Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

48 hour exclusion rule

88 replies

Samsond · 02/03/2024 11:01

Ok I know IANBU here but I want to moan anyway.
WHY? Do some parents think the 48 hour isolation rule for D & V doesn't apply to them / their kids??
A child threw up in my DCs class yesterday. Whilst running to the door so managed to pass quite a few pupils close by whilst actually vomiting. (Poor kid)
She then told the teacher she'd been sick the day before and in the night but her parents thought she was feeling better so sent her in.
She has now directly exposed about a third of the class to her gastro bug as well as humiliated herself. I have emetophobia which was caused by throwing up on front of the class when I was 11 so I really feel for this poor girl and am very anxiously monitoring my DC for signs of nausea now.
Why are some people so fucking selfish???

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 02/03/2024 17:04

Because following the 48 hour rule my sons absence is unauthorised? It's unfair sick children are being caught up in government policy like thus but there you go

MeinKraft · 02/03/2024 17:02

48 hours seems like a long time, especially when quite a lot of instances of vomiting in children are they vomit once or twice and are fine shortly after. I can see why parents might think oh they just ate too much junk food or something and it's not a bug at all.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 02/03/2024 16:58

The issue is workplaces not offering paid time off for sick children. If parents knew they could stay home (and get paid) this would never be an issue in the first place.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 02/03/2024 16:57

Our secondary doesn't do the 48 hour rule, it's 6 hours clear of vomiting and if you are off its an unauthorised absence for sickness. And kids who don't get 100% attendance miss out on all sorts of benefits.

My eldest was sent home from her secondary (a different one to the school above which my son attends) puking her guts up. She had been fine that morning, got her home about 1pm. By 6pm she was filling her face like she was starving and absolutely fine! I kept her off as her school does have the 48 hour rule but she was well enough to go in..

She had a friend sleep over at ours, who vomited all over my bathroom Sunday morning (missing the toilet totally). I joked when her mum picked her up about getting out of school. Nope, next day she was back at school as her mum was a teacher there and couldn't take time off. It's not hard to imagine other parents in the same position.

DontCallMeKidDontCallMeBaby · 02/03/2024 16:51

KatieB55 · 02/03/2024 16:35

Ditto impetigo & conjunctivitis. Both require prescription from GP if child under 1 and child has picked up from nursery.

Obviously, they’re at least 4, by my dc’s school policy around conjunctivitis is to stop at the pharmacy on the way to school. As soon as they’ve had one dose of drops, you’re supposed to send them in. It’s madness.

AuntMarch · 02/03/2024 16:50

ShirleyPhallus · 02/03/2024 13:13

Because vomiting isn’t always caused by a bug

and some parents don’t have the luxury of being able not to send your child in for the day of school as they don’t have other childcare and can’t afford not to work

Neither can I, but when my child caught something from a child who went in on Monday after being ill all weekend, I had no choice. Selfish cunts.

DontCallMeKidDontCallMeBaby · 02/03/2024 16:48

I kept my eldest off witch chicken pox, then a few weeks later a d&v bug. The school referred me to the attendance team. Both of these illnesses affected quite a few members of the class, and I know of at least 3 other parents who are also being ‘monitored’. My dc is in year 2. He had 100% attendance in Reception and Year 1. This is the first time he’s been poorly during school term.

If parents are spooked by the headlines around fines etc for attendance, I can understand (why at my dc’s school at least), they’re reluctant to keep them home.

Barleysugar86 · 02/03/2024 16:40

My son has a bad habit of throwing up from coughing. On more than one occasion I have had him sent home having thrown up from coughing and then had to keep home a perfectly fine kid (coughing aside) for two and a half days. So this rule frustrates me although I do understand it.

If it happens at home where the school doesn't see, and no other symptoms beside the cough, I send him in.

Mama2many73 · 02/03/2024 16:40

Our goddaughter threw up at comp around 11am the other week. Staff told her to 'see how she went' they phoned her mam at 1.15 to see if she could be collected!!
As they left the deputy head said hope yo see you tomorrow!!
Now obviously her mum did not send her in but was phoned by the school to 'explain her absence!! WTAF!! She quoted the County policy at them and I've told her to write to the Govenors! All about attendance figures I believe!

KatieB55 · 02/03/2024 16:35

Ditto impetigo & conjunctivitis. Both require prescription from GP if child under 1 and child has picked up from nursery.

fliptopbin · 02/03/2024 16:32

I guess by "under the weather", people are meaning that their child vomited at teatime, then at 2am, but has now not vomited for 6 hours and says they don't feel like they will be sick again. I can see how, if you are on a zero hours contract you might just chance it.
Also, after Covid, I could see that some people might feel like a mug for following the rules when nobody else does.
This is hypothetical by the way, as luckily I have never been in that situation.

RicePuddingWithCinnamon · 02/03/2024 16:31

ShirleyPhallus · 02/03/2024 13:13

Because vomiting isn’t always caused by a bug

and some parents don’t have the luxury of being able not to send your child in for the day of school as they don’t have other childcare and can’t afford not to work

But what about when they spread it to other children and THIER parents can’t afford time off work?

Soreteatowel · 02/03/2024 16:27

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2024 16:18

People are listening.
They're just pointing out that there's a lot of families who need to work and aren't in a position to have their children with a revolving door of illnesses because other parents think it's fine to make everyone else's children unwell.

If everyone actually followed the 48 hours, there'd be less illness going round, fewer children would be unwell and everyone would be taking less time off work.

The problem when some people don't do 48 hours is that more children come in unwell, more children get unwell, more parents end up having to take more days off work (which in turn can cause issues in their workplaces that wouldn't be an issue if absence for illness was occasional).

Edited

I know that, and thankfully I've never been in a position where I needed to send a potentially sick child to school, I'm just saying I don't believe that all those judging people who have would do anything different if there was a real risk to their family's livlihood.

CarrotOfPeace · 02/03/2024 16:20

Whilst I understand the rule I do also understand why parents can't take multiple days off work. They can try but employers will soon get shitty.

They need to normalise "dependents leave" at the moment it's meant for emergancies/last minute absence but really it would help if parents knew they could have 2 days if their kid was ill

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2024 16:18

People are listening.
They're just pointing out that there's a lot of families who need to work and aren't in a position to have their children with a revolving door of illnesses because other parents think it's fine to make everyone else's children unwell.

If everyone actually followed the 48 hours, there'd be less illness going round, fewer children would be unwell and everyone would be taking less time off work.

The problem when some people don't do 48 hours is that more children come in unwell, more children get unwell, more parents end up having to take more days off work (which in turn can cause issues in their workplaces that wouldn't be an issue if absence for illness was occasional).

Soreteatowel · 02/03/2024 16:04

Samsond · 02/03/2024 15:57

Of course it's hard to lose a couple of day's pay. But now potentially lots of other families are going to be in that boat as well. And since the child got sent home anyway the original family will still (presumably) be in that boat anyway.
And frankly even if you're selfish enough to not give a shit about all the other kids in the class, what about your own child? That poor little girl probably felt awful all morning up until the point she threw up and then had the embarrassment of being sick in front of her entire class. That sort of shit traumatizes some kids. I'm 100% sure my emetophobia goes back to when that happened to me age 11. And to be fair to my parents I hadn't been ill the day before like this poor kid.
Absolute arseholes.

You're not listening, it's not just a couple of days pay for lots of people, it's the prospect of any further work.

I'm not saying it's right, I'm saying I don't think you'd do anything different if you thought your rent wouldn't be paid and you couldn't do the weekly shop.

Samsond · 02/03/2024 15:57

Of course it's hard to lose a couple of day's pay. But now potentially lots of other families are going to be in that boat as well. And since the child got sent home anyway the original family will still (presumably) be in that boat anyway.
And frankly even if you're selfish enough to not give a shit about all the other kids in the class, what about your own child? That poor little girl probably felt awful all morning up until the point she threw up and then had the embarrassment of being sick in front of her entire class. That sort of shit traumatizes some kids. I'm 100% sure my emetophobia goes back to when that happened to me age 11. And to be fair to my parents I hadn't been ill the day before like this poor kid.
Absolute arseholes.

OP posts:
CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 02/03/2024 15:14

Soreteatowel · 02/03/2024 14:05

I don't believe anyone here wouldn't risk sending in a child who's been a bit off, but seems OK this morning, if the alternative was not paying the rent, not working again for weeks or having hours drastically cut.

Very easy to do the right thing when it carries no real disadvantage to you or your family.

Define "a bit off".

The child in the OP had thrown up in the night. I wouldn't send a child in who had actually vomited. Other things are more of a judgement call based on what they're normally like, and what the symptoms are.

DH and I both work full time with 2 children under 5. Kids getting ill is undeniably a massive pain. But sometimes keeping them off school/nursery is just something you have to do - don't send them in with chicken pox, impetigo, 48 hours after D&V, and a number of other things that require absence.

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2024 15:04

I don't believe anyone here wouldn't risk sending in a child who's been a bit off, but seems OK this morning, if the alternative was not paying the rent, not working again for weeks or having hours drastically cut
You're making a lot of assumptions about people's circumstances here.

There's alsoba big difference between a child feels a bit off and a child who has been vomiting though.

But who cares let's make sure that many more families also have poorly children.

I'm freelance. If someone sends their vomiting children in and mine get unwell, I don't get paid or I have to hope my clients can rearrange. I'd rather not have to lose work because other people send their children in to spread their vomiting bugs.

sleepyscientist · 02/03/2024 15:01

@HoHoGo less illness = more autoimmunity tho.

Soreteatowel · 02/03/2024 14:05

I don't believe anyone here wouldn't risk sending in a child who's been a bit off, but seems OK this morning, if the alternative was not paying the rent, not working again for weeks or having hours drastically cut.

Very easy to do the right thing when it carries no real disadvantage to you or your family.

NotSmallButFunSize · 02/03/2024 13:57

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2024 13:30

And you have no idea how many families live, if you think it's about "annoying" the boss. If you're in a zero hours job, you lose that day's pay and the chance of other shifts, which will be give to those seen as more reliable.

Maybe wobble your own head?
No head wobbling needed thank you.

I'm well aware some people are in the situation where the loss of a day pay is a big issue.

The thing here is that each time a child is sent in vomiting, that parent is saying "actually it's totally fine for up to 20 other families to have to take time off work, lose pay, have multiple unwell children in their family as the bug goes through their household".

Or do those families not matter?

But sure, let's not bother trying to reduce the spread of nasty illnesses. Let's send vomiting children into school so that another family can lose a fortnight's pay whilst their 2-3 children come down unwell one after the other. At least one parent didn't have to take a day off work.

Maybe those other people are not their problem, their own finances are more of an issue unfortunately.

I'm not saying I agree with spreading bugs, drives me mad, but let's not pretend people can necessarily afford to be altruistic when having to think about their own financial situation

HoHoGo · 02/03/2024 13:50

@sleepyscientist no, because that's how it spreads like wildfire. What we need to do is enforce the 48-hour rule, so that these things can't spread so much in the first place. If everyone stuck to the rule, there would be far less illness about, and that would be much more beneficial to the families who struggle to get the time off work.

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2024 13:30

And you have no idea how many families live, if you think it's about "annoying" the boss. If you're in a zero hours job, you lose that day's pay and the chance of other shifts, which will be give to those seen as more reliable.

Maybe wobble your own head?
No head wobbling needed thank you.

I'm well aware some people are in the situation where the loss of a day pay is a big issue.

The thing here is that each time a child is sent in vomiting, that parent is saying "actually it's totally fine for up to 20 other families to have to take time off work, lose pay, have multiple unwell children in their family as the bug goes through their household".

Or do those families not matter?

But sure, let's not bother trying to reduce the spread of nasty illnesses. Let's send vomiting children into school so that another family can lose a fortnight's pay whilst their 2-3 children come down unwell one after the other. At least one parent didn't have to take a day off work.

sleepyscientist · 02/03/2024 13:30

HoHoGo · 02/03/2024 13:24

@Soreteatowel but that also applies to the other 10 or so families who likely now have to take a couple of days off work. Who's to say they're not in the same situation?

So do we stop the 48hour and say they can go in when not actively vomiting.