Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I controlling and Insecure?

92 replies

Biscuits21 · 01/03/2024 08:39

My partner thinks my behaviour is controlling and coercive. He thinks I’m insecure. We have vastly different perspectives. I’d like an outsider's opinion.

Scenario 1:
My partner is making music for around 40 mins before bed. After about half an hour, I ask him if he's coming to bed.
My perspective - I want him to come and cuddle and spend time with me in bed.
His perspective - I'm bothered by what he is doing and want him to stop so that I can have attention. He is doing something he enjoys and I am encroaching on him.

Scenario 2:
We get in bed, it’s around 10:15pm, I’m very tired. My partner is on his laptop with the light on. I say ‘I’m ready for you to turn the light off when you’re ready.’ I repeat myself 5 mins later (I sometimes do this when I’m tired and delirious).
My perspective - I’m very tired and want to sleep. I’ve asked him in the nicest way possible to turn the light off.
His perspective - It’s okay for the light to be on for a few more minutes, I’m controlling what time he needs to turn the light off. I’m encroaching on his freedom of having the light on.

Scenario 3:
I get home from work, walk to the kitchen. I playfully say ‘ooo I can see you’ve had toast today, something with chopsticks… dumplings?’ We often play lighthearted ‘guessing games’ with each other.
My perspective - I’m trying to have a laugh and bond.
His perspective - I’m keeping tabs on what he’s eaten for lunch like I’m trying to watch his every move.

Scenario 4:
We get in bed, he’s on his laptop, I lay next to him and watch whatever he’s doing. I often say ‘can we both watch something?’
My perspective - I want to spend time with him in bed.
His perspective - I’m trying to stop what he’s doing for attention.

I have explained to him that in these scenarios, I’m simply trying to spend time with him. I feel rejected a lot of the time to his screen usage.

My partner says I’m insecure and all of these comments and my behaviour is coming from a huge insecure place. He says I need therapy to as all of our issues are my insecurities. I do believe I am insecure in ways but not necessarily these scenarios.

I have taken on board what he’s said and willing so seek therapy to delve into why I may act this way and where it comes from.

Has anyone had experiences with being an insecure person in a relationship and how they helped themselves? Or is he being unreasonable?

OP posts:
BirdsofPrey1 · 01/03/2024 11:28

You sound needy to me, sorry.

Turkeyhen · 01/03/2024 11:26

He says I need therapy to as all of our issues are my insecurities.

This is a worry for me. It seems arrogant of him to state that ALL of your relationship issues are down to your insecurities and YOU need therapy.

Maybe he didn't say it as baldly as that, but if he did I would be offended by his refusal to take any responsibility for his part in whatever relationship issues you're having. Surely it can't be so clear cut?

A pp said you sound incompatible, and, from what you've said, you do. But presumably things haven't always been this way, or you wouldn't still be together? What has changed?

I must admit I would find the specific behaviours you describe suffocating and clingy if they were a regular occurrence. Is it the case that he used to be more attentive, but as the relationship has gone on he is less so and this is triggering the feelings of insecurity? In his shoes I would be looking at my own behaviours to try to understand where you're coming from, not baldly stating that your insecurities are the ONLY problem and YOU need therapy to sort it out. Some sort of compromise should be possible and a willingness to work together to address the issues in a way that meets both of your needs.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 01/03/2024 11:22

AnnaMagnani · 01/03/2024 11:15

With your update, he is a dick.

You have adopted a wheedly communication style because if you are direct, at best he ignores you and at worst is rude.

He is not a keeper.

Or maybe he ignores her because of her communication style?

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 01/03/2024 11:17

JonVoightBaddyWhoGrowls · 01/03/2024 10:31

Welcome to MN where any of OP's behaviours from a man would be declared as abusive and controlling but because her DP has said she is controlling he is a knob and misappropriating language to look like a victim?!

Are we reading the same thread? Most of the comments I've seen have suggested she is, at the bare minimum, poor at communication, passive aggressive, needy, insecure and at worst, possibly controlling.

Literally the post above mine is someone calling him a knob and saying he's playing the victim...

Thankfully, yes, most are calling the OP out but there are a fair few in the "knob and playing the victim" category

AnnaMagnani · 01/03/2024 11:15

With your update, he is a dick.

You have adopted a wheedly communication style because if you are direct, at best he ignores you and at worst is rude.

He is not a keeper.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 01/03/2024 11:09

Ultimately, he seems to have a problem with you wanting his attention. If he was interested in you, it would be freely given.

Not everyone wants or needs constant attention- it doesn't mean they're not interested in their partners.

If DH expected me to come to bed with him at half ten or watched over my shoulder while I used my computer I would wonder why he was behaving like a toddler.

gannett · 01/03/2024 11:08

I think I do require reassurance and compassion and when he's constantly on a screen, I feel rejected. If I ask him 'please can we have less screen time and more quality time throughout the week?' I'm worried he would say I'm telling him what to do. He's a typical guy who doesn't like being told what to do.

This is perfectly valid and I think in these days of everything being online, it can feel isolating if your partner is always staring at a screen. It's so easy to do though - I finish my work on my laptop, then I watch a show on my laptop, then I think I'll turn it off and hang out with DP, but there are bills that need to be paid on my laptop and I need to book a table at a restaurant on my laptop and then a friend has messaged me on my laptop... I've done it to DP, DP has done it to me, I'm probably worse for it and it's something I've had to consciously address.

The time to address it is not in the moment. Not when someone's in the middle of something. It's better to bring it up in a calmer or chill moment so that neither of you feels pressure to react right then and there. And the solution is to plan ahead. If you want to watch a show together, suggest it ahead of time. "Do you want to watch Yellowjackets? Shall we start it tomorrow night?" Ditto for things to do out of the house together. You don't need to diarise couple time completely rigidly but a rough idea of when you'll be hanging out and also when you'll be doing your own thing is helpful.

It could be that he still pushes back and doesn't seem enthusiastic about the idea of planning to spend time with you in which case I would be rethinking whether the relationship makes me happy at all.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 01/03/2024 11:04

No, it's because his response to that is to pretend he is a victim. Nothing whatsoever wrong in telling the OP straight that he wants to go to bed when he wants. Everything wrong with the misappropriation of serious terminology to portray a woman who wants a different level of engagement in the relationship than he does as an abuser.

It a man was behaving the way OP is then he would be labelled controlling at best and abusive at worst.

His responses are not the problem here.

handskneesandbumpsadaisy · 01/03/2024 11:03

This sounds like a person with anxious attachment issues meets someone with avoidant attachment issues tbh. Not insurmountable but ones that could do with a bit of thinking about.

nononocontact · 01/03/2024 11:01

It seems to me that:

Your perspective: you want to spend time with him, you are taking an interest

His perspective: he is not interested in you, he would prefer to spend time by himself doing his own thing

Ultimately, he seems to have a problem with you wanting his attention. If he was interested in you, it would be freely given.

You may well be feeling insecure, but if so, maybe it’s because you can feel him detaching?

I wouldn’t be sticking around…

yellowsmileyface · 01/03/2024 10:59

5128gap · 01/03/2024 09:10

You're not compatible. He needs a lot more personal space. You need more affection and companionship. Added to this, he is attracted to the idea of himself as a victim and is using hyperbolic abuse related terms to shame you into behaving in ways that don't irritate him. You are frightened to upset him so are using irritating (passive/hinting/joking) behaviour to try to get what you want, rather than being assertive which compounds the problem. This isn't the right relationship for you.

I agree with this.

Also, you say "I’ve asked him in the nicest way possible to turn the light off." Why do you need to ask someone in the "nicest way possible" to turn the light off at bedtime so you can sleep, as though you're breaking the news to someone that their new haircut really doesn't suit them?

Sounds like you really need to work on your communication style and try to be more direct with people, and perhaps explore why you feel a need to tip-toe around people when attempting to express your wants or needs.

2chocolateoranges · 01/03/2024 10:58

You do sound as though you like everything your way eg bedtime

however I think you both need to work on communicating better with each other.

5128gap · 01/03/2024 10:57

Requesting your partner spend time with you in the evening, asking what they have eaten and asking them not to keep you awake with the light from their lap top is not controlling, regardless of the sex of the person making the request.
It is behaviour that stems from a mismatch as to the level of companionship/engagement there should be in the relationship, no more, no less. For there to be control requires one party to be exercising power over another to force them to comply, and there is no indication the OP is in a power position in her relationship. Quite the reverse as it appears that her partner continues to do as he pleases despite her requests, which isn't unreasonable either. This is a couple who are not suited and should separate. There's no need to label one a victim and the other an abuser when 'incompatible' suffices.

Biscuits21 · 01/03/2024 10:56

Thanks for all of the responses.

I know I'm insecure and I do want to work on it, my partner says he wants the best for me and wants me to delve deeper.

For those asking what happened after each scenario.

Scenario 1: he ignored me but came to bed a little while later. He could have said 'I'm staying up playing music, good night', and I would have accepted.

Scenario 2: he ignored me the first time I asked him to turn the light off. The second time he got annoyed and called me a dickhead.

Scenario 3; I see why you all think the food thing is weird and I can see now why my partner might find it weird. I wasn't bothered about the dishes being messy. We had fun at similar times before such as choosing what to eat, but I now understand that this probably wasn't the best time to have that joke.

Scenario 4: he told me he was busy on his laptop. However our routine used to be watching something in bed together each night. This hasn't happened for a while and I miss it.

From this post I think I've realised that all of these scenarios together do come across like I'm encroaching on his space and time.

As some people have mentioned though, I do struggle to communicate because I have been knocked back before. If I directly said 'please can you turn off the light' he would get annoyed and think I'm telling him what to do. That's why I feel I have to phrase it in a kinder way (I thought I was being kind, not passive aggressive, but I can see how it seems like PA). I also think he should be respectful and turn the light off when I'm super tired.

I think I do require reassurance and compassion and when he's constantly on a screen, I feel rejected. If I ask him 'please can we have less screen time and more quality time throughout the week?' I'm worried he would say I'm telling him what to do. He's a typical guy who doesn't like being told what to do.

I know I need to work on my communication and I think becoming more secure would probably lead to more confident communication and me needing him less.

I'm willing to do the work on myself. I think we both need to work on communication.

Any tips or book recommendations on how to communicate better or how to become more secure would be appreciated.

OP posts:
RB68 · 01/03/2024 10:55

yeah food guessing game is hints of - you are messy why haven't you cleaned up.

The whole music/light/laptop thing I get - he is pushing you out to do his own thing but in doing so is actually also controlling what you do. He is putting strain on the relationship by doing it, you are by not being direct. I think you BOTH need therapy to understand where each of you is coming from and actually communicate positively about it

gannett · 01/03/2024 10:52

S1 and S4: you're interrupting something he's doing. S4 isn't particularly important but no one likes having a show they're watching be interrupted by someone who wants to watch something else right then and there. I would say no, or at least "wait until this episode is over". S1 - if someone's in the middle of their creative process definitely don't interrupt them. I have a creative hobby and have friends who make music, art etc and in all cases getting into the flow of it without interruption is crucial. 40 minutes is not that long to have been doing it.

In both those cases you were definitely thoughtless and probably a bit needy.

S2 you weren't unreasonable to want the light off, and it's ridiculous to call you controlling over it. But why couldn't you have just asked outright? It's a perfectly normal request, you don't have to hint. (Tip: separate bedrooms for people with different body clocks will do wonders for your relationship.)

S3 I don't see the problem with what you said at all.

As annoying as I'd have found S1 and S4, I also take issue with him labelling your behaviour "controlling" and "coercive". Those are words associated with abusive behaviour, not needy and slightly annoying behaviour. So he's not exactly doing a great job of communicating with you either. I might give him the benefit of the doubt as that sort of therapy-speak is so widely misused these days but there might be a touch of gaslighting going on.

Rinoachicken · 01/03/2024 10:50

I’m wondering if he’s using the laptop in bed because the OP insists on him being with her when SHE goes to bed and so he’s compromising since he’s not ready for sleep yet but if he stays downstairs or in another room he knows the OP will be constant with the ‘I’m ready for you to come to bed now, i miiiissss youuuu’ BS

Sounds to me like he has very little autonomy over how he spends his own time - it’s apparently ‘not acceptable’ for him to be downstairs for 40mins if the OP is upstairs, but not ok for him to be upstairs with her either unless he sleeps when she wants him to or does what she wants!

BoohooWoohoo · 01/03/2024 10:49

I think that you need to be more direct.

Scenario 1- I can see why he’d be annoyed at this. I’d imagine that making music isn’t really something that you can suddenly stop- once you’re on a roll, you want to continue and he’d only been playing for 40 mins.

Food Scenario- is this really playful banter or a comment about his good choices or leaving the plates out? If the sexes were reversed then I wouldn’t be surprised if the woman felt that the man was making a statement about her food choices and made her feel crap.

Light scenario - this is probably a common one all across the world. Annoying for both people.

Watching something together - Ask when he opens the laptop or earlier in the evening, not when he’s in the middle of doing something on the laptop. Asking midway will make him feel annoyed because he’s doing something of interest and being asked to stop is going to dampen his enjoyment if he continues.

I think it’s sad that you’ve come to the conclusion that you must be in the wrong. It’s very possible that you crave his attention because he’s not putting in the effort now that you’re married. He wouldn’t be the first spouse to take their partner for granted and not make an effort (if that’s the case here) There’s not enough to go on for us to know if you have a point and you’re not spending enough time together. Hobbies like making music are important but growing apart from your spouse can happen slowly and become unfixable after some time.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 01/03/2024 10:40

If he is too engrossed in his laptop/phone and you need to go to bed just tell him he needs to go in another room. If one of you wants to sleep then the bedroom is needed, the person that wants to be on electronics should naturally move to another room, the way you are saying it is too nice and he is still calling you controlling. I just say "I am tired and your light is keeping me awake, please go in another room if you want to stay on your phone"- there you are not controlling what he does, but setting your boundary that you need a dark bedroom to sleep on!. The scenario about lunch is just weird, if you can't just ask what you had for lunch and get a straight answer then I just don't know how will he react to more loaded topics and conversations...weird all round!

TinyGingerCat · 01/03/2024 10:35

You sound very needy - scenario 3 in particular gave me the ick. You are very passive aggressive and for a lot of people this is a huge turn off. Learn to say what you want and don't dress it up as "we like to play guessing games" because clearly your partner doesn't.

JonVoightBaddyWhoGrowls · 01/03/2024 10:31

Welcome to MN where any of OP's behaviours from a man would be declared as abusive and controlling but because her DP has said she is controlling he is a knob and misappropriating language to look like a victim?!

Are we reading the same thread? Most of the comments I've seen have suggested she is, at the bare minimum, poor at communication, passive aggressive, needy, insecure and at worst, possibly controlling.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 01/03/2024 10:29

Wow

Welcome to MN where any of OP's behaviours from a man would be declared as abusive and controlling but because her DP has said she is controlling he is a knob and misappropriating language to look like a victim?!

OP - you have communication issues.

S1 - do you know he's planning to make music for 40 minutes? Or is it that's he goes off to make music and you decide after half an hour that's enough, go bother him and after another 10 minutes he decides to give up because your intrusion has ruined the mood?

S2 - Use your words properly. "I'm tired so can you turn the light off? If you want to continue can you go downstairs?" Or "can we decide on only phones in the bedroom and not use them there once the other is asleep?" Your wording is when he is ready and then to get annoyed because he ISN'T ready when YOU want

S3 - do you do this every day? It'd be maddening to me! It doesn't sound like a fun guessing game (and that sounds like you trying to minimise what it is anyway) but you checking up on him/going through his washing

S4 - if he's busy on his laptop, asking to be part of that can come across as "pay attention to meeeeee"

5128gap · 01/03/2024 10:15

Janehasamane · 01/03/2024 09:21

I agree with PP that it's possible that if you were to be assertive, he'd respond in the same way, because he's a knob

whys he a knob? Because he doesn’t wish to be told when to go to bed, or asked what he’s eaten?

No, its because his response to that is to pretend he is a victim. Nothing whatsoever wrong in telling the OP straight that he wants to go to bed when he wants. Everything wrong with the misappropriation of serious terminology to portray a woman who wants a different level of engagement in the relationship than he does as an abuser. If he thinks the OP is too demanding, well she's not locked him in the cellar, he's free to leave her.

foodglorious · 01/03/2024 10:15

Op you sound super needy, like thats hard work.

Also it sounds quite unnatural and try hard.

bradpittsbathwater · 01/03/2024 10:05

You are coming off as passive aggressive and clingy, and not communicating well. It is likely frustrating for him. I would refer yourself for some counselling.