Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this teacher should be made to apologise to these students?

36 replies

EasterEggsComeAtMe · 29/02/2024 21:12

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12211691/amp/EXCLUSIVE-Mother-Year-8-pupil-scolded-gender-proud-her.html

It's an older article from July. Just came across it from a random tik tok video and listened to the whole recording on the article. Scary to think without the recording how the poor girls would've been made out to be troublesome teenagers or exaggerating most likely...

Yanbu - apologise
Yabu - don't apologise

EXCLUSIVE Mother of Year 8 pupil scolded over gender 'proud of her'

EXCLUSIVE: Two teenage Year 8 pupils at Rye College in East Sussex were ordered to stay behind in class after clashing with their classmate who identifies as a cat.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12211691/amp/EXCLUSIVE-Mother-Year-8-pupil-scolded-gender-proud-her.html

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 01/03/2024 02:39

ExtraOnions · 01/03/2024 00:52

At no point did anyone identify as a cat .. a badly managed conversation was whipped up by the media.

https://amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jun/26/girl-didnt-identified-as-a-cat-post-truth-politics-media-gender-identity

That makes it worse doesn’t it?

If there was no child in the class identifying as a cat, then the girls were just using an example to explain their position and did not shame or otherwise directly criticise or contradict another class member. So this was simply a teacher trying to shame the girls for voicing their belief and understanding.

NumberTheory · 01/03/2024 02:10

Arbor · 01/03/2024 00:52

@NumberTheory

If you listen to the recording it seems like the teacher was far more confused about sex and gender and sexuality, amoung a bunch of other things.

This wasn't kids "just mucking about in class" from the conversation the teacher had with the girls. It was about the girls refusing to accept a controversial view of identity as fact and a teacher threatening them with a loss of a place at the school for standing up for their belief that claiming a gender identity separate from your sex, or a species identity separate from your biological species is not a legitimate way to describe yourself.

I listened to the recording, and I don't agree. The kids, IMO, were implicitly in the wrong for shaming a classmate and questioning the teacher. "Standing up for a belief" is absolutely fine, but do it appropriately. (I will also say it isn't their belief they are standing up for - it is clearly their parents'. 13-year-olds challenging adults on beliefs and facts shouldn't be a standard to clap over.)

I don’t disagree that the classmate felt shamed, since she cried I would assume she did. People who aren’t prepared for debate often feel shame when their ideas are exposed as ridiculous. 13 year olds are not going to have the best skills for challenging gently, nor the best for accepting that their ideas aren’t accepted by everyone. That’s a really tricky discussion for a teacher to lead well and one that, I would think, was inappropriate at that age without a lot of prep work.

That doesn’t make what the kids were doing “just mucking about” as you claim. They are being introduced to ideas that they find unbelievable - which isn’t surprising, since vast majority of people find the idea of being cat gender unbelievable - they challenged that. That’s not “just mucking around”, it’s engaging in learning. Questioning what you don’t understand is essential to gaining understanding They may not have the best skills to do so well, and a good teacher would hopefully be able to help the whole class develop the sort of discursive and critical thinking skills necessary to do it respectfully. This teacher didn’t attempt to do so. Given her own appalling grasp of the issues she was clearly ill prepared on the specific subject matter, but that doesn’t mean she shouldn’t have been able to model the skills she wanted to see from the kids instead of trying to shame them (which was spectacularly unsuccessful given she couldn’t string a coherent sentence about the ideas together) and threatening them about their place in the school.

*All this assumes there was a girl who identified as a cat and cried in class - which, if we are to believe the guardian, may not have been the case at all, in which case we are simply talking about discussing the idea of identity theory, not about kids who shamed another child.

Arbor · 01/03/2024 00:57

ExtraOnions · 01/03/2024 00:52

At no point did anyone identify as a cat .. a badly managed conversation was whipped up by the media.

https://amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jun/26/girl-didnt-identified-as-a-cat-post-truth-politics-media-gender-identity

Aha. That's typical. Of course they didn't, but we won't let pesky things like facts get in the way of a bit of froth.

Arbor · 01/03/2024 00:52

@NumberTheory

If you listen to the recording it seems like the teacher was far more confused about sex and gender and sexuality, amoung a bunch of other things.

This wasn't kids "just mucking about in class" from the conversation the teacher had with the girls. It was about the girls refusing to accept a controversial view of identity as fact and a teacher threatening them with a loss of a place at the school for standing up for their belief that claiming a gender identity separate from your sex, or a species identity separate from your biological species is not a legitimate way to describe yourself.

I listened to the recording, and I don't agree. The kids, IMO, were implicitly in the wrong for shaming a classmate and questioning the teacher. "Standing up for a belief" is absolutely fine, but do it appropriately. (I will also say it isn't their belief they are standing up for - it is clearly their parents'. 13-year-olds challenging adults on beliefs and facts shouldn't be a standard to clap over.)

BobbyBiscuits · 01/03/2024 00:51

I heard that the whole 'girl identifies as a cat' thing was pure BS. Maybe someone said I'm a cat, but no school ever endorsed it.
It's just trying to stir shit where there are more important things to think about regarding schooling.

NumberTheory · 01/03/2024 00:30

Arbor · 29/02/2024 23:25

It seems that the girl's Mum is confused re: the gender debate, going by this quote:

'There are girls in her class and at the school who are trans and she has no problem with any of them, she calls them by their preferred pronouns and accepts them for who they are - but there are only two sexes. It's just science, you are born male or female.
'The fact that the school is shielding this young girl who identifies as a cat and reprimanding anyone who challenges that notion seems to me to be completely absurd.
‘Why on earth are 13-year-old kids being taught about gender identity anyway? They're just children. It’s not right.'
Is this about sex or gender? Or is it about a couple of girls mucking up in class, challenging a teacher and making another student cry? If they didn't agree with an aspect of the curriculum, that isn't the right way to go about it.

If you listen to the recording it seems like the teacher was far more confused about sex and gender and sexuality, amoung a bunch of other things.

This wasn't kids "just mucking about in class" from the conversation the teacher had with the girls. It was about the girls refusing to accept a controversial view of identity as fact and a teacher threatening them with a loss of a place at the school for standing up for their belief that claiming a gender identity separate from your sex, or a species identity separate from your biological species is not a legitimate way to describe yourself.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 01/03/2024 00:17

It must be damn near impossible to be a teacher these days.

While I think she was wrong, it must be difficult to try to protect a clearly struggling child who sits in her classroom while claiming to be a cat.

At least with the trans thinking, people are still human.

A child identifying as a cat need help. It shouldn't be indulged. The child should be referred a mental health specialist.

DragonGypsyDoris · 29/02/2024 23:40

If it's true, the teacher's competence should be questioned.

Arbor · 29/02/2024 23:25

It seems that the girl's Mum is confused re: the gender debate, going by this quote:

'There are girls in her class and at the school who are trans and she has no problem with any of them, she calls them by their preferred pronouns and accepts them for who they are - but there are only two sexes. It's just science, you are born male or female.
'The fact that the school is shielding this young girl who identifies as a cat and reprimanding anyone who challenges that notion seems to me to be completely absurd.
‘Why on earth are 13-year-old kids being taught about gender identity anyway? They're just children. It’s not right.'
Is this about sex or gender? Or is it about a couple of girls mucking up in class, challenging a teacher and making another student cry? If they didn't agree with an aspect of the curriculum, that isn't the right way to go about it.

nimski · 29/02/2024 22:21

The world has gone mad.

Swipe left for the next trending thread