progress is irrational - and points to our productivity issue.

'It doesn't impact many people' isn't a reason to accept a 100%+ tax rate on people. It's clearly unfair, and having a negative impact on tax take, parents ability to go back to work (if they have a higher earning partner), peoples longer term career prospects etc.

And - given the freezing of tax thresholds this will be impacting more and more people every year.

It's an ill thought out policy and given the Conservatives must think this is a group which might actually vote for them, their thinking on this is very odd.

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 11:25

I know it’s a permanent feature. Nonetheless it affects a small number of people who have preschool age children. The kids start school and the problem goes away. I saw somewhere that it affects about 300,000 people at any one time, that’s a miniscule percentage of the workforce.

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 11:18

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 10:31

It’s unintended consequences. But let’s face it, it’s something that affects a small number of people for a limited period, just like the WASPI women. It’s intensely irritating during the period you’re affected and you forget all about it as soon as you’re not.

Not really, this is a permanent feature of the tax system.

And - it disincentivises work among those paying the most tax, which is counterproductive.

JaninaDuszejko · 04/03/2024 10:35

Usernameisnotavailable0 · 03/03/2024 19:02

Does anyone know how much you can earn and still get 100% CB. Is it £50k (gross minus pension)

Example = salary is £57k pension paid 4k. A further 3k salary needs to be paid into pension pot to be entitled to 100% CB.

If you work where you get a 'one off' bonus that would all need to go into pension too?

It's £50K + tax free childcare (up to £2K per year per child) + pension payments (up to £60k per year) + salary sacrifice benefits + charitable contributions + investments in Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) or Venture Capital Trust (VCT). So you could be on a really high salary but had everything arranged so you didn't pay high rate tax or lose your child benefit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread