Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my niece she won’t make it into Oxford uni?

561 replies

Awfulaunt · 01/03/2024 17:35

Hi all,
first off sorry if there’s typos I’m typing this on my phone.
for context, I’ve been a private tutor for years, mainly English and History. Over the years I’ve helped with lots of UCAS and applications including a few oxbridge ones. My niece is at the age where she’s thinking about uni and her parents asked me to tutor her for English and History, I agreed. She is bright, gets Bs and the occasional A or C. She asked me if I think she should apply to Oxford and I said “No not for your undergrad. Maybe if you work really really hard at uni and do extracurriculars and things while you’re there and come out with a first you could try for your masters if you want to do one, but it’s not really an option at this moment in time.” All seemed fine, we carried on and she seemed okay. Fast forward to now and I just had SIL on the phone shouting at me that I crushed her dreams and that she was going to apply and get in and show me (etc). I said I’d love it if she did, I’d be absolutely thrilled if she got in to spite me.
I don’t think I was harsh when I told her, I don’t think it was cruel. I think it’s kind of my job to tell her. I didn’t rule it out in the future because I feel like once she’s at uni she will flourish academically because she will have more freedom etc and I’ve told her this many times. I feel horrible that I’ve upset her but I genuinely think it was the right thing to do.
I sent her a message saying I am sorry if I came off harsh or anything I just want what is best for her. Also spoke to DB who said SIL was just angry because niece was upset and that he thinks I did the right thing. Bit miffed that he let her speak to me like that, but also when she goes off best thing to do is stay out the crossfire.
Am I in the wrong and just blind to it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Olivegardenishome · 15/03/2024 01:00

Teddleshon · 15/03/2024 00:29

Nope, didn't go right over my head. Quite the opposite, spurred me on to prive her wrong. My school careers adviser explicitly told me not to bother applying for Law and not to bother applying for the leading University in Law.

I was the same as you.
I was always clever though, but had a baby at 19 (planned, because I was 19 and knew better than anyone else!). Everyone said I’d ruined my life. Used that as my motivation to finish my law degree and training contract while renovating a house I’d bought with my then boyfriend, now husband.

Everyone said “you’ll never be able to manage uni with a baby” - I did.

Then everyone said “you’ll never be able to buy a house with a baby” - me and my DH did.

Then everyone said “you’ll never be able to work as a lawyer with a baby” - I did.

Then everyone said “you’ll never be able to travel the world with a young child” - we did.

Then everyone said “you’ll never be able to make your relationship work, you’re too young and there’s too much pressure with the baby” - we did (married 19 yrs).

I am glad everyone - I mean everyone - told me I couldn’t do stuff as it motivated me. Now I just don’t listen to anyone 😂

But yeah, anyone doubting your post is just like one of those naysayers that I look back on now with a mixture of
pity for them, but gratitude they inspired me to be motivated and not like them.

Teddleshon · 15/03/2024 00:29

Nope, didn't go right over my head. Quite the opposite, spurred me on to prive her wrong. My school careers adviser explicitly told me not to bother applying for Law and not to bother applying for the leading University in Law.

Ramalangadingdong · 14/03/2024 23:34

Teddleshon · 12/03/2024 03:19

Exactly right, someone who is determined would use it as a motivation.

And you had such motivation when you were 17/18 that the verdict of “expert” adults went right over your head?

Teddleshon · 12/03/2024 03:19

Exactly right, someone who is determined would use it as a motivation.

willWillSmithsmith · 11/03/2024 17:24

I don’t see how OP could have crushed her dreams by simply saying she didn’t think she’d get in to Oxford. If that’s all it took to dash her dreams then that’s probably a characteristic Oxford is not looking for. The mum is the issue here, and the niece’s lack of conviction, not the OP.

Merrymouse · 11/03/2024 15:35

It’s not about lacking brilliance - there could be many reasons why the niece got Bs and Cs in her GCSEs. (An A in music, but apparently she is not taking that forward).

It’s about the timing of the admissions process and the LACK OF EVIDENCE, at this point, to demonstrate that she would be suitable.

With the best will in the world, universities do not have time to review every student who doesn’t have the grades on paper, but might be an undiscovered gem.

harryw66 · 11/03/2024 12:30

I did not make it clear in my previous post that my son did get into Oxford.
According to him, the PAT test (Maths and Physics) he had to sit were much more challenging than his A level Maths and Physics exams.
Also, he had to do 3(or 4?) interviews - which were also very tough (compared to interviews at other leading Universities) - he was convinced after 2 of them that he had messed up and would not be getting in.. In fact he did not get an offer from the College of his choice - but thankfully was made one by another College and had to interview for them as well..
He is home for end of term and I asked him how it felt being at Oxford. He has several friends attending other top (mostly London) Universities and having discussed his course with theirs, he just sees Oxford as very good Uni - just like the ones his friends are attending....

Cantrushart · 10/03/2024 08:45

@Hollowgast
I'm ashamed to say that I was one of those parents. I told DS not to bother applying because he didn't have a clean sweep of grade 9s at GCSE and, in my head, it was for ultra brilliant posh folk. He ignored me, applied anyway , and was accepted. I believe now that the biggest barrier to admission is not having the confidence to apply in the first place.

Teateaandmoretea · 10/03/2024 07:49

Yanbu op. ‘Crushing of dreams’ 😂

Dreams need to align with what is attainable. Oxbridge look for a special stamp of academic brilliance, I’ve already explained that to my year 10 dd. She’s very academic but unless something hugely changes she won’t deliver what they are looking for at interview.

Success in life is about dreams and reality merging, sad but true.

JessS1990 · 10/03/2024 07:39

Stephenra · 10/03/2024 05:44

The anomalies here to me are the curious fixation on one single, particular university, to the exclusion of all others, and the blame being heaped upon one aunt for 'dashing a kid's dreams' by uttering one, reasonable, fact-based opinion.

What is it about Oxford, and Oxford alone, that can fulfil the girl's hopes and dreams? It seems to me that anyone pinning their lifetime ambitions on attending one particular institution is unreasonable, and says a lot more about fantasy, daydream and delusion rather than having reasonable and rational aims.

Then we have the SIL calling up to 'shout' to say the aunt had 'crushed her dreams'. The SIL is just as much in La-la land. Since when did failure to get into one college 'crush anyone's dreams'? There are other colleges.

All the aunt did was to give an honest opinion. What about the opinion of other educational professionals?

The choices available to a young person are legion. Rabid obsession with one particular institution has more to do with misplaced notions of prestige and acute status anxiety and snobbery from a parent who wishes to validate their own sense of failure, financial, social and academic by achieving standing in society by achieving it through their offspring. Seen it dozens of times.

Only dozens?

Snow plough parents love to remove every obstacle from their child's path in life, but then come up against the hard reality that what the top universities are interested in, is selecting student who are problem solvers, which little poppet isn't because all problems have been removed from their path.

Teddleshon · 10/03/2024 06:48

They should be grateful to have an involved Auntie who is able to offer informed advice. Chances are her own school would have told the niece at some point that Oxford is unlikely.

Stephenra · 10/03/2024 05:44

The anomalies here to me are the curious fixation on one single, particular university, to the exclusion of all others, and the blame being heaped upon one aunt for 'dashing a kid's dreams' by uttering one, reasonable, fact-based opinion.

What is it about Oxford, and Oxford alone, that can fulfil the girl's hopes and dreams? It seems to me that anyone pinning their lifetime ambitions on attending one particular institution is unreasonable, and says a lot more about fantasy, daydream and delusion rather than having reasonable and rational aims.

Then we have the SIL calling up to 'shout' to say the aunt had 'crushed her dreams'. The SIL is just as much in La-la land. Since when did failure to get into one college 'crush anyone's dreams'? There are other colleges.

All the aunt did was to give an honest opinion. What about the opinion of other educational professionals?

The choices available to a young person are legion. Rabid obsession with one particular institution has more to do with misplaced notions of prestige and acute status anxiety and snobbery from a parent who wishes to validate their own sense of failure, financial, social and academic by achieving standing in society by achieving it through their offspring. Seen it dozens of times.

ftp · 10/03/2024 00:25

Think we are getting off-topic here. It matters not what Oxbridge are accepting. She is not ready to go yet. OP shut her down, and smashed her aspirations. It has been known with extra help - which she SHOULD have been providing - for suddenly the light to go on. My own DD was struggling with a specific math section at 13 (I scraped GCE), but just talking through with her and re-reading the instructions, and asking questions - it clicked and off she went, leaving me well behind literally in days, all the way to her A level and on to her degree.
You really never know.

ToWhitToWhoo · 09/03/2024 20:30

bombastix · 09/03/2024 19:08

Well it used to be the super talented got the "FF". They wanted you so badly that they didn't care about your A levels.

In the past, most applicants were selected mainly on the basis of an entrance exam. If you did well on that (and in interview, and had done well in O levels), you received an unconditional offer- in a sense, the entrance exam substituted for A levels. The entrance exam was eventually abolished, mainly because it advantaged pupils who went to schools that were experienced in preparing pupils for this somewhat 'niche' exam (i.e. mostly private and top grammar schools). Nowadays, applicants are given offers conditional on A levels, except for the few who apply post- A level.

Macaronichee · 09/03/2024 19:49

JessS1990 · 09/03/2024 18:46

Every student for the same course at Oxford is made the same offer if they are made an offer.. Some courses are AAA, others are AAA.

True. First son made an offer of AAA, as was everyone on his course. Second son applying post-ALevel with two A stars and an A so ‘offer’ not applicable but was rejected without interview. Can’t have done well on entrance exam.

bombastix · 09/03/2024 19:40

Yea. And the interview. This is obviously years ago, but the FF candidate invariably either totally smashed their A levels or went down in flames because of their intransigent mindset. A particular kind of Oxbridge brilliance.

Sksjsndn27373 · 09/03/2024 19:37

bombastix · 09/03/2024 19:08

Well it used to be the super talented got the "FF". They wanted you so badly that they didn't care about your A levels.

Because of entrance exam?

bombastix · 09/03/2024 19:08

Well it used to be the super talented got the "FF". They wanted you so badly that they didn't care about your A levels.

JessS1990 · 09/03/2024 18:46

Macaronichee · 09/03/2024 18:43

The days of offers of lower than AAA for Oxford and AAA for Cambridge are long gone. Those given a 3 A offer are the sort of candidate who will achieve much higher. Some courses are less competitive (roughly 50% of applicants get in for Theology, fewer than 18% for Philosophy and Theology at Oxford). Two of my sons (who are both state school educated) applied for Oxford. One of them received an offer of AAA but achieved 3As. My other son applied post-A Level with two A*s and an A and didn’t even get an interview. Standards are very high.

Every student for the same course at Oxford is made the same offer if they are made an offer.. Some courses are AAA, others are AAA.

Macaronichee · 09/03/2024 18:43

The days of offers of lower than AAA for Oxford and AAA for Cambridge are long gone. Those given a 3 A offer are the sort of candidate who will achieve much higher. Some courses are less competitive (roughly 50% of applicants get in for Theology, fewer than 18% for Philosophy and Theology at Oxford). Two of my sons (who are both state school educated) applied for Oxford. One of them received an offer of AAA but achieved 3As. My other son applied post-A Level with two A*s and an A and didn’t even get an interview. Standards are very high.

EmeraldA129 · 04/03/2024 17:49

Ramalangadingdong · 04/03/2024 16:34

I assumed this meant that the aunt's tuition is in addition to DN's school work. I probably made the assumption because I have voluntarily tutored my friends children over the years. In that capacity I am always clear that I work I do with their kids is merely supplemental to their schoolwork. I always defer to their teachers.

Really? When I was at school I had tutors that were not related to me. My parents would have expected them to answer my questions (or theirs) honestly & fairly when it came to my capabilities & expectations. I would have thought the same would have applied in this situation.

Ramalangadingdong · 04/03/2024 16:34

EmeraldA129 · 04/03/2024 14:30

The op said her DN’s parents asked her to be their daughter’s tutor.

I assumed this meant that the aunt's tuition is in addition to DN's school work. I probably made the assumption because I have voluntarily tutored my friends children over the years. In that capacity I am always clear that I work I do with their kids is merely supplemental to their schoolwork. I always defer to their teachers.

Mittleme · 04/03/2024 16:29

Quite rightly so .
Oxford and Cambridge are not easy schools to get into .
Most teachers can tell who is suitable for these schools .
I know from experience and very unlikely to get in to a child getting B's and the odd A or C
you have to be naturally gifted , and definitely be a consistent A , A* grade .
Note my use of naturally gifted because they conduct their own entrance tests and interviews so no matter how many A, A you get ,
they want to know how you think .

EmeraldA129 · 04/03/2024 14:30

Ramalangadingdong · 04/03/2024 12:55

I think op has blurred the lines. She is an auntie who has volunteered to tutor her niece. Therefore the academic responsibility to counsel niece about whether or not she can apply to Oxford lies with her actual teachers.

The op said her DN’s parents asked her to be their daughter’s tutor.

Ramalangadingdong · 04/03/2024 12:55

EmeraldA129 · 04/03/2024 11:45

Since you’re her teacher too you are not being unreasonable. If you were just auntie then you would have been over stepping a bit. Maybe your SIL has blurred these lines.

I think op has blurred the lines. She is an auntie who has volunteered to tutor her niece. Therefore the academic responsibility to counsel niece about whether or not she can apply to Oxford lies with her actual teachers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread