Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my niece she won’t make it into Oxford uni?

561 replies

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

OP posts:
Merrymouse · 02/03/2024 08:28

Animatic · 02/03/2024 08:08

Why would you crash the dream though? I would have told "oxford is very difficult, we will aim there but it's good to have a solid back-up plan too". Abd save all lecturing on do ing well and doing masters for when she doesn't get in.

But that wouldn’t be a truthful explanation of how the application process works, and wastes one of her 5 applications.

The OP hasn’t crashed the dream. Nothing is stopping the niece from working to get As and applying post A level, or, as the OP says, excelling at a different university and applying to do a masters.

willWillSmithsmith · 02/03/2024 08:24

HumphreyCobblers · 01/03/2024 17:41

I honestly think it is cruel to give completely false hope to children. You did the right thing.

I agree. I think giving false hope is far worse than giving realistic expectations. Oxbridge is hard to get into, it makes sense to understand that and not think scraping a couple of As will cut it.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 08:22

ThanksItHasPockets · 02/03/2024 08:13

People who didn’t get in always had a tall tale as to why. I’m not suggesting that the admissions process is above reproach but this is a total myth.

Sometimes intellectual challenge questions can be asked that might ( perhaps) involve something like cherry stones, but the point would not be one of manners or etiquette. If these people really thought that, perhaps they had not even understood what the question was getting at, let alone known how to answer. 😒In my day the story doing the rounds was that someone set fire to the don’s sofa during the interview - and, of course, (!) this generated such an impression he got in.

MarmiteRoasties · 02/03/2024 08:22

penelopepinkbott · 01/03/2024 17:40

If you said it with kindness then I think that's fine, surely a teacher would have said similar. Sounds like her mum thinks she's more clever than she is. Is she an only child?

Wtf? Judgement much against only children?! Not all parents of onlies think that they’re perfect ffs

TheRaptures · 02/03/2024 08:19

mathanxiety · 02/03/2024 02:51

Oxbridge undergrads are not a race of superhumans. To a large extent everyone who leaves school and starts afresh - in college, in university, in an apprenticeship, in the armed services, or in a job realises that they're in a much bigger pond and they're starting again at the bottom.

Thousands upon thousands of applicants get rejected from Oxbridge every hear. Hundreds of undergrads - even those from cosseted backgrounds where they have had private tutors - manage to deal just fine with the expectations and pressure of the big pond, and those who don't can always withdraw and start again somewhere else. It is not the big, special deal people here are making it out to be.

Most Oxbridge undergrads get there with the help and support of a great many boosters and supporters. Some have this support from schools where it is assumed the majority of the students will apply to RGs/Oxbridge, and some get there because a family member encouraged them to dream big or there was one teacher who thought it wouldn't hurt to be encouraging.

I know one Oxford graduate who went to a small rural vocational secondary school in Ireland - did the Leaving Cert - and decided to do the application process on the basis of "nothing ventured, nothing gained" and because she figured the application and possible interview process for Oxford would provide a unique experience with very little cost to her.

Who does the OP think she is to say to this young person that her potential is limited? And why? It is not her place to manage expectations. All she had to do was be tactful and remember that she is not the chair of the admissions committee.

@mathanxiety, I am Irish, I was from a very poor background, and I went to Oxford without any help from school (rough, deprived intake, demoralised teachers) or parents (who were against me going to any university whatsoever because ‘it’s only for rich people’). I’m well aware Oxford undergraduates are not superhuman because I was one of them. I had barely left my own county and never my country before I went to interview.

I still hold to my point that if the OP’s niece is demoralised by someone throwing cold water on her chances at this point, and her impulse is to complain to her parents about her aunt not encouraging her, she’s not likely to be suited to the actual application process or teaching style. Which is fine. It’s not for everyone.

ThanksItHasPockets · 02/03/2024 08:13

YouJustDoYou · 02/03/2024 06:51

I should add I went to the other uni on Oxford (the non-famous, non-"Oxford" one), and it was renowned from the "failed" kids that when you went to interviews, for some colleges there were additional "sneak" tests - for one of the colleges, they invited the prospectives applicants to a collective dinner, and served cherries - they would fail them based on how they disposed of the cherry pips (ie - manners. "How refined are you?"). It was pretty insane. Hopefully that's changed now haha.

People who didn’t get in always had a tall tale as to why. I’m not suggesting that the admissions process is above reproach but this is a total myth.

Bennettsister · 02/03/2024 08:13

Anyway OP I think you did the right thing. You need mainly 9/8a at GCSE, predicted A/A* at a level (mainly the latter).

Bennettsister · 02/03/2024 08:12

YouJustDoYou · 02/03/2024 06:51

I should add I went to the other uni on Oxford (the non-famous, non-"Oxford" one), and it was renowned from the "failed" kids that when you went to interviews, for some colleges there were additional "sneak" tests - for one of the colleges, they invited the prospectives applicants to a collective dinner, and served cherries - they would fail them based on how they disposed of the cherry pips (ie - manners. "How refined are you?"). It was pretty insane. Hopefully that's changed now haha.

That’s such bollocks and a really damaging myth and will put less advantaged kids off applying.
Oxford and Cambridge go out of their way now to attract state school students. I can’t fault their outreach. Unlike Durham, Bristol and Exeter which are public school ghettos.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 08:09

BusyMummy001 · 02/03/2024 07:46

OP responded in person to a question DN asked her directly, relying on her professional experience. DN appeared to take it well and may in fact have been matter of fact in the way she told her parents that she would probably not be including Oxbridge in her choices.

My inference here is that SiL is the one that is wanting her child to apply and has been selling that narrative at home - unrealistic given DN did not get grades 7-9s in GCSEs other than Music. Even children with accommodations for ASD, dyslexia etc (lap top, extra time in exams) can get high grades - I know several who do - so there is no leeway or ‘excusing’ C-B/5-6 Grades, unless a contextual offer is a possibility and has been couched by school.

I think SIL is very much part of the picture.

But whether the drive is coming from DN or not, I do feel sorry for her with a war waging about her regarding her competency or otherwise.

Animatic · 02/03/2024 08:08

Why would you crash the dream though? I would have told "oxford is very difficult, we will aim there but it's good to have a solid back-up plan too". Abd save all lecturing on do ing well and doing masters for when she doesn't get in.

TheRaptures · 02/03/2024 08:01

YouJustDoYou · 02/03/2024 06:51

I should add I went to the other uni on Oxford (the non-famous, non-"Oxford" one), and it was renowned from the "failed" kids that when you went to interviews, for some colleges there were additional "sneak" tests - for one of the colleges, they invited the prospectives applicants to a collective dinner, and served cherries - they would fail them based on how they disposed of the cherry pips (ie - manners. "How refined are you?"). It was pretty insane. Hopefully that's changed now haha.

Well, this isn’t giving me much of an impression of the intellect of Brookes’ students.

You’re parroting something ( soft fruit with the stones left in as a test of social resourcefulness, in some versions also served in a rimless bowl) that is supposedly associated with the All Souls Fellowship interviews, not undergraduate ones. You know, All Souls, the college that famously has no students, and selects potential Fellows for the seven year prize Fellowships by things like setting a translation paper in a dozen languages in which you work through as many as you can and, formerly, an essay paper where the topic is a single word like ‘comedy’ or ‘water’) in the first part of the 20thc and is probably apocryphal anyway. I think the legend is mostly based on AL Rowse (who was the son of a China clay worker from Cornwall, so far from socially elevated himself, and got a Fellowship).

It’s depressing people are parroting this ‘socially exclusive’ stuff about a university in 2024.

If you had at Brookes people who hadn’t got into Oxford, it definitely wasn’t because they didn’t know what to do with their cherry stones.

Some past All Souls general exam papers from recent years, for anyone interested —

https://www.asc.ox.ac.uk/sites/default/files/2023-10/General%202021.pdf

https://www.asc.ox.ac.uk/sites/default/files/2023-10/General%202021.pdf

Merrymouse · 02/03/2024 07:47

Those advocating that she should apply anyway, how is that supposed to work?

You need to have predicted grades per the prospectus (or meet the requirements for a contextual offer) to get an offer from any university.

If her GCSEs are Bs and Cs and work submitted is at a B level, her teachers aren’t going to predict As.

Of course it’s possible to apply again after A levels, but I don’t think that is what is being suggested.

BusyMummy001 · 02/03/2024 07:46

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 07:28

I think this has been a case of “ shoot the messenger OP.”

I’m not sure why you took on the role of messenger, especially as there seem to be tensions between you and SIL anyway. I can’t help but get the sense you two are using it to have a bit of a go at each other and are each putting yourselves and your emotions in the middle of what is really DN’s disappointment ( ie; her saying DN will do it to spite you; you saying you are angry with DB that he “let her” speak to you that way etc) . Poor DN seems caught in the middle of the pair of you wanting to inflict blows on each other.

I’d have told her to get guidance from school as you “would be biased” or something thing like that. But it’s said now, and I think you are probably quite right about the outcome.

OP responded in person to a question DN asked her directly, relying on her professional experience. DN appeared to take it well and may in fact have been matter of fact in the way she told her parents that she would probably not be including Oxbridge in her choices.

My inference here is that SiL is the one that is wanting her child to apply and has been selling that narrative at home - unrealistic given DN did not get grades 7-9s in GCSEs other than Music. Even children with accommodations for ASD, dyslexia etc (lap top, extra time in exams) can get high grades - I know several who do - so there is no leeway or ‘excusing’ C-B/5-6 Grades, unless a contextual offer is a possibility and has been couched by school.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 07:39

reluctantbrit · 01/03/2024 22:59

I know students who left an Open Day after the speeches because they didn't like the vibe. One went to Sheffield, is now doing her PhD with full funding and bursaries due to her undergrad results.

There are good unis out there outside Oxbridge and your SIL should do her homework what is achievable.

DD is at the same stage, she is predicted BBB but gets AAB on a regular basis so far. She doesn't even think about Oxbridge, she looks at unis offering the courses she wants and not a label.

A friend's DD is on paper an Oxbridge student but based on her personality she may not succeed in an interview because the girl can't sell herself. She may tick all boxes on paper but not in person. Parents should support but be realistic and encourage alternatives and differnt ways to carry on.

You might be surprised. That type sometimes open up beautifully in interview once they get into the academic style questions. The “chit chat” is really just there to settle them ( and some aren’t much settled by it actually, and do better with some proper knotty questions to sink their teeth into). They aren’t looking for tv personalities, and I think sometimes people misconstrue what the interview is looking for.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 07:28

I think this has been a case of “ shoot the messenger OP.”

I’m not sure why you took on the role of messenger, especially as there seem to be tensions between you and SIL anyway. I can’t help but get the sense you two are using it to have a bit of a go at each other and are each putting yourselves and your emotions in the middle of what is really DN’s disappointment ( ie; her saying DN will do it to spite you; you saying you are angry with DB that he “let her” speak to you that way etc) . Poor DN seems caught in the middle of the pair of you wanting to inflict blows on each other.

I’d have told her to get guidance from school as you “would be biased” or something thing like that. But it’s said now, and I think you are probably quite right about the outcome.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 07:16

LuluBlakey1 · 02/03/2024 07:03

Lettuce Liz lacks intellect.

Boris hasn’t got common sense but he does have intellect. They aren’t the same thing. I know Oxford dons who have redefined areas of academia but couldn’t book a train ride to London ( well, needed help and direction!)

I think the problem with the dream big comments is that, while I’m not against that line of thought, unless the DN has a tangible plan ( ie has very high iq and knows she hadn’t been applying herself and is now determined to etc) the process makes that kind of gamble a waste of a UCAS choice. Also, many applicants don’t get to interview so there is no point hanging everything on somehow astonishing them at that point. And fabulous interviews are given by very bright students. Not people who spit cherry stones the right way, as someone suggested above.( There are no such apocryphal tests).

One of the most helpful things now is to come from a group that there is a push to have better represented there.

Catopia · 02/03/2024 07:09

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 20:07

Maybe so, but it sounds silly and ignorant. Nobody who has actually been to either of them or teaches at either of them refers to 'Oxbridge'.

I went to Oxford and my cousin went to Cambridge. We both say Oxbridge to refer to the two collectively, as does everyone I know... We even used to call the X2 bus that runs from Oxford to Cambridge via Milton Keynes the Oxbridge Express...

springbrigid · 02/03/2024 07:03

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 19:27

To be fair my SIL has always been happy to use me as a babysitter and tutor but we have never seen eye to eye so it would just be adding to the long list of things that are my fault. At the end of the day I don’t have to like her or spend much time with her - she’s a good mum and that’s all I care about. You’re probably right tho.

If you don't really get on with your SIL then there was always a danger of upsetting her. I'd have kept it pretty bland with your niece and just shown her the grades most people need to get in and then mentioned it to your SIL - 'niece says she wants to go to Oxford, so for that most people need 3-4 As' or whatever. And then leave it up to them* to draw their own conclusions and to consult with your niece's school.

LuluBlakey1 · 02/03/2024 07:03

Lifeomars · 01/03/2024 21:43

Liz Truss went to Oxford, the university, not the city, as did Boris Johnson, Matt Hancock and Jacob Rees Mogg. None of them strike me as having any depth of intellect...

Lettuce Liz lacks intellect.

Hereyoume · 02/03/2024 06:58

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

You're a tutor?

Seriously?

YireosDodeAver · 02/03/2024 06:56

Yanbu

There are enough straight-A students to fill every oxbridge course several times over. There are loads of straight-A students who don't get in. Someone who isn't on target for straight As shouldn't bother unless they qualify for a contextual offer

OneInEight · 02/03/2024 06:55

This was years ago but I always remember a classmate announcing he could have got into Oxford as xxx had. Well actually no he couldn't because unlike xxx he did not apply.

The only certain way to not get into Oxbridge is to not apply. Anyone else has a chance - maybe remote, maybe they will have to work harder and maybe they will be disappointed - but at least they will have tried.

BusyMummy001 · 02/03/2024 06:54

Late to this thread, but am assuming she is in year 12 as applications for sept are closed now on UCAS?

So, there is time to get her grades up but I think you were right to encourage her to be realistic. Oxbridge interviews/application processes are brutal and not geared to bring out the best in applicants who are ND or have dyslexia - and she will be competing against candidates with 10-12 grade 7-9s (A-A*) at GCSE and predicted 3-4 A/A at A level. You clearly know this but mum doesn’t want to hear it.

Depending upon the subject, there may be much plenty of Russell Group unis with more contemporary modules and, more significantly, much better pastoral/student support. Oxbridge has a shocking reputation for the latter. It is more important she goes to a uni where she likes the course content, will have great tutors and student support - ie a higher chance of getting a 2:1 or 1st - than she goes to a university because her mum can flex over it.

OP I think you were very wise - I know of many Oxbridge drop outs and many who failed to get in but thrived in RG unis. Mum needs to consider what she thinks a place at Oxbridge actually means for her daughter.

springbrigid · 02/03/2024 06:52

AmaryllisChorus · 01/03/2024 17:53

YABU. If you were tutoring her and she said she wanted to apply to Oxford, all you need to do is say, 'Great. You'll need to be getting A*s in everything and understanding why you don't, if you don't. You need to be reading very widely outside the curriculum. Read Shakespeare for fun (if applying for English.) Come back to me next week with the homework I set you plus a 2k word essay on a literary book you have read for pleasure or a popular genre book that you can analyse with fresh insights. This is exciting. Go for it.' She'll either realise she isn't up to it, or she'll rise to the challenge.

No point in saying, 'You can't.' Better to say, 'If you want this, you need to XYZ'

Edited

I more or less agree with this. It really isn't up to you to tell her she couldn't get in and you should have known it would upset her - all you had to do was look at the likelihood with her in terms of applications vs acceptance and required grades and discuss what she'd need to do to attain those grades. Then having (presumably) concluded together the very slim possibility of getting in, talk about postgrad and make sure she has a plan B, C, D for undergrad that she would also be happy with.

YouJustDoYou · 02/03/2024 06:51

I should add I went to the other uni on Oxford (the non-famous, non-"Oxford" one), and it was renowned from the "failed" kids that when you went to interviews, for some colleges there were additional "sneak" tests - for one of the colleges, they invited the prospectives applicants to a collective dinner, and served cherries - they would fail them based on how they disposed of the cherry pips (ie - manners. "How refined are you?"). It was pretty insane. Hopefully that's changed now haha.