Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my niece she won’t make it into Oxford uni?

561 replies

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

OP posts:
xsquared · 01/03/2024 18:04

NothingVenturedAndAllThat · 01/03/2024 18:02

@xsquared I suspect it's a bonus if you're also a gifted rower.

Almost spat my tea out. I'm at Durham and it's bad enough there 😭🤣

Are you a student? I live in Durham too.

Goldenbear · 01/03/2024 18:04

There was no contextual offer either.

Cantrushart · 01/03/2024 18:03

xsquared · 01/03/2024 17:50

They like all rounders and for you to talk about yourself outside the subject area during the interview, as you need to stand out from the 100s of other applicants with the same predicted grades as you.

I suspect it's a bonus if you're also a gifted rower.

Edited

That's not true. They don't care in the slightest about extracurriculars unless they are a strong indicator of specific subject interest. Colleges are quite clear that they are looking for depth of knowledge and passion in a specific area rather than an 'all-rounder'. Interviewers will not ask about your grade 4 music exam or debating society. You don't win a Nobel prize for rowing.

Goldenbear · 01/03/2024 18:03

entropynow · 01/03/2024 17:54

No. A good fit for Oxford means consistent As across the board with A* in key subjects. This student gets consistent Bs and an occasional A, if you re-read the OP. Even then you may not get in: it is really, really competitive, especially for Arts subjects. Not to mention the weight that they undoubtedly give to overseas students, who pay a lot more.

Edited

Interesting is this different for Cambridge? When DS discussed this at his 6th form college with a second year student in History, she told us that she had been offered a place at Cambridge despite have two 6s, one in Math's.

NothingVenturedAndAllThat · 01/03/2024 18:02

@xsquared I suspect it's a bonus if you're also a gifted rower.

Almost spat my tea out. I'm at Durham and it's bad enough there 😭🤣

Emmelina · 01/03/2024 18:01

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

As long as you were kind, I don't think you were unreasonable. There is SO much competition for Oxford and Cambridge, if she averages at a B grade it's a very unrealistic goal unfortunately.

GasPanic · 01/03/2024 18:00

TheRaptures · 01/03/2024 17:51

Not unreasonable, no. those grades aren’t good enough.

Though sometimes people surprise you. I once gave feedback on the Oxford PS/admissions exercise of the kid of a client of DH’s — it was stolid, dull, right but uninteresting stuff. I gave a detailed critique and told him via email what he should be aiming for, and gave him interview tips once he was called, not thinking he had a hope. He got in. I was gobsmacked. He must have really upped his game.

Was she talking about a joint degree in history and English?

Being specifically coached for Oxford I think ups your chances considerably, because they are looking for more than just ability in the subject you intend to study, they are looking for indivduals who can contribute in sport and in social life as well.

Quite a few people get very low grades offered because they do so well at the interview. But to do well at the interview you really need to be coached. My guess is someone who is less intelligent and coached will stand a far better chance than someone of very high intelligence and has no coaching.

Againsttheflow · 01/03/2024 17:59

NothingVenturedAndAllThat · 01/03/2024 17:59

You know, from the title, I thought you were unreasonable, but having read it, I think you might just spur that kid on to graft her arse off and get in anyway.

This. I'd knuckle down out of spite.

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:59

RedHelenB · 01/03/2024 17:41

Is she Y12? What were her gcse grades?

Bs and Cs, mostly Cs and one A in music. she has struggled with dyslexia and the school weren’t great with support tho (college are much better). I do seriously thinks she will do well at uni, probably really well because she will be able to chose what she does more. I do think maybe Oxford or Cambridge or whatever she wants once she finds her feet at uni because she has a really good writing style and when it’s something she’s interested in she gets really into it.

OP posts:
Againsttheflow · 01/03/2024 17:59

entropynow · 01/03/2024 17:54

No. A good fit for Oxford means consistent As across the board with A* in key subjects. This student gets consistent Bs and an occasional A, if you re-read the OP. Even then you may not get in: it is really, really competitive, especially for Arts subjects. Not to mention the weight that they undoubtedly give to overseas students, who pay a lot more.

Edited

Again. She may surprise you.

NothingVenturedAndAllThat · 01/03/2024 17:59

You know, from the title, I thought you were unreasonable, but having read it, I think you might just spur that kid on to graft her arse off and get in anyway.

MrsToothyBitch · 01/03/2024 17:57

No, you were absolutely fair. My mum had to pop the bubble for me after illness (brought on by a dreadful GP) wrecked what was probably a slight though initially viable chance anyway.

I'm glad I found out that way tbh. I still begrudge the psycho doctor though!

Kattenburg · 01/03/2024 17:56

Your SIL is nuts. And rude.

entropynow · 01/03/2024 17:54

Againsttheflow · 01/03/2024 17:50

I would have encouraged her. If she's consistently getting As and Bs she may pull something out the bag in her exams, and if she's otherwise a good fit for Oxford and meets the rest of the application criteria I'd not have quashed her dreams

No. A good fit for Oxford means consistent As across the board with A* in key subjects. This student gets consistent Bs and an occasional A, if you re-read the OP. Even then you may not get in: it is really, really competitive, especially for Arts subjects. Not to mention the weight that they undoubtedly give to overseas students, who pay a lot more.

AmaryllisChorus · 01/03/2024 17:53

YABU. If you were tutoring her and she said she wanted to apply to Oxford, all you need to do is say, 'Great. You'll need to be getting A*s in everything and understanding why you don't, if you don't. You need to be reading very widely outside the curriculum. Read Shakespeare for fun (if applying for English.) Come back to me next week with the homework I set you plus a 2k word essay on a literary book you have read for pleasure or a popular genre book that you can analyse with fresh insights. This is exciting. Go for it.' She'll either realise she isn't up to it, or she'll rise to the challenge.

No point in saying, 'You can't.' Better to say, 'If you want this, you need to XYZ'

MsFogi · 01/03/2024 17:52

What year is she in? If year 9 - YABU!

TheRaptures · 01/03/2024 17:51

Not unreasonable, no. those grades aren’t good enough.

Though sometimes people surprise you. I once gave feedback on the Oxford PS/admissions exercise of the kid of a client of DH’s — it was stolid, dull, right but uninteresting stuff. I gave a detailed critique and told him via email what he should be aiming for, and gave him interview tips once he was called, not thinking he had a hope. He got in. I was gobsmacked. He must have really upped his game.

Was she talking about a joint degree in history and English?

xsquared · 01/03/2024 17:50

MollyButton · 01/03/2024 17:45

Okay except I can't see the relevance of extracurriculars to applying as a grad student. Love of subject, high grades, being interested in the right sub discipline and/or luck are the only criteria.

They like all rounders and for you to talk about yourself outside the subject area during the interview, as you need to stand out from the 100s of other applicants with the same predicted grades as you.

I suspect it's a bonus if you're also a gifted rower.

Againsttheflow · 01/03/2024 17:50

I would have encouraged her. If she's consistently getting As and Bs she may pull something out the bag in her exams, and if she's otherwise a good fit for Oxford and meets the rest of the application criteria I'd not have quashed her dreams

SandyY2K · 01/03/2024 17:48

I don't think you needed to say that to her, because her predicted grades would weed her out of the process anyway.

When students are applying, unless, they're in the top few percent and getting As and 8/9s, it just won't happen. With the grades you mentioned, she probably wouldn't even get into a RG uni, never mind Oxford.

Why would you put yourself in that position.

Or another way to say what you did, without actually saying it, would be to tell her what grades Oxford normslly expect and to advise her of the rigorous interview process, as it's not just about getting all As or A* .

She would then figure out if she could apply.

SomersetTart · 01/03/2024 17:46

I would have had the conversation with her parents before I had it with her.

GasPanic · 01/03/2024 17:46

One of the perils of doing business with family.

You're not tutoring her for free are you ?

Remember no good deed goes unpunished :)

Edit : It may well be you have destroyed your sister in laws dreams and not your nieces.

MirandaWest · 01/03/2024 17:45

How old is she?

MollyButton · 01/03/2024 17:45

Okay except I can't see the relevance of extracurriculars to applying as a grad student. Love of subject, high grades, being interested in the right sub discipline and/or luck are the only criteria.

xsquared · 01/03/2024 17:44

I think you were just being realistic, but there is nothing stopping your neice from applying anyway. The worst that can happen is that she gets rejected before even being offered an interview. At least then, she will know that getting an undergraduate place is super competitive, and that's that.

I wouldn't say you crushed her dreams as you gsve her some hope that she may still try after her first degree.

Your SIL overreacted and certainly shouldn't have spoken to you like that though. I suspect your neice will recover better than your SIL, and she's probably embarrassed with the way her mum went off on one at you.