Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £110 for this Activity Week is too much?

136 replies

Eastie77Returns · 02/03/2024 12:54

DD’s school has a Y6 Activity Week in the Summer term. It costs £110 and comprises:-

A movie and popcorn afternoon
Visit to the local the park (park is 2 mins from the school)
A day at a local beach
Visit to a theme park (entry is £23 per child)
An afternoon of tech design in the school

I cannot for the life of me work out how this can possibly cost £110. The school will receive almost £10k across the 3 form entry year. I’m a bit baffled??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Eastie77Returns · 09/03/2024 09:32

waterrat · 05/03/2024 11:02

this bus chat is making me laugh.

Our S London primary school took children on the tube all the time! I went as a volunteer taking reception year to the Museum of transport (which tbh I did think was bonkers as they barely understood what was going on) - we got buses and tubes across london!

We never used a coach for any of our trips.

That included SEN children.

The comments on this thread around the ‘risks’ of taking children on the underground are truly baffling.

OP posts:
crackfoxy · 09/03/2024 07:41

I thought that seemed cheap!

surreygirl1987 · 08/03/2024 19:26

Valeriekat · 07/03/2024 07:14

Overtime for teachers! Are you joking?

Hahaha I think some people do actually think teachers get paid extra for doing extra. If only - I'd be rolling in it!

Valeriekat · 07/03/2024 07:14

TheGirlWhoLived · 02/03/2024 12:58

The trips going to the beach and the theme park will cost around £25 and £45 at least respectively, stuff for tech design maybe £10 pp, popcorn and movie maybe £5pp. Add in teachers and you could make it up to £100 quite easily. Does it include lunch at the beach maybe or overtime for
teaxhers?

Overtime for teachers! Are you joking?

ancienticecream · 05/03/2024 11:06

I think it's fine to go on the Tube with 30 six year olds if you're going along one line with no changes. Imagine trying to get from Shepherd's Bush Market to Waterloo - what a nightmare!

YANBU to suggest that it's a bit steep price-wise, but I guess everything has increased exponentially in recent years. You should ask for a breakdown of costs, OP. It'll be interesting, I'm sure.

waterrat · 05/03/2024 11:02

this bus chat is making me laugh.

Our S London primary school took children on the tube all the time! I went as a volunteer taking reception year to the Museum of transport (which tbh I did think was bonkers as they barely understood what was going on) - we got buses and tubes across london!

We never used a coach for any of our trips.

That included SEN children.

Eastie77Returns · 05/03/2024 10:44

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 04/03/2024 23:34

I haven't tried.

Pregnant women have to have their own RA.

They can have medical conditions which are made worse via their pregnancy. At 8 months she might go into labour early. She might require more chance to sit down. Stress isn't good for aa pregnant woman and losing a child on a trip is stressful. In likelihood this would be mitigated by having extra staff/volunteers there if the teacher HAS to go

Non-native speaker with minimal English - doesn't understand the teacher's directions on which train to get on, cannot read the signs to know where they are, unable to communicate with other members of the public if they get lost, cannot follow the instructions from the station if there was a problem which required Evacuation, could even be they are overwhelmed by the crowds or being underground if they are here because they fled a war for example

So the non English speaking child observes their entire class boarding a train. Their teacher is also waving them on but they might not understand “the instructions” and so just remain on the platform.

Do you think a child lacks basic cognitive processing skills just because English isn’t their mother tongue?

And they also mustn’t use the tube in case the station is evacuated??

The 8 months pregnant teacher. I just can’t 😭

Anyway, I’ll leave it there as this is all a bit silly and unrelated to my original post.

OP posts:
NowYouSee · 05/03/2024 10:18

It is worth bearing in mind that when schools take kids - particularly of primary school age - on trips via the tube they are not going at rush hour. They would set off after the morning rush is over and return before the evening rush so being too busy is rarely an issue - and if one comes and is busy you wait for the next.

Also kids whose schools are walking distance to a tube station will likely be relatively used to going on the tube, they are not (generally) going to be awestruck by the District Line. In my child’s (outer London) primary school, parents would be baffled at the idea of hiring a coach to go to a central London museum. As opposed to using the tube which most families have 1-2 parents commuting to work on daily.

Yes sure schools need to do risk assessments and sometimes on the specifics the risks may be too high to do a specific trip with a specific group. But honestly the way London transport gets described sometimes on Mumsnet generally you’d swear it eats children daily like a Doctor Who plot and has a terrorist lurking around every corner.

peakygold · 05/03/2024 10:09

The Pupil Premium will cover the cost for parents' who can't afford the £110. The rest will just have to enjoy being rinsed to give some teachers a week off.

drspouse · 05/03/2024 09:48

How many Y1s can read the signs on the tube? And yet schools take them on the train/tube all the time.

I took Rainbows, Brownies and Guides on a train trip to go ice skating. Changed trains (both ways). Walked from the train station to the ice rink. Lost nobody - everyone had their small group to take charge of. Had a phone link system for when we (inevitably) missed our connection on the way back. All happy.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 04/03/2024 23:34

Eastie77Returns · 04/03/2024 19:43

Yet you’ve been unable to tell me why a pregnant teacher or a non native English speaking child is ‘at risk’ when travelling on the tube.

I haven't tried.

Pregnant women have to have their own RA.

They can have medical conditions which are made worse via their pregnancy. At 8 months she might go into labour early. She might require more chance to sit down. Stress isn't good for aa pregnant woman and losing a child on a trip is stressful. In likelihood this would be mitigated by having extra staff/volunteers there if the teacher HAS to go

Non-native speaker with minimal English - doesn't understand the teacher's directions on which train to get on, cannot read the signs to know where they are, unable to communicate with other members of the public if they get lost, cannot follow the instructions from the station if there was a problem which required Evacuation, could even be they are overwhelmed by the crowds or being underground if they are here because they fled a war for example

Eastie77Returns · 04/03/2024 20:00

drspouse · 04/03/2024 16:59

I think some people do find it hard to realise that for some children, for a multitude of reasons, the only way they experience some things is when schools are able to offer them.

We have a DC in a specialist school and he gets absolutely none of these educational visits or even fun trips - or any on-site enrichment (because they let him choose to play computer games during his weekly enrichment session so he doesn't choose anything else).

We take him to the beach, the theatre, the cinema, swimming, climbing etc. but there is absolutely no requirement or any will AFAICS to provide this for any child who "doesn't want to" aka is too nervous or who will take an easy option when given the choice.

They don't have any clubs of any variety, music, choir, sports, hobbies, nothing like that.

In his last school (a PRU) they had external providers for music and sport and he did engage a bit with them but he wasn't allowed to go swimming with school and they provided nothing at all other than that. His first school was on the same road and they took children for simple walks, as well as coach trips to the panto, to see Father Christmas etc.
And no, "but risk assessment" isn't an excuse. He was fine with a 1:1 on all the trips he took in his first school, and they had 1:1s for all the children who needed them. If children are never taken out, they will become anxious about going out. This, in itself, is a risk.

Given that children in poverty are massively over-represented in specialist schools, I think this is shameful.

I think it’s pretty shocking that the school is allowed to do this😣

I agree that if a child is nervous about trying something it can make the situation worse if you avoid introducing the activity altogether.

OP posts:
Eastie77Returns · 04/03/2024 19:43

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 04/03/2024 17:41

The melodrama and doomsday scenarios from some people over a simple 30 minute trip on the tube😭

Thus spake the person who has never had to do a Risk Assessment

Yet you’ve been unable to tell me why a pregnant teacher or a non native English speaking child is ‘at risk’ when travelling on the tube.

OP posts:
ButWhatAboutTheBees · 04/03/2024 17:41

The melodrama and doomsday scenarios from some people over a simple 30 minute trip on the tube😭

Thus spake the person who has never had to do a Risk Assessment

drspouse · 04/03/2024 16:59

I think some people do find it hard to realise that for some children, for a multitude of reasons, the only way they experience some things is when schools are able to offer them.

We have a DC in a specialist school and he gets absolutely none of these educational visits or even fun trips - or any on-site enrichment (because they let him choose to play computer games during his weekly enrichment session so he doesn't choose anything else).

We take him to the beach, the theatre, the cinema, swimming, climbing etc. but there is absolutely no requirement or any will AFAICS to provide this for any child who "doesn't want to" aka is too nervous or who will take an easy option when given the choice.

They don't have any clubs of any variety, music, choir, sports, hobbies, nothing like that.

In his last school (a PRU) they had external providers for music and sport and he did engage a bit with them but he wasn't allowed to go swimming with school and they provided nothing at all other than that. His first school was on the same road and they took children for simple walks, as well as coach trips to the panto, to see Father Christmas etc.
And no, "but risk assessment" isn't an excuse. He was fine with a 1:1 on all the trips he took in his first school, and they had 1:1s for all the children who needed them. If children are never taken out, they will become anxious about going out. This, in itself, is a risk.

Given that children in poverty are massively over-represented in specialist schools, I think this is shameful.

Eastie77Returns · 04/03/2024 16:49

Abouttimeforanamechange · 04/03/2024 15:15

My kids school (zone 2) take the kids loads of places on local buses and tube. As young as Year 1. Why would you teach them that private transport is better when it’s slower, more expensive and less environmentally conscious. Schools need to risk manage it.

OK, so in your Yr 1 class you've got one child in a wheelchair and another with his leg in plaster and no lift at either your home station or your destination station, or both. Another child who is scared of escalators. Another who is likely to become overwhelmed by noise, crowds, etc, and might bolt or have a meltdown on the platform. Two more who have just arrived in the UK, have minimal English and can't follow instructions because they don't understand them. Oh, and the class teacher is eight months pregnant. How would you risk manage that?

What is the likelihood of all of those scenarios occurring within a single class😂

The kid with a leg in plaster wouldn’t be going on a school trip, even on a coach. I already mentioned in DD’s class there was a child with mobility issues. Step free access (lifts) is a thing in London Underground.

Why is a pregnant teacher a risk? You know pregnant women use the tube everyday right..?

Kids who have minimal English should 100% be encouraged to use the Tube and get used to our public transport system. They are not at risk and of course they can follow instructions. Do you think they are learning impaired and more likely to jump in front of a train because they are not native English speakers?

Plenty of kids are a bit nervous of escalators but there’s no reason for them to avoid the underground completely.

The melodrama and doomsday scenarios from some people over a simple 30 minute trip on the tube😭

OP posts:
ButWhatAboutTheBees · 04/03/2024 16:31

Risk management means your conclusion might be that private hire transport is the safest and best option

Risk management can take into account previous incidents. So they did lose Little Johnny on the platform last time and it took 30 minutes to find him, whilst trying to contain the other 29 children in the class, 10 of whom want to wander off, 3 are crying because Little Johnny is lost and obviously he's never going to be seen again, 5 of them have started getting their lunch out and you're starting to get in the way of the notoriously impatient London commuters.

Sirzy · 04/03/2024 15:35

KarmenPQZ · 04/03/2024 13:40

My kids school (zone 2) take the kids loads of places on local buses and tube. As young as Year 1. Why would you teach them that private transport is better when it’s slower, more expensive and less environmentally conscious. Schools need to risk manage it.

Schools do risk manage, that’s why they pick the best option for the trip on the balance of it.

i am going on a school trip this week and we are using public transport. We are going on another trip in a few months and using a coach. The different trips have different locations and situations meaning different things are appropriate.

I don’t think some people realise the amount of planning that goes into these trips.

Abouttimeforanamechange · 04/03/2024 15:15

My kids school (zone 2) take the kids loads of places on local buses and tube. As young as Year 1. Why would you teach them that private transport is better when it’s slower, more expensive and less environmentally conscious. Schools need to risk manage it.

OK, so in your Yr 1 class you've got one child in a wheelchair and another with his leg in plaster and no lift at either your home station or your destination station, or both. Another child who is scared of escalators. Another who is likely to become overwhelmed by noise, crowds, etc, and might bolt or have a meltdown on the platform. Two more who have just arrived in the UK, have minimal English and can't follow instructions because they don't understand them. Oh, and the class teacher is eight months pregnant. How would you risk manage that?

KarmenPQZ · 04/03/2024 13:40

My kids school (zone 2) take the kids loads of places on local buses and tube. As young as Year 1. Why would you teach them that private transport is better when it’s slower, more expensive and less environmentally conscious. Schools need to risk manage it.

Blondeshavemorefun · 04/03/2024 13:28

£22 fat fingers

Blondeshavemorefun · 04/03/2024 13:25

£21 a day seems fair esp as needs to pay for travel costs - insurance and teachers /cover

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 04/03/2024 13:24

It's a good job OP doesn't plan these events if they think it's ok that a child wanders off!

And they don't seem to understand what a risk assessment is

Longma · 04/03/2024 10:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Eastie77Returns · 04/03/2024 07:32

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 03/03/2024 18:40

I don’t think it’s reasonable for the school to spend ££££ on coaches into London because one child in the class suffers from anxiety. I know I’ll be flamed but I would have exactly the same opinion if it was my child who was anxious. The child doesn’t have to miss out. If it was mine, I’d take him to museum myself by another method and meet the school there

Which is why its a good job YOU aren't planning these events. Because you HAVE to consider the needs of EVERY child. Even if it will cost extra. Not every parent/carer can make the trip themselves, that may have been considered as an option but the parent/carer couldn't or wouldn't (because they felt it singled their child out and made them look different, might make them a bullying target etc) take them

And what is the big deal about travelling in rush anyway. It’s the tube in London, not a dangerous freight train in a war zone.

Rush hour can be horrendous. Getting on as a couple can be impossible, getting a group of 30 children through the crowds, not losing one as you get on the tube, making sure they can all fit on etc would be even worse

What terrorist level??!

There's a terror level for London which rises and falls depending on what's going on. Its something schools and groups have to consider and RA for when travelling into London

Another reason could be that the school has previously used the tube but there was an incident such as a child getting left on the platform and so the school is being more cautious now.

Dozens of schools take 30 odd children on trips via the tube every day without incident. Of course there is a risk a child might wander of or get lost but that’s life…there are small risks involved in most activities. If a child was left on a platform then obviously that’s a serious incident but even if that did happen there is absolutely no reason whatsoever to ban future travel on the tube.

A school coach crashed and multiple children were killed year last year. Should coach travel be banned as well? You simply can’t stop doing certain things because x,y or z might happen.

I stand by my view that one child’s inability to do something shouldn’t mean the entire class misses out. Where do you draw the line with that kind of policy?! If one child suffers from debilitating travel sickness and can’t go via the coach, what then? The entire class walks to central London?

The likelihood of a terrorist attack on the tube is really quite low. At the height of IRA attacks my primary school took us on the underground all the time. There are children in London who take the tube to school every single day along with millions of commuters.

OP posts: