Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I controlling and Insecure?

92 replies

Biscuits21 · 01/03/2024 08:39

My partner thinks my behaviour is controlling and coercive. He thinks I’m insecure. We have vastly different perspectives. I’d like an outsider's opinion.

Scenario 1:
My partner is making music for around 40 mins before bed. After about half an hour, I ask him if he's coming to bed.
My perspective - I want him to come and cuddle and spend time with me in bed.
His perspective - I'm bothered by what he is doing and want him to stop so that I can have attention. He is doing something he enjoys and I am encroaching on him.

Scenario 2:
We get in bed, it’s around 10:15pm, I’m very tired. My partner is on his laptop with the light on. I say ‘I’m ready for you to turn the light off when you’re ready.’ I repeat myself 5 mins later (I sometimes do this when I’m tired and delirious).
My perspective - I’m very tired and want to sleep. I’ve asked him in the nicest way possible to turn the light off.
His perspective - It’s okay for the light to be on for a few more minutes, I’m controlling what time he needs to turn the light off. I’m encroaching on his freedom of having the light on.

Scenario 3:
I get home from work, walk to the kitchen. I playfully say ‘ooo I can see you’ve had toast today, something with chopsticks… dumplings?’ We often play lighthearted ‘guessing games’ with each other.
My perspective - I’m trying to have a laugh and bond.
His perspective - I’m keeping tabs on what he’s eaten for lunch like I’m trying to watch his every move.

Scenario 4:
We get in bed, he’s on his laptop, I lay next to him and watch whatever he’s doing. I often say ‘can we both watch something?’
My perspective - I want to spend time with him in bed.
His perspective - I’m trying to stop what he’s doing for attention.

I have explained to him that in these scenarios, I’m simply trying to spend time with him. I feel rejected a lot of the time to his screen usage.

My partner says I’m insecure and all of these comments and my behaviour is coming from a huge insecure place. He says I need therapy to as all of our issues are my insecurities. I do believe I am insecure in ways but not necessarily these scenarios.

I have taken on board what he’s said and willing so seek therapy to delve into why I may act this way and where it comes from.

Has anyone had experiences with being an insecure person in a relationship and how they helped themselves? Or is he being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Dweetfidilove · 01/03/2024 09:49

I don’t know about controlling, but you sound awfully needy and passive aggressive.

He also sounds like a rather non-cooperative person (maybe because he’s been controlled before or is wary of losing control).

You both need some counselling and some help with your communication skills.

WandaWonder · 01/03/2024 09:49

KreedKafer · 01/03/2024 09:44

He's saying the OP is being controlling rather than recognising that a lot of her communication probably stems from an insecurity

The fact that it stems from insecurity doesn’t make it any less controlling. It absolutely IS controlling and her insecurity doesn’t mean he shouldn’t point that out to her.

A man who phones his wife every ten minutes when she’s out to make sure she isn’t with another man / tells her what to wear because he doesn’t want other men chatting her up / guilt-trips her about her hobby because romantic time with him should be more important / goes through her phone every night to check what she talks about with her friends, is also behaving in a way that stems from an insecurity. But it doesn’t make him any less controlling and it doesn’t mean his wife has to put up with it or be kind about it, because regardless of where it comes from, it’s still emotionally abusive and it’s still controlling.

Yes, man does it controlling

Women does it anxiety, vulnerable, inseure, jealous, has issues, I need to feel wanted, hormones, over emotional

AntonFeckoff · 01/03/2024 09:46

I’m sorry but that would make me feel claustrophobic. I think that level of intertwined-ness can work for some couples but for other people it’s suffocating. I was with someone who was like this and it felt like he wanted me to be an extension of him.

Scenario 1 would give me the rage.

Scenario 2 - he’s a dick for sitting in bed with the light on but you need to communicate better. I’d tell him no screens in the bedroom at night. I hate lying next to someone on their phone/laptop, the light and tapping is so annoying.

The lunch comment is almost like you’re monitoring him, that he can’t have anything for himself, even something as innocuous as what he’s had for lunch, without you passing comment on it.

Scenario 4 is just too much. Give him some personal space. But why is he in bed with his laptop? Do you go to the bedroom early and use it like a lounge until bedtime? Or is this at bedtime?

KreedKafer · 01/03/2024 09:44

He's saying the OP is being controlling rather than recognising that a lot of her communication probably stems from an insecurity

The fact that it stems from insecurity doesn’t make it any less controlling. It absolutely IS controlling and her insecurity doesn’t mean he shouldn’t point that out to her.

A man who phones his wife every ten minutes when she’s out to make sure she isn’t with another man / tells her what to wear because he doesn’t want other men chatting her up / guilt-trips her about her hobby because romantic time with him should be more important / goes through her phone every night to check what she talks about with her friends, is also behaving in a way that stems from an insecurity. But it doesn’t make him any less controlling and it doesn’t mean his wife has to put up with it or be kind about it, because regardless of where it comes from, it’s still emotionally abusive and it’s still controlling.

AnneLovesGilbert · 01/03/2024 09:44

Just say what you mean. The way you attempt to address things would drive me insane.

Mylovelygreendress · 01/03/2024 09:42

If my DH tried to tell me when to go to bed/ put light off etc I would not be happy .
Scenario 3 is a bit weird !

Shamalar · 01/03/2024 09:40

What happened immediately after each of those scenarios OP? Because that’s quite important.

TiIIyM · 01/03/2024 09:36

I'm with your DH sorry.

JonVoightBaddyWhoGrowls · 01/03/2024 09:36

You do sound a bit needy and passive aggressive, which absolutely could come across as controlling. But he could also be, as others have said, a knob.

Scenario 1: Totally ridiculous. I mean, sure, if you want him to come to bed for a specific reason, you could ask him. But why must he stop doing something he's enjoying just to cuddle with you? And why do you get to dictate his bedtime? That one IS controlling and frankly, unpleasant.

Scenario 2: if you want him to turn th slight off because it's bothering you, say that. Suggest that he either turns it off, or goes into another room. If he refuses, he's a knob. But th passive aggressive attempt to get him to turn it off without asking him is very childish.

Scenario 3: You do sound like you're keeping tabs on him. He doesn't like it. Stop doing it.

Scenario 4: Asking to watch something together is totally fine. If he says no, he's a bit of a twat unless you have very different watching preferences.

KreedKafer · 01/03/2024 09:33

If my partner did the things you’ve described, he would drive me insane. It’s clingy and suffocating.

I also think it absolutely is controlling. You want him to come to bed when you’re ready and when you want to cuddle. You want him to turn the light out at 10.15 because you are tired and ready to sleep. You want to know what he had for lunch because you think that’s bonding for some reason. You watch what he’s doing on his laptop and ask him to stop doing it because you want to watch something together.

Basically, you don’t want him to have any privacy or personal interests and everything he does a) has to involve you and b) has to be what you want. If I were in his position, I would have left.

The fact that you do this in a passive-aggressive way, and dress it up as just wanting to spend time with him, doesn’t make it any less controlling and clingy. Yeah, you’re not shouting and screaming at him. But it’s still control and it’s still emotionally abusive.

Janehasamane · 01/03/2024 09:31

BardRelic · 01/03/2024 09:29

@Janehasamane To clarify, I think he might be a knob. The 'possible' in that sentence referred to his possible knobbiness, as well as how he might behave. He's saying the OP is being controlling rather than recognising that a lot of her communication probably stems from an insecurity, and you don't help someone become more secure by saying they're controlling you. And it's fairly common for women not to express themselves directly more out of fear and worry about possible retribution than anything else. So he sounds as if he could be inconsiderate.

You can now accuse me of man-hating if you like but much as I like some men, there's an awful lot of toxic masculinity around, and the OP's description of her partner makes me a bit twitchy.

I just think it’s a huge leap. As you don’t know how long they have been together, how much he’s been subjected to this behaviour and what he’s tried before to get her to stop.

BardRelic · 01/03/2024 09:29

@Janehasamane To clarify, I think he might be a knob. The 'possible' in that sentence referred to his possible knobbiness, as well as how he might behave. He's saying the OP is being controlling rather than recognising that a lot of her communication probably stems from an insecurity, and you don't help someone become more secure by saying they're controlling you. And it's fairly common for women not to express themselves directly more out of fear and worry about possible retribution than anything else. So he sounds as if he could be inconsiderate.

You can now accuse me of man-hating if you like but much as I like some men, there's an awful lot of toxic masculinity around, and the OP's description of her partner makes me a bit twitchy.

WandaWonder · 01/03/2024 09:28

If this was reversed I would think my husband was acting controlling and needy if he acted like this

Mrsttcno1 · 01/03/2024 09:26

Yeah I have to say this is all sounding a bit clingy, controlling and would annoy me if it’s a common thing. It’s very “me, me, me”, going to bed when you want to, lights out when YOU want to, having to watch something “together” on laptop. And guessing what he eats? He obviously doesn’t enjoy these little guessing games and I’m not sure I would either its all very intrusive

Janehasamane · 01/03/2024 09:21

I agree with PP that it's possible that if you were to be assertive, he'd respond in the same way, because he's a knob

whys he a knob? Because he doesn’t wish to be told when to go to bed, or asked what he’s eaten?

Throwawayme · 01/03/2024 09:20

This would all annoy me and be far too clingy for me. My partner bugging me to go to bed when I was making music and wasn't ready would get on my nerves then being asked indirectly to turn out the light before I wanted to. I'd just get back up. Go to bed without him if you're so tired you're delirious at 10.15. If you want to some time with him, just tell him that.

Janehasamane · 01/03/2024 09:20

I’m not sure it’s controlling, although I can see why he feels that way.

you sound needy and clingy. You put your needs above his. Want him to fullfill your needs with no thoughts to himself. And guessing what he’s eaten is weird. And it’s not light hearted if he doesn’t like it.

so I can see why he thinks what he does.

BardRelic · 01/03/2024 09:14

Your communication comes across as passive aggressive OP but I'm curious about why you behave in that way. I agree with PP that it's possible that if you were to be assertive, he'd respond in the same way, because he's a knob. So have you resorted to PA communication because you've found that direct expression gets knocked back?

I struggled with this when I got together with my DP. Like many women, I'd basically been brought up to be passive aggressive, because I'd been told not to express myself. However, I needed to find a way to say what I wanted, so I resorted to that kind of sideways communication. But my DP's response rather than accuse me of being controlling, was just to ask 'what do you want?' And then I'd say what I wanted and we'd go from there.

So I think yes, your communication needs work but I'm quite suspicious of your partner. It's a leap to accuse someone of being controlling and I wonder if he's actually using it as a way to control you.

Shoxfordian · 01/03/2024 09:11

Yeah you'd annoy me with all that as well tbh

5128gap · 01/03/2024 09:10

You're not compatible. He needs a lot more personal space. You need more affection and companionship. Added to this, he is attracted to the idea of himself as a victim and is using hyperbolic abuse related terms to shame you into behaving in ways that don't irritate him. You are frightened to upset him so are using irritating (passive/hinting/joking) behaviour to try to get what you want, rather than being assertive which compounds the problem. This isn't the right relationship for you.

Picklestop · 01/03/2024 09:09

You seem very clingy and your food guessing game clearly isn’t fun for him and so far I don’t think anyone on the thread has said that seems like a fun thing to do either. It’s weird. Adults should be able to go to bed when they like. If he isn’t ready for bed at 10pm then he should come to bed later, not come up and then still get moaned at because he is on his laptop, taking a laptop to bed isn’t great anyway.

I don’t really like that he calls you controlling or insecure, instead of just telling you to stop it, but overall it does seem to be you causing the issues.

HettieHampshire · 01/03/2024 09:09

I'm afraid you would drive me mad OP! I'd be running a mile.

SleepingStandingUp · 01/03/2024 09:08

I think you're just being quite vague and passive and he's being over sensitive but alot depends on tone.

S1: much depends on the time and what he's said. I don't think there's an issue saying I'm off to bed are you coming, once, if it's a reasonable time. Similarly reasonable to say I'll see you up there, I'm finishing this. But is your tone wheedling? Has he already said he'll be x time and you're asking earlier?

S2: this would annoy me on both counts. If he wants to work on his laptop he turns the big light off or goes downstairs. But "I'm ready for you to turn the light off when you're ready" is pretty passive aggressive, especially if you keep repeating it. Clearly you're not saying what you mean. Just ask him to turn it off as you're exhausted.

And if you're so exhausted at 10.15 that you're delirious you need to go to bed at 9 without him and get some sleep

S3: you say you play these guessing games but he doesn't like it being about his food, so just don't do it. Is it based on smells or the washing up? Mess left? A random guess? If it's about messy and it bothers you, tell him that.

Catza · 01/03/2024 09:08

I cannot see a scenario where "guessing game" can be perceived as anything other than a passive-aggressive comment on the mess he made while you were at work.
What kind of a phrasing is "I am ready for you to turn the light off when you are ready"?
And if you know he is making music for 40 minutes before bed time, why bother him after 30 minutes? Surely, you know he will be coming to bed in 10 minutes-time.

TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 01/03/2024 09:08

That would really annoy me, I'm an adult, I have my own bedtime. If someone says to me " when you're ready " I will do it when I'M ready