Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have ever grieved for someone who’s passed away who you have never met?

208 replies

Acapulco12 · 29/02/2024 21:58

It seems strange, I know. I don’t think this has ever happened to me before, but at the moment, I think I’m feeling all the usual stages of ‘grief’ for someone whose death I read about in the news and who I’ve never met. It’s very strange and unexpected. I just wondered if anyone else has ever had anything like that.

OP posts:
Luddite26 · 01/03/2024 04:07

I have been upset and I would describe it as deep grief over the death of Freddie Mercury. Even now when I hear him sing I find it hard to believe because his voice sounds so alive. I have marked his anniversary and birthday and even though it's been 33 years I still can't not feel sad.
I have felt really sad about George Michael passing away too and The Queen passing really made me feel a deep loss and brought back memories of my grand parents . I think it was the end of an era feeling. And things haven't felt quite right since.
And when Nelson Mandela died I had to take the day off work. But again I think that was more to do with the end of an era feeling and the history of his life .
Dealing with the emotions of my biological father dieing has never come close to the loss of Freddie.
At the time I wasn't really upset about Princess Diana dieing but since Prince William had his kids I have felt really sad about the void she left in their lives and as the world carries on I have felt sad that she was no longer in it I think as I got to the age she was when she died and then the years I've had since and having time with the grandchildren it has made me feel sad for her but not a grief.

OverdramaticAndTrue · 01/03/2024 03:40

No. I think it’s just sadness. Like if you’ve been a fan of a singer, their music has been a soundtrack to important moments in your life so you feel a connection to them. It’s not the same as grief of someone you actually knew and had contact with though.

TooBigForMyBoots · 01/03/2024 03:15

George Michael.

I never met him but I loved him, grew up with him, appreciated his talent and grieved him.💞

FallingStar21 · 01/03/2024 01:22

Noicant · 29/02/2024 22:34

Extreme sadness, only for children who have died through neglect or abuse though I’ve never really felt much about adults, maybe a passing sadness for someone who’s died prematurely or in tragic circumstances but with children it lingers.

I agree @Noicant
Don't understand the upset and grief around celebrities who die like hundreds other people do every day. Feel sadness for adults who've died tragically, but the crimes against children is what I can never get over (and what has had a profound, lasting effect on my mental health). I rarely read the news anymore.

user1471462634 · 01/03/2024 01:20

This will sound absolutely strange but JFK. I've read a lot about him over the years. I've just finished watching a documentary about him too & his death just really got to me.

I'm actually reading another book about him now & know when I get to the end I'll be hit again.

It's very odd I know but there was just something about him that I feel drawn to.

EasyPeelings · 01/03/2024 01:10

Yes, I have. It was when I was in my early teens and the person who died was a famous person for whom I'd developed a very strong crush. I felt as though I knew him and I was utterly heartbroken and sort of fell apart when he died. I just couldn't process it in my mind. Nobody understood and I felt very alone. I had suicidal thoughts and felt as though I would never be happy again. It was about 2 years before the feelings of grief and loss subsided.

Thedogscollar · 01/03/2024 00:51

@Acapulco12
I've just read the impact statements from Sarah's family within the Angioloni Inquiry.
They are utterly heartbreaking and so powerful.
There is no recovery from such evil.

Orab · 01/03/2024 00:28

Sksjsndn27373 · 29/02/2024 23:57

DH and I both had our father's pass away before we met and got married.

DC do often wish they could have met their grandfathers. They love their grandmothers but do wish they had a grandad

This strikes a chord with me because I initially read the OP and thought no I have never experienced this but actually both my parents lost a parent in childhood and their respective absences did cast a shadow - obviously life was very different financially and practically eg for both mum and dad, and that (poverty) does have knock-on effects, plus I just wish I could have known them. I have photos but I'd love to know what their voices sounded like, just sit and have a cup of tea with them in the kitchen like I did with my other grandparents, and I feel sad that there was so much potential life they missed out on including how our family has unfolded.

But even that isn't grief really, it's more wistful regret.

And the kind of "that's a shame" sadness I feel about eg musicians whose work I enjoyed is another notch down from that, for me. That isn't grief at all. I've felt actual mind bending heart gnawing grief on losing people I love and that is nothing like the same.

I certainly wouldn't feel grief about Navalny! Who doesn't even seem like a nice bloke.

Acapulco12 · 01/03/2024 00:25

BarelyLiterate · 01/03/2024 00:16

No.

Of course it’s sad when people you admire die before their time, particularly if the circumstances are tragic. Deaths which particularly saddened me include Ayrton Senna, George Michael & Amy Whitehouse. But I didn’t know them, and their deaths were not about me.

Grief is for their loved ones, not for people who never met them. Fake, vicarious grief comes across as empty virtue signalling at best, or at worst cynical attention seeking by grief vultures, exploiting the tragedies suffered by others for sympathy & ‘likes’.

I completely agree with this. I think this is the key bit that resonates with me when I think about people’s deaths who have moved me the most but who I don’t know on a personal level - it’s sad when people you admire die before their time, particularly if the circumstances are tragic.

Without wishing to sound inappropriately grandiose or over dramatic, I’m curious about whether Navalny will become a Martin Luther King-like figure, or perhaps JFK, for our times. I wonder whether, in 15 or 20 years, we will see his death as comparable to other historical figures who were assassinated for their beliefs. I’m not sure if this will happen though, because I obviously Martin Luther King and JFK’s legacies were encouraged and celebrated, whereas whilst Navalny’s legacy might be encouraged outside Russia, we know that it will be suppressed inside Russia.

OP posts:
HollyKnight · 01/03/2024 00:19

I often feel a sense of grief over people (and animals) who die young or in horrible circumstances. It's why I usually avoid the news when I'm not in a good headspace.

Acapulco12 · 01/03/2024 00:19

carerneedshelp · 01/03/2024 00:11

I was devastated when Deborah James died. I didn't know her in person but had listened to her regular podcasts, read her book and newspaper column. Her story and strength and courage really helped me through my own 'journey' through cancer.
What I have been through is nothing in comparison to what she and her family went through.

I felt very sad when she died too. I read one of her books (How to live when you could be dead) shortly after she died and it’s excellent - I highly recommend it. It’s got very good practical advice in it for how to manage challenging times in your life. I thought she was incredibly brave and I loved her optimism and sense of humour.

OP posts:
BarelyLiterate · 01/03/2024 00:16

No.

Of course it’s sad when people you admire die before their time, particularly if the circumstances are tragic. Deaths which particularly saddened me include Ayrton Senna, George Michael & Amy Whitehouse. But I didn’t know them, and their deaths were not about me.

Grief is for their loved ones, not for people who never met them. Fake, vicarious grief comes across as empty virtue signalling at best, or at worst cynical attention seeking by grief vultures, exploiting the tragedies suffered by others for sympathy & ‘likes’.

carerneedshelp · 01/03/2024 00:11

I was devastated when Deborah James died. I didn't know her in person but had listened to her regular podcasts, read her book and newspaper column. Her story and strength and courage really helped me through my own 'journey' through cancer.
What I have been through is nothing in comparison to what she and her family went through.

changedagain67543 · 01/03/2024 00:08

Yes. I stupidly read about the James Bulger case when my eldest was little and had a week of crying every day, feeling genuine grief. I was in bits. Also when I read about baby p - I accidentally came across that and again got immersed in the details. I now avoid reading anything involving young children even though my DCs aren’t babies anymore.

Runningwildish · 01/03/2024 00:07

I was rather more upset about these deaths than I expected to be , The Queen and Alan Rickman.

Diamondcurtains · 01/03/2024 00:07

Not grieved as such but was very upset when the Queen and Prince Philip died also Caroline Flack.

Acapulco12 · 01/03/2024 00:05

murasaki · 29/02/2024 23:55

Sarah Everard wasn't grief as such, but horror in that I would have done the same thing if a policeman had showed his warrant card. There but for the grace of god etc. It could have been any of us who trusted authority, and should be, and are now, I hope, more sceptical.

Edited

Me too. I’m sure I would have complied in the same sort of situation as I wouldn’t have known any different. It’s a tragedy that it’s only after Sarah Everard’s completely preventable death that we’ve learned what rights we have when we’re stopped by a police officer.

OP posts:
Acapulco12 · 01/03/2024 00:04

Thedogscollar · 29/02/2024 23:52

Sarah Everard, her murder was so horrific and unsettling.
I can't quite comprehend that her last few hours on this earth were with pure evil and the torture he put her through.

What Sarah Everard went though was terrible and shocking. When I heard about what had happened to her, I remember feeling the same way you describe here and thinking that her final hours of life must have been spent in utter terror. It makes me so angry to think of what she suffered and what her family and friends are going through since her completely preventable and traumatic death.

Her family have also always come across as extremely dignified, which has impressed me, given the huge weight of the grief they have to live with.

On a side note, the Angiolini inquiry - which was set up to investigate how a police officer was able to murder Sarah Everard - was released today and it can be accessed here if you’d like to read it - https://iipcv-prod.s3.eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/E02740018_Angiolini-Inquiry.pdf.

https://iipcv-prod.s3.eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/E02740018_Angiolini-Inquiry.pdf

OP posts:
Sksjsndn27373 · 29/02/2024 23:57

DH and I both had our father's pass away before we met and got married.

DC do often wish they could have met their grandfathers. They love their grandmothers but do wish they had a grandad

murasaki · 29/02/2024 23:55

Sarah Everard wasn't grief as such, but horror in that I would have done the same thing if a policeman had showed his warrant card. There but for the grace of god etc. It could have been any of us who trusted authority, and should be, and are now, I hope, more sceptical.

Thedogscollar · 29/02/2024 23:52

Sarah Everard, her murder was so horrific and unsettling.
I can't quite comprehend that her last few hours on this earth were with pure evil and the torture he put her through.

OzziePopPop · 29/02/2024 23:50

Oh yes, Kurt Cobain, I was a teen and a huge fan.

murasaki · 29/02/2024 23:44

murasaki · 29/02/2024 23:37

It really does depend on many factors. I didn't really cry when my MiL died last year ( well that's not entirely true, I did on the phone to his sister when she phoned me as DP was at work and she wasn't sure whether to wait until he got home,) but that was shock, I think, as it came out of nowhere. And at the funeral I didn't as I was on it for him, his dad and sister.

But for my ex landlady, I'd lived in the flat above her for 4 years, she hosted my wedding, I'd known her kids since they were in primary, yes. She'd seemingly recovered from a brain injury and it came out of the blue. The family speeches at the wedding nearly set me off, but when they asked all of us to sing along to her favourite song, Alison Krauss's I'll fly away, that was it. Gone. She had so much va va voom, and I cried for that loss to the world.

Too late to edit, but speeches at the funeral, obviously. Clearly her loveliness re the wedding sticks in my mind.

Acapulco12 · 29/02/2024 23:44

Dontdoit1 · 29/02/2024 23:39

Hind Rajab’s death was devastating. It was so upsetting to read about it. I also felt very sad about the death of Alfie Steele in Droitwich.

OP posts:
SheerLucks · 29/02/2024 23:43

Yes. Princess Diana. I had a busy work/social life at the time and didn't really think about her that much, But when she died I reacted in a way I hadn't anticipated.

I think she'd been omnipresent at the time and I really felt her loss - to this day it makes me incredibly sad to think about it.

I watched the first two episodes of the last season of The Crown, which chronicles her death, with my two teens, and even they were crying. I think the show really conveyed how magical but tragic she truly was.