Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my niece she won’t make it into Oxford uni?

561 replies

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

OP posts:
Penguinmouse · 02/03/2024 09:38

It would be unreasonable to look at her grades and encourage her to apply - she wouldn’t get in. There are students getting the grades who don’t get in because it’s so competitive.

you can encourage her to study and can offer help if she wants to bring her grades up to a consistency but I think mum is annoyed that you’ve damaged her dreams of having a child at Oxford, not the child’s.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 02/03/2024 09:37

You might have been being realistic but it’s a really really shitty thing to do to your own niece.

Ramalangadingdong · 02/03/2024 09:35

Merrymouse · 02/03/2024 09:32

People on here think that is a soft approach. It really isn’t. If we want to raise a generation of strong women we have to boost their confidence by teaching them how you overcome obstacles to achieve goals.

And a start would be reading and understanding the admissions process.

True! That is the way to get a young person to face reality. Not telling them bluntly they won’t make it. Let them see for themselves and then take them on a virtual tour of other brilliant unis. There are so many ways of approaching this issue.

ThanksItHasPockets · 02/03/2024 09:35

What subject does she want to read?

Merrymouse · 02/03/2024 09:32

People on here think that is a soft approach. It really isn’t. If we want to raise a generation of strong women we have to boost their confidence by teaching them how you overcome obstacles to achieve goals.

And a start would be reading and understanding the admissions process.

Merrymouse · 02/03/2024 09:31

Then having (presumably) concluded together the very slim possibility of getting in, talk about postgrad and make sure she has a plan B, C, D for undergrad that she would also be happy with.

That isn’t how the U.K. system works.

Yasai · 02/03/2024 09:29

YANBU.

I hate this kind of thing. Your SIL is limiting her potential.

A friend at school went to Oxford - fiercely bright, A*’s across the board. Even then it wasn’t a given.

when this time arrives for my daughters, I’ll be honest with them too. DH’s younger cousin used to speak endlessly about how she was “going to go to Oxford” and it was painfully obvious she wasn’t quite at the required level. She didn’t end up going to university at all because she got DDE at a alevel and only applied to Oxford and of course didn’t even get an interview. What’s the point of lying to a kid?!

Merrymouse · 02/03/2024 09:29

mids2019 · 02/03/2024 08:55

I think these threads start to bring out maybe the slight disappointment of those who achieved near perfect grades at GCSE and A level and didn't get into Oxbridge and therefore assume that candidates with slightly lower grades will not get in.

I think you should go with the official Oxford and Cambridge entrance criteria and if you are near to those go for it.

There are those with near perfect GCSE s and A levels that possibly went to very selective schools and Oxbridge to look at the context of the grades to some extent. You will always have your tales of the exceptionally well educated not getting in but that is another debate.

I think you should go with the official Oxford and Cambridge entrance criteria and if you are near to those go for it.

That is the point. From what the OP says, she is not near the criteria.

There seems to be some general misunderstanding on this thread about how the application process works.

You can apply to 5 universities (no Poly back up these days) and even if you get 5 offers you then have to choose a firm and an insurance offer, and reject the other 3.

Many universities will only allow applications for accommodation if you pick them as a firm offer.

Sometimes straight A students end up with no offers because they only apply for competitive courses. They then reapply the following year and find a place so not the end of the world - but the point is that sometimes it takes time and it’s more complicated than just firing off applications and crossing your fingers.

Ggttl · 02/03/2024 09:25

Parents think you don’t believe in their children if you don’t think they are capable of getting into a top school or uni. It is better to tell them the entrance criteria and percentage of applicants who get in, and then let the information sink in.

I would never tutor children of friends or family.

Ramalangadingdong · 02/03/2024 09:25

springbrigid · 02/03/2024 06:52

I more or less agree with this. It really isn't up to you to tell her she couldn't get in and you should have known it would upset her - all you had to do was look at the likelihood with her in terms of applications vs acceptance and required grades and discuss what she'd need to do to attain those grades. Then having (presumably) concluded together the very slim possibility of getting in, talk about postgrad and make sure she has a plan B, C, D for undergrad that she would also be happy with.

@springbrigid and @AmaryllisChorus I agree strongly with you both. If you are teachers I am relieved that there are teachers like you.

I find it awful to write kids off so early on in their lives. It is a total myth that some people are innately brilliant and others not. Most of us are capable - with training - of achieving more than we imagine. Brilliance is rare but when it exists is often also the product of training. In my experience you really don’t know who is going to end up thriving. A tutor is like a coach helping the student to achieve peak performance - which is a process. I would not allow my child to work with someone who erodes their confidence under the guise of “honesty”.

People on here think that is a soft approach. It really isn’t. If we want to raise a generation of strong women we have to boost their confidence by teaching them how you overcome obstacles to achieve goals.

Op doesn’t say why she thinks dn won’t get in. She is already getting A’s and B’s. So what does she have to do to push her over the line?

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 02/03/2024 09:19

I thought GCSEs were number grades now?

Anyway, YANBU. Not only because you were asked within the context of you being a tutor and it sounded like you answered kindly, but also because you only get to apply to 5 unis. If she's not realistic she could waste her applications.

ChekhovsMum · 02/03/2024 09:15

Does she actually want the ridiculous amount of work and intellectual demand of GOING to Oxford, or just the prestige of GETTING IN to Oxford? And what about her mum?
So, so many parents think that (a) tutoring is a ticket to academic achievement when the child’s initial ability and motivation to learn is mediocre, and (b) getting into a top institution guarantees career success.
I suppose really it’s an extension of the aspirational middle class attitude that money can buy everything.

springbrigid · 02/03/2024 09:10

willWillSmithsmith · 02/03/2024 08:35

If she wanted to get into Oxbridge surely she should already be aware how difficult it is and what’s expected of her to get in? She shouldn’t need anyone telling her at all to be honest. If she can’t think for herself and work that out already then maybe she’s not a good fit for it anyway?

Yes - not sure why it's your sole fault/responsibility in crushing/supporting her 'dreams'?
You're very kind and patient to help her so much, but sounds like your SIL thinks you've overstepped a bit despite this being your area of expertise, a classic case of the mix of work and family getting too emotional.
Seeing as your SIL has bitten the hand that feeds her, all you can really do is help your dn as you are but direct all talk of university applications on to your SIL/your dn's school.
It's really the responsibility of the student firstly, maybe coupled with their school and parents. It's up to her to figure it out now.

bombastix · 02/03/2024 09:09

I think we've established that Oxbridge is pretty commonly used as conventional shorthand for educational style. It's also used by employers snd schools.

theresapossuminthekitchen · 02/03/2024 09:05

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 20:09

Well, it is mine, and I know a fair few alumnae and current lecturers at both universities.

No one says ‘I’m a History fellow at Oxbridge’ or ‘I went to Oxbridge’, obviously. Oxbridge tends to be used when talking about applications or a generalisation about the difference between those two universities and the others (see also: ‘Russell Group’) or if trying to be deliberately vague to hide details. In those cases it’s a useful shorthand and much quicker than saying or writing ‘Oxford or Cambridge’.

I’m an Oxford alumnus and I would use Oxbridge when talking about applying for uni with my sixth form students, but I will also refer to ‘Oxford and Cambridge’ sometimes and will also discuss the differences between them where relevant.

Twiglets1 · 02/03/2024 09:04

HelloTreacle9 · 02/03/2024 08:59

YANBU

A) Sounds like a SIL idea. Parents can project… I was a B/C student and my mum insisted I sit the Oxford entrance. It was her ambition, not mine. I failed. I was never going to get in, it was a memorably mortifying and confidence-knocking experience all round. There are plenty of great unis for non-straight-A kids.

B) My teens and all their mates are OBSESSED with Saltburn, and a couple of my friends with teens have said they’ve mentioned that they fancy Oxford uni after watching it…

Right....because they want to be invited somewhere like that to spend their summers with such nice families

HelloTreacle9 · 02/03/2024 08:59

YANBU

A) Sounds like a SIL idea. Parents can project… I was a B/C student and my mum insisted I sit the Oxford entrance. It was her ambition, not mine. I failed. I was never going to get in, it was a memorably mortifying and confidence-knocking experience all round. There are plenty of great unis for non-straight-A kids.

B) My teens and all their mates are OBSESSED with Saltburn, and a couple of my friends with teens have said they’ve mentioned that they fancy Oxford uni after watching it…

mids2019 · 02/03/2024 08:55

I think these threads start to bring out maybe the slight disappointment of those who achieved near perfect grades at GCSE and A level and didn't get into Oxbridge and therefore assume that candidates with slightly lower grades will not get in.

I think you should go with the official Oxford and Cambridge entrance criteria and if you are near to those go for it.

There are those with near perfect GCSE s and A levels that possibly went to very selective schools and Oxbridge to look at the context of the grades to some extent. You will always have your tales of the exceptionally well educated not getting in but that is another debate.

Notalwaysthismean · 02/03/2024 08:45

These days, a successful oxbridge candidate will have 10+ GCSEs at 8/9 and 4 a levels (or at the very least 3 a levels and a very impressive epq) with at least 2 A* predictions.
This is not because those are the requirements, but because a student who will be successful at Oxbridge will be the type of student who has the ability to achieve these kind of results.
ETA so I think you were right op. Better to be realistic and focus efforts on other, also brilliant, unis.

ohdamnitjanet · 02/03/2024 08:41

You sound fantastic and I wish to God my ds had an aunt like you.

TheRaptures · 02/03/2024 08:39

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 08:22

Sometimes intellectual challenge questions can be asked that might ( perhaps) involve something like cherry stones, but the point would not be one of manners or etiquette. If these people really thought that, perhaps they had not even understood what the question was getting at, let alone known how to answer. 😒In my day the story doing the rounds was that someone set fire to the don’s sofa during the interview - and, of course, (!) this generated such an impression he got in.

I think the version of this circulating in my day was a supercilious interviewer who was reading a newspaper and ignoring the interview candidate. Eventually he said ‘Interest me’ and the candidate set his newspaper on fire.

willWillSmithsmith · 02/03/2024 08:35

Animatic · 02/03/2024 08:08

Why would you crash the dream though? I would have told "oxford is very difficult, we will aim there but it's good to have a solid back-up plan too". Abd save all lecturing on do ing well and doing masters for when she doesn't get in.

If she wanted to get into Oxbridge surely she should already be aware how difficult it is and what’s expected of her to get in? She shouldn’t need anyone telling her at all to be honest. If she can’t think for herself and work that out already then maybe she’s not a good fit for it anyway?

Merrymouse · 02/03/2024 08:33

Garlicking · 02/03/2024 02:42

I can't fathom why it's a brilliant idea to tell a kid not to TRY for something they really want! DN can apply and see what happens. It won't stop her going to another university.

Nothing wrong with pointing out the difficulty level, but for heaven's sake encourage her to get in there and give it her best! Did any of you read this week's 'Resilience' thread? Well, if you're all in favour of not even pushing kids to try where they may not succeed, I think I'm seeing how the problem arises Confused

Back in my sixth form days (the Pleistocene), Cambridge offered me B,B,C to read linguistics & French. I had 7 average-to-poor O levels (it was that long ago!) I know everything's changed since then, but I'd been told to expect no offer or 3 As at best. I'm glad nobody suggested that was a reason not to even try!

It won't stop her going to another university.

It literally will because you can only apply to 5 universities.

Everything has changed since the 80s.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 08:31

drumbeats · 01/03/2024 20:57

@xsquared they really don't give a rats arse about extra curricular activities. People thinking DofE or county hockey will help are naive

Selection is made by academics. All they care about is who is going to be good to teach and who might be future academics

That is spot on. The teaching system is such ( heavily based on small tutorial groups, and often within college) that they want to know the fit in terms of academic style will be right.

A similar approach applies in terms of interview style. It isn’t about being the life of the party, or particularly personable, or having posh mannerisms or knowing how to “ sell themselves.”; it’s about how they grapple with intellectual questions.

mitogoshi · 02/03/2024 08:30

Whereabouts is your niece based as GCSEs have numbers not letter grades now in England. I don't think you are being unreasonable btw just that perhaps it's better to suggest alternatives rather than crush dreams eg this is a great university and they have this and that extra curricular activity you enjoy.

The bigger issue if she's predicted b or below at a level is that nearly all of the better universities require A's these days though in reality many will let them drop grades in august