Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There’s NO point earning over £50k?!

735 replies

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 02/03/2024 21:04

Because of the £50k child benefit limit and 40% tax rate!

So I earn £78,000 pro rata overall now with my job following a mid year pay rise. This includes bonus and car allowance. I work 4 days a week (80% equivalent) which brings the overall pay this year down to just shy of £50k with a £9.6k bonus.

Out of the £9.6K bonus due in March, I’ve worked out 40% will go to the taxman, over £2K will need paying back for child benefit as I’m now over the £50k threshold, and a further £800ish will go towards my student loan. Deductions of just under £6k!!! This means I’ll only take home 30% of my bonus?!

I’m now on mat leave for baby number 3. AIBU to make sure when I go back I remain under the £50k mark by reducing hours even further?! I’d then have less to pay in childcare mitigating the difference in the pay I’d receive working an extra day each week.

Its an absolute joke, I was hoping to go back to work after my last baby and push on hard with my career but what is the actual point!! I may as well work less hours, keep the child benefit and pay less in childcare!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
freespirit333 · 05/03/2024 13:05

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 19:04

It’s £1500 a year for two children. Significant for low income families.

Of course, but not comparably so if you have two working parents on £48k each. I think

TerroristToddler · 05/03/2024 11:39

Talking and bitching at each other about who works harder isn't relevant here at all and is too subjective. We all work hard when at work - I think we can agree that.

Some jobs are paid lower than others, and some jobs are paid higher. That's how it is, rightly or wrongly. Sometimes its because those higher paid jobs involved a lot of initial financial outlay to enter the profession, other times its simply that the job is a niche skill or a skill that is in demand.

Vod · 05/03/2024 11:17

cardibach · 05/03/2024 10:56

Except as a highly effective and skilled English teacher and HoD I have no idea whether it’s worth earning over £50k because I’ve never been given the option. Given the OP’s figures, I’m pretty sure it still is and I would have said yes though.

Well, given that we've still failed to curb inflation and the child benefit thresholds remain frozen at 2013 rates meaning it's lower in real terms every year, perhaps you'll get chance to find out.

The stuff about who works harder is totally stupid though, I agree with you there.

cardibach · 05/03/2024 11:08

BotDranning · 02/03/2024 21:50

You have no idea. The jealousy in this post is palpable. If YOU want more do something to go earn it. Its funking irritating to work hard, earn a good salary then get half of it taken to pay for those that don't.

It’s fucking irritating to work hard and hardly get paid anything then be accused of sponging off high earners too, I imagine (not my experience - I’ve had a professional - though not highly paid - career. I just have some awareness of the lives of others). Do you really think you work harder than someone in a minimum wage job?

cardibach · 05/03/2024 10:56

Exasperateddonut · 02/03/2024 21:13

Fill up your pension. Find out about any salary sacrifice your company does.

All those ‘my heart bleeds’ types…. Remember that well paid jobs are needed in society. Not everyone has the skills to be a CEO. The higher you get the longer you’re usually out between jobs/contracts as it’s a very different market. These people are paid well for a reason. More risk, more responsibility, more flexibility required. Envy is a sad thing.

Except as a highly effective and skilled English teacher and HoD I have no idea whether it’s worth earning over £50k because I’ve never been given the option. Given the OP’s figures, I’m pretty sure it still is and I would have said yes though.

Stevie77 · 05/03/2024 10:54

The cliff-edging of our taxation system is crap and very demoralising, regardless if it's at the £50k mark or the £100k mark, so I agree with you OP.

bombastix · 05/03/2024 10:37

Feelingstrange2 · 05/03/2024 08:55

I have semi retired to earn under 50k BUT I spent 6 years earning well over as self employed and put as much of my higher rated earnings into my SIPP pension as I could.

It's going to encourage many more people who are in the 15 years approaching retirement to go part time. The Government are just soooo blinkered to it.

Yes indeed! I am planning on exactly this basis.

Vod · 05/03/2024 09:27

WithACatLikeTread · 05/03/2024 09:19

Curious to see how this thread would have planned out if I was to say I had three kids, work but want to drop hours to get more Universal credit. 🤔

You'd get a load of moralising there too, just from a different set of posters. The insistence on centering their own sympathies rather than acknowledging that people respond to incentives would be identical.

WithACatLikeTread · 05/03/2024 09:19

Curious to see how this thread would have planned out if I was to say I had three kids, work but want to drop hours to get more Universal credit. 🤔

Feelingstrange2 · 05/03/2024 08:55

I have semi retired to earn under 50k BUT I spent 6 years earning well over as self employed and put as much of my higher rated earnings into my SIPP pension as I could.

It's going to encourage many more people who are in the 15 years approaching retirement to go part time. The Government are just soooo blinkered to it.

T0AD · 05/03/2024 08:44

We have an income of £50k between us. We don't have money to save but we do go on holidays and go out to restaurants etc. I don't feel poor

daffodilandtulip · 05/03/2024 08:41

I'm friends with a person like this and it's tedious to hear about how hard it is ... whilst living in the capital, owning a huge house, doing extensive renovations, going abroad for holidays. People seem to see these things as essentials, not privileges. It's not a list of must-haves, cut your cloth.

Vod · 05/03/2024 08:21

BIossomtoes · 04/03/2024 19:52

I know. Imagine what child benefit means to them. It’s give or take 10% of their gross income for two kids.

Unlikely. Someone on 23k with two kids would be entitled to UC top up. It could be quite substantial depending on childcare costs, whether they rent and where, but even the basic child element would be payable.

Unless of course the household has enough other income to render them ineligible, but then of course that too would make the 10% claim incorrect.

clarehhh · 05/03/2024 08:07

Pay into your pension the excess as an AVC and then take yourself below the threshold. Can change it when rules change, though this may be in the budget this week?

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 05/03/2024 07:39

WingsofRain · 02/03/2024 21:24

I’ve worked hard all my life and currently get £12k a year. I’ll swap for your £70k+ if you like.
Or even the £50k, actually. 👍🏻

You could just get a higher paid job then if it’s so easy for OP and she clearly doesn’t work harder than you? Only yourself to blame that you don’t earn more money really, if you want it go and get it, don’t berate others who have done it.

JessS1990 · 05/03/2024 07:20

DoodleDoo37 · 04/03/2024 22:48

Ok so let me explain. Most big firms - Banks / Lawyers etc - will not hire their cleaners directly - they will contract out to a cleaning company. The cleaning company will then hire cleaners (making sure they take their cut) - and the cleaners will generally get minimum wage plus benefit top ups from the Government. The person earning £125k will not work for the same company as the cleaner coming in to clean - and I would be surprised if cleaners were earning (in general) above 23k per year (but would be v happy to be proven wrong on this) - and I would also be surprised if anyone at the cleaning company was earning £125k - so they could take a pay cut - that's not how the world works I'm afraid. And generally speaking - people get paid their worth - so a lawyer say may get paid £125k as it is deemed to be a skilled job - and it is also likely they had to incur costs to become one - student debt of circa 50k plus loss of potential earnings for 3-4 years while studying - a cleaner is not deemed to be a skilled job (if you wind up falsely accused of a crime a cleaner cannot defend you) - there is a difference - whether you like it or not. And if you are going to pay a lawyer with long hours in a stressful position - 55k - but a cleaner 33k - then why bother be a lawyer? Once you add on student debt repaid at 7% interest - and the hours worked they would not be on much more than minimum wage themselves (as the Barristers who went on strike recently highlighted). Highly skilled jobs are rewarded in this manner because entry costs are high - working conditions are stressful and hours are long. Also the lawyer will have no benefits - no tax free allowance - no children's allowance - no rent allowance and the cleaner who is earning less is also receiving benefits which they are not paying tax to earn. And the tax the lawyer is paying equals 7 cleaners on 33k.

So the company still employs cleaners on the minimum wage only indirectly.
Thank you for clarifying that important point.

It does not change the fact the company has a choice as to whether to pay all its employees enough to live on without government subsidies or not. It is then a bit of if the company makes that choice and those who are paid more than they need then complain that their taxes are used to pay benefits because they are paid instead of others being paid.

khakifingers · 05/03/2024 07:20

Morph22010 · 05/03/2024 05:38

Cgt is only 20% (10% within basic rate) it’s just 28% on residential property.

Dividend Tax is 23% I think (could be less) - no matter how much you earn.

Let's be a bit clearer on dividend tax rates - less and more and it does depend on how much you earn - still making stuff up is less effort than finding out the facts - which change continually, so always best to check. 😎

  • 8.75% for basic rate taxpayers.
  • 33.75% for higher rate taxpayers.
  • 39.35% for additional rate taxpayers.
JessS1990 · 05/03/2024 06:48

DoodleDoo37 · 04/03/2024 23:11

Just one further point - say a student goes to Uni for 3 years to study to become a lawyer - meanwhile your cleaner in Utopia is on 33k a year - so that's 99k the student could have earned while they were studying. Now on top of that - they leave Uni with say 70k student debt - which is a bit on the low side - as it assumes the student can rent - pay bills - eat and travel for 3 years on roughly 16k a year. Current interest rates on student loans is 7.7% - paid back over a 15 year period - that works out to be £120k to be repaid (more if they take longer to repay) - so that's almost £220k - the student has to earn before they are in any way positive on their education....... or equal to the cleaner - who by now has been working for 3 years and doesn't have a debt (with interest) of £120k to repay. And the student will not start on £125k - far from it - a good starting salary for a trainee is probably 40-50k. And they will find it hard to buy a home while they are saddled with student debt..... so it's not all roses for those who later in life climb the corporate ranks and get to earn £125k.

Just to keep it factually accurate. It is not possible to go to uni to study to be a lawyer.
One can study a law degree, after which one would either have to take SQE or Bar exams, which means a year or two more of studying.

YoureALizardHarry11 · 05/03/2024 06:20

The ‘’get a better job’’ rhetoric always makes me eye roll 🙄. In theory it makes sense, but If everyone did, or indeed could get a better job, then two things would happen.

  1. society wouldn’t function for a lack of lower paid workers. No factory workers, no bin men, no cleaners, no public transport drivers etc and;
  2. Those higher paid jobs would no longer be as highly paid anyway as more people would have the skillsets needed.

People’s financial situation isn’t always easy to change and being in a low paid role doesn’t make them unambitious or lazy. I Sympathise with OP’s predicament, but as posters always tell low earners, sometimes you have to cut your cloth accordingly!

Morph22010 · 05/03/2024 05:38

DoodleDoo37 · 04/03/2024 19:53

Not on his income tax...... that's his salary. Dividends and capital gains are income but not earned income - and therefore are not taxed under PAYE rules - CGT is 28% - Dividend Tax is 23% I think (could be less) - no matter how much you earn. There are more forms of income apart from earned from going out to work.

Cgt is only 20% (10% within basic rate) it’s just 28% on residential property.

Morph22010 · 05/03/2024 05:35

Jeannie88 · 04/03/2024 21:59

My dh has been hit with this at 50k?

He won’t be paying all of it back at £50k though, it’s tapered so you pay a very small amount at £50k which gradually increases depending on your income and at £60k you’d have to repay the whole amount

samarrange · 04/03/2024 23:39

NoCloudsAllowed · 04/03/2024 16:34

Well, your kids won't be young forever.

Student loan is a debt you took on and will be paid off one day.

Child benefit - reasonable to focus this on lower income groups.

Payment of tax - who do you think should pay, if not high earners?

Student loan is a debt you took on and will be paid off one day.

^^This.

I get that the OP maybe doesn't want to pay her student loan back faster than she currently is, but the only disadvantage of having to do so is that she gets less benefit from her pay rise now. That extra £800 means the loan will be paid off sooner (so she will stop paying 9% of her income sooner), plus she will save having to pay the interest on that.

So, given that the debt is there anyway (the debate over whether student loans are a good idea is separate), this extra payment is more of a forced saving scheme than a loss to tax, and I don't think it's really correct to include this in the OP's calculation of how much of her pay rise is "going in tax", which to me implies "you'll never see it again".

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 04/03/2024 23:16

JessS1990 · 04/03/2024 22:27

We are expected to believe that they are so talented they are worth paying that much, but also expected to believe they are not capable of managing their money.

Not bad with money but 3x maternity leave, 3x nursery fees, mortgage to pay....

DoodleDoo37 · 04/03/2024 23:11

JessS1990 · 04/03/2024 22:26

I would love to know where these companies are that pay cleaners and other anciliary staff so well that they do not need government top ups to their wages.

Just one further point - say a student goes to Uni for 3 years to study to become a lawyer - meanwhile your cleaner in Utopia is on 33k a year - so that's 99k the student could have earned while they were studying. Now on top of that - they leave Uni with say 70k student debt - which is a bit on the low side - as it assumes the student can rent - pay bills - eat and travel for 3 years on roughly 16k a year. Current interest rates on student loans is 7.7% - paid back over a 15 year period - that works out to be £120k to be repaid (more if they take longer to repay) - so that's almost £220k - the student has to earn before they are in any way positive on their education....... or equal to the cleaner - who by now has been working for 3 years and doesn't have a debt (with interest) of £120k to repay. And the student will not start on £125k - far from it - a good starting salary for a trainee is probably 40-50k. And they will find it hard to buy a home while they are saddled with student debt..... so it's not all roses for those who later in life climb the corporate ranks and get to earn £125k.