Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That 50% of MPs should be women

147 replies

Frumpitydoo · 01/03/2024 07:49

Why aren't they? Why isn't this mandated? I know fewer females go into politics, but having had this brought to my attention through Mumsnet, boy has it riled me.

We just get shat on and shafted from the get go and stand no chance, do we?

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 01/03/2024 11:28

@ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees nobody is suggesting giving jobs to people that are unqualified for them. That is a common misunderstanding of the concept of "levelling the playing field" or "positive action". it's about eliminating disadvantage not giving an unfair advantage.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 01/03/2024 11:28

lizzowhiz · 01/03/2024 11:17

@ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees I haven't experienced a workplace where there are female quotas in recruitment - but I do have a lot of experience in interviewing and management.

It's depressingly common for women to not choose to seek promotion, or to see their career as in second place to their partner's. Until women want to take on more senior roles, more powerful positions, it's difficult to see how things will change. If you don't want to be on equal terms with regard to work and earning in your own family life, you're unlikely to be pushing for it on a wider basis

I agree with you.

If women don't want to,then they shouldn't have too.

I spend my time working with the women who do or who aren't sure. I won't force those who don't want to be involved to get involved.

My last 2 hires were male. They had to be on the interview and experience. A female colleague had a go at me for not appointing a women when she absolutely refused to apply for the role. She would have stood a fair chance at interview and possibly would have been appointed but she absolutely does not want any management responsibilities. Other than that outburst, she's brilliant. I've told her so and encouraged her to apply but it doesn't fit either what she wants and I have to respect that.

lizzowhiz · 01/03/2024 11:17

@ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees I haven't experienced a workplace where there are female quotas in recruitment - but I do have a lot of experience in interviewing and management.

It's depressingly common for women to not choose to seek promotion, or to see their career as in second place to their partner's. Until women want to take on more senior roles, more powerful positions, it's difficult to see how things will change. If you don't want to be on equal terms with regard to work and earning in your own family life, you're unlikely to be pushing for it on a wider basis

Growlybear83 · 01/03/2024 11:15

Yes I definitely agree with compulsory voting, provided there is an option to vote for 'none of the above' or something similar. The turnout in the UK is usually extremely low, and yet people who can't be bothered to vote still seem to think they have a right to express their views on the government/ council that has been elected.

FranticHare · 01/03/2024 11:09

I reluctantly agree women only shortlists aren’t the way forwards.

What I do believe would change things is mandatory voting.

I think Australia has this? And other countries. Everyone HAS to vote. Our turnouts here are so low, that our MPs cannot be said to be properly representative when only a small percentage have actually bothered to turn out and vote.

I reckon it would change things - whether for the better or not I have no idea!

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 01/03/2024 11:02

Why just 50%.

We've normalised the male majority for so long we dont even think to demand that equality would be the next 200 years of female majority parliaments.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 01/03/2024 10:36

CurlewKate · 01/03/2024 10:02

@ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees Ah yes. Good old anecdotage. Pesky women/just not up to it, are they? Glad things have gone back to normal.

It's what happened. I have no reason to lie.

For the roles in question, it's typical than anyone man or women would have 5 years experience at say level 2 before moving to level 3.

Some of them had no level 2 experience or only 1/2 years. They all voiced their opinions at the time about it being too early, many people did.

They would have been ideal future candidates but it was fast tracked without any support. It had a determental impact in that a lot of them actually left and it eroded confidence.

Everyone admits it was wrong and unfair to all.

I am an advocate for women and a lot of women have got promoted since which is really positive but putting people into roles they don't want or haven't the experience for, just to look balanced will never be a good idea.

You used the term pesky women not me. I don't refer to anyone as pesky.

Growlybear83 · 01/03/2024 10:35

But how can you ensure that there are women on every shortlist? That's not realistic.

CurlewKate · 01/03/2024 10:33

@lizzowhiz Of course you can't force women. But ensuring that there are women on all short lists would at least normalise their presence.

taxguru · 01/03/2024 10:30

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/03/2024 10:20

Frumpitydoo · Today 08:02

Because they don't represent the people they supposedly represent, nor do they represent women's best interests.
**
See also The Met. and the Police in general”

Cressida Dick didn’t seem much of an improvement.

Likewise with London's first female chief fire officer who had to resign after her poor performance at the Grenfell Fire Inquiry.

The thing with quotas/targets, etc., is that you can end up with the "best woman" for a top job rather than the "best person", which sometimes mean the top job is held by someone who isn't competent enough and only got there due to gender.

What we need is a level playing field where women can compete on a level playing field so that we don't have a man taking a job just because he's a man, rather than an equally competent/able female.

Positive discrimination is just as bad, if not worse, than negative discrimination.

coureur · 01/03/2024 10:25

It's currently 35%, up from 17% in 2001 and still rising. I'm sure it will get there soon. I'm far more concerned about the number of MPs, both men and women, who come from a very narrow demographic of privately educated, law/journalism/City/policy wonk backgrounds.

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/03/2024 10:20

Frumpitydoo · Today 08:02

Because they don't represent the people they supposedly represent, nor do they represent women's best interests.
**
See also The Met. and the Police in general”

Cressida Dick didn’t seem much of an improvement.

lizzowhiz · 01/03/2024 10:19

@CurlewKate personally I'd love to see better representation not just in govt but in senior roles in the workforce. But you can't force women. It's depressingly common on Mumsnet to see posts from women who are happy to let their husbands have the high flying career and higher earnings. In my experience in the workplace far more women than men want to work fewer hours, accepting lower wages and lower pension.
It starts within the home, in the family. If a woman doesn't want equality with her partner it's very difficult to see how it can be achieved on a wider scale

midgetastic · 01/03/2024 10:18

We would expect that in a society that wasn't sexist there would be an equal number of male and female candidates and that there would be an equal number of males and females who were sucessful

That there isn't is the proof that we still live in a society that has sexism throughout its structure

Yes you can't vote for what isn't there

ACynicalDad · 01/03/2024 10:18

I basically believe that every constituency should be a battle between the best people for the job and what comes out comes out. But it's bad if parties aren't trying for good representation of their candidates and if they put all the women and minority candidates in unwinnable seats.

I sometimes wonder if we'd have a better country if it was a majority of women, but there's no accounting for awful women like Preeti Patel, Zarah Sultana and the extremes on both sides.

Growlybear83 · 01/03/2024 10:14

Why on earth should there be an equal number of men and women elected as MPs? You can only vote for the candidates who are put forward for election, and presumably people vote for whoever represents their views and who they think would would make the best MP. I couldn't care less whether the person who is elected as my MP is make or female. My MP at the moment is a woman but it's her political views thst make her better than her predecessor, not the fact that she's a woman. If her political party had selected her from a women-only shortlist, I would not have voted for her in protest.

WhistPie · 01/03/2024 10:07

Tattletwat · 01/03/2024 08:47

Labour has 52% of its MPs who are women so I would imagine they stopped them as got the aim of half.

And they elected some mighty fine women constituency MPs in that time. But since the all women shortlists have been abandoned, they've gone back to generally having men as the candidate. Let's see what the split is after the next election.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 01/03/2024 10:06

CranfordScones · 01/03/2024 09:44

In the September 2022 Conservative leadership election there were 8 confirmed candidates. Half of those were women. And two of those were non-white. These are the people at the top of the party, not the low-downs, remember.

And the Conservatives achieved that without using rigged shortlists, quotas or positive discrimination. In fact 4 of the final 8 where non-white, and people still like to maintain that the Conservatives have a race problem. This is the party that's given us three female prime ministers and numerous non-white cabinet ministers including the current prime minister.

The evidence suggests that encouraging more people to put themselves forward and then promoting on merit is an effective strategy. So let's do more of that, and stop with the other nonsense.

But if you want 50% of MPs to be women, then you need to define woman. Try getting the parties to agree on that...

The Tories are indeed a party of equal opportunity. They've promoted just as many incompetent ideologues and self-promoters who are female as male.

itsnotabouthepasta · 01/03/2024 10:03

I agree @ErrolTheDragon

CurlewKate · 01/03/2024 10:02

@ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees Ah yes. Good old anecdotage. Pesky women/just not up to it, are they? Glad things have gone back to normal.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/03/2024 09:57

LakeTiticaca · 01/03/2024 09:51

Maybe they don't want to be an MP. Why would they want to now we are at a stage where we have violent mobs targeting their private homes?
Would any of you want to put your families and children at risk?

Quite so.

My guess is that people who put themselves forward - of both sexes but moreso for women - tend to be quite atypical in many ways.

niadainud · 01/03/2024 09:56

AgnesX · 01/03/2024 07:52

Why should they be? MPs should always be voted for. Irregardless of sex.

Is that you, George?

ErrolTheDragon · 01/03/2024 09:54

itsnotabouthepasta · 01/03/2024 09:46

I think the issue goes far beyond just a gender split.

In an absolutely ideal scenario, I would love to see parliament split between men/women/race/age but also more people entering politics from a state school environment.

I also think it should be mandated that if you are rising through the ranks to senior cabinet position, you should have a background in the area you represent. E.G. Education secretary should be a qualified teacher, or health/social care secretary should be a social worker/doctor

These people do exist - Emma Lewell-Buck was a social worker. Dan Poulter is still a practicing doctor.

There's too many people who get promoted into areas where they are vastly underqualified and thats how we ended up in this shitting mess.

There's a distinct underrepresentation by people who are scientifically and technically literate, let alone anything like experts. Problem is, good scientists often love doing science and don't want to become politicians. Same in many walks of life.

That's where the anachronistic HoL serves some useful purpose. It'd help if they'd ditch the purely political /mates lordships and appoint more experts, more representatives of various disabled groups etc etc.

LakeTiticaca · 01/03/2024 09:51

Maybe they don't want to be an MP. Why would they want to now we are at a stage where we have violent mobs targeting their private homes?
Would any of you want to put your families and children at risk?

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 01/03/2024 09:51

CurlewKate · 01/03/2024 09:10

@ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees "
I think the concept hinders women, suggests that they wouldn't get the role otherwise, and results in incapable women getting roles ahead of men who are better suited to the role."

Are there any examples you know of where this has happened?

My workplace about 7-8 years ago.
They decided we weren't balanced and promoted a lot of women in one go to correct it.

Only 1 was a correct appointment and remains in the position. 4 of them didn't even want the jobs but found it hard to turn down the money.

75% of staff are male so it's going to be that way at the top too. There was never an issue with the women who wanted to progress to higher levels getting there.

It proved to be a disaster and has been rectified since. All promotions are now on merit.

Often this need for gender balance seems to be pushed above what women actually want. If women decide that they don't want certain roles then that's up to them and they shouldn't be criticised for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread