Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my niece she won’t make it into Oxford uni?

561 replies

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

OP posts:
PlumpAndDeliciousFatcat · 02/03/2024 13:20

I work with sixth-formers and have noticed a definite increase in the number expressing an interest in Oxbridge. This is great but there is a caveat that quite a few of them are openly motivated by the ‘aesthetic’ and the idea of floating around in a dark academia cosplay for three years. It doesn’t take long after a conversation about the course content and structure for them to come to their own conclusions about whether Oxbridge is right for them, before we even begin to consider whether they are right for Oxbridge. One boy was immediately put off once he saw a photo of the (truly hideous) English faculty building in Oxford Grin.

PP are absolutely correct that, in the humanities at least, Oxbridge undergraduate courses tend to be very traditional and classical in their approach and this isn’t for everyone!

BusyMummy001 · 02/03/2024 13:17

Goldenbear · 02/03/2024 13:12

Yes, possibly, friend's son was studying Maths at Oxford, he has a 6 in English and English lit.

The other young person was studying History and had a 6 in Maths.

My DS is being encouraged by his politics teacher to think about Oxbridge but as he is currently working at A* in politics, A in Economics and B in History this was in November so had only been at college for 2 months but he has some 6s at GCSE not in core subjects but having read this I don't think there is any point.

My DH read natural sciences at Cambridge - also got C grade (ie today’s grade 6) in Eng lang and Lit at GCSE’s, but 9 As in other subjects, and As in A Levels - albeit 30 years ago. Under today’s criteria, that’s a 9.0 average across top 8 GCSEs and top grades in the relevant A levels for his degree. I think this explains the students you mentioned above.

BusyMummy001 · 02/03/2024 13:12

Goldenbear · 02/03/2024 12:44

I wonder how the two students I know got past the first hurdle of having a 6 in Maths and another having 6 in English at GCSE, I am very close to one of their families, there are no mitigating circumstances.

Perhaps it was to do with the subject? My friend is on the med school and sciences admissions team so the number of applications or places are ridiculously high - and I can only go by what he has categorically told me when discussing my DC’s future plans (and the fact that I haven’t encouraged my kids down this router - despite a DH who went to Cambridge, from a state school, with all A grades, 30 years ago).

The OP’s DN (we’ve not been given grades, so am assuming she didn’t get all 7-9’s otherwise she might have said?) is only getting B’s (with some As and Cs) in her y12 assignments, it seems. Perhaps the students you know were getting A’s from day one in 6th form and therefore there was a strong case to present their grade 6s in their personal statements/school reference, due say to all the other grades being 8/9s? Who knows.

At our local state 6th forms colleges you have to sign up for the ASPIRE programme in Jan of y12 and already be getting A grades on assignments to be considered. If you do not have a 7.5 average in your top 8 GCSE grades you also cannot take part. (I’m assuming your two students did?) So the point stands - OP has not qualified her post with any information that suggests DN is gifted and talented.

Goldenbear · 02/03/2024 13:12

LarkspurLane · 02/03/2024 12:51

Would it not be possible to have a 6 in English and then go on to do a physics degree (for example), assuming great grades in physics, maths, etc?

Yes, possibly, friend's son was studying Maths at Oxford, he has a 6 in English and English lit.

The other young person was studying History and had a 6 in Maths.

My DS is being encouraged by his politics teacher to think about Oxbridge but as he is currently working at A* in politics, A in Economics and B in History this was in November so had only been at college for 2 months but he has some 6s at GCSE not in core subjects but having read this I don't think there is any point.

willWillSmithsmith · 02/03/2024 13:09

My son is very bright, mostly 9s in GCSE (and a couple of 8s). Predicted A*and A in A levels but I still don’t think he’d get into Oxbridge if he applied. He’s not motivated, passionate or driven enough. Nor does he want to work as hard as Oxbridge students have to. He applied to Unis that have a good balance of work and play and has offers from all of them.

He wasn’t upset or offended when I said he wouldn’t get in, he agreed with me, but that’s because it was never his ‘dream’.

Even if you’re bright it’s not for everyone, there are lots of great unis out there that would be more enjoyable for some.

Stuckinthemiddle7890 · 02/03/2024 13:00

Ramalangadingdong · 02/03/2024 09:35

True! That is the way to get a young person to face reality. Not telling them bluntly they won’t make it. Let them see for themselves and then take them on a virtual tour of other brilliant unis. There are so many ways of approaching this issue.

Love the way you speak as if you know the girl. Imagine what she would think reading all this. How on earth do you know she won't make it. It's up to her to decide if she can make it and that's the direction she should have been given. Sorry added this post to the wrong quote apologies to the person I quoted

Merrymouse · 02/03/2024 12:58

The colleges do take other circumstances into account, but I'm not sure if any of that is relevant in this case. Getting Bs at GCSE shouldnt necessary be a hindrance, but if she wants to go she needs to turn the wick up in sixth form, really get her head down and aim for top grades in yr12 and A level mocks.

Oxbridge applications are in October, so before mocks. Obviously the niece should be working hard anyway, but there are plenty of other options that aren’t Oxbridge.

There is nothing stopping the niece from applying post A level, but there is no reason to assume that she is particularly disadvantaged. (On the contrary she has an aunt who is a tutor).

LarkspurLane · 02/03/2024 12:51

Goldenbear · 02/03/2024 12:44

I wonder how the two students I know got past the first hurdle of having a 6 in Maths and another having 6 in English at GCSE, I am very close to one of their families, there are no mitigating circumstances.

Would it not be possible to have a 6 in English and then go on to do a physics degree (for example), assuming great grades in physics, maths, etc?

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 12:50

Goldenbear · 02/03/2024 12:44

I wonder how the two students I know got past the first hurdle of having a 6 in Maths and another having 6 in English at GCSE, I am very close to one of their families, there are no mitigating circumstances.

To be honest, I’m wondering too.

Could they be said to belong to an under-represented demographic?

While grades aren’t actually particularly decisive once they get to interview ( hence the best candidates grade-wise who get rejected in favour of someone with lesser grades), the grades do matter for the first cut. It’s a surprising outcome.

Thefrogwife · 02/03/2024 12:45

Hollowgast · 02/03/2024 12:27

I'm sorry I don't think you were fair. One reason that Oxbridge has such a high proportion of private school students there is that they are actively encouraged and expected to apply. So many state school teachers are either indifferent or actively discourage bright candidates for applying, saying "it's not for us"; I've seen people on MN saying this too. It never will be unless they apply. I know this first hand as a state school kid who was discouraged ("we've never had anyone who got in there") but was successful and went to Cambridge, emerging seven years later with a PhD. She should absolutely apply, but the way I would word it is "there are multiple applications per place, and the vast majority of the people that apply will be expecting A*AA or better, so unless there are other circumstances (poverty, underperforming school, difficult family circumstances) then getting Bs at A level won't be good enough".
The colleges do take other circumstances into account, but I'm not sure if any of that is relevant in this case. Getting Bs at GCSE shouldnt necessary be a hindrance, but if she wants to go she needs to turn the wick up in sixth form, really get her head down and aim for top grades in yr12 and A level mocks.

Note: I went to Churchill College Cambridge, which has a high proportion of STEM students and a state school ratio of over 70%. It's a few years old but the link below is a fly on the wall report from an admissions review meeting, demonstrating what they seem important and how they rake applicant circumstances into account.
Admissions, Churchill Cambridge.

But we (private school teachers) wouldn't encourage pupils who are getting Bs and Cs at A level to apply. We offer extra sessions after school throughout Y12 to prepare- extra reading, essay writing. It wouldn't be a good use of resources to encourage the B and C grade kids (which at my school would be 95% of pupils as we get very few Ds etc) to apply as well.

Goldenbear · 02/03/2024 12:44

BusyMummy001 · 02/03/2024 12:11

You can’t teach a child ‘what it would take to get in’!

They are either of the academic level where they are suitable or not (ie high grades, self starter, highly self-motivated, deeply passionate about their A Level subjects and the chosen degree subject, proven academic ability, not needing additional academic supervision).

She doesn’t have the grades to even make it through their first sweep. A friend is an admissions officer for both Oxbridge Unis - there are between 10-25 applications for every single place. The baseline policy is to dismiss anyone without high enough GCSE grades; then they dismiss those who are not predicted grades in line with the course brochure’s minimum grade requirement for A Levels; THEN then rule out on the basis of the personal statement; and finally interview. OP’s DN would fall at the first hurdle.

It’s unfair as it makes no allowances for illness, family issues etc that may have impacted GCSE grades, but if they are sifting through 2000+ applications for 80 places they cannot review every individual child’s personal stories.

OP is right - DN should consider applying for Masters if she pulls off a 1st at undergraduate level, or she could have a shot at it after A levels if she pulls out all the stops and she gets all A’s/A*s, though from the OP comment it didn’t seem as though DN was especially driven to do this or I suspect it would have been mentioned.

It’s downright cruel of DN’s mother to be pushing her child towards a path that she will simply not succeed in a this stage, that makes makes any other choice seem not good enough [for mum], and will be wasting 1/5 UCAS choices.

I wonder how the two students I know got past the first hurdle of having a 6 in Maths and another having 6 in English at GCSE, I am very close to one of their families, there are no mitigating circumstances.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 12:43

TheRaptures · 02/03/2024 08:39

I think the version of this circulating in my day was a supercilious interviewer who was reading a newspaper and ignoring the interview candidate. Eventually he said ‘Interest me’ and the candidate set his newspaper on fire.

I think yours sounds closer to an original version! Without ever taking it seriously, I’d always faintly envisaged the slow ( probably quite smelly) burn of a sofa as not particularly impressive at all and something of an anticlimax! Presumably the next version added dousing it in petroleum first ( especially as candidates do tend to turn up to interview with a spare can of it. ) Fwiw I’ve never come across an interviewer who would be so rude - or so easily impressed!

TheRaptures · 02/03/2024 12:43

TheRaptures · 02/03/2024 12:42

As I said above, it’s a possibly apocryphal anecdote associated with the historian AL Rowse, who sat for (and won) an All Souls fellowship in 1925. A century ago, possibly never happened and not anything to do with the undergraduate admissions process then or now.

Sorry, was agreeing with you, but sounded as if I wasn’t!

TheRaptures · 02/03/2024 12:42

ToWhitToWhoo · 02/03/2024 12:11

This is one of the myths that gets spread about Oxbridge, and has a very negative effect in terms of discouraging pupils from poorer backgrounds, and those who just aren't very socially confident, from ever applying.

I suppose some unsuccessful applicants may 'trade on' spreading the myth, because they prefer it to people thinking that they weren't academically able enough to get in; but usually it just comes from the rumour factories and too much watching of Brideshead Revisited!

I am not sure if there was ever a time when such things happened; but they certainly weren't even in the early 80s, let alone at any time since.

As I said above, it’s a possibly apocryphal anecdote associated with the historian AL Rowse, who sat for (and won) an All Souls fellowship in 1925. A century ago, possibly never happened and not anything to do with the undergraduate admissions process then or now.

Hollowgast · 02/03/2024 12:36

ToWhitToWhoo · 02/03/2024 12:11

This is one of the myths that gets spread about Oxbridge, and has a very negative effect in terms of discouraging pupils from poorer backgrounds, and those who just aren't very socially confident, from ever applying.

I suppose some unsuccessful applicants may 'trade on' spreading the myth, because they prefer it to people thinking that they weren't academically able enough to get in; but usually it just comes from the rumour factories and too much watching of Brideshead Revisited!

I am not sure if there was ever a time when such things happened; but they certainly weren't even in the early 80s, let alone at any time since.

Agree. It's utter tripe.

Calliopespa · 02/03/2024 12:30

Goldenbear · 02/03/2024 11:16

I know two people that didn't have contextual offers and didn't get all 8,9s they had a 6 in Maths and one had a 6 in English. This is a state 6th college though not private school.

That last comment makes all the difference. There is a huge emphasis on equal access/ opportunities now.

Hollowgast · 02/03/2024 12:27

I'm sorry I don't think you were fair. One reason that Oxbridge has such a high proportion of private school students there is that they are actively encouraged and expected to apply. So many state school teachers are either indifferent or actively discourage bright candidates for applying, saying "it's not for us"; I've seen people on MN saying this too. It never will be unless they apply. I know this first hand as a state school kid who was discouraged ("we've never had anyone who got in there") but was successful and went to Cambridge, emerging seven years later with a PhD. She should absolutely apply, but the way I would word it is "there are multiple applications per place, and the vast majority of the people that apply will be expecting A*AA or better, so unless there are other circumstances (poverty, underperforming school, difficult family circumstances) then getting Bs at A level won't be good enough".
The colleges do take other circumstances into account, but I'm not sure if any of that is relevant in this case. Getting Bs at GCSE shouldnt necessary be a hindrance, but if she wants to go she needs to turn the wick up in sixth form, really get her head down and aim for top grades in yr12 and A level mocks.

Note: I went to Churchill College Cambridge, which has a high proportion of STEM students and a state school ratio of over 70%. It's a few years old but the link below is a fly on the wall report from an admissions review meeting, demonstrating what they seem important and how they rake applicant circumstances into account.
Admissions, Churchill Cambridge.

So who is good enough to get into Cambridge?

Cambridge University says it wants more students from state schools. But how does it really decide who deserves a place amid intense competition? Jeevan Vasagar gained unprecedented access to the admissions process to find out

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2012/jan/10/how-cambridge-admissions-really-work

Butchyrestingface · 02/03/2024 12:23

She doesn’t sound particularly bright or well-informed to me, if she’s sitting in sixth form, averaging B grades, and still entertaining ideas of Oxbridge. That’s got nothing to do with dyslexia, a casual look at the Oxford website should have put her straight on entrance requirements.

is the SiL a bit high-strung?

ToWhitToWhoo · 02/03/2024 12:20

People involved in admissions do review special/ mitigating circumstances, and people with relatively low GCSE grades do sometimes get admitted if there are special circumstances (e.g. very disadvantaged school; serious illness/ accident/ bereavement at the time of exams); but these are unusual cases, especially if the lower grades are in maths or English.

By the way, it's often not just a matter of your exams and your interview; many subjects also set an aptitude test.

ToWhitToWhoo · 02/03/2024 12:11

YouJustDoYou · 02/03/2024 06:51

I should add I went to the other uni on Oxford (the non-famous, non-"Oxford" one), and it was renowned from the "failed" kids that when you went to interviews, for some colleges there were additional "sneak" tests - for one of the colleges, they invited the prospectives applicants to a collective dinner, and served cherries - they would fail them based on how they disposed of the cherry pips (ie - manners. "How refined are you?"). It was pretty insane. Hopefully that's changed now haha.

This is one of the myths that gets spread about Oxbridge, and has a very negative effect in terms of discouraging pupils from poorer backgrounds, and those who just aren't very socially confident, from ever applying.

I suppose some unsuccessful applicants may 'trade on' spreading the myth, because they prefer it to people thinking that they weren't academically able enough to get in; but usually it just comes from the rumour factories and too much watching of Brideshead Revisited!

I am not sure if there was ever a time when such things happened; but they certainly weren't even in the early 80s, let alone at any time since.

BusyMummy001 · 02/03/2024 12:11

AmaryllisChorus · 02/03/2024 11:54

But I don't think that is the point. The point is to teach her what it would take to get in. Not to tell her she can't. She has dyslexia, that has only recently been accommodated, and her grades have improved. If she did three hours a day extra-curricular reading, studied essay structure for fun, joined a debating society to develop her critical thinking skills, aimed for A*s from now on, she might be in with a chance. And even if she wasn't, she'd have gained so much from the experience. Or given up - no shame in that if it is because she's learned that she truly doesn't love her subject that much, and would prefer an easier life with more time spent socialising.

You can’t teach a child ‘what it would take to get in’!

They are either of the academic level where they are suitable or not (ie high grades, self starter, highly self-motivated, deeply passionate about their A Level subjects and the chosen degree subject, proven academic ability, not needing additional academic supervision).

She doesn’t have the grades to even make it through their first sweep. A friend is an admissions officer for both Oxbridge Unis - there are between 10-25 applications for every single place. The baseline policy is to dismiss anyone without high enough GCSE grades; then they dismiss those who are not predicted grades in line with the course brochure’s minimum grade requirement for A Levels; THEN then rule out on the basis of the personal statement; and finally interview. OP’s DN would fall at the first hurdle.

It’s unfair as it makes no allowances for illness, family issues etc that may have impacted GCSE grades, but if they are sifting through 2000+ applications for 80 places they cannot review every individual child’s personal stories.

OP is right - DN should consider applying for Masters if she pulls off a 1st at undergraduate level, or she could have a shot at it after A levels if she pulls out all the stops and she gets all A’s/A*s, though from the OP comment it didn’t seem as though DN was especially driven to do this or I suspect it would have been mentioned.

It’s downright cruel of DN’s mother to be pushing her child towards a path that she will simply not succeed in a this stage, that makes makes any other choice seem not good enough [for mum], and will be wasting 1/5 UCAS choices.

dapsnotplimsolls · 02/03/2024 12:09

LarkspurLane · 02/03/2024 11:27

A lot of schools have "aspire to Oxbridge" type programs, I wonder if her school does and if she is on it?

With B grades? I doubt it.

Toastcrumbsinsofa · 02/03/2024 12:05

@Awfulaunt you definitely did the right thing by being honest with your niece. I’m a retired tutor and it’s a difficult situation when students or parents ask for your opinion about potential university entrance. You would have got the blame if your niece was rejected by Oxford if you had been too optimistic about her academic abilities. Instead, you are being blamed for crushing her dream. Unfortunately, this is the life of a tutor!

Which subject does your niece wish to study? One of my students managed to get into Cambridge with A grades rather than A* by choosing a very unpopular degree subject!

Merrymouse · 02/03/2024 12:02

AmaryllisChorus · 02/03/2024 11:54

But I don't think that is the point. The point is to teach her what it would take to get in. Not to tell her she can't. She has dyslexia, that has only recently been accommodated, and her grades have improved. If she did three hours a day extra-curricular reading, studied essay structure for fun, joined a debating society to develop her critical thinking skills, aimed for A*s from now on, she might be in with a chance. And even if she wasn't, she'd have gained so much from the experience. Or given up - no shame in that if it is because she's learned that she truly doesn't love her subject that much, and would prefer an easier life with more time spent socialising.

That might mean it would be possible to apply after A-levels if she did get really good grades, but she just doesn’t meet the criteria to get an offer now.

BusyMummy001 · 02/03/2024 11:57

Zodfa · 02/03/2024 11:20

I do Oxbridge admissions (undergrad and postgrad). Extracurricular activities are only relevant if closely related to the subject (though those which are can make a difference).

Is this what I’ve seen referred to as supra-curricular, rather than extra-curricular?