Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Vod · 04/03/2024 18:22

Oh I forgot this, here's a Treasury Committee report, drawn up by a multi party group, discussing cliff edges and explaining why they're a problem.

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm5803/cmselect/cmtreasy/1425/report.html#heading-0

Vod · 04/03/2024 18:20

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 17:02

The fact that you've not even mentioned what might have the most positive impact on tax take or the worker and skills shortages we currently face says it all.

To be fair you haven’t either. Maybe tell us your ideas instead of constantly making personal attacks? It would make for a much more interesting debate.

Hardly, the idea that we need to be considering these things specifically and giving them much greater priority than people's sympathies is my whole and repeatedly stated point.

But don't just take my word for it, some good stuff about the importance of addressing our marginal tax rates problem here. The mention of child benefit is about halfway down.

https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/britain-needs-better-taxes-rather-than-just-higher-ones-to-boost-fairness-and-economic-growth/

Notice there's nothing in here claiming that none of the people involved are single parents.

Here's a report from the Resolution Foundation on the particularly perverse incentives faced by those families who both face child benefit withdrawal and receive UC, a small but growing group.

https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/inconsistent-incentives/

They characterise this as a problem, a serious design flaw and something the government will have to fix.

This is a year old now, but the situation hasn't materially changed and it gives a useful range of examples across the income spectrum. It specifically mentions taxation as a reason for middle and higher income couples finding work not to be financially worthwhile.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/13/full-time-part-time-work-no-longer-pays-uk-economy

There's loads more, these are just the ones I found quickly. Presumably the existence of a tight labour market, skills shortage and the principle that it would be good if we could fill vacancies are generally agreed?

Britain needs better taxes, rather than just higher ones, to boost fairness and economic growth • Resolution Foundation

https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/britain-needs-better-taxes-rather-than-just-higher-ones-to-boost-fairness-and-economic-growth

DoodleDoo37 · 04/03/2024 18:13

I'm sorry and I know I'll get flamed for this - but this is exactly what is wrong in the UK - and why we are in such trouble economically - people just refusing to maximise their potential. So why work and contribute more to the tax coffers when you can get the tax payer to sudsidise you with child benefits etc.... surely your student loan is payable regardless of how much you get paid - and because of it you are in a better paid job! It annoys me when I see people complaining because their salary means they pay more tax - of course you do - it's proportional - why don't you go full time and aim to get your salary and therefore bonus above the 78k or start making massive contributions to your pension for when you retire and reduce your tax liability - (or do you expect the future tax payer to pay 100% for that as well) - or invest the extra into an ISA and make back a bit extra on interest tax free....... people like this baffle me - and the next thing they'll say is how expensive everything is..... and how the cost of living is impacting their lifestyle..... but if more people don't step up and go out to work - this country will be absolutely finished in 10-15 years - economically we are sitting on a time bomb!

Mazanna123 · 04/03/2024 18:12

WingsofRain · 02/03/2024 21:24

I’ve worked hard all my life and currently get £12k a year. I’ll swap for your £70k+ if you like.
Or even the £50k, actually. 👍🏻

Assuming you dont work full time for £12k per year.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 04/03/2024 18:02

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 04/03/2024 15:31

That’s the key difference though isn’t it - you’re out of the childcare years and I’m in the thick of it at the moment. So it therefore makes more sense for me to choose to work less as the financial difference is negligible for the additional amount of stress 5 days vs 3 would be.

I’m sure when I have all three at school or at least eligible for the 30 free hours in 2025/6 it will make more sense to up my hours, but while it’s not I may as well make the choice to work less and be around more. If the child benefit wasn’t needed to be repaid (circa £3k a year for three kids) it would influence my decision, but it really feels like a double whammy when also creeping into the higher tax bracket.

Anyway, I don’t really believe I’m ‘stamping my foot’ as you’ve put it, I’m just more puzzled by the government and reassessing my priorities!!

I mean drop your hours by all means, I got the sense you didn't actually want to do that though, but were saying it was an option as then you get to keep the child benefit? Is the child benefit equal or more than the amount of bonus you are getting? Is the amount your husband earns equal to or more than the amount you're paying in childcare? Because surely it would make more sense for him to reduce hours than you?

But it's up to you of course. Whatever you think is best. Personally I wouldn't do part time in my role as I just know it would mean I'd be working out of hours which I am not willing to do.

Leedsfan247 · 04/03/2024 17:59

You only pay the 40% on everything above £37k

Scarletttulips · 04/03/2024 17:55

I don’t believe in subsidising the child care of people earning £100k+. I do think people on low incomes should have subsidised childcare. I do believe single parents are unfairly treated

Nonody should have subsidized childcare - everyone should earn enough to pay their own - which means companies are using the giverment to shore up its workers.

By giving you a temporary pay rise with under 3’s you are grateful, but that money should be in your account every month - paying your own way.

This was the worse thing the labour government brought in, keeping the lower paid in lower wages and expecting them to be grateful for crumbs.

whistleblower99 · 04/03/2024 17:23

These threads are like Groundhog Day. Same unemployed and retired posters on here ALL day explaining how paying 70% marginals is acceptable. Not thinking long-term about how this is a vary precarious issue wrt to tax take and state funding. Madness.

newusern99 · 04/03/2024 17:14

I did my self assessment to pay the child benefit tax charge due to going over this year. By the time I’d entered my gift aid charity donations hmrc owed me money instead 🙄

NoCloudsAllowed · 04/03/2024 17:03

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 16:45

Where do you think these 60 / 70 / 80 / 90 / 100% tax thresholds should be kicking in then?

As this is what many high (and not so high) earners are facing at present.

I don't know, I'm not the chancellor.

I do know child poverty is growing through. And it's not because mummy has to pay 70% tax on the last 30% of her annual bonus.

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 17:02

The fact that you've not even mentioned what might have the most positive impact on tax take or the worker and skills shortages we currently face says it all.

To be fair you haven’t either. Maybe tell us your ideas instead of constantly making personal attacks? It would make for a much more interesting debate.

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 16:45

NoCloudsAllowed · 04/03/2024 16:34

Well, your kids won't be young forever.

Student loan is a debt you took on and will be paid off one day.

Child benefit - reasonable to focus this on lower income groups.

Payment of tax - who do you think should pay, if not high earners?

Where do you think these 60 / 70 / 80 / 90 / 100% tax thresholds should be kicking in then?

As this is what many high (and not so high) earners are facing at present.

Vod · 04/03/2024 16:44

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 16:30

When the discussion is about child benefit or free nursery hours, the response will be about need and greed.

That’s a perfectly rational response. If additional money’s going to be given to anyone I’d prefer it to go to single parents - who get a really shit deal at all income levels - and/or people who are really struggling. Not those with very high incomes who can afford to work less to minimise their tax deductions. That’s not an option that’s open to someone on minimum wage or an average income.

Nah, it's not.

You've assumed that single parents and people with incomes high enough to be affected by either the child benefit bottleneck or the 100k hours are two separate groups. They are not. You even admit yourself that they get a shit deal at all income levels, and yet posters who piously froth about how their hearts bleed frequently fail to exclude single parents caught in these income traps from their complaints.

Additionally, the sweeping claim about what options are affordable to who is is silly when people on average incomes experience such wildly varying housing and childcare costs. That's true in any discussion about affordability and choices.

And lastly, it inherently ignores the underlying problems with our tax system. The fact that you've not even mentioned what might have the most positive impact on tax take or the worker and skills shortages we currently face says it all. It's another example of people refusing to think beyond where their sympathies lie. Merely making that assumption at all is a logic fail, even if you'd done a better job of it.

underthebun · 04/03/2024 16:41

Payment of tax - who do you think should pay, if not high earners?

Far too much on PAYE though which is part of the problem vs other income

NoCloudsAllowed · 04/03/2024 16:34

Well, your kids won't be young forever.

Student loan is a debt you took on and will be paid off one day.

Child benefit - reasonable to focus this on lower income groups.

Payment of tax - who do you think should pay, if not high earners?

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 16:30

When the discussion is about child benefit or free nursery hours, the response will be about need and greed.

That’s a perfectly rational response. If additional money’s going to be given to anyone I’d prefer it to go to single parents - who get a really shit deal at all income levels - and/or people who are really struggling. Not those with very high incomes who can afford to work less to minimise their tax deductions. That’s not an option that’s open to someone on minimum wage or an average income.

justteanbiscuits · 04/03/2024 15:48

kikilaw · 04/03/2024 15:20

Its a massive issue. Also for those of us earning over £100k we are paying an effective rate of 62% up to £125k (with the loss of the personal allowance) and on top losing all childcare assistance.

Its all well and good saying put it in your pension but some of are already making provision for our future and need the money today.

I have no problem with payment of fair share - but 62 % (i think it is 67 in scotland) isn't fair and is totally out of kilter with most western economies and way too complicated.

but you're not paying 62% on it all. You only pay the higher rates on money over the threshhold.

Don't get me wrong. I think child care costs in this country are completely ridiculous. When I went back to work after my second, until the 15 hours for my first kicked in, I was paying more in childcare than I was earning!

justteanbiscuits · 04/03/2024 15:46

Katherina198819 · 04/03/2024 14:00

Yes, you have all the right to be upset as it is absolutely ridiculous!
The worst is when you earn over 50k as it won't allow you for any essential help and have to pay an insane amount of tax. Earning 50-70k these days is not as glamorous as some people might think- governement should really acknowledge this!
I will also go back to part-time after my maternity leave for this exact reason. Don't see the point to work my arse off, miss time with my family while I would basically earn the same with part time.

You don't pay an insane amount of tax. You only pay the higher rate on earnings over the higher rate thresh hold.

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 04/03/2024 15:31

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 04/03/2024 14:56

I'm afraid I don't really understand your point.

You're still getting 30% of your bonus? And you've had three babies, I assume using NHS resources and will (if you're not already) using educational resources? So probably a bit of a balance of resources used and paid for (you can literally see this if you log into the Governent Gateway thing btw, it'll tell you how much of your tax is allocated where).

I mean by all means, cut off your nose to spite your face by putting it into your pension - you'll benefit then but not now from that extra cash.

And PS - I'm earning about the same as you, just commented actually on how I had to pay back most of my child benefit from last year and am no over the threshold. Difference being I guess that I am out of the childcare years so can see how the pain of childcare really is a short-term pain that must be borne out. And my husband earns just over minimum wage, but only for the last year. He was a SAHD for years as my earning capacity far outstripped his.

Stamping your foot and staying home when you don't really want to just to get child benefit isn't the answer. I can't tell if you want to or not.

That’s the key difference though isn’t it - you’re out of the childcare years and I’m in the thick of it at the moment. So it therefore makes more sense for me to choose to work less as the financial difference is negligible for the additional amount of stress 5 days vs 3 would be.

I’m sure when I have all three at school or at least eligible for the 30 free hours in 2025/6 it will make more sense to up my hours, but while it’s not I may as well make the choice to work less and be around more. If the child benefit wasn’t needed to be repaid (circa £3k a year for three kids) it would influence my decision, but it really feels like a double whammy when also creeping into the higher tax bracket.

Anyway, I don’t really believe I’m ‘stamping my foot’ as you’ve put it, I’m just more puzzled by the government and reassessing my priorities!!

OP posts:
kikilaw · 04/03/2024 15:20

Its a massive issue. Also for those of us earning over £100k we are paying an effective rate of 62% up to £125k (with the loss of the personal allowance) and on top losing all childcare assistance.

Its all well and good saying put it in your pension but some of are already making provision for our future and need the money today.

I have no problem with payment of fair share - but 62 % (i think it is 67 in scotland) isn't fair and is totally out of kilter with most western economies and way too complicated.

Vod · 04/03/2024 15:07

Stamping your foot and staying home when you don't really want to just to get child benefit isn't the answer. I can't tell if you want to or not.

Why isn't it? Dropping some hours, whether accompanied by a foot stamp or not, may very well be the answer when a person is presented with a situation where the benefits received for working don't justify the effort. OP has a number of factors to weigh up.

Vod · 04/03/2024 15:04

You are not giving a rational answer to exclude these people from accessing this benefit other than how you feel about it emotionally.

She's plenty of company. It's very often what happens when we have threads about the existence of disincentives to work more and the way people respond to them.

Posters who don't like hearing it tend to focus on why they think the people concerned should behave differently. When the discussion is about those on a low income, the response will be about self sufficiency and scroungers. When the discussion is about child benefit or free nursery hours, the response will be about need and greed.

Meanwhile, we continue to face a shortage of workers and skills across many sectors plus a precarious looking tax base.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 04/03/2024 14:56

I'm afraid I don't really understand your point.

You're still getting 30% of your bonus? And you've had three babies, I assume using NHS resources and will (if you're not already) using educational resources? So probably a bit of a balance of resources used and paid for (you can literally see this if you log into the Governent Gateway thing btw, it'll tell you how much of your tax is allocated where).

I mean by all means, cut off your nose to spite your face by putting it into your pension - you'll benefit then but not now from that extra cash.

And PS - I'm earning about the same as you, just commented actually on how I had to pay back most of my child benefit from last year and am no over the threshold. Difference being I guess that I am out of the childcare years so can see how the pain of childcare really is a short-term pain that must be borne out. And my husband earns just over minimum wage, but only for the last year. He was a SAHD for years as my earning capacity far outstripped his.

Stamping your foot and staying home when you don't really want to just to get child benefit isn't the answer. I can't tell if you want to or not.

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 14:31

I expect to have my view challenged @MidnightPatrol. It would be a very dull world if we all held the same opinions.

Katherina198819 · 04/03/2024 14:00

Yes, you have all the right to be upset as it is absolutely ridiculous!
The worst is when you earn over 50k as it won't allow you for any essential help and have to pay an insane amount of tax. Earning 50-70k these days is not as glamorous as some people might think- governement should really acknowledge this!
I will also go back to part-time after my maternity leave for this exact reason. Don't see the point to work my arse off, miss time with my family while I would basically earn the same with part time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread