Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have ever grieved for someone who’s passed away who you have never met?

208 replies

Acapulco12 · 29/02/2024 21:58

It seems strange, I know. I don’t think this has ever happened to me before, but at the moment, I think I’m feeling all the usual stages of ‘grief’ for someone whose death I read about in the news and who I’ve never met. It’s very strange and unexpected. I just wondered if anyone else has ever had anything like that.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Orab · 08/03/2024 10:24

Thing is, "anti-Putin" covers a lot of ground.

Before Putin came to power the mafia were running things. It was quite usual for people to not be paid wages for years at a time under Yeltsin, who was a drunk and incompetent. So regular work and money stopped meaning anything. If you wanted regular income, it would come from under the radar activity. If you had a business then you had to pay bribes. As mafia built up their money they started to buy up all the legitimate institutions like banks and so on. They also fought a lot of turf wars, gunning rivals down as they walked from work to their car and such. It was very wild. Of course all the US businesses also operated within that and also made a lot of money.

Then the rouble crashed and only the dodgiest people had any money at all which was all hard (and dirty) currency. So they scooped up businesses and assets at rock bottom prices and these are the oligarchs.

Putin was selected as being the person who could control them and that is what he did and continues to do. They are rich and powerful so it's not possible to destroy them outright. And these people are naturally very "anti-Putin". But as I hope you can see they are not nice people. They are crooks and murderers. Their business interests extend way beyond Russia into the murkiest parts of international trade - private armies who control diamond and gold mining for example - and of course into more legitimate concerns like global housing and other asset markets. They are even richer since the US started the money printing craze in 2008.

Not that Putin is some caped crusader, anything but. For him this is a prolonged power struggle that you see playing out now still with these mysterious deaths and it is not about good and evil, same as it isn't for the people who go against him. However he's kept a lid on a lot of the violence that plagued Moscow in particular and at least people get paid actual wages now.

Acapulco12 · 08/03/2024 09:40

Orab · 07/03/2024 23:53

Just read up on Russia I guess. Russia hasn't really experienced democracy as such so the political terminology we use doesn't mean the same when talking about it. Eg calling him an opposition spokesman isn't strictly accurate - he used to operate within the structure, then he lost influence and started operating outside of it, which meant he openly worked against Putin because Putin operates within it. Likewise the concept of anti-corruption campaigning doesn't make much sense - there isn't a Russian alive who doesn't know that politics is corrupt. This is not news for Russians. I guess you could call him a corruption cataloguer or something. Interestingly his own money came from a couple of anonymous sources hidden behind paywalls constructed by his pals in the tech industry and with a daughter at Stanford University this is fundraising on a different level than a gofundme for tiddles to get his operation.

As for his unsavoury views, there are neo-Nazis and neo-fascists all over that area. For the modern history of that you could start with the war that broke up Yugoslavia. That's where a lot of those seeds were sewn. It's how Putin gets traction when he talks about neo-Nazis in Ukraine. Man's not wrong, there most certainly are neo-Nazis in Ukraine, and they're on the army payroll.

It's a complex situation that, same as everything in life, isn't a case of good guy vs bad guy.

Thanks Orab, that’s really helpful. I thought that at part of his money comes from anti-Putin Russian businessmen living outside Russia. He mentioned this on one of his Instagram posts that he made when he was recovering in Germany after being poisoned,
explaining where the funding had come from to pay for his medical bills for his recovery in Germany.

OP posts:
Orab · 07/03/2024 23:53

Just read up on Russia I guess. Russia hasn't really experienced democracy as such so the political terminology we use doesn't mean the same when talking about it. Eg calling him an opposition spokesman isn't strictly accurate - he used to operate within the structure, then he lost influence and started operating outside of it, which meant he openly worked against Putin because Putin operates within it. Likewise the concept of anti-corruption campaigning doesn't make much sense - there isn't a Russian alive who doesn't know that politics is corrupt. This is not news for Russians. I guess you could call him a corruption cataloguer or something. Interestingly his own money came from a couple of anonymous sources hidden behind paywalls constructed by his pals in the tech industry and with a daughter at Stanford University this is fundraising on a different level than a gofundme for tiddles to get his operation.

As for his unsavoury views, there are neo-Nazis and neo-fascists all over that area. For the modern history of that you could start with the war that broke up Yugoslavia. That's where a lot of those seeds were sewn. It's how Putin gets traction when he talks about neo-Nazis in Ukraine. Man's not wrong, there most certainly are neo-Nazis in Ukraine, and they're on the army payroll.

It's a complex situation that, same as everything in life, isn't a case of good guy vs bad guy.

Acapulco12 · 07/03/2024 15:16

Just returning with a long post.

I feel very conflicted about Navalny, to be honest. I admire his bravery, charisma and energy which he all used to great effect in his fight against Putin and against corruption in Russia.

The humour he managed to maintained throughout his frequent imprisonment, poisoning - followed by his horrific death - have all added to my admiration of him. I see him as someone who stood up time and time again for his beliefs.

However, I do understand that he had some very strong views on issues such as immigration, LGBT+ rights and gun control - for example - which I do not at all share. I do understand the importance though of not aligning his views to ‘Western’, ‘liberal’ views though, because the society in which he grew up - Soviet then Russian - has very different cultural values in many ways to those in Western Europe and the USA, for instance. So I want to try and avoid looking at his views through that lens.

In all honesty, I’m finding it very difficult to get my head around my admiration of his bravery, energy and charisma and the fact that he had such unpleasant political views.

I have approached this so far by focusing a lot on his courage and the determination he showed in his work as an anti-corruption campaigner, which I think is out of the ordinary and should be celebrated.

Being completely honest, I have blinded myself to the less savoury aspects of his politics. I have tried to address this by reading and watching a lot about him, and I have bought a book about him written by academics.

However, I know there is a lot more I need to learn about him. Does anyone have any recommendations for how I can learn more about him?

Unhelpfully, I don’t speak Russian, so that will of course limit the resources I can access to learn more about him. Of course, those resources - like with any resource - will have a degree of bias and a particular position and view on him.

Grateful for any advice and guidance. Thanks.

OP posts:
Manthide · 07/03/2024 08:21

Snowpaw · 06/03/2024 17:08

My child has only ever had 1 grandparent and I feel sad for the deceased grandparents who would have absolutely loved her, had they met her. I never met my DP's parents and I'm not particularly sad about that for myself, but I do think about how my DD has missed out on unconditional love from 3 people, which makes me sad.

Both of my df's parents died when he was young, his father when he was a few months old and his mother when he was 15 with breast cancer. I became a gm a couple of years ago and my cousin died of breast cancer after living with it for more than 10 years. I cried thinking if my gm had lived 10 more years she would have met 7 of her 9 grandchildren.

Acapulco12 · 06/03/2024 21:10

Connected1 · 06/03/2024 17:28

https://acf.international/
Navalny was one of the founders and they're determined to continue his work.

By the way, the Navalny doc was repeated on BBC the other night. I just couldn't rewatch - too sad.

Thanks so much, @Connected1 - I’ll look at the link you’ve posted here. I’ve just started watching that documentary as I got recommended it by a family member who’d seen it when it first came out. I’m not very far in yet but, when he speaks about politics and Russia, he has so much conviction, energy and passion that I found it both really impressive and moving.

I also love that he was able to keep a sense of humour in spite of everything. It’s quite dark humour, with lots of sarcasm and irony, so it’s not necessarily everyone’s cup of tea, but it appealed to me.

OP posts:
Connected1 · 06/03/2024 17:28

Acapulco12 · 06/03/2024 13:57

Also meant to add - @Ginandpangolins, please do keep me posted if you spot any campaigns on keeping Navalny’s fight going and continuing his legacy. I haven’t seen anything yet, but I’ll keep my eyes peeled.

https://acf.international/
Navalny was one of the founders and they're determined to continue his work.

By the way, the Navalny doc was repeated on BBC the other night. I just couldn't rewatch - too sad.

Together against Putin

Project of Navalny’s team

https://acf.international

Ginandpangolins · 06/03/2024 17:23

Acapulco12 · 06/03/2024 13:01

I absolutely agree. I feel exactly the same.

I’ve written to my MP to ask if they can do anything to put greater pressure on the Russian government to release Russian political prisoners and to allow Russian people who want to pay their respects to Navalny to do this without being intimidated or sent to prison.

In my letter to my MP, I’ve also asked if the British government could do anything to recognise Navalny for the bravery he showed as an opposition leader. I know there is a street in London named after Boris Nemtsov, an opposition leader killed by the Russian government in 2015 (Boris Nemstov Place, in Hampstead) and I wonder if we could do something similar for Navalny. Of course, it won’t bring him back, but it will keep his name and memory alive and hopefully it will help spark conversations about political rights, democracy and human rights etc.

That sounds great. I'll do the same. I know that the activist Bill Browser is calling for some international anti corruption legislation and for it to be called the Navalny Law. That sounds like a very fitting tribute to his work.

GuppytheCat · 06/03/2024 17:09

A couple of family ones, yes.

My mother found out in her 50s that she had had a half-brother, but that he'd died a few years previously.

And DH was sent a photo via Ancestry that had his uncle in it, who died at 19 near the end of the war. He'd never seen a picture of him, and they were the image of each other. Again, it was a sort of grief that he'd missed so much of life, that we'd never had the chance to know him, and we'd never known how FIL felt about raising a son who looked so like his brother.

Snowpaw · 06/03/2024 17:08

My child has only ever had 1 grandparent and I feel sad for the deceased grandparents who would have absolutely loved her, had they met her. I never met my DP's parents and I'm not particularly sad about that for myself, but I do think about how my DD has missed out on unconditional love from 3 people, which makes me sad.

BusyCaz · 06/03/2024 16:57

Shocked/sad, never grief like I have felt for lost loved ones.

keffie12 · 06/03/2024 16:41

I just wanted to add on Vladimir and Putin - I am old enough to remember when
Mikhail Gorbachev was president between 1985-1991. He bought Russia into a world of freedom, follow by Boris Yeltsin continuation of it..

When Putin took over everything they had built changed. Mikhail Gorbachev, passed away last year a broken man. He knew Putin as a young man who he helped counsel.

Mikhail Gorbachev couldn't get over what Putin has slowly done to Russia. When Putin declared war in Ukraine that really finished him. Yes Gorbachev was 91 so it was his time however he was indeed broken by what Putin had done.

Incidentally: The Norwegian Nobel Committee awarded the 1990 Nobel Peace Prize to Mikhail Gorbachev, for his leading role in the peace process which characterized important parts of the international community, he served.

Depending on who you read Gorbachev was/is a hero and to others he was and is too liberal/a nuisance.

Regarding Yeltsin, he stood as an independent as he had resigned from Mikhail Gorbachev party. Yeltsin continued the period of stability before he unexpectedly stook down making way for Putin and we know what has happened with Putin regime

Acapulco12 · 06/03/2024 13:57

Also meant to add - @Ginandpangolins, please do keep me posted if you spot any campaigns on keeping Navalny’s fight going and continuing his legacy. I haven’t seen anything yet, but I’ll keep my eyes peeled.

OP posts:
Acapulco12 · 06/03/2024 13:01

Ginandpangolins · 06/03/2024 09:15

Navalny's family are exceptional aren't they. I'm going to see if there is any campaign going on in the UK, where British people can add their voices to the fight. It's not much but I'd like to feel like I can contribute, even in a small way.

I absolutely agree. I feel exactly the same.

I’ve written to my MP to ask if they can do anything to put greater pressure on the Russian government to release Russian political prisoners and to allow Russian people who want to pay their respects to Navalny to do this without being intimidated or sent to prison.

In my letter to my MP, I’ve also asked if the British government could do anything to recognise Navalny for the bravery he showed as an opposition leader. I know there is a street in London named after Boris Nemtsov, an opposition leader killed by the Russian government in 2015 (Boris Nemstov Place, in Hampstead) and I wonder if we could do something similar for Navalny. Of course, it won’t bring him back, but it will keep his name and memory alive and hopefully it will help spark conversations about political rights, democracy and human rights etc.

OP posts:
Acapulco12 · 06/03/2024 12:55

OldMrsHempstock · 06/03/2024 08:58

A musician, Mark Lanegan. He was the singer of Screaming Trees, one of the earlier Seattle bands tagged as grunge. He went on to record a huge body of imcredible, highly acclaimed work both solo, and with other artists such as Queens of the Stone Age and Isobel Campbell.

He had absolutely debilitating addictions to alcohol, heroin & crack. He got clean in the early 2000's, and had just moved to Ireland with his wife and sounded to be settling in to a quiet and contented life, when he got Covid so badly he spent months in a coma. He seemed to be on the mend, and then he died.

His memoir, Sing Backwards and Weep, is one of the best things I've ever read, in turns heartbreaking and hilarious.

Anyway, he died just over 2 years ago and I grieved, and still am grieving. I'll wake up in the night crying and feeling sick to the stomach. I know it isn't normal. But shortly after he died I was diagnosed with incurable cancer. I'm sure a psychologist would say I'm actually crying for myself. I don't know.

Other deaths have upset me a lot - Kurt Cobain, Taylor Hawkins, Terry Pratchett, John Peel, Amy Winehouse, David Bowie - but not on the same level.

My goodness, I’m so sorry @OldMrsHempstock ❤️🌺🌺

OP posts:
Ginandpangolins · 06/03/2024 09:15

Acapulco12 · 05/03/2024 23:05

I’ve just been watching an Instagram post by Navalny’s wife, Yulia. She is incredible too - so strong and resolute. I wish I knew Russian so I could fully understand what she is saying in the Instagram video. I hope we hear much more from her (and Navalny’s children, if they wish to speak out as well) in the coming years. I know that Navalny’s daughter has spoken about her dad in public a few times now, but I hope we carry on hearing more from his family in the years to come.

Navalny's family are exceptional aren't they. I'm going to see if there is any campaign going on in the UK, where British people can add their voices to the fight. It's not much but I'd like to feel like I can contribute, even in a small way.

OldMrsHempstock · 06/03/2024 08:58

A musician, Mark Lanegan. He was the singer of Screaming Trees, one of the earlier Seattle bands tagged as grunge. He went on to record a huge body of imcredible, highly acclaimed work both solo, and with other artists such as Queens of the Stone Age and Isobel Campbell.

He had absolutely debilitating addictions to alcohol, heroin & crack. He got clean in the early 2000's, and had just moved to Ireland with his wife and sounded to be settling in to a quiet and contented life, when he got Covid so badly he spent months in a coma. He seemed to be on the mend, and then he died.

His memoir, Sing Backwards and Weep, is one of the best things I've ever read, in turns heartbreaking and hilarious.

Anyway, he died just over 2 years ago and I grieved, and still am grieving. I'll wake up in the night crying and feeling sick to the stomach. I know it isn't normal. But shortly after he died I was diagnosed with incurable cancer. I'm sure a psychologist would say I'm actually crying for myself. I don't know.

Other deaths have upset me a lot - Kurt Cobain, Taylor Hawkins, Terry Pratchett, John Peel, Amy Winehouse, David Bowie - but not on the same level.

Acapulco12 · 05/03/2024 23:05

Ginandpangolins · 05/03/2024 22:44

I completely agree with you. Russians who are willing to speak up are literally putting themselves on the line. I am an average Western numpty who occasionally mouths off about politics. Someone in my position in Russia could possibly find themselves in prison. I totally agree with you re the bravery of Navalny, Kara Murza and all the brave Russian dissidents. I hate to say it but if I were in their position I would probably keep my mouth shut. All power to them.

I’ve just been watching an Instagram post by Navalny’s wife, Yulia. She is incredible too - so strong and resolute. I wish I knew Russian so I could fully understand what she is saying in the Instagram video. I hope we hear much more from her (and Navalny’s children, if they wish to speak out as well) in the coming years. I know that Navalny’s daughter has spoken about her dad in public a few times now, but I hope we carry on hearing more from his family in the years to come.

OP posts:
Ginandpangolins · 05/03/2024 22:44

Acapulco12 · 05/03/2024 22:14

Jesus. This makes me think more and more that Navalny was killed precisely because of the elections coming up and because Putin thought that Navalny would pose a threat to him despite being in prison.

I’ve been thinking exactly the same as you about the bravery of Russian people who publicly oppose Putin. I’m in awe of them. I think that’s why Navalny made such a massive impression on me. If I was Russian and living in Russia, I’m not sure I would have been brave enough to pay my respects at his funeral last week. I think their bravery is astonishing and really inspiring.

I also read in a couple of newspapers recently that Russia is close to becoming a dictatorship, or perhaps it already is one. I don’t say that lightly at all. I don’t have the words to describe how atrocious Putin is behaving. This is horrifying.

I completely agree with you. Russians who are willing to speak up are literally putting themselves on the line. I am an average Western numpty who occasionally mouths off about politics. Someone in my position in Russia could possibly find themselves in prison. I totally agree with you re the bravery of Navalny, Kara Murza and all the brave Russian dissidents. I hate to say it but if I were in their position I would probably keep my mouth shut. All power to them.

BionicBadger · 05/03/2024 22:37

Thank you. Fabulous user name btw!

Nanny0gg · 05/03/2024 22:16

BionicBadger · 05/03/2024 18:15

God I’m really sorry @Nanny0gg, I didn’t think about the spoiler! My apologies. Anyway it wasn’t and she didn’t and I don’t know in any case. Lawks.

You're forgiven!

Acapulco12 · 05/03/2024 22:14

Ginandpangolins · 05/03/2024 21:45

According to the Washington Post, a mildly oppositional candidate Boris Nadezhin has been barred from running as a presidential candidate due to "technicalities". This guy is so "inoffensive" he even has a presence on Russian state media, yet has still been shut down. I have so much respect for the ordinary people in that country who are willing to put their head above the parapet. They are so brave.

Jesus. This makes me think more and more that Navalny was killed precisely because of the elections coming up and because Putin thought that Navalny would pose a threat to him despite being in prison.

I’ve been thinking exactly the same as you about the bravery of Russian people who publicly oppose Putin. I’m in awe of them. I think that’s why Navalny made such a massive impression on me. If I was Russian and living in Russia, I’m not sure I would have been brave enough to pay my respects at his funeral last week. I think their bravery is astonishing and really inspiring.

I also read in a couple of newspapers recently that Russia is close to becoming a dictatorship, or perhaps it already is one. I don’t say that lightly at all. I don’t have the words to describe how atrocious Putin is behaving. This is horrifying.

OP posts:
Ginandpangolins · 05/03/2024 21:45

Acapulco12 · 05/03/2024 20:29

I completely agree with your point about Putin. I hope that the opposition leaders who are still in prison (Vladimir Kara Murza, Ilya Yashin and all of the others) will survive Putin but I’m not sure. I really do hope so though.

According to the Washington Post, a mildly oppositional candidate Boris Nadezhin has been barred from running as a presidential candidate due to "technicalities". This guy is so "inoffensive" he even has a presence on Russian state media, yet has still been shut down. I have so much respect for the ordinary people in that country who are willing to put their head above the parapet. They are so brave.

Acapulco12 · 05/03/2024 20:29

Ginandpangolins · 05/03/2024 19:21

Kara Mirza is the guy I was thinking of. I read today that his wife had been in conversation with David Cameron. I find it interesting that Putin seems to dismiss his opposition as non entities, yet still feels heavily invested in silencing / killing them. What's your problem, Vlad?

I completely agree with your point about Putin. I hope that the opposition leaders who are still in prison (Vladimir Kara Murza, Ilya Yashin and all of the others) will survive Putin but I’m not sure. I really do hope so though.

OP posts:
Ginandpangolins · 05/03/2024 19:21

Acapulco12 · 04/03/2024 18:40

I hope there are lots of people there to take his place.

I don’t know a great deal about who is there to step up to carry on with the opposition, but I think most of those people are in jail (e.g. Ilya Yashin or Vladimir Kara-Murza) or outside Russia (Navalny’s own family and his supporters).

I hope that those people who are in jail will be released and also that Navalny’s family and supporters can do something outside Russia to galvanise support for the opposition.

Kara Mirza is the guy I was thinking of. I read today that his wife had been in conversation with David Cameron. I find it interesting that Putin seems to dismiss his opposition as non entities, yet still feels heavily invested in silencing / killing them. What's your problem, Vlad?

Swipe left for the next trending thread