Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to close Baby & Toddler group due to one 'mum' with a fake bump?

158 replies

HeyJugee · 02/03/2024 04:28

I ran into a friend who runs a baby & toddler group this week and am still thinking about her dilemma. Had no good advice at the time but now I can't sleep I can't stop thinking about it so am parking here.

After Christmas a new person started coming along to the B&T group with their DGD - this person dresses as a woman (no wig but bald on top and grown out long hair and bright lipstick) and has given a woman's name.

Other mums stopped coming along so numbers were down quite a lot almost immediately - since then a few new mums have come but no one new has come back the next week. My friend was thinking ok well the DGD will age out of the group soon naturally but last week it was her, her niece (helping out during half term) another helper friend/mum and this grandparent and his/her DGD.

The grandparent was wearing a fake pregnancy bump and doing a lot of stroking of his/her stomach, telling DGD to be careful of nanny's tummy.

My friend has said this was what she can't continue to run the group for the benefit of one person, can't tell them not to come even if it means no one else will so will just have to stop the group because she is not willing to go along with whatever is going to happen with the fake bump. SHe is worried for the DGD in being involved in this even one day a week (when this person cares for her). She wonders if the parents of the DGD know what goes on and are fine with it

Is she being reasonable or unreasonable in letting the group fold?

And if you think she is being unreasonable what can she do to make other mums comfortable in attending again?

And if you think she is reasonable to stop doing the group, do you think she should be alerting SS with what info she has to DGD or is she just being discriminatory and this is not safeguarding?

(ps. I don't think I would have gone back to the group - as a new mum I would have felt very sharply that I was being mocked by this person but then I had PND; I think what she told me has really disturbed me because if I had not been able to engage with this group my life could have been very different)

OP posts:
MariaVT65 · 02/03/2024 08:13

Luckyducky123 · 02/03/2024 08:10

Oh @MariaVT65, I’m completely with you, 100%. But as ’trans discrimination’ is now woven into the equality act, it’s for a court to determine if this is discrimination - if Grandfather believed there were grounds for it. I’d hope, and still hold out some hope, that the courts would see clearly this is inappropriate. But would the baby group facilitator want to put herself in this potential situation. It’s very, very sad that this has to be considered, but it’s worth noting that this may be a risk

I’d be quite happy to be accused of transphobia and go to court if it means protecting young children tbh!

I’m guessing the law states that a man is allowed to claim to a be woman. I’m guessing it doesn’t say it’s acceptable to pretend to be pregnant and make other people go along with it.

DrJoanAllenby · 02/03/2024 08:13

It sounds horrific.

My first reaction was to wonder why your friend didn't tell him to sling his hook from day one but reading the replies about discrimination etc it's very worrying that your friend could face charges if she's not careful.

FallingStar21 · 02/03/2024 08:12

SgtJuneAckland · 02/03/2024 07:49

Why is the focus on the group rather than the well being of that toddler. The fake pregnancy etc indicates mental health concerns and as a leader of a children's group your friend needs to report this to social care.

This!!!!

I've just seen this thread and am utterly shocked that nearly all of the replies just talk about the baby group and how to get this man out.

There is a young vulnerable child with him, goodness knows what she is subjected to - as PP said if she is even his DGD and how this creep is messing with her head... At the very least!
I'd be worried he could be harming/abusing her further, and what kind of parents let him "look after" her???

If I were a mum in that group I wouldn't be just turning round and leaving, I'd be trying befriend him and the child out of concern, to gain more understanding of what's going on - and would be reporting this.

Even more so if I was running the group- your friend has a duty of care towards that child.

All adults are creeped out/sickened by this man but all they think about is leaving or closing the group. Leaving him to it with a vulnerable child, eh?

AngelinaFibres · 02/03/2024 08:12

BreakingAndBroke · 02/03/2024 07:36

How do you know they aren't coming back due to this specific person? Perhaps some have gone back to work? Perhaps it is out of budget for some due to col? Perhaps the group has changed or just isn't very good anymore?

Without being there to see it for yourself, how do you know your friend's assumptions are correct?

Perhaps the fake bump was a game that the dgc wanted to play and nanny was just going along with it?

Perhaps nanny has just had an operation and the fake bump is a bandaged wound that nanny was telling the dgc to be careful of.

Also, balding on top doesn't mean male - could be alopecia or chemo drugs or something else entirely.

Oh dear God there's always one

pensione · 02/03/2024 08:12

candgen625 · 02/03/2024 08:08

Yea I'm with you on this. Quite a few men came to all my baby groups as well it never seemed to really bother anyone.

You can’t see why a balding man with grown out hair and bright lipstick pretending to be pregnant and rubbing a fake pregnancy bump would put off new mums?

Luckyducky123 · 02/03/2024 08:10

MariaVT65 · 02/03/2024 08:01

I still don’t agree this couldn’t be classed as discrimination, especially due to the fake baby bump. Inappropriate behaviour is just that even if caused by MH. The group is at risk of being shut down because of this one person. People are allowed to feel safe.

Oh @MariaVT65, I’m completely with you, 100%. But as ’trans discrimination’ is now woven into the equality act, it’s for a court to determine if this is discrimination - if Grandfather believed there were grounds for it. I’d hope, and still hold out some hope, that the courts would see clearly this is inappropriate. But would the baby group facilitator want to put herself in this potential situation. It’s very, very sad that this has to be considered, but it’s worth noting that this may be a risk

crockofshite · 02/03/2024 08:09

BreakingAndBroke · 02/03/2024 07:36

How do you know they aren't coming back due to this specific person? Perhaps some have gone back to work? Perhaps it is out of budget for some due to col? Perhaps the group has changed or just isn't very good anymore?

Without being there to see it for yourself, how do you know your friend's assumptions are correct?

Perhaps the fake bump was a game that the dgc wanted to play and nanny was just going along with it?

Perhaps nanny has just had an operation and the fake bump is a bandaged wound that nanny was telling the dgc to be careful of.

Also, balding on top doesn't mean male - could be alopecia or chemo drugs or something else entirely.

Yeah, perhaps, could be, maybe, who knows 🤣

You twat.

UtterlyOtterly · 02/03/2024 08:08

BreakingandBroke Don't be so ridiculous. Of course the women at the group can tell if it is a man or a woman.

You are so obviously a man who thinks women are stupid. We are not.

pickledandpuzzled · 02/03/2024 08:08

Spread the word among the original members to stay in touch, it’s being addressed. Ask them to come back after Easter.

Talk to the man. Find out a bit more about their circumstances.
I don’t think you can assume any threat to the child beyond the currently acceptable requirement to accept men are women. If there is more play acting around the bump that could be safeguarding issue. Ask whether people register to go there- does she have a name address etc.

After a session doing the above, change the age range of the group to focus more on babies. Age his toddler out. Increase the age as needed when it feels safe to do so.

candgen625 · 02/03/2024 08:08

RedHelenB · 02/03/2024 07:20

Males went to every toddler group I attended, although very much in a minority. I can't quite see why no one comes any longer, fake pregnancy bump or not. I'd assume if they found him a bit odd they'd just more or less ignore him beyond what manners required.Running a group like that can't really be controlled.

Yea I'm with you on this. Quite a few men came to all my baby groups as well it never seemed to really bother anyone.

FilthyforFirth · 02/03/2024 08:08

Ask him to leave, domt shut the group down, report to SS.

I would not have come to a group where he was present. And I say this as someome who made a great dad friend at a baby class with my second.

crockofshite · 02/03/2024 08:07

It's a bl8ke in a fr8ck.

Close the group and reopen by invitation only.

MariaVT65 · 02/03/2024 08:06

SidewaysOtter · 02/03/2024 08:04

Unfortunately men who claim to be women are very quick to claim discrimination, and various authorities are equally quick to back them for fear of being seen to be “transphobic” or “unkind”.

Women just get chucked under the bus. We’re expected to budge up and relinquish our rights to be safe in the name of “inclusivity”.

Again, this is why i’ve said from post 1 only to mention the fake bump issue, not the trans factor.

If a biological woman came in with a fake bump, i’d still be concerned.

SidewaysOtter · 02/03/2024 08:04

MariaVT65 · 02/03/2024 08:01

I still don’t agree this couldn’t be classed as discrimination, especially due to the fake baby bump. Inappropriate behaviour is just that even if caused by MH. The group is at risk of being shut down because of this one person. People are allowed to feel safe.

Unfortunately men who claim to be women are very quick to claim discrimination, and various authorities are equally quick to back them for fear of being seen to be “transphobic” or “unkind”.

Women just get chucked under the bus. We’re expected to budge up and relinquish our rights to be safe in the name of “inclusivity”.

MariaVT65 · 02/03/2024 08:03

BreakingAndBroke · 02/03/2024 07:36

How do you know they aren't coming back due to this specific person? Perhaps some have gone back to work? Perhaps it is out of budget for some due to col? Perhaps the group has changed or just isn't very good anymore?

Without being there to see it for yourself, how do you know your friend's assumptions are correct?

Perhaps the fake bump was a game that the dgc wanted to play and nanny was just going along with it?

Perhaps nanny has just had an operation and the fake bump is a bandaged wound that nanny was telling the dgc to be careful of.

Also, balding on top doesn't mean male - could be alopecia or chemo drugs or something else entirely.

i’m trying to think of a response to this without getting banned 😂

UtterlyOtterly · 02/03/2024 08:03

Do any of the mums have a house large enough to invite several mums and babies? That way it is a private get together and not one the man can gatecrash.

It is absolutely appalling that the woman who runs the group cannot just tell him to leave. The world has gone very wrong.

But I agree that the safety of the little girl is important and it needs to be logged with SS.

Zyq · 02/03/2024 08:03

sashh · 02/03/2024 06:09

I'm not a lawyer but could it be argued that this person using a fake baby bump is discriminating against the women in the group by ridiculing and demeaning the state of pregnancy?

No

LittlePinkLampshade · 02/03/2024 08:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

rainydaysandwednesdays · 02/03/2024 08:01

My god. Get rid of the nut job and report!

MariaVT65 · 02/03/2024 08:01

Luckyducky123 · 02/03/2024 07:53

This makes me so sad, years ago, this type of behaviour would have been called out and likely the Grandfather would have been removed from the class. Now, because we are pressured to accept another’s reality (socially and legally in some cases), individuals with quite complex MH disorders are allowed to turn up to a toddler group, with a fake bump - just because they ‘feel’ like it.

If your friend does make it explicitly clear that she doesn’t want him to attend, she will likely be met with legal threats on the grounds of discrimination. And so, I really like the above suggestion that a closed, invite only group sounds like the best way forward.

That poor grandbaby having to miss out is the saddest part of all. But Grandfathers reality is very distorted, and whatever he ‘believes’ is true, is true. That’s a slippery slope and a safeguarding concern around children.

I still don’t agree this couldn’t be classed as discrimination, especially due to the fake baby bump. Inappropriate behaviour is just that even if caused by MH. The group is at risk of being shut down because of this one person. People are allowed to feel safe.

BelindaOkra · 02/03/2024 07:59

I would put in a safeguarding as a man wearing a fake pregnancy bump and acting in a delusional manner towards a child is a concern. SS may decide it isn’t an issue, but I would be concerned by the stroking of a fake bump. FWIW I would raise a safeguarding about a woman doing the same thing in charge of a child.

Being trans isn’t an issue - but this sounds like something else. However, it will be difficult to navigate because it is hard to put into words how it is different. Is the group run by a church or charity or anything? Or is there advice available from the LA?

drspouse · 02/03/2024 07:59

BreakingAndBroke · 02/03/2024 07:36

How do you know they aren't coming back due to this specific person? Perhaps some have gone back to work? Perhaps it is out of budget for some due to col? Perhaps the group has changed or just isn't very good anymore?

Without being there to see it for yourself, how do you know your friend's assumptions are correct?

Perhaps the fake bump was a game that the dgc wanted to play and nanny was just going along with it?

Perhaps nanny has just had an operation and the fake bump is a bandaged wound that nanny was telling the dgc to be careful of.

Also, balding on top doesn't mean male - could be alopecia or chemo drugs or something else entirely.

I see the bloke in question has found the thread.
We know a man is a man. We have eyes and ears.

EveSix · 02/03/2024 07:58

Urgh. The man's toddler companion is an accessory to his fetish. He is exploiting a child fir sexual gratification. Report.

SidewaysOtter · 02/03/2024 07:58

Oh, and I’d absolutely be reporting this man to social services. He is using his grandchild (and is it even his grandchild?) as part of whatever it is that’s wrong with him. What kind of mindfuck is being played on that child that “Grandad” is suddenly “Granny who is having a baby”?!

SaturdayGiraffe · 02/03/2024 07:58

What else is he getting away with because women are too afraid of hurting his feelings.