Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - to not want to work outside my contracted hours

92 replies

Clove76 · 02/03/2024 07:27

Bit of background - I’m a Speech and Language Therapist, work 3 days a week and find I’m unable to do my job in the hours I’m paid for. There’s just so much admin on top of the appointments to get done each day that I can’t help but have to do that bit extra to keep up (just basic documentation and reports, I’m certainly not doing tasks above and beyond what’s expected).

I’ve worked for 3 organisations now (including government and private) and it’s the same scenario in each.

I know for a fact I’m not the only one who’s having to do more to ‘keep up’, as I had considered perhaps I’m the problem and just too slow.

Husband who has been my sounding board on this (and whether to stay in my profession) thinks most professional jobs require a bit of extra time to get things done. I don’t want to believe that’s true. So I pose the question - what do you do for a job and how frequently do you work outside the agreed hours? Am I being unreasonable to expect that some weeks I could just get away with doing my contracted hours?

I’m just so annoyed because I think I could love my job if I just felt the admin side of it was awarded as much time as it needs. As it stands I don’t think I can stay in this job much longer and am considering taking a much lower paid job that I can guarantee only requires me to work within the stated hours. I want to be more present for my kids and husband and not feel constant guilt that I haven’t done something.

OP posts:
Surroundyourselfwiththerightpeople · 02/03/2024 09:40

Also in public sector. Everyone I know works over their hours. Salaries between 32-55,000. Many don’t take all their AL.
One colleague has recently refused to continue. Problem is everyone else is now picking up their work and inevitably going forwards people won’t want them for new projects.
Lack of funding is the problem.

Nomorewine123 · 02/03/2024 09:36

Specialist nurse here - rarely take my lunch break and rarely finish on time - my usual is to work an hour extra a day sometimes more. I’m not sure of how to stop this - I have seriously ill patients on my caseload - if I do my admin in my work time there will be knock on effects on who is seen. My day as it is, is a constant juggling act and trying to prioritise daily whose need is more. Its easy to say “just don’t do it” but then it’s me who has to ring a very sick person and say “no I don’t have capacity to see you today”

Willmafrockfit · 02/03/2024 09:35

i think 4 is too much
it should be 2 or 3 allowing time for admin surely

Catza · 02/03/2024 09:34

there will always be an expectation to see minimum 4 patients a day

4 patients a day is a very reasonable caseload and should leave plenty of time for admin, though. Or are you having to travel between patients?

mynameiscalypso · 02/03/2024 09:34

StormKevin · 02/03/2024 09:24

I think that most professional jobs involve more than just the 9-5, and I’ve always thought it a bit odd that health professionals are so precious about their hours, having their mandated breaks etc etc. Doctors get diary monitoring to ensure they are not (officially) working too many hours. Not saying they don’t work hard, but it’s odd to treat it like a shift in a factory where you clock in and out.

I expect you could work more efficiently in reality. No one wants to read a really long report. Be realistic about what really needs to be included. Use dictation software which saves some standard texts or paragraphs which you can quickly insert into all your reports.

I always assumed that it was stricter with medical professionals because if you're tired/burnt out/have been working hundreds of hours, you're more likely to make a mistake and the impact of that could be catastrophic. If I'm tired because I had to pull an all-nighter (which I have in the past) and fuck up, there's no real consequences other than looking like a bit of an idiot.

NeedToChangeName · 02/03/2024 09:31

Shorter reports could be the way to go, but sometimes it's difficult to know what to leave out

StormKevin · 02/03/2024 09:24

I think that most professional jobs involve more than just the 9-5, and I’ve always thought it a bit odd that health professionals are so precious about their hours, having their mandated breaks etc etc. Doctors get diary monitoring to ensure they are not (officially) working too many hours. Not saying they don’t work hard, but it’s odd to treat it like a shift in a factory where you clock in and out.

I expect you could work more efficiently in reality. No one wants to read a really long report. Be realistic about what really needs to be included. Use dictation software which saves some standard texts or paragraphs which you can quickly insert into all your reports.

AgnesX · 02/03/2024 09:12

I'm senior admin in a global company and sometimes it's needed to make deadlines. In this industry it's generally par for the course BUT its give and take. Not a permanent, regular thing.

Gymmum82 · 02/03/2024 09:09

I work in a professional but low paying role and get TOIL for overtime worked. It is expected to work outside contracted hours. Those higher up than me work masses of overtime. Often until 10pm or later and weekends. They are not paid nor do they get TOIL however their wages reflect the extra work they are expected to do

MimiGC · 02/03/2024 09:08

I'm an academic. All my colleagues and I work well over our hours, evenings, weekends and holidays included. It is expected and normalised. And it sucks.

Clove76 · 02/03/2024 08:56

ShiteRider · 02/03/2024 07:49

I’m an OT, generally I’ve always worked a few hours extra each week but taken it back in TOIL.

More recently I have worked as a lecturer and did about 15 hours extra a week, moved into university support services now and do 5-10 hours extra a week (neither including the fact that I also usually don’t have a lunch break). I think it’s pretty standard in public services, services which are underfunded (so can’t employ more staff) combined with people who go into it because they’re passionate about supporting people. Ultimately the choice is people who need help miss out and are left vulnerable or I get up early a couple of times a week to catch up with admin. Extra hours is my preference.

So lucky to get TOIL! Unheard of in roles I’ve been in. It’s good to hear your perspective having done some different roles and it seems doing extra is the norm in professional job roles..

OP posts:
Pickledprawn · 02/03/2024 08:52

I'm a part time nurse (office based) and I'm usually about two weeks behind on my admin work. I still see patients regardless if admin is complete. If I get too behind then I work overtime and get TOIL. I wouldn't work over all the time because it is reflected in your annual leave entitlement and it is a sneaky way of them getting more hours out of you for less pay.

Willmafrockfit · 02/03/2024 08:51

where i am the ahp put in for admin, x hours for patients and x hours for admin
@Clove76

Clove76 · 02/03/2024 08:50

Wrongsideofpennines · 02/03/2024 08:13

I'm an AHP in the community and rarely work extra hours. Mainly because I can't because the children need picking up and there is nobody else to do it. But I also manage my own diary. In an emergency it may happen that I do extra but we don't have RTT wait list pressures in the same way so I can manage my own caseload. I do know though that AHPs in other areas have similar problems to you. Plenty of physios in MSK will pray for a patient to cancel last minute so they can catch up on notes.

In this kind of role its not as simple as stopping doing the extra. Notes can't be done any later than 24hrs so if you don't complete your notes within that timescale then in theory you could be reported to HCPC and they will complete disciplinary proceedings.

Is there anyway your manager would reduce the amount of appointments you have in a day? Can you ask admin to book you one fewer a day and see if that helps? Unfortunately if you do the extra unpaid then you don't reflect the true cost of the service and then there is no evidence that further funding/staffing is needed.

Yes so true - it’s not as simple stopping doing the extra. The RCSLT also recommends a timeframe I believe of 2 weeks to get a report done. I’ve actually left the NHS and now work for a private company but have found the caseload issue to generally be the same. I think I’m just coming to terms with the fact that there will always be an expectation to see minimum 4 patients a day and keep up with admin in my own time. If I’m having to ask for the extra time for admin then I’m probably just not suited to the role.

It’s interesting the variety of experiences of AHPs. I’ve met paeds OTs who, at the same banding as me at the time, worked just their hours and use to clock out at 5 on the dot every day, claimed they did not do extra at home. Such a different life!

OP posts:
Phineyj · 02/03/2024 08:50

I should add that my current school are decent about overtime and gladly pay me if I lead a trip on my non work days. Which I do several times a year.

updownleftrightstart · 02/03/2024 08:49

There would be absolutely no way I could get my job done without working contracted hours. It was so bad I moved to a different organisation and it’s better but still everyone works more.
I know quite a few people in this profession at different organisations and there’s only one who is only expected to work roughly contracted hours.

Phineyj · 02/03/2024 08:49

I understand where you're coming from.

I'm a secondary school teacher in an essay based subject with all exam classes. I'm on a three day a week contract. I work at least 40 hours a week and if I were full time, it would be 60.

I get push back from colleagues for being part time sometimes even though 40 hours a week is not part time, is it?

For me it's worth it because I am guaranteed 2 days a week to do marking without staying up late to work, can do things for themselves and DD those days and it also reduces my tax bill. Plus as an experienced teacher but not management, I don't need to do a lot in school holidays.

I am well aware I am contributing to my own exploitation though. And I've knackered my career prospects but don't much care given the state of teaching. And pension can be a consideration but I am older and have other investments.

So I don't have an easy answer for you, but decide where your boundaries are personally and stick to them.

Willmafrockfit · 02/03/2024 08:47

can you minimise your work by copy and pasting certain aspects of your reports

get some short cuts

LoveAutumnColours · 02/03/2024 08:46

I used to work in the corporate world as an officer of the company (large multinational). I often didn’t start “my” work until around 4pm as I was always needed here, there etc. my contracted hours were Monday to Friday 9 to 5 with an hour for lunch. I cannot tell you how many “working lunches” I had, breakfast meetings at 7:30. As I started “my work” so late in the day, my “usual” hours were until 7:00/7:30 pm. Plus I had to be on my mobile phone checking that when not at work. On holidays, I’d have a dedicated hour for work to contact me.

this happens in many types of jobs and many different roles.

so no, not unreasonable to move jobs.

ask about this in interviews. Years and years ago, when my children were younger and I relied on a child minder, I let people know during interviews (this was admin role) that I had to leave by X time ever day due to child care and that I was doing an evening further education class to not available in the evenings. It worked.

but I did have to leave there to progress and then that required the crazy hours.

if you can take the lower pay, do so. Be clear in the interview process that you’re not available outside your contracted hours. Ask about others’ working hours and if they have a procedures manual. This can help you make your decision to accept or not.

familyissues12345 · 02/03/2024 08:40

Forgot to add, to add insult to injury I'm currently on MW too, so working extra means I'm really paid under MW - not on!

BendingSpoons · 02/03/2024 08:40

Re. The therapeutic hour, it depends how often you are seeing them. If it's an assessment then I agree no chance unless it is straightforward speech sounds! If I am doing blocks of therapy I aim for them in the room for 40mins rather than an hour (manage it probably 50% of the time!). But yes, there will be different expectations where parents are paying and want their money's worth understandably.

familyissues12345 · 02/03/2024 08:38

I'm about to leave a role due to the level of extra work required to get the job done.

I wouldn't have minded, I've done a lot of volunteering over the years so used to giving my time for free, but working extra has become an expectation and when I raised my unhappiness (and how it was impacting me, my sleep, my home life) my current boss was pretty rude about it.

So I'm off! The grass may not be greener, but I sense my new role will include the time I need to complete my job, fingers crossed!

Gwenhwyfar · 02/03/2024 08:37

montysma1 · 02/03/2024 07:47

Why on earth should individuals keep businesses and organisations afloat by working for free.
So long as folk keep doing this, they will keep taking the piss.

Yes and it also takes jobs away from other people as they can get away with not having enough staff.

3Ls · 02/03/2024 08:37

Speech and language therapist. Work my hours. If it doesn't get done today it gets done tomorrow. No one died because a report wasn't wrote - plus shorten these as SLTs have a habit of going on and no one wants to wade through so much stuff.

Band seven excellent appraisal reports part time. I work flat out when there. It can be done but takes extreme displine and being comfortable with a. To do list

Happy Birthday Bday GIF by Kyle Gordon
Clove76 · 02/03/2024 08:37

theduchessofspork · 02/03/2024 08:30

Yeah but OP’s husband is taking about professions.

Anyway, yes it is OP, sorry to say. I can’t think of anyone who doesn’t, across a huge variety of industries

Yes, this has been hugely useful to see it is actually quite commonplace amongst people in professional jobs.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread