Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to close Baby & Toddler group due to one 'mum' with a fake bump?

158 replies

HeyJugee · 02/03/2024 04:28

I ran into a friend who runs a baby & toddler group this week and am still thinking about her dilemma. Had no good advice at the time but now I can't sleep I can't stop thinking about it so am parking here.

After Christmas a new person started coming along to the B&T group with their DGD - this person dresses as a woman (no wig but bald on top and grown out long hair and bright lipstick) and has given a woman's name.

Other mums stopped coming along so numbers were down quite a lot almost immediately - since then a few new mums have come but no one new has come back the next week. My friend was thinking ok well the DGD will age out of the group soon naturally but last week it was her, her niece (helping out during half term) another helper friend/mum and this grandparent and his/her DGD.

The grandparent was wearing a fake pregnancy bump and doing a lot of stroking of his/her stomach, telling DGD to be careful of nanny's tummy.

My friend has said this was what she can't continue to run the group for the benefit of one person, can't tell them not to come even if it means no one else will so will just have to stop the group because she is not willing to go along with whatever is going to happen with the fake bump. SHe is worried for the DGD in being involved in this even one day a week (when this person cares for her). She wonders if the parents of the DGD know what goes on and are fine with it

Is she being reasonable or unreasonable in letting the group fold?

And if you think she is being unreasonable what can she do to make other mums comfortable in attending again?

And if you think she is reasonable to stop doing the group, do you think she should be alerting SS with what info she has to DGD or is she just being discriminatory and this is not safeguarding?

(ps. I don't think I would have gone back to the group - as a new mum I would have felt very sharply that I was being mocked by this person but then I had PND; I think what she told me has really disturbed me because if I had not been able to engage with this group my life could have been very different)

OP posts:
WithACatLikeTread · 02/03/2024 07:28

I have a "hand that rocks the cradle" vibes on this.

BCBird · 02/03/2024 07:26

Wtaf. It horrible ur friend is in this position. He should not be around the kids. U should not have to shut down. It will be a lifeline gor some people. Seek legal advice

MariaVT65 · 02/03/2024 07:24

RedHelenB · 02/03/2024 07:20

Males went to every toddler group I attended, although very much in a minority. I can't quite see why no one comes any longer, fake pregnancy bump or not. I'd assume if they found him a bit odd they'd just more or less ignore him beyond what manners required.Running a group like that can't really be controlled.

I have no issues whatsoever with dads or grandads going to toddler groups. I encourage it in fact.

A man pretending to be pregnant is not normal and is most likely a perverted sexual fetish and should in no way be around kids.

bubblesforbreakfast · 02/03/2024 07:21

sashh · 02/03/2024 06:09

I'm not a lawyer but could it be argued that this person using a fake baby bump is discriminating against the women in the group by ridiculing and demeaning the state of pregnancy?

The grandparent has a much clearer case under the equalities act for being asked to leave.

RedHelenB · 02/03/2024 07:20

Males went to every toddler group I attended, although very much in a minority. I can't quite see why no one comes any longer, fake pregnancy bump or not. I'd assume if they found him a bit odd they'd just more or less ignore him beyond what manners required.Running a group like that can't really be controlled.

CRAmum · 02/03/2024 07:19

MinnieMountain · 02/03/2024 07:17

And how do you feel about it @CRAmum ?

It gives me the ick and would put me off going back to this group ever again.

MinnieMountain · 02/03/2024 07:17

And how do you feel about it @CRAmum ?

Codlingmoths · 02/03/2024 07:16

I’d ask them to leave. What harm could it do since the group would fold if he keeps coming? No one else would come.
id be worried about that poor little gd. Your friend should make sure she has support on hand in case he takes it badly, but explain this group is for mums and I’m afraid while it’s clear you’d like to be one, that’s not possible and I need to ask you to leave.
then contact everyone else quietly and meet somewhere different next week.

MariaVT65 · 02/03/2024 07:16

CRAmum · 02/03/2024 07:11

I've just mentioned this to my DH and thinks it's super creepy and would be really unhappy for me to take our DS to this group. It's really frustrating because the reality is that this person is a man but the way the world the world is, confronting this man could be seen as discrimatory.

It’s not discriminatory to confront someone because they are falsely claiming to be pregnant.

Needmoresleep · 02/03/2024 07:14

LovelyButteryBiscuitBase · 02/03/2024 07:07

Nope that is not the solution.

If we want men to take a full and active role in caring for their children, things like toddler groups should be accessible for Dads as well. It is the only way that we are ever going to get any traction true equality for women.

My DH is the primary carer of our children and regularly takes our daughter to the local parent and toddler group where they are both welcomed.

OP, I can understand where your friend is coming from. The person coming to the group is not technically doing anything wrong, and to specifically exclude them will be discriminatory.

SS are already over run dealing with caseloads at the very highest thresholds imaginable, with very little resources. By all means make a referral, but it will likely be an open and then shut operation.

But does your DH wear a fake bump and claim to be a woman?

That is the issue. Other people (mums, even possibly the odd dad) will perceive this as potentially fetatistic behavior, which they won't want to be party to.

Untethered · 02/03/2024 07:14

CRAmum · 02/03/2024 07:11

I've just mentioned this to my DH and thinks it's super creepy and would be really unhappy for me to take our DS to this group. It's really frustrating because the reality is that this person is a man but the way the world the world is, confronting this man could be seen as discrimatory.

Why do we need your DH’s opinion?

CRAmum · 02/03/2024 07:11

I've just mentioned this to my DH and thinks it's super creepy and would be really unhappy for me to take our DS to this group. It's really frustrating because the reality is that this person is a man but the way the world the world is, confronting this man could be seen as discrimatory.

LovelyButteryBiscuitBase · 02/03/2024 07:07

Justfinking · 02/03/2024 05:52

I think you should ask him to leave, I try to be open minded but this is quite creepy. Say that other people have complained and left. Alternatively, set up another group and say only mothers are allowed with their children or something.

Nope that is not the solution.

If we want men to take a full and active role in caring for their children, things like toddler groups should be accessible for Dads as well. It is the only way that we are ever going to get any traction true equality for women.

My DH is the primary carer of our children and regularly takes our daughter to the local parent and toddler group where they are both welcomed.

OP, I can understand where your friend is coming from. The person coming to the group is not technically doing anything wrong, and to specifically exclude them will be discriminatory.

SS are already over run dealing with caseloads at the very highest thresholds imaginable, with very little resources. By all means make a referral, but it will likely be an open and then shut operation.

pensione · 02/03/2024 06:57

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 02/03/2024 06:10

He's a man. Everyone knows he's a man.

At least mn is a safe place to state reality.

Men can legally be excluded from certain women only spaces under the Equality Act if it serves a legitimate aim.

A group for mothers, who have all recently given birth should qualify for this exemption.

She might just be better renaming it a mothers or post partum group (as above).

The fetish/fake bump thing I'd want to report but no one will do anything without more evidence of harm to the child.

I agree. He shouldn’t be allowed. It’s a shame if these groups close.

Arewethebadguys · 02/03/2024 06:51

Ridiculous24 · 02/03/2024 05:39

It might be the easiest outcome, but it is not the best outcome. I would ask the male to leave the group.

So would I. Sometimes the grown ups in the room need to say enough is enough.

I'd report to SS, at the very least this person has mental health issues surrounding the fake bump.

No wonder you can't sleep. No neither will I! Madness

effoffwind · 02/03/2024 06:50

I'm sorry but I'd ask this man to leave

Nofilteritwonthelp · 02/03/2024 06:47

Ozgirl75 · 02/03/2024 06:01

When we aged out of our mothers group, we just got each others phone numbers and arranged to meet in a cafe, park or whatever. It wasn’t a formal group, just a group of friends meeting up. Could you suggest that she just texts the actual mums and doesn’t add the rando and they continue like that. There’s no discrimination because it’s just a group of mums.

Something like this, just be clever about it. Although it's really unfair, the trans thing isn't as bad as the fake bump which takes it into creepy territory

Sapphire387 · 02/03/2024 06:24

sashh · 02/03/2024 06:09

I'm not a lawyer but could it be argued that this person using a fake baby bump is discriminating against the women in the group by ridiculing and demeaning the state of pregnancy?

I think this could be argued.

Section of Equality Act here:

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/section/26/enacted?view=plain

Equality Act 2010

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/section/26/enacted?view=plain

Needmoresleep · 02/03/2024 06:22

Even if legally in the right, your friend may want the hassle of a potential discrimination claim. I would speak to SS about the worrying behavior around the DGD. The instincts of a number of mums may well be correct. Indeed it is possible that this person is already known to SS.

If SS are sensible your friend should be able to have a constructive conversation with them. The group will be a valuable resource to new mothers. But there is no guarantee they will be.

If she does want to continue I would report on the feminism, sex and gender board where there will be some knowledgeable people able to advise on how best to proceed.

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 02/03/2024 06:10

He's a man. Everyone knows he's a man.

At least mn is a safe place to state reality.

Men can legally be excluded from certain women only spaces under the Equality Act if it serves a legitimate aim.

A group for mothers, who have all recently given birth should qualify for this exemption.

She might just be better renaming it a mothers or post partum group (as above).

The fetish/fake bump thing I'd want to report but no one will do anything without more evidence of harm to the child.

user1492757084 · 02/03/2024 06:10

I agree that she should initiate that the other Mums meet casually in this case.
Close the official group and rename the next one.

Once it's up and running the initial Mums (older casual group of Mums) could be invited to any associated information talks etc.

sashh · 02/03/2024 06:09

I'm not a lawyer but could it be argued that this person using a fake baby bump is discriminating against the women in the group by ridiculing and demeaning the state of pregnancy?

YireosDodeAver · 02/03/2024 06:08

If a group is "by invitation only" rather than open to all comers then you can invite who you like and discrimination doesn't apply.

Close down the invaded group. Set up a new invitation-only group (different day, different venue) and invite all the old members. Create a joining procedure with garekeeping to ensure only bona fife mums with toddlers can join.

Ozgirl75 · 02/03/2024 06:01

When we aged out of our mothers group, we just got each others phone numbers and arranged to meet in a cafe, park or whatever. It wasn’t a formal group, just a group of friends meeting up. Could you suggest that she just texts the actual mums and doesn’t add the rando and they continue like that. There’s no discrimination because it’s just a group of mums.

sashh · 02/03/2024 06:00

Close it down and open a 'post partum support group'. That way the group can be for mothers only. The Equality Act allows for sex discrimination for women's safety and dignity.

Which is a shame for any stay at home or single dads who might want to bring their toddler.