Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - to not want to work outside my contracted hours

92 replies

Clove76 · 02/03/2024 07:27

Bit of background - I’m a Speech and Language Therapist, work 3 days a week and find I’m unable to do my job in the hours I’m paid for. There’s just so much admin on top of the appointments to get done each day that I can’t help but have to do that bit extra to keep up (just basic documentation and reports, I’m certainly not doing tasks above and beyond what’s expected).

I’ve worked for 3 organisations now (including government and private) and it’s the same scenario in each.

I know for a fact I’m not the only one who’s having to do more to ‘keep up’, as I had considered perhaps I’m the problem and just too slow.

Husband who has been my sounding board on this (and whether to stay in my profession) thinks most professional jobs require a bit of extra time to get things done. I don’t want to believe that’s true. So I pose the question - what do you do for a job and how frequently do you work outside the agreed hours? Am I being unreasonable to expect that some weeks I could just get away with doing my contracted hours?

I’m just so annoyed because I think I could love my job if I just felt the admin side of it was awarded as much time as it needs. As it stands I don’t think I can stay in this job much longer and am considering taking a much lower paid job that I can guarantee only requires me to work within the stated hours. I want to be more present for my kids and husband and not feel constant guilt that I haven’t done something.

OP posts:
Clove76 · 02/03/2024 08:36

BendingSpoons · 02/03/2024 08:26

I'm a SALT working 3 days in the NHS. I am VERY lucky to work in a relatively well funded service where we are told not to overwork as it masks the need. Many still do of course, but I don't particularly. I might do an extra hour a week to catch up but that's generally it. I do get that caseload pressures make that tricky.

A few thoughts:

  • we don't write reports other than for EHCP (and occasionally for other purposes at special request). We write targets, sometimes on a written form, sometimes via email. That's the main thing people e.g. schools want.
  • can you shorten the length of your clinical appointments to free up admin time? Hard I know if they have waited ages. We aim for a 'therapeutic hour' where we have planned, delivered and documented in the hour, although I am terrible at it and talk too much!

I know this needs to come from the top though.

Could you consider working privately? You can charge for your admin time too.

I’m actually currently working for a private practice (employed) but was NHS for years before. Unfortunately report writing is required for all children both where I currently work and in my previous role, and is unlikely to change as parents demand it in the current role. When I was in the NHS I would have found a therapeutic hour impossible tbh! Unless they had a speech sound difficulty perhaps. Most of the cases I saw were social comm, complex needs etc.

OP posts:
FaceMaker · 02/03/2024 08:33

DP works full time in education administration (so doesn't get the long holidays that teaching staff do). He works an extra three hours outside of his contracted hours every single day.

Willmafrockfit · 02/03/2024 08:32

admin is part of your role
if it takes more time then you must have a meeting and reduce your caseload to allow for proper admin time

theduchessofspork · 02/03/2024 08:30

Beezknees · 02/03/2024 07:32

Customer service for a big 6 energy company. I do not work outside my contracted hours unless I'm on a phone call that overruns. There is no admin to do to be fair and I only get paid £24k so nah. I think my area manager works outside contracted hours but they are on £70k salaries.

Yeah but OP’s husband is taking about professions.

Anyway, yes it is OP, sorry to say. I can’t think of anyone who doesn’t, across a huge variety of industries

Clove76 · 02/03/2024 08:28

Hiddenvoice · 02/03/2024 07:31

I’m a primary teacher and feel I work ridiculous hours to make my day teaching possible. I wish I could change it but the paperwork has steadily increased over the years and if I didn’t go in early and work late at night then I know I wouldn’t be prepared.
My dh is the same, he feels that yes there is usually a bit of extra work always needing done but he doesn’t agree with the amount of time it takes up- nights, weekends and holidays.

Solidarity with you. I know teachers have it so much worse than most professions, you work ridiculous hours in a role with huge responsibility and the pay simply doesn’t reflect this.

OP posts:
ShiteRider · 02/03/2024 08:27

Catza · 02/03/2024 08:10

Unfortunately, I have worked through quite a few CQC commissions, upper management ward visits and similar to say that people on the lower end of the chain deliberately hide the realities of what is going on day to day. Every time we have a ward visit, we would be fully staffed, extra bank nurses would be called and everything would look as if all is well in the world. In reality, most days we would only have one or two nurses running around like blue-arsed flies trying to look after 30+ patients. But does the higher management see that? No, because lower management, for whatever reason chooses to throw all their energy on making it look pretty.
Yes, patient s wait a long time for our service but I cannot hold myself personally accountable for it. I am also a person and if I leave due to burnout, over 100 patients on my caseload will have to wait even longer to get their regular appointments, not to mention the waiting list for new patients will keep growing. So keeping myself well is about the best I can do to improve patient care.

Completely agree about the looking after yourself, for me getting up early a couple of days a week is how I do this. I’m an early riser anyway and this way I can feel that I’m doing the best I can for my patients, not interfering with family life and keeping on top of what needs doing.

I realise that not everyone feels the same and that’s OK, I discourage my team from doing this and they all know that I don’t expect it from them. All I ask from the is that they are compassionate and dedicated in the hours that they are paid to work. I’m lucky and our patients are lucky, they’re fricking awesome.

WingingIt09 · 02/03/2024 08:27

I am also an SLT for the NHS. I've worked for 4 different NHS trusts over my career and in 2/4 of them the expectation was that we worked over our hours to complete our admin, which is unsustainable and leads to burnout!
In my current job I am a team leader in community paediatrics as well as still working clinically and my trust are really hot on staff wellbeing.
We actively encourage our staff to keep to their hours, although many still do work over. Personally, I probably work over by 3-5 hours some weeks but not all the time (I work 3 days a week) by doing things like working through lunch and staying up to an hour over some days to complete notes. However, I'm forced to leave relatively on time due to childcare pick up and I'm very strict with myself on not picking my laptop up once home after my experience in previous jobs. My opinion (and what I tell my team) is that working over our hours masks the need for more staff and we need to have for commissioners to prove we can't cope with current staffing. Also, even if you did all your admin every evening our waiting lists will still be long and you'll end up burnt out and off sick, which makes things worse in the long run.

BendingSpoons · 02/03/2024 08:26

I'm a SALT working 3 days in the NHS. I am VERY lucky to work in a relatively well funded service where we are told not to overwork as it masks the need. Many still do of course, but I don't particularly. I might do an extra hour a week to catch up but that's generally it. I do get that caseload pressures make that tricky.

A few thoughts:

  • we don't write reports other than for EHCP (and occasionally for other purposes at special request). We write targets, sometimes on a written form, sometimes via email. That's the main thing people e.g. schools want.
  • can you shorten the length of your clinical appointments to free up admin time? Hard I know if they have waited ages. We aim for a 'therapeutic hour' where we have planned, delivered and documented in the hour, although I am terrible at it and talk too much!

I know this needs to come from the top though.

Could you consider working privately? You can charge for your admin time too.

Clove76 · 02/03/2024 08:25

BelindaOkra · 02/03/2024 07:48

I’m an SLT as well and have worked in a number of other professions. I think it is normal for professional work I’m afraid & SLT has been better than other professional jobs.

However, SLTs are not paid much in relation to other professions (in common with other AHPs) - but it may be that we have more paperwork than others? Not sure as I don’t know enough about physios etc. I now have a job where I am paid hourly - which works well imo.

Maybe change areas? Acute seems to me to give the best chance for working contracted hours?

It’s good to hear some different perspectives. Sad to hear that SLT is one of the better ones in terms of working extra though :-(

We definitely have more extensive paperwork. Been doing this long enough now and worked alongside other AHPs and seen how brief their notes/ reports are. Honestly I think it’s so hard to sum up a person’s communication briefly and clients are always so complex.

I’ve considered acute work and just don’t think it’s for me - I don’t cope well with being around really unwell people, not to mentioned I’d need to retrain essentially as I’ve been in Paeds for 9 years.

Re filling in the gaps and masking how much work there actually is - I’ve tried just doing my hours, and what happens is my reports get months behind and it feels awful. It feels like I can’t change the entire culture of an organisation on my own because the entire rest of the team will continue working extra anyway.

OP posts:
cansu · 02/03/2024 08:25

I agree that many professional jobs have an unwritten expectation that people work out of hours. This doesn't mean it's right and you are within your rights to push back. I simply couldn't keep my head above water without working sone hours on the weekend and some evenings but I have definitely cut it down now. I used to spend the whole day on planning on Sundays. I have now trimmed this down.

Decorhate · 02/03/2024 08:16

On average I do an extra hour each day. It’s a support role in a school. I probably kept more to my contracted hours when I started first as children needed to be collected etc.

Many others at the school do even more than this, teachers especially but also the pastoral support team.

I don’t mind doing the extra - I’ll occasionally need a day off in term time so it’s give and take.

Wrongsideofpennines · 02/03/2024 08:13

I'm an AHP in the community and rarely work extra hours. Mainly because I can't because the children need picking up and there is nobody else to do it. But I also manage my own diary. In an emergency it may happen that I do extra but we don't have RTT wait list pressures in the same way so I can manage my own caseload. I do know though that AHPs in other areas have similar problems to you. Plenty of physios in MSK will pray for a patient to cancel last minute so they can catch up on notes.

In this kind of role its not as simple as stopping doing the extra. Notes can't be done any later than 24hrs so if you don't complete your notes within that timescale then in theory you could be reported to HCPC and they will complete disciplinary proceedings.

Is there anyway your manager would reduce the amount of appointments you have in a day? Can you ask admin to book you one fewer a day and see if that helps? Unfortunately if you do the extra unpaid then you don't reflect the true cost of the service and then there is no evidence that further funding/staffing is needed.

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/03/2024 08:11

I think most professional roles require a degree of work outside of contracted hours. As a social worker I certainly did because my case load was high and I had very vulnerable families and carried a lot of risk. My current role isn’t practice based but I can still put in extra hours for a particular piece of work. My role is very flexible and well paid and I consider it part of the job. I couldn’t do the 50+ hours I was doing in practice now though.

Catza · 02/03/2024 08:10

ShiteRider · 02/03/2024 08:00

Except they won’t, and it will be patients who suffer. In theory you’re right but in salaried jobs where there is no option to pay people overtime or bank staff that’s just theoretical. The reality is patients end up (depending on your role) in dangerous positions because they’re not getting the support they need but the ‘higher ups’ don’t notice because they’re in their ivory towers counting beans.

Unfortunately, I have worked through quite a few CQC commissions, upper management ward visits and similar to say that people on the lower end of the chain deliberately hide the realities of what is going on day to day. Every time we have a ward visit, we would be fully staffed, extra bank nurses would be called and everything would look as if all is well in the world. In reality, most days we would only have one or two nurses running around like blue-arsed flies trying to look after 30+ patients. But does the higher management see that? No, because lower management, for whatever reason chooses to throw all their energy on making it look pretty.
Yes, patient s wait a long time for our service but I cannot hold myself personally accountable for it. I am also a person and if I leave due to burnout, over 100 patients on my caseload will have to wait even longer to get their regular appointments, not to mention the waiting list for new patients will keep growing. So keeping myself well is about the best I can do to improve patient care.

Clove76 · 02/03/2024 08:04

TheSuggestedAmendment · 02/03/2024 07:42

It depends on pay, doesn’t it?

I am a lawyer, I don’t expect to work my contracted hours, and my pay reflects that.

Most professional jobs come with ongoing responsibility - and it sounds as though it is responsibility that is bothering you as well as time.

Yes, I think this and others mentioning pay are right. My profession isn’t known for good pay so it kind of hurts being made to feel I have to work so much and am not exactly rewarded for it.

And you are so right; I think I find the responsibility of it all bothers me too.

OP posts:
circlesand · 02/03/2024 08:04

ShiteRider · 02/03/2024 08:00

Except they won’t, and it will be patients who suffer. In theory you’re right but in salaried jobs where there is no option to pay people overtime or bank staff that’s just theoretical. The reality is patients end up (depending on your role) in dangerous positions because they’re not getting the support they need but the ‘higher ups’ don’t notice because they’re in their ivory towers counting beans.

Well that's why I think people like SLTs are in a good position to actually take a stand on it because their patients are generally not in life threatening situations (apart from those working in hospitals with swallowing issues etc).

Dox9 · 02/03/2024 08:04

I work in finance PT and have agreed overtime payments as working beyond my hours was getting ridiculous. I made over 10k in overtime last year.

ShiteRider · 02/03/2024 08:00

circlesand · 02/03/2024 07:55

Sorry, I completely disagree with this, especially when it comes to lower paid professionals like allied health professionals and social workers.

I know that it happens, because the public sector is woefully underfunded.

But this is not a healthy way to think, that if you want a profession you have to work over your paid hours.

Just no. You don't have to. You only have to because this shitty government is not funding services properly, and relying on good will.

Stop giving so much good will, and those further up will have to listen.

Except they won’t, and it will be patients who suffer. In theory you’re right but in salaried jobs where there is no option to pay people overtime or bank staff that’s just theoretical. The reality is patients end up (depending on your role) in dangerous positions because they’re not getting the support they need but the ‘higher ups’ don’t notice because they’re in their ivory towers counting beans.

Crazycrazylady · 02/03/2024 07:56

I think a few extra hours are standard in a more professional role but as other mentioned these roles tend to lend themselves to other perks like better pay, more flexibility etc.

I try and minimise extra hours but do have to take quick calls on my days off usually for yes/no type of answers . In the scheme of things I can live with that.

I think I'd be bored in a more menial role even it meant I could do bang on my hours so there's the trade off too I suppose.

circlesand · 02/03/2024 07:55

MaryShelley1818 · 02/03/2024 07:51

I agree with those that say it's often (not always) the difference between a profession and a job.
I'm a Social Worker and everyone in my team works far over and beyond what they're paid to work.

Sorry, I completely disagree with this, especially when it comes to lower paid professionals like allied health professionals and social workers.

I know that it happens, because the public sector is woefully underfunded.

But this is not a healthy way to think, that if you want a profession you have to work over your paid hours.

Just no. You don't have to. You only have to because this shitty government is not funding services properly, and relying on good will.

Stop giving so much good will, and those further up will have to listen.

devildeepbluesea · 02/03/2024 07:55

I think in general for any job, if it can’t be done in the hours required then your workload is too heavy. I’m not talking about the odd time when there’s something important to finish or an emergency, but on a day to day basis. You’re not a charity, you’re not working out of the goodness of your heart.

My job can’t be done in the hours (in fact I’m not sure 2 people could do it) and I’m just coming back after a period off stick because it finally broke me - first time off sick in 30 years. I am not going to do any more than my contracted hours from now on. If they want to get rid of me for this they’re welcome to try.

WinchSparkle80 · 02/03/2024 07:54

Easily work 15 hours a week over my 37.5 contracted hours. But, I work in finance, am reasonably paid and it’s just what is expected over past 20 years.

Whilst I find another job (due to also being expected to check work at weekends and days off) I am slowly trying to put more boundaries in place.

eatsleepfarmrepeat · 02/03/2024 07:53

What does your contract say? Mine states fixed hours and then hour outside of this to facilitate the role.

How senior are you, what is you pay, is it worth it?

I do work outside of my fixed hours but I’m an associate director in a fee earning role and my bonus is linked to my billing so for me, it’s all relative. If it doesn’t work for you, you need a rethink.

MaryShelley1818 · 02/03/2024 07:51

I agree with those that say it's often (not always) the difference between a profession and a job.
I'm a Social Worker and everyone in my team works far over and beyond what they're paid to work.

BelindaOkra · 02/03/2024 07:50

Circlesand makes a good point. To recruit more SLTs the manager needs to make a case that it is needed. If you all fill in the gaps by working additional hours for free you will always be short staffed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread