Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to close Baby & Toddler group due to one 'mum' with a fake bump?

158 replies

HeyJugee · 02/03/2024 04:28

I ran into a friend who runs a baby & toddler group this week and am still thinking about her dilemma. Had no good advice at the time but now I can't sleep I can't stop thinking about it so am parking here.

After Christmas a new person started coming along to the B&T group with their DGD - this person dresses as a woman (no wig but bald on top and grown out long hair and bright lipstick) and has given a woman's name.

Other mums stopped coming along so numbers were down quite a lot almost immediately - since then a few new mums have come but no one new has come back the next week. My friend was thinking ok well the DGD will age out of the group soon naturally but last week it was her, her niece (helping out during half term) another helper friend/mum and this grandparent and his/her DGD.

The grandparent was wearing a fake pregnancy bump and doing a lot of stroking of his/her stomach, telling DGD to be careful of nanny's tummy.

My friend has said this was what she can't continue to run the group for the benefit of one person, can't tell them not to come even if it means no one else will so will just have to stop the group because she is not willing to go along with whatever is going to happen with the fake bump. SHe is worried for the DGD in being involved in this even one day a week (when this person cares for her). She wonders if the parents of the DGD know what goes on and are fine with it

Is she being reasonable or unreasonable in letting the group fold?

And if you think she is being unreasonable what can she do to make other mums comfortable in attending again?

And if you think she is reasonable to stop doing the group, do you think she should be alerting SS with what info she has to DGD or is she just being discriminatory and this is not safeguarding?

(ps. I don't think I would have gone back to the group - as a new mum I would have felt very sharply that I was being mocked by this person but then I had PND; I think what she told me has really disturbed me because if I had not been able to engage with this group my life could have been very different)

OP posts:
Beefcurtains79 · 02/03/2024 07:57

Don’t feed the disingenuous TRA.

instantick · 02/03/2024 07:56

if the whole family seem messed up with gender then i believe it could be a sign of abuse. hillbillys spring to mind. if my nan wore a fake bump and acted strange around us she would be thrown out of the family, as the girl is niece thats also a bit strange were is mom? Social services clearly if this said person was ok then people would still be coming back to group however they must sense stranger danger!

SidewaysOtter · 02/03/2024 07:56

If we want men to take a full and active role in caring for their children, things like toddler groups should be accessible for Dads as well. It is the only way that we are ever going to get any traction true equality for women.

But this person isn’t attending the group as a father, he’s attending pretending to be a woman and pretending to be pregnant. He either has some kind of mental health problem or a fetish. If the latter, he is using the women in the group to feed his fetish and they have not consented to that. I’m not a clinician but I believe that that is a central tenet of paraphilias (Google it because MN often deletes posts which reference one of the specific paraphilias that could apply here).

We need to stop “being kind” and call this out for what it is: creepy unacceptable behaviour that is happening around non-consenting women and children.

Form a new, private group that’s invitation only. If you’re all friends there’s nothing to stop you meeting up as such.

Unfortunately you might still get backlash from this man. I heard of a similar situation where the women started to meet privately at one of their houses. The man (who called himself a woman) called the police and demanded to be let in! Hmm

Luckyducky123 · 02/03/2024 07:53

This makes me so sad, years ago, this type of behaviour would have been called out and likely the Grandfather would have been removed from the class. Now, because we are pressured to accept another’s reality (socially and legally in some cases), individuals with quite complex MH disorders are allowed to turn up to a toddler group, with a fake bump - just because they ‘feel’ like it.

If your friend does make it explicitly clear that she doesn’t want him to attend, she will likely be met with legal threats on the grounds of discrimination. And so, I really like the above suggestion that a closed, invite only group sounds like the best way forward.

That poor grandbaby having to miss out is the saddest part of all. But Grandfathers reality is very distorted, and whatever he ‘believes’ is true, is true. That’s a slippery slope and a safeguarding concern around children.

Clarebelle878 · 02/03/2024 07:51

could she change her booking procedure so it’s booking only? She could then say she’s full to him when he tries to book. And to minimise the risk of it happening again she could offer trial lessons (bookable but maybe discounted) for new joiners? I’m so sorry your friend is going through this. I’ve noticed lots of groups say no walk ins now. Perhaps this is a reason why.

OolongTeaDrinker · 02/03/2024 07:49

BreakingAndBroke · 02/03/2024 07:36

How do you know they aren't coming back due to this specific person? Perhaps some have gone back to work? Perhaps it is out of budget for some due to col? Perhaps the group has changed or just isn't very good anymore?

Without being there to see it for yourself, how do you know your friend's assumptions are correct?

Perhaps the fake bump was a game that the dgc wanted to play and nanny was just going along with it?

Perhaps nanny has just had an operation and the fake bump is a bandaged wound that nanny was telling the dgc to be careful of.

Also, balding on top doesn't mean male - could be alopecia or chemo drugs or something else entirely.

Are you really saying that the OP’s friend can’t distinguish between a woman with hair loss and a man pretending to be a woman?! No trans woman ever passes as a biological female no matter how much they wish to. Also in what world do you live in that a toddler would ask the grown up
responsible for them to wear a fake bump? You are really reaching here.

SgtJuneAckland · 02/03/2024 07:49

Why is the focus on the group rather than the well being of that toddler. The fake pregnancy etc indicates mental health concerns and as a leader of a children's group your friend needs to report this to social care.

MariaVT65 · 02/03/2024 07:48

RedHelenB · 02/03/2024 07:46

I wouldn't mention his bump to him, just like I wouldn't mention one of those reborn dolls to someone. As to sexual.fetishes, I don't spend time thinking about what a person at a group is thinking or imagining. OP hasn't mentioned any incidents in particular that might make someone stay away, as I've said if someone was perceived as a bit odd then people would sit in groups elsewhere.

Why do you think this is acceptable behaviour around little children?

This counts as more than ‘a bit odd’

RedHelenB · 02/03/2024 07:46

Cailin66 · 02/03/2024 07:37

Those fathers were not pretending to be pregnant. Nor were they attending in order to carry out a sexual fetish. And getting sexual kicks from attending. This man who in my view is a pervert is seeking validation as a woman, knowing full well the other women have to pretend he is actually pregnant.

This is not someone being a bit odd. I’m surprised you think this is all it is. Why do you think all the mothers stopped coming?

Are you really prepared to put up with a stranger who wants you to validate his sexual fetishism, for his sexual excitement?

I wouldn't mention his bump to him, just like I wouldn't mention one of those reborn dolls to someone. As to sexual.fetishes, I don't spend time thinking about what a person at a group is thinking or imagining. OP hasn't mentioned any incidents in particular that might make someone stay away, as I've said if someone was perceived as a bit odd then people would sit in groups elsewhere.

TheaBrandt · 02/03/2024 07:43

I think the creepy grandad has joined the thread

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 02/03/2024 07:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

BiologicalKitty · 02/03/2024 07:42

The mental gymnastics some people are capable of is almost impressive.

We don't need to survey the women who have stopped attending the group to have a solid idea as to why. The bloke has invaded women's group, clomped around marking his new territory, and is basically destroying it.

In this Brave New World of ours, where men are whatever they say they are, and women can't speak truth to power, the very presence of a trans identified individual means you must remain silently accepting, or risk being vilified, hunted down, destroyed. And even silent acceptance may not be enough for some people.

This specific group is doomed, I'm afraid. Women will need to meet in secret, by invitation only. So much for inclusion.

HeyJugee · 02/03/2024 07:42

Thanks for replies. From reading through its obvious now that The old mums who stopped are meeting somewhere else already aren’t they? She just needs to see if she can re route new comers to them - church hall was very conveniently close so the women will have to go to ground for a bit/ meet elsewhere. Also I am going to see if I can find her an employment solicitor who does free30 min initial consult - I know it’s not employment but about services provision and how she can refuse ‘service’.

if anyone has watched Beef on Netflix I keep thinking of the personification of Amy’s self loathing as the fake mum - it gave me a real jump scare and to walk into that a few weeks after giving birth (or months for that matter) would have just freaked me out so much

OP posts:
Blahdeblah12345 · 02/03/2024 07:41

Imagine this happening even 10 years ago. It wouldn't have been tolerated. Something has gone badly wrong in society that not only are people afraid to say anything but that we have people actively defending males subjecting unwilling women and children to their fetish. It's obviously going to have to take some really public and damaging examples of this for people to wake up and see what is happening and who they are enabling. And it will happen. when people like this feel emboldened, they will escalate their behaviour. At what cost though?

Sletty · 02/03/2024 07:40

Mumsnet is the only place we can call this shit out and say this is a man occupying women’s spaces with his obvious fetish

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 02/03/2024 07:39

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

JulesJules · 02/03/2024 07:38

He's using the group - the mothers and toddlers - to validate and feed his sexual fetish. I think the best option would be as described above, close the group and then set up another by invitation only. If you ask on the Feminism board, or ask MN to move the thread there, I'm sure someone will have experience and advice for this situation.

Soontobe60 · 02/03/2024 07:38

LovelyButteryBiscuitBase · 02/03/2024 07:07

Nope that is not the solution.

If we want men to take a full and active role in caring for their children, things like toddler groups should be accessible for Dads as well. It is the only way that we are ever going to get any traction true equality for women.

My DH is the primary carer of our children and regularly takes our daughter to the local parent and toddler group where they are both welcomed.

OP, I can understand where your friend is coming from. The person coming to the group is not technically doing anything wrong, and to specifically exclude them will be discriminatory.

SS are already over run dealing with caseloads at the very highest thresholds imaginable, with very little resources. By all means make a referral, but it will likely be an open and then shut operation.

I don’t think the OP is as much concerned about the male identifying as female, more the fake pregnancy aspect. It’s clearly a man with a fetish. So the exclusion would be based on that as opposed to his actual sex. Would you be happy with someone parading his fetish in front of your toddler???
Id be looking at leaving out some Sex Matters flyers for the group!

Cailin66 · 02/03/2024 07:37

RedHelenB · 02/03/2024 07:20

Males went to every toddler group I attended, although very much in a minority. I can't quite see why no one comes any longer, fake pregnancy bump or not. I'd assume if they found him a bit odd they'd just more or less ignore him beyond what manners required.Running a group like that can't really be controlled.

Those fathers were not pretending to be pregnant. Nor were they attending in order to carry out a sexual fetish. And getting sexual kicks from attending. This man who in my view is a pervert is seeking validation as a woman, knowing full well the other women have to pretend he is actually pregnant.

This is not someone being a bit odd. I’m surprised you think this is all it is. Why do you think all the mothers stopped coming?

Are you really prepared to put up with a stranger who wants you to validate his sexual fetishism, for his sexual excitement?

lifeturnsonadime · 02/03/2024 07:37

Well isn't he a peach?

He's clearly acting out his fetish on mothers and their toddlers. Bet he loves using the women's toilets too.

This is a great example of how the TRAs have done a job on us. We've got people saying your friend can't act for fear of breaching the Equality Act. In years gone by this man wouldn't have been emboldened to act in this way. Now we have the BBC doing articles on men's 'breast milk' being a thing and this is where it leads us!

Unfortunately I do think your friend needs to tread carefully.

These fucking males have no limits to the way in which they want to make women uncomfortable. And society has enabled it by insisting we are 'kind' to people who say they are something they are not.

K1ran · 02/03/2024 07:36

As someone who also helps run a baby toddler group, before your friend shuts the group down, she should engage this individual in conversation. She needs to establish if this person is competent enough to be caring for a small child. If he is stroking his belly to imply he is pregnant, he has some mental health issues and the welfare of the child could be at risk.
She should establish why the child's mother is not bringing the child as it is a mother and baby/toddler group.
If anything he says raises concerns she should get an address, this is easy as all you say is they need to get him to do is complete a health and safety allergy form, (some children have airborne allergies you need to be aware of when running these groups) and then report him to SS. They will take note and you never know, they may already be involved. If the man is simply a freak of nature then she should politely tell him that this is a mother and baby group so unless the child is coming with the mother, unfortunately he won't be able to attend.
And carry the group on for the other mothers.

BreakingAndBroke · 02/03/2024 07:36

How do you know they aren't coming back due to this specific person? Perhaps some have gone back to work? Perhaps it is out of budget for some due to col? Perhaps the group has changed or just isn't very good anymore?

Without being there to see it for yourself, how do you know your friend's assumptions are correct?

Perhaps the fake bump was a game that the dgc wanted to play and nanny was just going along with it?

Perhaps nanny has just had an operation and the fake bump is a bandaged wound that nanny was telling the dgc to be careful of.

Also, balding on top doesn't mean male - could be alopecia or chemo drugs or something else entirely.

Idontjetwashthefucker · 02/03/2024 07:32

Beefcurtains79 · 02/03/2024 07:29

You can’t understand why no one wants to hang out with a guy wearing lipstick and a fake pregnancy stomach at a baby group?
Really?

Of course she can

FUBAR77 · 02/03/2024 07:32

Your poor friend is basically being held to ransom and in this new woke world there’s nothing she can do without looking like a bigot.

What a sad world now where we cant tell a creepy old bastard to do one.

Looks like men have found yet another loop hole in controlling us…by pretending to be women…

Beefcurtains79 · 02/03/2024 07:29

RedHelenB · 02/03/2024 07:20

Males went to every toddler group I attended, although very much in a minority. I can't quite see why no one comes any longer, fake pregnancy bump or not. I'd assume if they found him a bit odd they'd just more or less ignore him beyond what manners required.Running a group like that can't really be controlled.

You can’t understand why no one wants to hang out with a guy wearing lipstick and a fake pregnancy stomach at a baby group?
Really?