Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH, sex & divorce

144 replies

AmIDelulu · 02/03/2024 15:57

Sorry, it's v v long!

I know AIBU can be brutal but please remember I have feelings and we are a family with young DC (8&3).

DH and I have been at logger heads for a while. I feel like he treats me like shit and he is unsatisfied with my lack of affection/sex.

We have had many 'make or break' conversations which go round in circles. I want to be treated nicely but he says the lack of affection from me frustrates & hurts him and makes him feel like he is not a husband, which causes his shit treatment of me. I say if you treat me properly then affection/sex would come naturally! Convos usually end with him being sorry and he will treat me right (without expectation). But then a few days later it starts again because he either hasn't changed or he did for a few days but didn't "see results" from me.

Today he has decided that he 'cant keep waiting' and he is fed up of his feelings not being considered. That we both have a deadline of 2 weeks to make improvements towards each other or call it quits. So he will start treating me right but I have to also give him affection/sex. If he doesn't see enough from me then he's done.

I have explained that he should want to treat me nicely/kindly/with respect and that is a basic in relationships and he should be doing that regardless. But he feels that what he wants is on par and one does not need to come before the over.

I don't feel like this is far. Why should I have to treat him above and beyond whilst he's treated me like crap. What happens if I am more affectionate/have sex and then his change (if any) was temporary. Or do I have to give it a try to know for sure? He has said no to counselling ("we know what we need to do") and will not agree to a separation ("it's just a way for people to do what they want" - wtf?!).

At the same time though I am so scared of divorce. I have no money, am a SAHM and carer for DC (8). I'd be on benefits for the rest of my life, no job would take me with the amount of appointments DC has. DC (2) adores DH and both DC adore the IL's. Would they resent me for splitting the family? Where would we live? I'd have no respite ever, it would be all me. My head is spinning......but I can't just be treated like crap forev
er can I 💔

OP posts:
ohdamnitjanet · 02/03/2024 19:16

AmIDelulu · 02/03/2024 17:42

Ooo I don't like this.

I'm not at home painting my nails. I'm looking after our 3 yr old. Also have 10 medical appointments for the other DC this month. Do you know how stressful that is with 2 kids trying to get one to do what the Dr is saying/trying to listen to the Dr and keep the little on occupied. It's not a walk in the park.

@AmIDelulu don't take any notice of @RhetoricalQuestion she’s fucking nuts and just goading you.

Dweetfidilove · 02/03/2024 19:16

I wouldn’t be with anyone who is disrespectful to me, so I’d leave him.

I also get very snappy when sex is scarce, so if that went on for an extended period, I’d leave you.

This marriage seems doomed any way, so I’d advise you start making plans. He is ready to walk and likely will, so there’s no point living on a hope and a promise in this awful situation.

MsCactus · 02/03/2024 19:15

AmIDelulu · 02/03/2024 17:44

It's interesting that this is kind of split though.

Can I ask how often you have sex? Sex have different importance to different people - I'm female but I honestly couldn't be happy in a relationship unless I had sex at least once a week. Maybe your DH is similar to me, you're not, and you're simply not compatible.

Either way it can't do either of you any good to stay together when you're both so unhappy

Floppyelf · 02/03/2024 19:15

MagicMaha · 02/03/2024 19:07

OP literally listed tonnes of reasons why she feels she can’t leave. They have a family. There are kids involved. Why do people act as if it’s just a case of packing a suitcase and driving off into the sunset amazes me infinitely

Why not? men do it all the time.

MagicMaha · 02/03/2024 19:15

MalcolmsMiddle · 02/03/2024 19:14

Having kids is not a barrier to ending a relationship. If anything it should be a stimulus in unhappy households.

Yes but it’s not a case of just “divorce him - problem solved!”
That advice is so unhelpful

MalcolmsMiddle · 02/03/2024 19:14

MagicMaha · 02/03/2024 19:07

OP literally listed tonnes of reasons why she feels she can’t leave. They have a family. There are kids involved. Why do people act as if it’s just a case of packing a suitcase and driving off into the sunset amazes me infinitely

Having kids is not a barrier to ending a relationship. If anything it should be a stimulus in unhappy households.

Floppyelf · 02/03/2024 19:13

I think at the core you are two people who aren’t meant to be together. You made the mistake of bringing children into this mess.
Posters are right… he is coercing you into sex but other posters have a valid point about you wanting the convenience he brings without being in a romantic and commited relationship.

Woman up, get some qualifications and make your own way in the world. He will have to do 50% of the medical appointments as not doing so would be neglect.

coercion is a criminal offence ( domestic abuse). Just end this farce and both move on.

Penguinmouse · 02/03/2024 19:09

Your husband should treat you with respect without the reward for that being sex.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 02/03/2024 19:08

RhetoricalQuestion · 02/03/2024 17:17

How nice for your husband OP.
He works to fund the family, enabling you to SAH, whilst you don't particularly seem to like him, aren't affectionate to him, don't have sex with him, are only with him because you'd have to go on benefits, AND, you want him to treat you nicely. What do you do for him? Genuinely?

Sure, couples should respect and be nice to each other without question, but I think I'd be pissed if my spouse saw me as their convenience and not much else.

Op is caring for their dc enabling this dickhead to work. He shouts, is passive aggressive and thinks it’s acceptable to bully his downtrodden wife into shagging him rather than actually treating her with the love, care and respect that she deserves and is standard behaviour for anyone with any conscience at all. There shouldn’t be conditions placed on behaving like a decent human being, least of all whether you get a shag that day. This fucker is a nasty piece of work who knows his poor dw has limited choices and as a result he chooses to treat her like this. He is a disgrace.

Choctrufflelover · 02/03/2024 19:08

This will probably be a very unpopular viewpoint but I was in a similar situation with DH being pretty horrible most of the time and me not wanting to have sex until he improved his behaviour towards me.
Eventually I got fed up with waiting for him to improve and it wasn't nice with him being so difficult most of the time. So I decided to just grit my teeth and get on with the sex regardless (sounds bad I know ...) We arranged a time, once a week, and however much I didn't feel like it I just got on with it anyway. Things improved quite quickly. Afterwards he was so much nicer towards me and that, in turn, made me feel closer and more affectionate towards him. Obviously he'd slip back sometimes and be nasty but then I can be the same sometimes (just having a bad day maybe ...)
I read somewhere that women need to feel loved in order to have sex whereas men need to have sex in order to feel loved. Elsewhere I've seen references to a "maintenance fuck" - maybe that's what I've been doing ...?
Anyway, it worked. It might have taken a few weeks but it was worth it.

MagicMaha · 02/03/2024 19:07

NothingVenturedAndAllThat · 02/03/2024 18:51

Look up barriers to women leaving relationships. There are hundreds. It's 2024. Are we still doing this? 🫠

OP literally listed tonnes of reasons why she feels she can’t leave. They have a family. There are kids involved. Why do people act as if it’s just a case of packing a suitcase and driving off into the sunset amazes me infinitely

MagicMaha · 02/03/2024 19:04

Sorry for quoting the OP I know you shouldn’t do that

NothingVenturedAndAllThat · 02/03/2024 19:04

lambhotpot · 02/03/2024 18:52

Their is help out there you just have to start somewhere.

There is help, sometimes, in some situations. It's not nearly as available or all-encompassing as it needs to be and some of the barriers are institutional.

MagicMaha · 02/03/2024 19:03

AmIDelulu · 02/03/2024 15:57

Sorry, it's v v long!

I know AIBU can be brutal but please remember I have feelings and we are a family with young DC (8&3).

DH and I have been at logger heads for a while. I feel like he treats me like shit and he is unsatisfied with my lack of affection/sex.

We have had many 'make or break' conversations which go round in circles. I want to be treated nicely but he says the lack of affection from me frustrates & hurts him and makes him feel like he is not a husband, which causes his shit treatment of me. I say if you treat me properly then affection/sex would come naturally! Convos usually end with him being sorry and he will treat me right (without expectation). But then a few days later it starts again because he either hasn't changed or he did for a few days but didn't "see results" from me.

Today he has decided that he 'cant keep waiting' and he is fed up of his feelings not being considered. That we both have a deadline of 2 weeks to make improvements towards each other or call it quits. So he will start treating me right but I have to also give him affection/sex. If he doesn't see enough from me then he's done.

I have explained that he should want to treat me nicely/kindly/with respect and that is a basic in relationships and he should be doing that regardless. But he feels that what he wants is on par and one does not need to come before the over.

I don't feel like this is far. Why should I have to treat him above and beyond whilst he's treated me like crap. What happens if I am more affectionate/have sex and then his change (if any) was temporary. Or do I have to give it a try to know for sure? He has said no to counselling ("we know what we need to do") and will not agree to a separation ("it's just a way for people to do what they want" - wtf?!).

At the same time though I am so scared of divorce. I have no money, am a SAHM and carer for DC (8). I'd be on benefits for the rest of my life, no job would take me with the amount of appointments DC has. DC (2) adores DH and both DC adore the IL's. Would they resent me for splitting the family? Where would we live? I'd have no respite ever, it would be all me. My head is spinning......but I can't just be treated like crap forev
er can I 💔

I would like to hear his side of the story on this. Is there anything you feel he would say about you if if he was writing this post, that you may have excluded?

Is he a good dad? Would he help out if you were divorced?

Your IL’s are not a reason to stay in a marriage. That’s only about you, DH and DC. No one else.

But if sex and affection is the ONLY issue and your relationship is otherwise fine, then would you consider opening the relationship? I know it sounds scary but adults have needs and it’s also not fair to permanently deprive someone of their biological desire. If you are clearly saying you don’t want to give that to him but he also can’t have it elsewhere then it’s just gonna cause hatred

Blackcats7 · 02/03/2024 19:01

It amazes me that women here accept horrible behaviour from men and often seem to blame any woman who dares to question anything less than full on abuse.
Who on earth would want to have sex with this man who is so blatant in the transactional nature of his “kindness”
Just yuck.
Leave him. Anything else is prostituting yourself for the sake of security which I totally understand but is that really the life you want or can sustain?

philosoppee · 02/03/2024 18:58

Life without someone putting you down and finding you irritating is always better. You can do this. You have a child with needs that means you cannot work - he will have to help support you.
You can do this without him and have a happier life.

lambhotpot · 02/03/2024 18:52

NothingVenturedAndAllThat · 02/03/2024 18:51

Look up barriers to women leaving relationships. There are hundreds. It's 2024. Are we still doing this? 🫠

Their is help out there you just have to start somewhere.

NothingVenturedAndAllThat · 02/03/2024 18:51

lambhotpot · 02/03/2024 18:49

Then why stay if its that bad.

Look up barriers to women leaving relationships. There are hundreds. It's 2024. Are we still doing this? 🫠

lambhotpot · 02/03/2024 18:49

Nanny0gg · 02/03/2024 18:46

Do you fancy people who talk to you like they've just scraped you off their shoe?

Then why stay if its that bad.

Nanny0gg · 02/03/2024 18:46

spicedlemonpie · 02/03/2024 18:21

Did you marry for love or money.
Sounds like you dont fancy him what if he didnt fancy you it would hurt.

Do you fancy people who talk to you like they've just scraped you off their shoe?

SummerAzure · 02/03/2024 18:45

Mumsanetta · 02/03/2024 18:22

I agree that his treatment of you is absolutely shameful. It’s fine to say that you need more physical contact and affection and ask if you can work towards that but it’s absolutely not ok to demand it in the way that your boss, sorry, DH, has.

It’s hard being a carer for a child. If I were you, I would tell him that you would like a divorce if that’s all he is offering and intend to ask for 50:50 split with children. That would provide you with some respite and, you never know, you might re-discover your sex drive once you are more rested and decide to test it out on a new man who sees you as more than just a hole to fvck.

I do agree with this, however the 50:50 split will only happen if her husband will agree to it. I suspect given he's used to having a wife who is a SAHM, he will run a mile. Unfortunately the system is such that you can't make a parent "parent" if they don't want to. All you can do is apply for maintenance, which if through the CMS is as we know, an absolute shambles. This man sounds like he will look for sex elsewhere as soon as they separate (if not before) and will no doubt think he's single with no responsibilities, leaving OP to continue with all the childcare. I feel for you OP. I'm not surprised you don't feel like having sex with him. Unfortunately though if this is the case I think it is over.

Nanny0gg · 02/03/2024 18:43

RhetoricalQuestion · 02/03/2024 17:17

How nice for your husband OP.
He works to fund the family, enabling you to SAH, whilst you don't particularly seem to like him, aren't affectionate to him, don't have sex with him, are only with him because you'd have to go on benefits, AND, you want him to treat you nicely. What do you do for him? Genuinely?

Sure, couples should respect and be nice to each other without question, but I think I'd be pissed if my spouse saw me as their convenience and not much else.

Enabling??

Did you see that she is a carer for one of their DC?

Angelsrose · 02/03/2024 18:41

Sadly op I think your DH falls into the category of men who hate women but love sex. There's no need for him to be rude to you. It's my personal bugbear and is certainly grounds to consider the future of your relationship.

Hmindr68 · 02/03/2024 18:25

No one should have to stay in a marriage with no affection.

LorlieS · 02/03/2024 18:24

@AmIDelulu What's stopping you from leaving him?
Do you work at all so could get a bit of money behind you?