Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my niece she won’t make it into Oxford uni?

561 replies

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

OP posts:
Calliopespa · 03/03/2024 08:14

cardiffcatarrhalchoices · 03/03/2024 08:12

I hold it a child abuse to even make the prediction. Burdening that onto the kids.
I don't know if the admissions process was already this tight in the 80s, not having been through it. But it was a very obvious abuse of me, when the adults excitedly labelling me gifted just because I had been a "hyperlexic" early reader spent half my childhood, from 8 to my pressure breakdown at 14, treating it as an expert certainty that I would go to Cambridge, and chicken countingly recklessly predicting it, both as part of my school's propaganda and to relatives the world away. At 8 they told me I had to want to do it because I would spend my life feeling frustrated if I underachieved.
Instead, their fantasy took on a life of its own, laughing off any cautious words by me and giving me no say over my own rational limits, resulting in a pushed too hard crash, adolescent unit, and the school still did not give up the Cambridge objective even after that, though my work now was not remotely near it. I achieved nothing beyond O-levels, did not go to uni at all, was better off for that as i was not in debt facing Thatcherism, and I have lifelong post-traumatic anxiety against taking on any type of exam course ever again.

I’m sorry to hear that Cardiff. It’s a very wise caution to parents.

cardiffcatarrhalchoices · 03/03/2024 08:12

BC2603 · 03/03/2024 07:12

I was put into the ‘Oxbridge’ group at 6th Form - those they encouraged to apply due to predicted grades. The application and interview process is hard and I didn’t get a place but I wasn’t upset about it. I didn’t get the vibe I wanted there. Instead I went to another top university which met my needs so much better

Oxbridge really isn’t everything!

I hold it a child abuse to even make the prediction. Burdening that onto the kids.
I don't know if the admissions process was already this tight in the 80s, not having been through it. But it was a very obvious abuse of me, when the adults excitedly labelling me gifted just because I had been a "hyperlexic" early reader spent half my childhood, from 8 to my pressure breakdown at 14, treating it as an expert certainty that I would go to Cambridge, and chicken countingly recklessly predicting it, both as part of my school's propaganda and to relatives the world away. At 8 they told me I had to want to do it because I would spend my life feeling frustrated if I underachieved.
Instead, their fantasy took on a life of its own, laughing off any cautious words by me and giving me no say over my own rational limits, resulting in a pushed too hard crash, adolescent unit, and the school still did not give up the Cambridge objective even after that, though my work now was not remotely near it. I achieved nothing beyond O-levels, did not go to uni at all, was better off for that as i was not in debt facing Thatcherism, and I have lifelong post-traumatic anxiety against taking on any type of exam course ever again.

Calliopespa · 03/03/2024 07:36

JessS1990 · 03/03/2024 06:55

I have met many more Oxbridge academics who would rather the students they teach did not do anything extra-curricular than who would like them to be well rounded. And have never heard of extra-curricular activities being a source of discussion at interview.

That’s very true. I understand why people are thinking it’s like a job interview, or even senior school, both of which will mean long hours spent with the applicant, perhaps having to interface with clients or at school needing to join in as s team member for games etc. In those contexts the roundedness is well sought, and with reason. But in the Oxbridge interview time will generally be spent in scholastic work. They want the ones who will grapple best with what they teach. Also colleges often are informally competitive within themselves: they want the best academically and they have a slightly different way of perceiving that from the gcse/ a level syllabus that focuses on conscientious preparation of a very accessible syllabus.

Gummybear23 · 03/03/2024 07:28

I come from a poor single parent household.

Got poor Alevels due to homelessness and caring resp.

Went to a low end university.

Entered world of work and realized I'm as bright as those who went to oxbridge.

Life has been wonderful to me since working.

Am happy, healthy and financially comfortable.

Hollowgast · 03/03/2024 07:25

Iliketosmile · 02/03/2024 19:39

Personally, I wouldn't recommend either Oxford or Cambridge for a 'normal' person. 3 x 8 week terms is very intense. My partner went to Cambridge and had a fairly horrible time. I did postgraduate there and loved it. If you're mega rich/went to private school/thrive on intense work load maybe. There's a lot of keeping up with the Joneses stuff going on. A good red brick first, then postgrad is more manageable and fun in my experience.

There's no denying that it's incredibly hard work. I did NatSci and had lectures on Saturday morning. Some people, like in all universities were unhappy, but there is a lot of support available. The key thing in my opinion is choosing your college. At Cambridge, Churchill was where I chose to go as it was 70% state school with lots of "normal" people and I had a great time. My best mates were the sons of a bus driver and a coal miner (really!). There are hardship funds available so you don't need to be mega rich. Other colleges can be more elitist (Trinity) and some outright snobby (St John's in my experience) which is why choosing is so vital.

Brexile · 03/03/2024 07:21

ftp · 02/03/2024 20:42

DofE on top of the same grades as the next person may well tip the balance of course, showing that you can work hard AND contribute to the life of the Uni.

This is absurd. I doubt there's a single admissions tutor in Oxford who cares about Duke of Edinburgh awards. In two years of sixth form, two summer schools for Oxbridge applicants and four years at Oxford I never once heard a single person even mention it. Not once.

BC2603 · 03/03/2024 07:12

I was put into the ‘Oxbridge’ group at 6th Form - those they encouraged to apply due to predicted grades. The application and interview process is hard and I didn’t get a place but I wasn’t upset about it. I didn’t get the vibe I wanted there. Instead I went to another top university which met my needs so much better

Oxbridge really isn’t everything!

Brexile · 03/03/2024 06:57

ItsallIeverwanted · 01/03/2024 18:43

I think it's fine to have a lower GCSE grade in a non-important subject, say Maths, if you read History, just one or two, but not beyond that. Also, people that went even 10 years ago, let alone when I went 30 years ago, there's been huge grade inflation, so they are looking at the very highest grades in A levels, understandably- a B is not a B in old money, it's a C.

This. How would someone even cope with the standards and the workload at Oxford if they were only getting Bs at A Level? Even if she did somehow get in, she'd be hopelessly out of her depth.

YANBU

JessS1990 · 03/03/2024 06:55

ftp · 03/03/2024 01:17

No, not a criteria. BUT Cambridge do interview more of their applicants than many other Unis, and going into interview alongside others with the same qualifications, as I said, it shows you have what it takes to get those AND do something else that rounded your life experience. With competition for space, it may well be the tipping point.
I can honestly say that I once got a great job - passed the assessment, and the tech interview. Final round was a quick chat with the big boss (the "fit" interview) A chat about my running Beaver Scouts was what tipped the balance.

I have met many more Oxbridge academics who would rather the students they teach did not do anything extra-curricular than who would like them to be well rounded. And have never heard of extra-curricular activities being a source of discussion at interview.

78Summer · 03/03/2024 06:51

Totally reasonable, you were simply giving your professional unbiased opinion.
Your sister in law will hopefully calm down in time.

Wait17 · 03/03/2024 06:49

Zanatdy · 01/03/2024 18:10

My son didn’t get an interview with 3 x A* and 97% on average in every A level paper he did (and mainly 9’s and 3 8’s in GCSE). So I think you were right to tell her it’s unlikely. I mean she would have to massively pull her socks up if she wanted to apply. Everyone applying has top grades

My son had 4 A* at A level and GCSE all 9s and one 8 and didn't get in. I don't know what they look for; didnt even get an interview. He ended up in Durham where they mostly take averages of Bs and As. So all the hard work and nothing. I don't think grades are the only thing that oxford looks at.
However, OP you are a relative, and regardless of the fact that you were tutoring her, I think the blow/dose of reality should have delt by someone else.

mids2019 · 03/03/2024 06:40

And yet we have Oxbridge sending out reach teams to schools in deprived areas where in reality very few students typically are getting A levels necessary for entrance with the message 'Oxbridge is for you!'

Ok for maybe 1% of a school cohort at a failing inner city comp this may have relevance but not for the vast majority. I think the out reach to areas which have historically sent few to Oxford or Cambridge maybe is slightly counter productive in that it gives false hope so I can see how some may have over optimistic thoughts of their offspring going to elite universities.

Yes reality checks are need as in this case but are Oxbridge helping by continually asking children for non standard backgrounds to apply when in reality those from traditionally underrepresented schools and regions can't apply because in the whole their grades are too low?

Stephenra · 03/03/2024 02:29

ftp · 03/03/2024 01:08

I have lost track of the number of children whose aspirations have been crushed by mean words. On my classroom wall is "Do not say you cannot do it, say you cannot do it YET". I had a very fierce word with my Grandson's football coach - he came home crushed and really upset, I finally found out that his coach had said he would not make a professional footballer because he did not listen - he was only 9 - how on earth would he know how the child would be? ( a child who was the major goal scorer for his team that year). What he SHOULD have said is that "if he listened more and did what was said, he might make a reasonable footballer". Just in the same way as advising the ways that chances can be improved is your job, and helping do those things, NOT telling them they cannot succeed.
I went to school with a boy who failed 11+, was bottom streamed by someone who was "facing the cold hard reality" for him. With a great teacher who analysed his problem, with specialist language skills help and remedial English lessons, he went on to FOUR A* levels in Maths, Pre Maths, Physics and Chemistry and an award winning career (but only a scrape at English GCSE it had to be said, but that was the door that opened it all).
Surely whatever her relationship, she was being paid to work out what was needed and provide it - if she is not good enough a tutor, she should have said so and recommended others

Edited

An object lesson in missing my point entirely and conflating utterly different things.

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/03/2024 02:05

ftp · 03/03/2024 01:17

No, not a criteria. BUT Cambridge do interview more of their applicants than many other Unis, and going into interview alongside others with the same qualifications, as I said, it shows you have what it takes to get those AND do something else that rounded your life experience. With competition for space, it may well be the tipping point.
I can honestly say that I once got a great job - passed the assessment, and the tech interview. Final round was a quick chat with the big boss (the "fit" interview) A chat about my running Beaver Scouts was what tipped the balance.

Congratulations on the job- but interviews for university admissions are not the same as (many) job interviews. Interviewers are not looking for rounded life experience! We are, after all, academics: i.e. what some would consider as un-rounded nerds!

We are not looking for all-rounders. We are not looking for a particular type of personality. We are not looking for ability to fit into an organization. We are looking for ability to think about the academic subject. What would make an applicant stand out is not their extracurricular experiences, but their ability, for example, to suggest ways of designing an experiment, if applying for a science subject, or their originality in discussing a literary work, if applying for a literature-related subject.

Of course, many universities don't interview at all; but those that do, are using the interview as part of an academic assessment.

The danger of the idea that universities are looking for 'all-rounders' or people with lots of extra-curricular experience, is that it can discourage students from disadvantaged backgrounds, students with health problems, or those who just lack social confidence from applying at all.

CrocusSnowdrop · 03/03/2024 01:56

I wonder if the confusion around "contributing to uni life" comes from Oxbridge having very good sports teams, university orchestras, choral foundations etc. It's true that there are a lot of students who are talented in areas outside their degree, as well as in their subject. But that doesn't mean that they're selected on extra-curriculars, it just means that clever young people are often clever or skilled in more than one area. At junior conservatoire, if you weren't going to conservatoire, you were going to Oxbridge. And of course, lots have never done any of the apparently desirable (but actually irrelevant) extra-curricular activities, and devote their free time to JCR roles, or learning a language at the language centre, or the pub.

CrocusSnowdrop · 03/03/2024 01:44

ftp · 03/03/2024 01:17

No, not a criteria. BUT Cambridge do interview more of their applicants than many other Unis, and going into interview alongside others with the same qualifications, as I said, it shows you have what it takes to get those AND do something else that rounded your life experience. With competition for space, it may well be the tipping point.
I can honestly say that I once got a great job - passed the assessment, and the tech interview. Final round was a quick chat with the big boss (the "fit" interview) A chat about my running Beaver Scouts was what tipped the balance.

Still not the case at Oxford though. Neither of my interviews so much as mentioned any of my extra curriculars, not even as ice breakers.
What did get me in was, I assume, my ability in the subject as demonstrated by the tasks set for me to work through in the interview, which also showed my capacity to be taught through the tutorial system, and my ability to back up what I said with super-curricular reading. Plus obviously the admissions test and A level grades.
There isn't a "fit" interview, it's not a job.

ftp · 03/03/2024 01:17

JessS1990 · 02/03/2024 20:53

Not part of the selection criteria, at either Oxford, Cambridge or any other UK university I am aware of.

No, not a criteria. BUT Cambridge do interview more of their applicants than many other Unis, and going into interview alongside others with the same qualifications, as I said, it shows you have what it takes to get those AND do something else that rounded your life experience. With competition for space, it may well be the tipping point.
I can honestly say that I once got a great job - passed the assessment, and the tech interview. Final round was a quick chat with the big boss (the "fit" interview) A chat about my running Beaver Scouts was what tipped the balance.

ftp · 03/03/2024 01:08

Stephenra · 03/03/2024 00:34

Tutor here. I can tell you I deal with some parents and students whose aspirations and ambitions are not even on the same planet as cold hard reality.

Your assessment of your neice's academic track record in relation to whether she can get into Oxford is perfectly correct, rational and realistic. ('The occasional A'???)

Also if dreams were trampled underfoot by one comment by a relative is seems that those 'dreams' were on pretty thin ice. And what about the commentaries from other teachers and schools and career officers? Doesn't seem reasonable they are behaving as though one remark from an aunt is enough to scupper life plans.

I can say that you seem to have been unwittingly pulled in as an unfortunate scapegoat. I have been blamed dozens of times for crappy exam results and failures for people to get into their college of choice.

But no. You were not 'in the wrong.' Stick to your guns.

Edited

I have lost track of the number of children whose aspirations have been crushed by mean words. On my classroom wall is "Do not say you cannot do it, say you cannot do it YET". I had a very fierce word with my Grandson's football coach - he came home crushed and really upset, I finally found out that his coach had said he would not make a professional footballer because he did not listen - he was only 9 - how on earth would he know how the child would be? ( a child who was the major goal scorer for his team that year). What he SHOULD have said is that "if he listened more and did what was said, he might make a reasonable footballer". Just in the same way as advising the ways that chances can be improved is your job, and helping do those things, NOT telling them they cannot succeed.
I went to school with a boy who failed 11+, was bottom streamed by someone who was "facing the cold hard reality" for him. With a great teacher who analysed his problem, with specialist language skills help and remedial English lessons, he went on to FOUR A* levels in Maths, Pre Maths, Physics and Chemistry and an award winning career (but only a scrape at English GCSE it had to be said, but that was the door that opened it all).
Surely whatever her relationship, she was being paid to work out what was needed and provide it - if she is not good enough a tutor, she should have said so and recommended others

Stephenra · 03/03/2024 00:34

Tutor here. I can tell you I deal with some parents and students whose aspirations and ambitions are not even on the same planet as cold hard reality.

Your assessment of your neice's academic track record in relation to whether she can get into Oxford is perfectly correct, rational and realistic. ('The occasional A'???)

Also if dreams were trampled underfoot by one comment by a relative is seems that those 'dreams' were on pretty thin ice. And what about the commentaries from other teachers and schools and career officers? Doesn't seem reasonable they are behaving as though one remark from an aunt is enough to scupper life plans.

I can say that you seem to have been unwittingly pulled in as an unfortunate scapegoat. I have been blamed dozens of times for crappy exam results and failures for people to get into their college of choice.

But no. You were not 'in the wrong.' Stick to your guns.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 23:24

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 23:23

It is part of it. It’s the first hurdle. But, because they know the limitations of those grades in terms of what they can tell about the candidate, they don’t just take them in order of best to worst grades from that point. So in theory the person with the very best grades could turn up and not get a place while people with lower grades did. (And actually it’s not just in theory that people with higher grades get turned down while people with lower grades get offers. Otherwise they might as well just get a computer to do the selection process).

And you don’t know that people are “ armchair experts.”

Ramalangadingdong · 02/03/2024 23:23

I honestly feel that we are so harsh on the younger generation. I wonder what it does to a young and still developing mind to live through a pandemic, to see on the news everyday the rising numbers of the dead and to see that reflected in one’s own family or the family of friends. I have noticed that this may have engendered a sense of hopelessness in some young people, the sense that the future is quite bleak. This is why I feel we should encourage them. Op is right not to give false hope but we should help them to see that there is a bright future ahead and give them options as to how to achieve it.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 23:23

Withinthesewalls · 02/03/2024 21:34

I haven’t misunderstood anything. I made an observation about the number of armchair experts confidently explaining what Oxford do or don’t want, and how they can’t all be correct.

I would have thought it was obvious to even the meanest intelligence that universities will consider exam results as part of their application process.

It is part of it. It’s the first hurdle. But, because they know the limitations of those grades in terms of what they can tell about the candidate, they don’t just take them in order of best to worst grades from that point. So in theory the person with the very best grades could turn up and not get a place while people with lower grades did. (And actually it’s not just in theory that people with higher grades get turned down while people with lower grades get offers. Otherwise they might as well just get a computer to do the selection process).

ExtraDay · 02/03/2024 23:22

Did you mean to put that on a different thread, myfaceismyown?

myfaceismyown · 02/03/2024 23:17

We only sent our DD to public school as her cohort were not even vaguely in the same league. She was way in front and frequently got into trouble for reading under her desk as she had finished the work. At the end of primary school they did a theatrical performance. That year's leavers voted for the future career of each other. We had builders, nail technicians, beauticians, plasterers and tanning salon owners. My DD was listed as "author".Hence my DM and DF paying for tuition at a minor public school .Yes public school not private. Dating back to 1700s with well known allumni throughout its long history. The whole private school thing appears to be an Americanisation. I don't really care about this as i just wanted our DD to have an apt education. At public school she was in a cohort who were on an equal academic and social level which made her school life far more pleasant. It has not benefitted her in the least with her occupation. That has been entirely on her own merit. What I would credit the school with is giving her confidence and self belief.

LubyLooTwo · 02/03/2024 22:54

I think you gave good advice.Forget what they think and move on.