Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my niece she won’t make it into Oxford uni?

561 replies

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

OP posts:
RealRubyBee · 03/03/2024 13:26

personal achievement and aspirations are powerful motivators, wanting to attend oxford can help to inspire someone to see what they can achieve and then strive for further improvements, and then pushing themselves academically and personally to achieve this,

setting such a goal as oxford can drive them to improve their grades, engage with more extracurricular activities and refine their essential soft and hard skills.

besides even if they do not ultimately make it to oxford the journey itself towards that goad can at least lead to various improvements in personal achievements,

sometimes what matters more is aiming high and then trying to achieve as much as possible.

Spybot · 03/03/2024 13:13

I knew someone who got into Oxford with BCD A levels in the 90s but he'd done really well on their own admission exam and interview. He went to to graduate with a 2:1. Is it purely about A levels these days?

Calliopespa · 03/03/2024 12:16

ItsallIeverwanted · 03/03/2024 11:17

Its also not incompatible with the Oxbridge desire to increase diversity. They are looking for those students who haven't got families full of uni grads and aunties who can tutor them in two subjects. They are looking for precisely those students who don't have those advantages and would be getting A stars if it weren't for their severe disadvantages (lack of family going to university, impoverished living conditions, living in poor area, experiencing discrimination etc).

This is very true . It’s just a lot easier said than done, especially as they need to be mindful of the impact on the students themselves in a course which for which they are not ideally suited. That latter concern actually equally applies to students who are in the right channels but not really hitting the results/ of the right intellectual style.
Oxbridge gets a lot of negativity directed at it, from absurd stories about dining etiquette being a basis of inclusion to angry denouncement from people who have struggled with the demands of the course, but much effort is directed at getting it right. Sadly there is no Hogwarts style “ sorting hat”; but for the right student it is a fabulous education ( though NOT necessarily a shortcut to a high paid job). It is for the genuinely academically inclined, and for the ambitious and exceedingly “rounded” there are lots of other options that may feed much more efficiently into the type of career they desire. It is a case of the applicants themselves being truly honest with themselves about their motivations and the draw and their real aspirations, as well as the university itself determining suitability in terms of intellectual approach. It really isn’t the rosiest path for all and the fact that the university is sensitive to that doesn’t make it elitist or any of the other tosh levelled at it .

Brexile · 03/03/2024 12:13

TheRaptures · 03/03/2024 09:32

That’s even sillier than the ‘You have to pass an arcane High Table dining test involving unpitted soft fruit’ myth.

Ah, the cherry pie test! That was All Souls, wasn't it? I went there once by mistake, ducking into a random college doorway when I was being followed and harrassed by a pervert on the High Street. A tweedy type walked through the quad, looked me up and down contemptuously, and asked me whether I was lost.😂Luckily by the time I was finally ejected and/or unable to withstand the embarrassment any longer, the pervert had gone.

Happy days.😀

ItsallIeverwanted · 03/03/2024 11:17

Its also not incompatible with the Oxbridge desire to increase diversity. They are looking for those students who haven't got families full of uni grads and aunties who can tutor them in two subjects. They are looking for precisely those students who don't have those advantages and would be getting A stars if it weren't for their severe disadvantages (lack of family going to university, impoverished living conditions, living in poor area, experiencing discrimination etc).

ItsallIeverwanted · 03/03/2024 11:09

Thing is- as I tried to explain before, focusing on Oxbridge while you would be better suited elsewhere is a waste of actual time and energy. You are better spending time thinking about your subject, where is good, looking up league tables, visiting on open days, finding out about extra opportunities (e.g. places where employability or placements are great, such as Bath), and working out where it makes economic sense to plough your efforts.

That's what's sensible to do.

Most of the examples of people on here limiting 'dreams' are real- many people are dismissed or not encouraged and that's an awful thing to do to a child or a teen. But in this instance, the OP's niece is already getting every advantage, she's having personal (possibly free?!) tutoring in two out of her three A levels, and is hitting good but not outstanding grades. Giving specialist advice, knowing the undergrad market, is not pouring water on dreams, it's valuable sensible advice that could help orient this person to getting into the best uni they can for their grades/wanted outcomes (e.g. getting into a RG uni, getting into somewhere in the top 5 for her subject, getting on a placement 4 year course or year abroad).

That's not the same as saying to a small kid 'you won't achieve this' for no particular reason.

scoobysnaxx · 03/03/2024 10:47

@Awfulaunt how are things OP? Have you spoken to your nice or SIL?

ExtraDay · 03/03/2024 10:25

Hollowgast · 03/03/2024 07:25

There's no denying that it's incredibly hard work. I did NatSci and had lectures on Saturday morning. Some people, like in all universities were unhappy, but there is a lot of support available. The key thing in my opinion is choosing your college. At Cambridge, Churchill was where I chose to go as it was 70% state school with lots of "normal" people and I had a great time. My best mates were the sons of a bus driver and a coal miner (really!). There are hardship funds available so you don't need to be mega rich. Other colleges can be more elitist (Trinity) and some outright snobby (St John's in my experience) which is why choosing is so vital.

Um, my (female) best mate was at Churchill and the daughter of a coal miner!

(Also a NatSci, 1980s vintage.)

scoobysnaxx · 03/03/2024 10:17

You did the right thing.

If she's looking at uni applications and looking at oxbridge she should already know her grades aren't though!

If she didn't already know this, then she doesn't have a clue about oxbridge.

Goldenbear · 03/03/2024 10:13

mids2019 · 03/03/2024 06:40

And yet we have Oxbridge sending out reach teams to schools in deprived areas where in reality very few students typically are getting A levels necessary for entrance with the message 'Oxbridge is for you!'

Ok for maybe 1% of a school cohort at a failing inner city comp this may have relevance but not for the vast majority. I think the out reach to areas which have historically sent few to Oxford or Cambridge maybe is slightly counter productive in that it gives false hope so I can see how some may have over optimistic thoughts of their offspring going to elite universities.

Yes reality checks are need as in this case but are Oxbridge helping by continually asking children for non standard backgrounds to apply when in reality those from traditionally underrepresented schools and regions can't apply because in the whole their grades are too low?

I know right, 'uneasy is the head that wears a crown'. The privileged or should we refer to them as the 'poor unfortunates', discriminated against, all in the name of, 'diversity'.

LlynTegid · 03/03/2024 10:12

Realism is being sensible, far too many young people have unrealistic ones. I think you did the right thing OP.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/03/2024 10:01

LarkspurLane · 03/03/2024 09:29

This is too late unless she wants to take a gap year and apply with grades in hand.

That’s what a dd did. Hadn’t been working, predicted grades not good enough for the course/uni she wanted.
She pulled her socks up and got the grades, applied post As, 6 unconditional offers, took a gap year, got a job and saved some money.

Merrymouse · 03/03/2024 09:54

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/03/2024 08:53

This sounds perfect.

Given the timetable of the admissions process, it’s not correct.

Withinthesewalls · 03/03/2024 09:39

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 23:24

And you don’t know that people are “ armchair experts.”

No that’s true, it is possible that the admissions staff of several Oxford colleges all happened to converge on every Oxford related thread.

Calliopespa · 03/03/2024 09:34

BabyBlue777 · 03/03/2024 09:09

If she claimed to be transexual or a minority she´d get in even as a C student. I heard directly from the horses mouth that Oxford has to become diverse now. IF she says she identifies as a cabbage she´d get in tomorrow.

Was the horse wot said it an actual horse or just identifying as one?

TheRaptures · 03/03/2024 09:32

BabyBlue777 · 03/03/2024 09:09

If she claimed to be transexual or a minority she´d get in even as a C student. I heard directly from the horses mouth that Oxford has to become diverse now. IF she says she identifies as a cabbage she´d get in tomorrow.

That’s even sillier than the ‘You have to pass an arcane High Table dining test involving unpitted soft fruit’ myth.

EarthlyNightshade · 03/03/2024 09:30

BabyBlue777 · 03/03/2024 09:09

If she claimed to be transexual or a minority she´d get in even as a C student. I heard directly from the horses mouth that Oxford has to become diverse now. IF she says she identifies as a cabbage she´d get in tomorrow.

Who or what is the horse on this occasion?

LarkspurLane · 03/03/2024 09:29

WelcomeMarch · 02/03/2024 21:40

A student getting solid Bs now might well pull them up to A grades by the time of the actual exams, though.

This is too late unless she wants to take a gap year and apply with grades in hand.

JessS1990 · 03/03/2024 09:25

BabyBlue777 · 03/03/2024 09:09

If she claimed to be transexual or a minority she´d get in even as a C student. I heard directly from the horses mouth that Oxford has to become diverse now. IF she says she identifies as a cabbage she´d get in tomorrow.

Its possible it was the donkeys behind you were listening to.

ExtraDay · 03/03/2024 09:12

BabyBlue777 · 03/03/2024 09:09

If she claimed to be transexual or a minority she´d get in even as a C student. I heard directly from the horses mouth that Oxford has to become diverse now. IF she says she identifies as a cabbage she´d get in tomorrow.

I think you need a new horse.

BabyBlue777 · 03/03/2024 09:09

If she claimed to be transexual or a minority she´d get in even as a C student. I heard directly from the horses mouth that Oxford has to become diverse now. IF she says she identifies as a cabbage she´d get in tomorrow.

Jzp · 03/03/2024 09:01

You’re the expert and have the experience. I don’t think you’re being at all unreasonable. SIL sounds pushy. Getting into Oxbridge is difficult even for the very academic and it’s not necessarily for everyone. There are plenty of other good universities

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/03/2024 08:53

AmaryllisChorus · 01/03/2024 17:53

YABU. If you were tutoring her and she said she wanted to apply to Oxford, all you need to do is say, 'Great. You'll need to be getting A*s in everything and understanding why you don't, if you don't. You need to be reading very widely outside the curriculum. Read Shakespeare for fun (if applying for English.) Come back to me next week with the homework I set you plus a 2k word essay on a literary book you have read for pleasure or a popular genre book that you can analyse with fresh insights. This is exciting. Go for it.' She'll either realise she isn't up to it, or she'll rise to the challenge.

No point in saying, 'You can't.' Better to say, 'If you want this, you need to XYZ'

Edited

This sounds perfect.

Calliopespa · 03/03/2024 08:53

mids2019 · 03/03/2024 06:40

And yet we have Oxbridge sending out reach teams to schools in deprived areas where in reality very few students typically are getting A levels necessary for entrance with the message 'Oxbridge is for you!'

Ok for maybe 1% of a school cohort at a failing inner city comp this may have relevance but not for the vast majority. I think the out reach to areas which have historically sent few to Oxford or Cambridge maybe is slightly counter productive in that it gives false hope so I can see how some may have over optimistic thoughts of their offspring going to elite universities.

Yes reality checks are need as in this case but are Oxbridge helping by continually asking children for non standard backgrounds to apply when in reality those from traditionally underrepresented schools and regions can't apply because in the whole their grades are too low?

The grade boundary for these applicants would often be lower . That’s what we are trying to say. The grades are a first screen but, as they are not the determining factor, if there are valid reasons a candidate may not have top grades, they may get a chance to show their “ untutored” aptitude at interview. It’s also why some people are saying “ but I know someone with a 6 who got in !” ; others are pointing to top grades that didn’t get in. The grades are a general starting point. There is so much negative talk around oxbridge interview process and that it excludes the underprivileged; but really it is designed to do exactly the opposite ( as far as practicable) by allowing the very people who will teach them to sit with them and see how they would perform on precisely the sorts of exercises they would need to do when they got there - irrespective of how well their school/ background prepared them for a set of exams not in fact see by that university.

Bennettsister · 03/03/2024 08:18

TheRaptures · 02/03/2024 08:39

I think the version of this circulating in my day was a supercilious interviewer who was reading a newspaper and ignoring the interview candidate. Eventually he said ‘Interest me’ and the candidate set his newspaper on fire.

Oh yes I heard that one too! Total crap but I believed it at the time and was intimidated by it - that’s why all these stories are actually damaging.