Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do family courts think about weekends?

36 replies

March34 · 01/03/2024 07:38

Sorry to post in here just not getting much help elsewhere. Due to go to family court soon. DD has not yet started school but will In Sept. How the other parent wants the contact to be will mean I don't have any weekend day with DD as I work one day and the other would be with the other parent. Would court take this into account and agree to EOW due to this? The other parent has no reason to not do the day I work they just don't want to.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Chocolateorange11 · 21/03/2024 09:19

In my experience of family court, they focus on the best interest of the child but there is also a lot around fairness and being reasonable. It is likely that you will both have to compromise.

Prior to court, you will submit a position statement where you can set out a schedule that meets the best needs of your child. Your ex will do the same. You may be able to reach a compromise/ agreement yourselves.

TheFireflies · 21/03/2024 09:06

Unlikely this will need a Section 7 report, those are only ordered where there’s significant welfare issues. Unless you’re in an area covered by the new pilot way if working, there’ll be an initial letter to the court giving advice.

It is obviously in your daughter’s best interests to have quality weekend time with you both, so I’d be astounded if your ex gets his way. Just couch everything you say to the court in terms of what’s in your child’s best interests. He will really struggle to do that.

(Assuming you can’t resolve it in mediation)

March34 · 21/03/2024 08:59

@TheFormidableMrsC Thank you, I had a feeling the court fees would now be gone. I have a feeling he'll say no to mediation just because he has to pay for it so we'll see!

OP posts:
TheFormidableMrsC · 21/03/2024 08:37

March34 · 21/03/2024 08:21

Just an update on this. So after advice, applied to court as urgent. They've come back and said they don't see it as urgent so need to do mediation first. If everything is agreed in mediation (doubt it will be but who knows) then does anyone know if I'll get the £250 back I've paid for court?

This is not a case for an urgent application I'm afraid and you won't get refunded fees. If things are not settled and agreed in mediation or if one party refuses mediation, the court will bring Cafcass in who will likely do a Section 7 report and make recommendations to the court.

Your ex being so rigid without good reason is not likely to just get him what he wants. The more likely scenario is that it will be EOW and one midweek contact. This is fairly standard. However, there was a woman on here recently who ended up with her ex getting every weekend contact. That is unusual and I think the judge was an absolute arse. Make your statements child centred, that you want her to have leisure time with both parents and make clear that your working schedule is as such that he can have a day every weekend while you work. I was in and out of court for about five years so I'm speaking from my own experience. Good luck.

March34 · 21/03/2024 08:21

Just an update on this. So after advice, applied to court as urgent. They've come back and said they don't see it as urgent so need to do mediation first. If everything is agreed in mediation (doubt it will be but who knows) then does anyone know if I'll get the £250 back I've paid for court?

OP posts:
March34 · 01/03/2024 19:55

@UnderScoredBrain Yes my family are brilliant and really supportive. I also have a free hour with a solicitor next week.

OP posts:
UnderScoredBrain · 01/03/2024 19:42

Do you have some one supporting you with the court process?

March34 · 01/03/2024 19:16

@UnderScoredBrain Thank you I just feel like it, which is probably his aim. Yes childcare on the day I'm working would be my mum one week and then my dad and stepmum the other week. They already have her on a Friday afternoon and then taking up a day of their weekend off feels awful but unless I start passing her to friends I have no other option. The poor thing isn't going to know where she is she'll just be passed around it horrible. I'm guessing she'd just be with his mum and dad although it seems she spends the majority of the time she's with him at theirs anyway with him there. I also don't know if to say in court that as I'm the one working and he doesn't that surely that should be taken into account but I don't want to sound bitchy. I'll be honest I think he's just wore me down so much and knows how much it will be upsetting me losing more time with her that I'm just scared to say anything that might make me look bad. He's also so utterly convinced that he'll get what he wants that I'm starting to worry he will.

OP posts:
SD1978 · 01/03/2024 19:09

Is there a reason they can't have every weekend day you work, and EOW? Who is currently looking after the child on the days your work? EOW, the day at the weekend you work, and during the week, still doesn't give them very much time together. But yes, I do agree you should be allowed family,time as well, both parents always should

Dalefarmdolly · 01/03/2024 18:43

The court will also take in to account keeping up the relationship with the maternal family, Nan and grandad etc, I wouldn't worry to much about it if your very insistent and make sure your reasons are based solely on what's best for your DD then there shouldn't be an issue

Mumma2024 · 01/03/2024 17:58

Yes, courts are very aware of weekends and won't allow one person to get all the fun time and none of the hard graft time

UnderScoredBrain · 01/03/2024 17:55

Also I don’t think you are the shit parent in this!

UnderScoredBrain · 01/03/2024 17:54

OP

Your preference should be he has her on the weekend day you work - this means more parental time for her, for her well-being, as if he didn’t she would be in child care (whatever that may look like). Be firm that for your DDs wellbeing you are not in a position to lose that day at work because financially it pays for X,Y and Z (swimming, whatever).

Point out this is what DD is used to and has been working for however long it has been.

Then the next position you would take is EOW, but that you feel this isn’t suitable as your DD will still be in childcare for the weekend you have her on the day you work.

It’s hard no for DD to spend every weekend with a day lost of one on one parent time due to your ex partner suddenly deciding he can no longer do this. Where will she be when he is busy doing his things he normally does (the reasons it is how it is now?)

Sweetheart7 · 01/03/2024 17:23

If you live near each other I would push that he does the school run on a Monday morning and you collect DD from school. Agree with @RB68 my ex wrangles out of Fridays and school run drop off Monday morning so I can't work a full shift on Sunday so annoying! Doesn't go out he's just difficult.

March34 · 01/03/2024 16:11

@RB68 That's one of the reasons why he originally agreed to the Saturday as Sundays are the days he's busy, but now he wants the Sundays. I think I'll go in with EOW and a day in the week for the week he doesn't have her the weekend. I feel so sorry for her it's just changes all the time and it's so unfair. Changing to the Sundays means that every other week I need to find someone to look after her while I'm at work on Saturday. I just feel like she's going to end up being pushed from pillar to post. Honestly making me feel like such a shit mum.
@BoohooWoohoo No distance issues luckily. Yes my side of the family are only available really at a weekend as don't live that close but I know she already spends both the days that she goes to dad's at the moment with her grandparents and cousins.

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 01/03/2024 15:26

EOW will be easy to ask for as both parents should have relaxation time and it’s often the only item that extended family are available for visits. Maintaining relationships with extended family and chilling with each parent are excellent reasons to request EOW.

If parents don’t live near each other then having weekends at home so that the child can go to events like birthday parties will also be important. (I’m assuming that weekends might mean Friday after school to Sunday lunchtime /evening) if there’s distance involved.

RB68 · 01/03/2024 15:21

One option could be to reverse the weekend days each weekend or every two weeks so long as this isn't too confusing to DD

RB68 · 01/03/2024 15:19

In my head alot of men avoid a Saturday because they are either playing sport themselves, wanting Fri nights out and a lie in or are sports fans and want to watch or go to games etc.

Focus on what is best for your daughter and couch everything in those terms, look for equal leisure time with each parent and a way of sharing the load with costs such as after school care or before school care. Sounds like he is going to be a right PITA so make sure to get as much in writing as possible without tying things down too tightly and causing yourselves issues if things need a bit of flexibility

March34 · 01/03/2024 11:15

Thanks for all the helpful comments it is making me feel slightly better. I think my main worry is DD's well-being as doing this will mean she basically doesn't get a full day with me for 5 days due to work/visitation already in place. I think the worst thing is that at the moment DD does go to dads on the weekend day I work but he's refusing to do it going forward. She's already struggling with adjusting to the overnight never mind this changing again. I know that more than likely won't be taken into account though.

OP posts:
CrazyHedgehogLover · 01/03/2024 10:21

My ex tried doing this and he ended up with one night a week which was Wednesday to Thursday.. because he was so unreasonable and was refusing everything I was suggesting, I offered more time in school holidays, I offered all sorts! But because it was me offering it he didn’t like it! It’s a way of taking control for them rather then thinking of what benefits there child, it was CAFCASS who came up with the Wednesday to Thursday due to his lack of cooperation and clear mind games, obviously they said it could be reviewed once our son started full time school.

the courts/Cafcass will see straight through his games. I would write down everything you possibly can (notes) of what you are putting forward for your child, come up with alternatives like you have done.. offer maybe an extra night during half terms/school hols.

they will see who is trying to make a structured and stable plan for there child and who is just doing things out of spite and nastiness.

my ex was extremely manipulative, as soon as things in that room wasn’t going “his way” rather than trying to see what was best for our son, his whole attitude towards the CAFCASS person changed, he got annoyed basically and his true colours came out because he wasn’t in control anymore! She even said to him “do you have a problem with your temper”..

they will always focus on what’s best for the child! You sound as though you’ve been more than reasonable and couldn’t do anymore than you have! He wants to play horrible spiteful games. It’s very unlikely they’ll grant him that day as you have good reason for needing the other day instead.. x

Mrsdsfm · 01/03/2024 10:21

I’m a family lawyer… the court will make a decision that is in the best interests of the child but absolutely it is very common for parents to both get weekend time so that one parent is not just dealing with the day to day school/homework routine etc. Just explain your position clearly to the Judge and CAFCASS and focus on your DD’s wellbeing and wishes and feelings if she is old enough to express them.

Collaborate · 01/03/2024 10:10

The court will try and fit in with your work schedule to give your daughter equal time with you both. That would mean that she will be with the other parent on the weekend day that you work, not alternating weekends. Alternating weekends would leave her with no one to care for her when you are at work.

BrassOlive · 01/03/2024 08:35

Every other weekend is the norm for exactly this reason, your child deserves leisure time with both their parents.

Zanatdy · 01/03/2024 08:32

I’m sure they will take that into account and ask him why he can’t have the day you’re working. They won’t be impressed if they can tell he’s being awkward, so more fool him unless he’s got a good reason

March34 · 01/03/2024 08:27

Thank you all. Yes it is manipulation and the worst thing he says I'm the one that the courts will see as manipulating it by saying I don't want him to have her every weekend. I'm happy for every weekend if it's the day I'm at work.
Yes been through mediation and he won't budge even though the mediator basically said to him he has no reason to not do the weekend day I work.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread