Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my niece she won’t make it into Oxford uni?

561 replies

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

OP posts:
YouJustDoYou · 02/03/2024 06:48

You were absolutely fair. Kids these days need honesty, not this false "oh of course darling you can do and be anything you want to be!!". I knew of a pair of sisters in my crappy state school, their parents were both teachers, and every single half term and holiday without fail they stayed in and were tutored endlessly by their parents, day in and day out. They each got As across the board (at least something crazy like 12), and both got in. They were just normal, average intelligence girls who just worked damned hard and sacrificed their childhood, but they got in. I also had a friend at my uni who was very smart, As across the board, and he didn't get in. Oxford told him "we don't think we'd be a good fit for you". The girls were middle class white girls, he was London Chinese from a poorer background, and back then it was more biased towards kids from a "better" background. It's entirely possible your neice could get in, but it sounds like she simple doesn't have the will power and dedication to study and sacrifice her current life to do it.

CoffeeCantata · 02/03/2024 06:46

Probably echoing what other pps have said, but...

Excellent grades are really just 'base camp' in most cases. Yes, sometimes colleges make a low offer but you'd have to be exceptional at interview.

I think older teenagers ought to be able to take frank advice if they've asked for it. Don't buy into the guilt tripping of 'crushing her dreams'. If she's that insecure, she wouldn't cope at Oxford!!

I knew of a girl of very average achievements whose parents had been able to send her to a private (but not particularly academic) school. They insisted, against the school's advice, that she apply to Oxford. The poor girl came back from her interview traumatised, wouldn't emerge from her room for a week and returned to school a very different person. It's really not for everyone.

I agree with the pp who suggested saying to her 'OK, you do the research as to admission criteria, admission stats etc' and then make a decision. This would be a good strategy because if she isn't up to doing this herself without input from you she certainly wouldn't be Oxford or Cambridge material.

XelaM · 02/03/2024 06:44

My brother graduated with a First from Cambridge and his school IB grades weren't that stellar. He didn't even tell anyone he applied to Cambridge and just told us when he got in.

Twiglets1 · 02/03/2024 06:26

(Don’t know how that gif got there btw but I’m on my phone & it’s early 😂)

Twiglets1 · 02/03/2024 06:25

Even if you had encouraged her to apply her college would hopefully have talked sense into her that she would be basically wasting one of her UCAS choices not to mention a lot of time in jumping through all the hoops necessary in an Oxbridge application.

Your advice was correct and honest. It was only your opinion though, it’s not like you forced her to give up the idea. She can still apply if she wants and SIL wants & get rejected. If you get any further negativity from them I would change your stance and say if your niece really wants to try for Oxford, then do it but just understand that most people do get rejected (people with MUCH better academics added silently in your head).

Emma Thompson Woman GIF by The Academy Awards
mathanxiety · 02/03/2024 04:51

BobbyBiscuits · 02/03/2024 01:56

She can't apply on Bs anyway so SiL can talk till she's blue in the face and it will make not a blind bit of difference. Tell her to take it up with the VC of Oxford. Haha.

Of course she can apply with less than stellar grades. What happens after that is up to Oxford.

Fraaahnces · 02/03/2024 04:48

Maybe SIL has been pressuring DN unrealistically to go to Oxbridge, or that she’s a wunderkind and can get in…. Perhaps DN isn’t upset at all that you told her that she’s not a candidate, and she is possibly relieved. (Someone who had a pushy, over-invested mum.)

BobbyBiscuits · 02/03/2024 03:34

@PingvsPong Yeah, I know. I can apply for the CEO position at Google too but I have 7 GCSEs and never worked in tech before.

Ramalangadingdong · 02/03/2024 02:52

When I was very young an older person told me that I should always pursue my dreams. She told me that other older people would deter me from doing so but I was to ignore them because they were only doing that because they had never followed their own dreams so didn’t want anyone else to either. I listened to the advice and secured my dream Job.

mathanxiety · 02/03/2024 02:51

TheRaptures · 01/03/2024 22:57

In fairness, if she wants to have a shot at Oxford, she’s going to have to deal with discouragement, a low chance of success even if she makes it to interview AND, if she actually gets a place, having a less than whelming essay ripped to shreds, and discovering you’re a small fish in a big pond on a regular basis. If she can’t cope with being told by one person she’s not good enough, and dealing with it by figuring out what she needs to get what she wants, then it’s not for her.

Oxbridge undergrads are not a race of superhumans. To a large extent everyone who leaves school and starts afresh - in college, in university, in an apprenticeship, in the armed services, or in a job realises that they're in a much bigger pond and they're starting again at the bottom.

Thousands upon thousands of applicants get rejected from Oxbridge every hear. Hundreds of undergrads - even those from cosseted backgrounds where they have had private tutors - manage to deal just fine with the expectations and pressure of the big pond, and those who don't can always withdraw and start again somewhere else. It is not the big, special deal people here are making it out to be.

Most Oxbridge undergrads get there with the help and support of a great many boosters and supporters. Some have this support from schools where it is assumed the majority of the students will apply to RGs/Oxbridge, and some get there because a family member encouraged them to dream big or there was one teacher who thought it wouldn't hurt to be encouraging.

I know one Oxford graduate who went to a small rural vocational secondary school in Ireland - did the Leaving Cert - and decided to do the application process on the basis of "nothing ventured, nothing gained" and because she figured the application and possible interview process for Oxford would provide a unique experience with very little cost to her.

Who does the OP think she is to say to this young person that her potential is limited? And why? It is not her place to manage expectations. All she had to do was be tactful and remember that she is not the chair of the admissions committee.

Garlicking · 02/03/2024 02:42

I can't fathom why it's a brilliant idea to tell a kid not to TRY for something they really want! DN can apply and see what happens. It won't stop her going to another university.

Nothing wrong with pointing out the difficulty level, but for heaven's sake encourage her to get in there and give it her best! Did any of you read this week's 'Resilience' thread? Well, if you're all in favour of not even pushing kids to try where they may not succeed, I think I'm seeing how the problem arises Confused

Back in my sixth form days (the Pleistocene), Cambridge offered me B,B,C to read linguistics & French. I had 7 average-to-poor O levels (it was that long ago!) I know everything's changed since then, but I'd been told to expect no offer or 3 As at best. I'm glad nobody suggested that was a reason not to even try!

DrJump · 02/03/2024 02:24

I think it's important to give realistic ideas to children. DS2 had a sporting event recently. He got to represent his school. He was hoping to got past that level but it was not realistic. I talked about what might be realistic for the day. I talked about how amazing it was he was already getting to represent his school and what an amazing thing it was that he was part of it.
He had a great day. Cheered for his team mates. Also so friends.from outside of school compete. He was pleased. We could talk about what he might do between now and next year to improve to see if he goes to the further level.

FloofCloud · 02/03/2024 02:12

I think perhaps your delivery was not really very nice, and to be honest, you never really know what may change over the coming year. There's no harm in trying to apply, but perhaps it would have been more encouraging to really boost her by giving her guidance to increase marks by guiding her in the areas she needs to develop in the coming year to help elevate her marks, rather than smother her ambition now. Tell her the requirements by all means but it's unnecessary to smother her flames, gently support and guide. Obviously she'll need to add additional universities when she applies too! If/when she doesn't get in you can support her by explaining her PG options then

PingvsPong · 02/03/2024 02:10

BobbyBiscuits · 02/03/2024 01:56

She can't apply on Bs anyway so SiL can talk till she's blue in the face and it will make not a blind bit of difference. Tell her to take it up with the VC of Oxford. Haha.

Well anybody can apply even if they get all D's. It's not a dropdown form that turns red and prevents you from submitting if your grades are less than the minimum admission requirements!

Whether they get in, or even past the first sift is another story.

Marchingforwards · 02/03/2024 02:01

That’s a badly written post for a tutor.

BobbyBiscuits · 02/03/2024 01:56

She can't apply on Bs anyway so SiL can talk till she's blue in the face and it will make not a blind bit of difference. Tell her to take it up with the VC of Oxford. Haha.

DaoineSidhe · 02/03/2024 01:51

I think you were completely wrong, you are nobody's God. You just say well it is difficult, this is what is required, this is where you are, if you can up the ante then you have a shot at it. I can't bear people like you - a 'know it all, who tells it like it is (the 'is' being the egotistical bias). Such a depressing outlook on life; we lift young people not shut them down. They can find stuff out on their own.

Redsquirrel5 · 02/03/2024 01:41

She asked for your opinion and you gave it.She didn't like the answer.

My neighbour told me her grandson's cousin was super clever. Her mother had told her sister and my neighbour. She said it to me as the child was where i worked. I had to hedge it by saying I hadn't been working in that class recently. Although she was a sweet child she was certainly not as clever as they thought. Some parents are disillusioned. Your SIL might be one of them.

Next time maybe discuss other Uni's that you think might suit her better. Encourage her to visit as many as she can. My colleagues son was asked to visit Cambridge years ago. He went down and no one showed him around. His 'buddy' took him to one thing then left him. He didn't know where to go for meals and received very little information about the course. He was a very clever lad and worked hard he got 100% in his A Level Maths and 96% on the Higher paper plus a good pass in Science and English.
He also visited Durham. He got a great welcome and lots of activities had been laid on for the students. He went to Durham and loved it so much he now works there. I think she needs to find the Uni that suits her rather than because it is the "right' one to go too.She needs to visit I started taking my daughter at 16 and she learnt a lot about the courses from speaking to tutors and students during Open days and that is what helped her choose and she was lucky that she gained places at all her top three choices and chose the one that she preferred but chose a different course to her original choice. She had applied for it as back up but after visiting decided that was a more suitable course for her.

ThanksItHasPockets · 02/03/2024 01:13

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 20:09

Well, it is mine, and I know a fair few alumnae and current lecturers at both universities.

As an alumna I can assure you that we use the portmanteau phrase regularly. It’s useful when referring to admissions as it’s not possible to apply to both Oxford and Cambridge in the same year, and although the universities are distinct the admissions processes are sufficiently similar that separate preparation guidance isn’t necessary.

Do you really only know female graduates of the two universities?

Daisy12Maisie · 02/03/2024 00:18

Completely helpful. My son thinks he will breeze into Cambridge to do medicine and it's just not being realistic for various reasons. With a lot of work and luck he may get in to do medicine but definitely not at Cambridge. I'm relying on the summer school to guide him with applications. That's part of what they help with. They will tell him where he is likely to get a place (if anywhere). Telling him he will get Cambridge would be a wasted choice unless things drastically change.
So you have done the most helpful thing. She can put down realistic options.

Ramalangadingdong · 02/03/2024 00:17

CommentNow · 01/03/2024 23:31

Yanbu. Your job is being a tutor. Your student asked your professional opinion and she got it. The fact you are working for free for family doesnt invalidate your profesional opinion.

Imagine her applying and getting rejected and asking for feedback and the backlash when the school politely insinuate that the tutor was either lying or inept.

I'd have thrown my toys out of the pram and said I think it's best I dont tutor niece in future as if they dont want my professional opinion when I'm explicitly asked for it then they cant trust my tutoring skills.

First and foremost she is an auntie. That isn’t a job. As an aunt I would want to support my niece as much as I could. I can’t imagine telling any young person outright that they weren’t up to a particular task. Any good tutor allows them to discover that for themselves by putting themselves out there and facing rejection.

Also, ime people who always tell you that they were just being honest usually have some sort of agenda.

ToWhitToWhoo · 02/03/2024 00:16

xsquared · 01/03/2024 17:50

They like all rounders and for you to talk about yourself outside the subject area during the interview, as you need to stand out from the 100s of other applicants with the same predicted grades as you.

I suspect it's a bonus if you're also a gifted rower.

Edited

Speaking as someone involved for many years in Oxbridge admissions: this is not the case. Oxbridge (and as far as I'm aware most British universities) are not interested in all-rounders, but in people who are academically suited to theIr chosen subject of study: not mainly in the sense of having learned a lot of facts, but in the sense of being able to think deeply about the subject and to demonstrate potential for learning, as well as motivation and interest in the subject.

Interviews are structured to try to assess the applicant's ability to think about problems related to their subject. How successful interviews actually are in achieving this aim may be a matter for debate; but this is the goal. An applicant who spent time during an interview talking about themselves outside the subject could well be putting themselves at a disadvantage. And nowadays at any rate, rowing or other sporting prowess would never be a criterion for selection. A selector who used such criteria would be at risk of disciplinary proceedings.

This doesn't mean that being good at sports or having other interests would disadvantage an applicant; certainly not! But interviewers are looking for academic potential in a particular subject; not in an applicant's non-academic characteristics- to do the latter could even be considered as a form of discrimination.

From what I've heard, some American universities and programmes may be more interested in extra-curricular interests and non-academic personal characteristics; but it is not nowadays generally the case in the UK,

Ace56 · 01/03/2024 23:59

Bigcoatweather · 01/03/2024 21:39

That’s just not true. I can know several students who got in with lower GCSEs than 8/9, some were from state schools, not all.

Several GCSEs lower than 7s though? I doubt it - 7 is equivalent to an A. I work in uni admissions.

spirit20 · 01/03/2024 23:55

I know myself as a teacher and a sixth form tutor, this can be a really difficult situation to be put in. I normally would never say outright to someone that they won't get in. Rather, I would phrase it something like 'oxbridge look for xxx grades and xxx extra curricular etc., so do you feel you can work towards that'?.

I know it's hard sometimes when you're faced with people who you know realistically won't stand a chance, but it can be difficult sometimes to be seen as the person who is 'destroying' their dreams, which is why I prefer to leave them to figure it out for themselves.

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 23:53

stayathomer · 01/03/2024 23:06

Tbh, I don't think it was your place to crush her hopes like that. You're family. She just wanted support and encouragement. The rejection from Oxford would have been hard on her, but not as hard as having your own family tell you you aren't good enough.
Exactly this. And I think people can say your sil was nuts to go off at you, but I think most of us would, even those who wouldn’t usually speak up or out. I can’t even imagine how your niece must have felt.

Edited

If you're not good enough, you're not good enough. Enough of this mollycoddling. I am not normally one to talk about 'Gen Z are useless' etc, and indeed I don't believe it, but one thing that has changed from my day is that people seem not to realise that some standards are absolute. It's all about how you feel rather than objective facts. Sometimes one needs a cold hard splash or reality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread