Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH, sex & divorce

144 replies

AmIDelulu · 02/03/2024 15:57

Sorry, it's v v long!

I know AIBU can be brutal but please remember I have feelings and we are a family with young DC (8&3).

DH and I have been at logger heads for a while. I feel like he treats me like shit and he is unsatisfied with my lack of affection/sex.

We have had many 'make or break' conversations which go round in circles. I want to be treated nicely but he says the lack of affection from me frustrates & hurts him and makes him feel like he is not a husband, which causes his shit treatment of me. I say if you treat me properly then affection/sex would come naturally! Convos usually end with him being sorry and he will treat me right (without expectation). But then a few days later it starts again because he either hasn't changed or he did for a few days but didn't "see results" from me.

Today he has decided that he 'cant keep waiting' and he is fed up of his feelings not being considered. That we both have a deadline of 2 weeks to make improvements towards each other or call it quits. So he will start treating me right but I have to also give him affection/sex. If he doesn't see enough from me then he's done.

I have explained that he should want to treat me nicely/kindly/with respect and that is a basic in relationships and he should be doing that regardless. But he feels that what he wants is on par and one does not need to come before the over.

I don't feel like this is far. Why should I have to treat him above and beyond whilst he's treated me like crap. What happens if I am more affectionate/have sex and then his change (if any) was temporary. Or do I have to give it a try to know for sure? He has said no to counselling ("we know what we need to do") and will not agree to a separation ("it's just a way for people to do what they want" - wtf?!).

At the same time though I am so scared of divorce. I have no money, am a SAHM and carer for DC (8). I'd be on benefits for the rest of my life, no job would take me with the amount of appointments DC has. DC (2) adores DH and both DC adore the IL's. Would they resent me for splitting the family? Where would we live? I'd have no respite ever, it would be all me. My head is spinning......but I can't just be treated like crap forev
er can I 💔

OP posts:
kkloo · 03/03/2024 00:34

@RhetoricalQuestion

Sure, couples should respect and be nice to each other without question, but I think I'd be pissed if my spouse saw me as their convenience and not much else.

Incredible how you read the OP and didn't see that she feels the same way.

She's at home caring for the children.
The husband treats her like he doesn't like her.
But expects her to have sex with him, like she's just a convenient hole to put his penis in.

kkloo · 03/03/2024 00:26

Golden407 · 02/03/2024 23:34

A team, yes exactly, the op however doesn't really seem to see it like that, he seems more of a convenience, someone to pay the bills and maintain the status quo because it's easier than the alternative of splitting up and having to re-order your whole life.
If you don't want to be with him that's fair enough but you have to accept that means to difficult adjustments will have to be made.

Of course she doesn't see them as a team now, how can she when he treats her like shit?
They have discussed this at length, he's refusing to go to counselling, he's now given her a 2 week ultimatum.

He clearly doesn't see them as a team either!

It is perfectly fair and understandable for a mother in her situation to be terrified of a future with no respite.

As would he be if he was going to be the one left with the caring responsibility!!

He would be the one who was afraid of upsetting the status quo and having to re-order his whole life if he was the carer for the DC.

RantyAnty · 02/03/2024 23:41

RhetoricalQuestion · 02/03/2024 17:17

How nice for your husband OP.
He works to fund the family, enabling you to SAH, whilst you don't particularly seem to like him, aren't affectionate to him, don't have sex with him, are only with him because you'd have to go on benefits, AND, you want him to treat you nicely. What do you do for him? Genuinely?

Sure, couples should respect and be nice to each other without question, but I think I'd be pissed if my spouse saw me as their convenience and not much else.

He'd still be working the same with or without a family.

Golden407 · 02/03/2024 23:34

kkloo · 02/03/2024 21:04

It's a narrative that good family men will also believe btw.
They appreciate that they wouldn't be able to have their career etc without their wife at home looking after the children, and particularly if the child/children has health issues.
And they don't see their role as more important than their partners at all. They see them as a team.

A team, yes exactly, the op however doesn't really seem to see it like that, he seems more of a convenience, someone to pay the bills and maintain the status quo because it's easier than the alternative of splitting up and having to re-order your whole life.
If you don't want to be with him that's fair enough but you have to accept that means to difficult adjustments will have to be made.

Golden407 · 02/03/2024 23:27

SchoolQuestionnaire · 02/03/2024 19:08

Op is caring for their dc enabling this dickhead to work. He shouts, is passive aggressive and thinks it’s acceptable to bully his downtrodden wife into shagging him rather than actually treating her with the love, care and respect that she deserves and is standard behaviour for anyone with any conscience at all. There shouldn’t be conditions placed on behaving like a decent human being, least of all whether you get a shag that day. This fucker is a nasty piece of work who knows his poor dw has limited choices and as a result he chooses to treat her like this. He is a disgrace.

Wow, you've really worked this man from a couple of paragraphs the OP has written from her point of view.

I think you're on totally different pages and to be honest you don't seem to see him as anything other than a means to pay the bills, honestly do you love him? I'm sure he picks up on how you feel. Things change and maybe you would be better moving on separately

kkloo · 02/03/2024 23:27

Stealthmodemama · 02/03/2024 22:29

I feel exactly the same - my sex drive is higher - and when I was not getting action I was vile.

We did the love languages and realised how different we are - we worked at it and our relationship is far healthier and stronger for it ..

OP you hold the cards and have a choice..

You can give him the sex he wants and see if it improves things

Or you can not give him the sex and leave

As far as I can see there is no middle ground.

He might treat you far better if you give him sex, if you don't want to = that is fine. .. but he has been pretty clear it's what he needs/wants.

And the OP has been clear about what she wants/needs.
So it is definitely not the case that the OP holds the cards.

Because her husband expects her to have sex without giving her what she needs first.

kkloo · 02/03/2024 23:25

brunettemic · 02/03/2024 22:54

You’re just drip feeding information with things like this though. He’s clearly not in the right but neither are you. I agree, to an extent, with the post you’re replying to here.

There's no drip feeding, she literally said it in the OP that she was a carer for her ds and no job would take me with the amount of appointments DC has .

How is she not 'in the right' to not want to have sex with someone who treats her like shit?

Overwhelmedmum1 · 02/03/2024 22:56

Of course op has the right to leave if she is not happy with the situation, and if she does not want sex with her husband, then she does not need anyone’s permission to end the relationship. It certainly wouldn’t be right for her to ‘force’ herself to do it just to please him.

My only point is that if op wants to remain in her marriage, then it’s a two way street. She may have to explore her feelings around sex and address them, as it is miserable to be a highly sexed partner being rejected all of the time and this does impact the health of the relationship, rightly or wrongly.

As we are talking to op, we can only advise her. If it were her husband asking for advice, then I would advise him to consider what his attitude towards her is saying and how that could impact her desire - but he’s not asking, so we can only make suggestions to op.

So op, no one would blame you for leaving. But if you want to stay, then you have to be aware that sex is very very important.

brunettemic · 02/03/2024 22:54

AmIDelulu · 02/03/2024 17:42

Ooo I don't like this.

I'm not at home painting my nails. I'm looking after our 3 yr old. Also have 10 medical appointments for the other DC this month. Do you know how stressful that is with 2 kids trying to get one to do what the Dr is saying/trying to listen to the Dr and keep the little on occupied. It's not a walk in the park.

You’re just drip feeding information with things like this though. He’s clearly not in the right but neither are you. I agree, to an extent, with the post you’re replying to here.

AfraidToRun · 02/03/2024 22:44

I had this, left the prick. Found a new man, no problems at all with my sex drive now.

I did however have to have therapy because of years of having painful sex that I didn't want because I felt like the world's shittest partner. Ex's love was conditional on access to my body. My new partner treats my body as mine and its a privilege not a right for him to have access to it.

Codlingmoths · 02/03/2024 22:37

On the one hand while we are busy and I’m not always very in the mood, I try and have sex weekly. On the other hand I wouldn’t ever be trying to get in the mood for a man who behaved like your husband does!! Not ever.

Stealthmodemama · 02/03/2024 22:29

Overwhelmedmum1 · 02/03/2024 20:51

I understand that, but having been in the position of not having the sex and affection I wanted, and then seeing how that came out in my angry, sulky, resentful behaviour, I am somewhat identifying with the other side.

Something has to give if the relationship is to survive. As op only has control of herself, I wondered whether there were other things stopping her wanting sex e.g. lack of attraction

I feel exactly the same - my sex drive is higher - and when I was not getting action I was vile.

We did the love languages and realised how different we are - we worked at it and our relationship is far healthier and stronger for it ..

OP you hold the cards and have a choice..

You can give him the sex he wants and see if it improves things

Or you can not give him the sex and leave

As far as I can see there is no middle ground.

He might treat you far better if you give him sex, if you don't want to = that is fine. .. but he has been pretty clear it's what he needs/wants.

pickledandpuzzled · 02/03/2024 22:16

Nothing kills desire like coercion. Having sex you don’t really want is hugely unproductive, it just makes it worse. You want it even less.

How considerate is he during sex? I can’t help thinking if he was an attentive, kind lover you’d be more likely to feel loved through touch.

AmethystSparkles · 02/03/2024 22:11

Oh OP this was me fifteen years ago. I tried for a while but I realised that I couldn’t live like that for the next however-many years. I remember the constant pressure every evening, thinking I’ve got to attempt to have sex but I just can’t. Then we’d have a big argument and he’d threaten me with divorce so I’d have sex with him (sometimes in tears) and I’d get two or three days of him being nice to me before the cycle started again. Mine used to watch porn in front of me as punishment.

I blamed myself for leaving for many years and he used my guilt as a way of paying less maintenance. But then I realised that he could have left me if he was so unhappy. Your DH could leave you….if he chooses to stay in the current situation, he has no right to treat you with contempt.

It’s a bit more difficult benefit-wise (I was on tax credits) but I’d book an appointment with the benefits advisor at the CAB. You’ll feel more in control knowing what you’re entitled to. I assume you’re already claiming DLA and carers allowance? If not, get that sorted first.

LorlieS · 02/03/2024 21:39

@Treeinthesky 😂

Treeinthesky · 02/03/2024 21:38

Join the gym go to a class 3 x per week when husband gets bk from work. It gives you energy and makes you feel better. Make his tea make him a coffee treat him better and he will copy etc. Have sex every week. However if he is threatening this is he having an affair??

secondscreen · 02/03/2024 21:35

pickledandpuzzled · 02/03/2024 21:34

She has a two year old and an eight year old with high medical needs.

If they split and go 50/50, he won’t be able to do the work he does now, no way. He totally relies on her childcare.

He needs to respect what she does and step up. Treating your wife like shit , refusing to do counselling, and threatening her if she doesn’t step up and provide sex… how very attractive.

Yes, and they have two parents, who could split both the work and the childcare.

pickledandpuzzled · 02/03/2024 21:34

She has a two year old and an eight year old with high medical needs.

If they split and go 50/50, he won’t be able to do the work he does now, no way. He totally relies on her childcare.

He needs to respect what she does and step up. Treating your wife like shit , refusing to do counselling, and threatening her if she doesn’t step up and provide sex… how very attractive.

StarDolphins · 02/03/2024 21:30

@Overwhelmedmum1 I sort like of get what you’re saying but ‘I was always short, rude or grumpy. I sulked a lot and I was angry much of the time’ would seriously put me off having sex It’s a viscous circle i Agee but someone being rude, sulky & grumpy is a massive turn off. I just couldn’t have sex with anyone that didn’t have basic decency towards me.

SummerAzure · 02/03/2024 21:25

@Overwhelmedmum1 Your dp presumably had a physical reason for not having sex that often with you though. That's completely different to the OP's situation. She can't just pop a pill and everything will be hunkydory. Your comparison is not helpful at all.

Treeinthesky · 02/03/2024 21:25

I'm separated for a year but every sat night without doubt was our thing. In a marriage u need this!! Have a drink and a shag every week, you wanna save ya marriage then that's what u gotta do. Or if you just don't wanna then separate you get carers allowance therefore will get uni credit anyways

RunningThroughMyHead · 02/03/2024 21:23

In my experience, sex increases when we feel respected, valued and supported. Good sex requires both parties to want it for the right reasons.

Your husband clearly either lacks emotional intelligence on a major scale or he's nasty and is happy to use you and your unhappiness for sex.

The relationship sounds dead in the water.

You can do this OP, you'll finally feel emotionally free and happy.

ChangeAgain2 · 02/03/2024 21:12

BIossomtoes · 02/03/2024 20:59

Op is caring for their dc enabling this dickhead to work.

No she’s not. She can only stay at home because he works. This is a ridiculous narrative that keeps getting trotted out on MN, like it’s a huge privilege to go to work, keep four people and pay all the bills.

The whole relationship sounds incredibly transactional and emotionless. Best for both of you to call it a day.

Not all SAHP want to be SAHP. It can be circumstantial, financial or both. I (a SAHP) absolutely didnt pick the life i currently have and I resent it.

Although, I do agree that they need to call it a day.

ChangeAgain2 · 02/03/2024 21:06

Your DH should treat you kindly and respectfully irrespective of sex. Being kind and respectful is a basic human decency.

I'd divorce him. I certainly wouldn't be bullied and coerced into having sex. Only a crank wants to fuck someone who isn't into it. It's about him, getting his willy wet, getting his needs met and control, it's not about passion, intimacy, love, your pleasure or indeed you at all.

I'd tell him to shove his 2 weeks up his arse. Your relationship is over. You don't need 2 weeks to know that.

kkloo · 02/03/2024 21:04

BIossomtoes · 02/03/2024 20:59

Op is caring for their dc enabling this dickhead to work.

No she’s not. She can only stay at home because he works. This is a ridiculous narrative that keeps getting trotted out on MN, like it’s a huge privilege to go to work, keep four people and pay all the bills.

The whole relationship sounds incredibly transactional and emotionless. Best for both of you to call it a day.

It's a narrative that good family men will also believe btw.
They appreciate that they wouldn't be able to have their career etc without their wife at home looking after the children, and particularly if the child/children has health issues.
And they don't see their role as more important than their partners at all. They see them as a team.

Swipe left for the next trending thread