Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my niece she won’t make it into Oxford uni?

561 replies

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

OP posts:
Startingagainandagain · 01/03/2024 20:35

Frankly it was none of your business to interfere in this way and her mother is perfectly right to be extremely angry.

All you had to say is advise her to get her grades up if she wanted to stand a chance.

She is perfectly entitled to have a go at it.

You telling her she is not good enough and never will be is unacceptable.

I would wonder if you don't have an agenda here for wanting her to fail.

Moshmoshi12 · 01/03/2024 20:26

I don't think you were unreasonable but on the other hand I went to Oxford and studied History. I have very average GCSEs (only 1 A) and at this point in my Y12 I'm sure none of my teachers would have thought it was even a possibility. My lower sixth mocks results shocked them - I came top in all my subjects. My head of sixth form and parents really encouraged me to give it a try.

It wasn't something that I'd even considered till then but I'm so glad I went there. The feedback I got from entrance exams and the interview was that it was all about academic potential- especially if you are from a state school. Not everyone who goes is all 9s and A*S. Things may well have changed in 30 years though!

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 20:18

myphoneisbroken · 01/03/2024 20:17

I went to one, taught at one, and regularly use the term Oxbridge - I work in a professional context where the term is widely used and I have never heard it queried as 'silly and ignorant'.

Well, if you say so.

ThreeLocusts · 01/03/2024 20:17

Used to work for an Oxbridge college, including doing admissions for history (not the world's most demanding subject, tbh). The whole process seemed bonkers to me, but the admissions tutor certainly was looking for As and A*s, not Bs with some As. So you were simply factually right.

That said - my impression was that for some of the MPhil courses, expectations were way lower. The MPhil I taught on had some pretty weak students, though they tended to be American, which meant that their transcripts were different anyway and they paid overseas fees, an incentive to let them in.

If her parents can find the money for one of these 9-month MPhils, she would certainly get the Oxbridge experience and perhaps get a bit of networking done. Though nothing like the undergrads.

One of the higher-ups at my college (whose own subject didn't have an MPhil) once referred to the MPhils derisorily as a 'finishing school'; they attract wealthy overseas students who want an Oxbridge certificate on their wall. But I certainly worked hard to supervise my MPhil students and the MPhil courses I knew anything about were good.

myphoneisbroken · 01/03/2024 20:17

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 20:07

Maybe so, but it sounds silly and ignorant. Nobody who has actually been to either of them or teaches at either of them refers to 'Oxbridge'.

I went to one, taught at one, and regularly use the term Oxbridge - I work in a professional context where the term is widely used and I have never heard it queried as 'silly and ignorant'.

bombastix · 01/03/2024 20:16

ilovebreadsauce · 01/03/2024 19:43

Some oxbridge courses aren't that difficult to get into .one or 2 have a higher than 50% acceptance rate

Land economy and Theology are unlikely to land you a lucrative career

NotmyfirstRodeomyfriend · 01/03/2024 20:13

I'm a careers adviser and speak weekly, if not daily to young people who want to go to University and often through in Oxbridge as if it's just something they might fancy... as adults we know this simply isn't the case. As previous posters have said, I think you've upset SIL more than niece. Young people often have completely misinformed views about Oxbridge and just say it because they thinks it's "the best"... why did she want to go there out of interest?

TwilightBee · 01/03/2024 20:12

MrsToothyBitch · 01/03/2024 17:57

No, you were absolutely fair. My mum had to pop the bubble for me after illness (brought on by a dreadful GP) wrecked what was probably a slight though initially viable chance anyway.

I'm glad I found out that way tbh. I still begrudge the psycho doctor though!

Genuinely curious, how does a doctor give you an illness?

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 20:09

Whatzzaapbaby · 01/03/2024 20:08

Really? That’s not my experience.

Well, it is mine, and I know a fair few alumnae and current lecturers at both universities.

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 20:08

Zyq · 01/03/2024 19:54

Do you think it would make a difference to her grades if she is given full support and other concessions for dyslexia?

She has been getting support at college and to be fair to the school they did get her some help for her GCSEs. She has a laptop to type on in class now and that’s made a world of difference - she struggled a lot in her first term of A levels and now she’s kind of settled in and started getting consistent grades.
A big part of her problem is she struggles to engage in things that don’t interest her and this means there’s some areas her knowledge is lacking. This is part of the reason I think (and hope) she will do really well at uni when she can have more academic freedom. She can also sometimes be a bit lazy, but that’s changing and she is a teenager after all.

OP posts:
Whatzzaapbaby · 01/03/2024 20:08

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 20:07

Maybe so, but it sounds silly and ignorant. Nobody who has actually been to either of them or teaches at either of them refers to 'Oxbridge'.

Really? That’s not my experience.

AngryBookworm · 01/03/2024 20:07

Totally fair and unlike other situations there is something to lose - she'd lose one of her slots to apply (assuming you still only get 5). She also asked if she should apply and you gave her the correct advice with the information you had at the time - of course if she now miraculously ups her game then you haven't destroyed her dream but given her the information she needed to overcome it. Telling her 'you go for it, girlfriend!' with grades like that would have been the crueller thing.

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 20:07

Againsttheflow · 01/03/2024 19:54

You can hate the term all you want but it's how the two universities are colloquially known.

Maybe so, but it sounds silly and ignorant. Nobody who has actually been to either of them or teaches at either of them refers to 'Oxbridge'.

MoreDollies · 01/03/2024 20:03

I don't think you're wrong. As a school careers adviser, I meet a lot of kids who start off aspiring for Oxbridge. However, I tend to avoid telling them they "can't" do something, instead I would do all the talk around making sure they seriously explore the expectations and look in detail at what's happened in recent years in terms actual grades achieved (including showing them that actual data) and that they really want to make sure that they can be as confident as possible they don't have a wasted slot on their UCAS application etc etc. Invariably those students don't end up applying, and I haven't been the bad guy who told them "no".

So yes, you're not wrong but there are always kinder ways of 'telling' someone something without being brutally honest.

I've only said a more explicit no once in recent years, at that was to a student doing entirely the wrong A levels, not even an art or DT and didn't draw in her spare time who was convinced she would walk into an architecture degree with low grades at A level and GCSE. She has entirely ignored everything I said though and still thinks she's going (while doing little to effect any change in her skill set)

mathanxiety · 01/03/2024 20:02

Agree 100% with @AmaryllisChorus

ExtraDay · 01/03/2024 20:00

Curse the asterisk formatting. I always forget. 2A*, 1A.

Previousreligion · 01/03/2024 20:00

LarkspurLane · 01/03/2024 19:17

I'd be interested to know if anyone has a child who was a B student in Y12 and upped their game enough to get into Oxford.

Not me but a guy at my college got in with Cs at A-level (he went to a terrible failing school and that was a factor.) I don't think it did him any favours as he really struggled and got very depressed, but he did get in.

ExtraDay · 01/03/2024 20:00

LarkspurLane · 01/03/2024 19:17

I'd be interested to know if anyone has a child who was a B student in Y12 and upped their game enough to get into Oxford.

Mine did. Range of 7 to 9 in GCSEs; predicted ABC in year 12; upped it to AAA in year 13; applied post-A level results.

myphoneisbroken · 01/03/2024 19:59

Just to agree with those who are saying that extra-curricular stuff is irrelevant for Oxbridge (and other university) admissions, and that it is much easier to get into to do a Master's - in my subject you don't even need to have a First, or a first degree in that subject.

mathanxiety · 01/03/2024 19:58

You should have been far more tactful and advised her to work hard to give herself as many options as possible, make sure she applies to a range of universities, visits/ does open days, and researches universities to make sure she chooses those that are a good fit for her preferences and learning style. You should have reminded her that there's plenty of time to figure all of that out, and in the meantime to develop her interest and dig deep into the subjects she's keen on.

Actually, you were as tactful as a sledgehammer in a bowl of jelly, and you should apologise.

A little encouragement can go a long, long way with some teens. My DS surprised everyone by becoming a doctor when about 99% of his teachers would have predicted a career as a forklift operator.

Zyq · 01/03/2024 19:54

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:59

Bs and Cs, mostly Cs and one A in music. she has struggled with dyslexia and the school weren’t great with support tho (college are much better). I do seriously thinks she will do well at uni, probably really well because she will be able to chose what she does more. I do think maybe Oxford or Cambridge or whatever she wants once she finds her feet at uni because she has a really good writing style and when it’s something she’s interested in she gets really into it.

Do you think it would make a difference to her grades if she is given full support and other concessions for dyslexia?

Againsttheflow · 01/03/2024 19:54

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 19:47

Where's 'Oxbridge'? I hate that term, it is meaningless. Oxford and Cambridge are two completely different universities.

You can hate the term all you want but it's how the two universities are colloquially known.

thing47 · 01/03/2024 19:51

LarkspurLane · 01/03/2024 19:17

I'd be interested to know if anyone has a child who was a B student in Y12 and upped their game enough to get into Oxford.

I don't know about that, but DD2 was a B student in Y12 and Y13 (she was at a not very good secondary modern school and those were good grades by its standards). Thrived at university, turned out to love high-tech lab research and went on to get a first-class (or the equivalent thereof) Masters on a world-renown course at a university at least on a par with Oxbridge in her particular field.

Which is exactly what @Awfulaunt has suggested as a possible course of action for her niece, incidentally.

Previousreligion · 01/03/2024 19:49

DahliaMacNamara · 01/03/2024 19:36

I think you were reasonably kind and realistic. Not all successful Oxbridge applicants have 8s and 9s or As and A*s across the board at GCSE, but they'll have a fair string of them all the same.
Extracurricular activities should be undertaken for their own sake. Some universities will want to hear about them, but Oxbridge interviews will be primarily, if not exclusively, subject-focused.

Mine weren't. I had three and only one was subject based. One was about human geography and the foundation of the welfare state (why I do not know, as I studied neither for A level and wasn't relevant to the course I was applying for), and the last was a general interview with the college principal who asked all sorts of questions about me.

RedRidingGood · 01/03/2024 19:48

AmaryllisChorus · 01/03/2024 17:53

YABU. If you were tutoring her and she said she wanted to apply to Oxford, all you need to do is say, 'Great. You'll need to be getting A*s in everything and understanding why you don't, if you don't. You need to be reading very widely outside the curriculum. Read Shakespeare for fun (if applying for English.) Come back to me next week with the homework I set you plus a 2k word essay on a literary book you have read for pleasure or a popular genre book that you can analyse with fresh insights. This is exciting. Go for it.' She'll either realise she isn't up to it, or she'll rise to the challenge.

No point in saying, 'You can't.' Better to say, 'If you want this, you need to XYZ'

Edited

100% agree with this.