Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this teacher should be made to apologise to these students?

36 replies

EasterEggsComeAtMe · 29/02/2024 21:12

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12211691/amp/EXCLUSIVE-Mother-Year-8-pupil-scolded-gender-proud-her.html

It's an older article from July. Just came across it from a random tik tok video and listened to the whole recording on the article. Scary to think without the recording how the poor girls would've been made out to be troublesome teenagers or exaggerating most likely...

Yanbu - apologise
Yabu - don't apologise

EXCLUSIVE Mother of Year 8 pupil scolded over gender 'proud of her'

EXCLUSIVE: Two teenage Year 8 pupils at Rye College in East Sussex were ordered to stay behind in class after clashing with their classmate who identifies as a cat.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12211691/amp/EXCLUSIVE-Mother-Year-8-pupil-scolded-gender-proud-her.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NumberTheory · 02/03/2024 14:05

Smerpsmorp · 02/03/2024 07:06

So the girls are being told off by their teacher, they record it because they don’t like being told off, run home to parents, parents demand teacher apologises.

they were not shouted, belittled or demeaned. Their first response to upsetting someone is to argue that they’re not allowed to say what they think. They should be ashamed. We aren’t talking about a changing rooms or safe spaces.

no I don’t agree with what the teacher is saying, but they’re trying to navigate a minefield and getting twisted, because they have been told.

we can’t just say what we want because it’s our beliefs. No the teacher shouldn’t have gotten into it, but the girls sound vile as they don’t care they’ve upset someone.

I think the teacher did belittle and demean them. She was trying o shame them for their views. The bit about going to a different school because they didn’t agree with her was outrageous.

The fact the teacher gets twisted trying to navigate this is a big clue that being so draconian towards the kids over what they can say and how they say it is unfair. They are also trying to navigate this.

We don’t know what went on in the classroom and how reasonable it is for this other girl to have been upset. But the teacher doesn’t seem to be accusing them of saying anything that isn’t challenging the idea that an animal identity is valid and linking that to the idea of gender identity theory. If they have to stop voicing their view and have it shut down and the other person’s view accepted as valid because that other person cries, it’s not surprising they have little sympathy for the person crying. It must be very frustrating for a young teen.

Since they don’t have loads of recordings of them being told off I suspect the recording was less about them not liking being told off (they sound bolshy uninhibited enough that they’ve probably been told off a fair amount) and more that they were a bit outraged at what they were being told off for and found it unfair and unreasonable. But we’ll never know, perhaps they are constantly recording in the hope something like this would happen but none of the other recordings see the light of day because it’s so rare for teachers to act this badly.

Smerpsmorp · 02/03/2024 07:06

NumberTheory · 01/03/2024 07:07

Do you think it was an appropriate way for the teacher to talk to them even if they had said something offensive?

The article clearly states it was recorded by one of the girls being spoken to by the teacher. The implication is that they didn’t think anyone would believe them if they reported the incident without evidence. Given the mother says she didn’t believe them until she heard the recording that’s probably not unfounded.

So the girls are being told off by their teacher, they record it because they don’t like being told off, run home to parents, parents demand teacher apologises.

they were not shouted, belittled or demeaned. Their first response to upsetting someone is to argue that they’re not allowed to say what they think. They should be ashamed. We aren’t talking about a changing rooms or safe spaces.

no I don’t agree with what the teacher is saying, but they’re trying to navigate a minefield and getting twisted, because they have been told.

we can’t just say what we want because it’s our beliefs. No the teacher shouldn’t have gotten into it, but the girls sound vile as they don’t care they’ve upset someone.

TheKeatingFive · 01/03/2024 17:41

The teacher was also woefully uneducated on the subject 'There are three sexes, male, female and intersex' No there most certainly isn't. There are differences in sexual development, but only 2 sexes. To be saying that in an educational setting is quite astonishing

Yes, this is shocking misinformation

Missamyp · 01/03/2024 17:21

Some teachers haven't changed have they, with the 'Teachers tone' as a rhetorical device to enforce an opinion.
Now it's leaked no doubt the teacher will be off with stress for 12 months.

Seagullstolemychips · 01/03/2024 17:11

ZebraDanios · 01/03/2024 09:27

No-one’s bothered about the girls secretly filming the conversation…?

If they thought they wouldn’t be believed they should have asked for another teacher to be present, not recorded the conversation without the teacher’s consent or knowledge.

The other teacher would back up the teacher, whether or not they agreed.

RedStripeypillow · 01/03/2024 17:03

Also, I think the girls were right to challenge. They weren't rude but did stand their ground. Good for them.

RedStripeypillow · 01/03/2024 17:00

It is a teacher's duty to remain neutral on controversial subjects. I am a teacher and would never enter into a discussion like this. She was unprofessional and should have said that this is a very emotive subject that she is unable to comment on.

We have been given absolutely no guidance on this at my school so I can see how easily a young woke inexperienced teacher would walk into a situation like this.

NumberTheory · 01/03/2024 15:04

ZebraDanios · 01/03/2024 09:27

No-one’s bothered about the girls secretly filming the conversation…?

If they thought they wouldn’t be believed they should have asked for another teacher to be present, not recorded the conversation without the teacher’s consent or knowledge.

I’m not bothered about it, no. In fact I think that sort of action is essential to holding people with power to account.

Ohnoooooooo · 01/03/2024 10:28

while I have very strong views on ensuring biological females keep their safe spaces - I would not be posting something about my child that is going to be in the public eye - these girls are going to get a lot of attention for this that is going to be disruptive to their schooling

ZebraDanios · 01/03/2024 09:27

No-one’s bothered about the girls secretly filming the conversation…?

If they thought they wouldn’t be believed they should have asked for another teacher to be present, not recorded the conversation without the teacher’s consent or knowledge.

lifeturnsonadime · 01/03/2024 09:22

Can anyone tell me how it is any more ridiculous to identify as a cat than as the opposite sex?

Neither are based in reality.

DingDongDenny · 01/03/2024 09:15

Gender identity does not have a scientific basis, it is a belief system that should be respected in the same way that other belief systems, such as religion are

Nobody should be compelled to accept someone elses belief system and that was what the teacher was doing here. Having gender critical beliefs is a legitimate position that also deserves respect, as long as expressing those beliefs don't amount to harrassing anyone.

The teacher was also woefully uneducated on the subject 'There are three sexes, male, female and intersex' No there most certainly isn't. There are differences in sexual development, but only 2 sexes. To be saying that in an educational setting is quite astonishing

Underthinker · 01/03/2024 09:00

@Arbor
There is a trend of children identifying as animals. There have been threads of parents talking about it here, and I know a teacher who has one in their year group. So even if it didn't happen it that school, it does happen.

But the point of the story really is how the teacher yelled at the kids for not agreeing with her own [false] beliefs. That the cat kid was hypothetical in this example is a mistaken assumption on the part of the Mail, who should have fact checked, but not the most important thing here.

Arbor · 01/03/2024 08:33

@Underthinker

But you didn't let that fact get in the way of your previous frothy comments about shaming a classmate.

Even without searching the its history - and I admittedly should have done - It was clear to me there was something wrong with the story as it was told in the Daily Mail. Thus my comments.

LakeTiticaca · 01/03/2024 08:25

Problem nowadays is people seem to have lost the ability to say no.
No you not a cat. Now get to school and stop being ridiculous
Oh and don't bring any dead mice home either 🤣🤣🤣

BishyBarnyBee · 01/03/2024 08:14

This was discussed to death at the time, and used as an example of how the world has gone mad and children are identifying as cats. Which is not what happened.

YABU unreasonable to raise it again months later.

olympicsrock · 01/03/2024 07:36

Having listened to the video, I think the teacher was a bit aggressive in pushing her views about gender identity . A reflective conversation would have been a better educational approach.
But no - i don’t think the teacher needs to apologise. I’m sure teachers all have moments when they have been driven to distraction by an unruly class.

NumberTheory · 01/03/2024 07:19

hettie · 01/03/2024 06:41

Jon Roson thoroughly debunks the ' cat litter boxes in classrooms' conspiracy. The 'it's soooo crazy how we've been captured by the woke agenda/kids identify as cats and teachers defend it' trope is closely related. If your not holding a huge amount of scepticism about the details of this story you should be.

The cat litter thing was on an entirely different continent.

The veracity of the recording in this incident, on the other hand, is not in doubt. Rye College has apologised to parents for the way they handled incident which they describe as unlike the normal way the subject is handled.
https://www.theguardian.com/education/2023/jul/13/school-in-cat-pupil-controversy-given-ofsted-all-clear-after-snap-inspection
No idea if the teacher responsible apologised to the kids she berated, though.

School in ‘cat pupil’ controversy given Ofsted all-clear after snap inspection

Inspectors praise ‘sensitive and impartial’ teaching of relationship and sex education at Rye College after secret video raised concerns

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2023/jul/13/school-in-cat-pupil-controversy-given-ofsted-all-clear-after-snap-inspection

NumberTheory · 01/03/2024 07:07

Smerpsmorp · 01/03/2024 06:58

It doesn’t matter your beliefs on gender or whether what they’re saying is true - they’ve upset someone. The teacher handled this wrong - in that she focussed on the debate and the discussion - rather than the fact that they’ve hurt someone’s feelings.

i don’t agree with the teachers views on gender, but the girls have upset someone with what they’ve said.

i had Muslim children in my class being homophobic. I said: “i will not allow you to use being Muslim as a way of saying homophobic things. Being a Muslim doesn’t mean you can upset someone.” I then had to have an investigation into whether or not I was racist. I was actually brought up Muslim in the first place. I should also add at no point in the lesson were we discussing homosexuality. I’m a performing arts teacher and we were learning to play ode to joy on the piano.

being a teacher is so hard right now - I didn’t listen to the entire discussion - but these girls have clearly made someone upset and if you care more about their beliefs about gender than other peoples genders (specifically when there’s no danger - like a public place where everybody’s minding their own business) then I think there’s bigger problems.

who recorded the teacher? Why is it recorded?

Edited

Do you think it was an appropriate way for the teacher to talk to them even if they had said something offensive?

The article clearly states it was recorded by one of the girls being spoken to by the teacher. The implication is that they didn’t think anyone would believe them if they reported the incident without evidence. Given the mother says she didn’t believe them until she heard the recording that’s probably not unfounded.

Smerpsmorp · 01/03/2024 06:58

It doesn’t matter your beliefs on gender or whether what they’re saying is true - they’ve upset someone. The teacher handled this wrong - in that she focussed on the debate and the discussion - rather than the fact that they’ve hurt someone’s feelings.

i don’t agree with the teachers views on gender, but the girls have upset someone with what they’ve said.

i had Muslim children in my class being homophobic. I said: “i will not allow you to use being Muslim as a way of saying homophobic things. Being a Muslim doesn’t mean you can upset someone.” I then had to have an investigation into whether or not I was racist. I was actually brought up Muslim in the first place. I should also add at no point in the lesson were we discussing homosexuality. I’m a performing arts teacher and we were learning to play ode to joy on the piano.

being a teacher is so hard right now - I didn’t listen to the entire discussion - but these girls have clearly made someone upset and if you care more about their beliefs about gender than other peoples genders (specifically when there’s no danger - like a public place where everybody’s minding their own business) then I think there’s bigger problems.

who recorded the teacher? Why is it recorded?

Underthinker · 01/03/2024 06:58

Arbor · 01/03/2024 00:57

Aha. That's typical. Of course they didn't, but we won't let pesky things like facts get in the way of a bit of froth.

But you didn't let that fact get in the way of your previous frothy comments about shaming a classmate.

hettie · 01/03/2024 06:41

Jon Roson thoroughly debunks the ' cat litter boxes in classrooms' conspiracy. The 'it's soooo crazy how we've been captured by the woke agenda/kids identify as cats and teachers defend it' trope is closely related. If your not holding a huge amount of scepticism about the details of this story you should be.

NumberTheory · 01/03/2024 06:03

Arbor · 01/03/2024 05:16

@NumberTheory

That doesn’t make what the kids were doing “just mucking about” as you claim. They are being introduced to ideas that they find unbelievable - which isn’t surprising, since vast majority of people find the idea of being cat gender unbelievable - they challenged that. That’s not “just mucking around”, it’s engaging in learning. Questioning what you don’t understand is essential to gaining understanding They may not have the best skills to do so well, and a good teacher would hopefully be able to help the whole class develop the sort of discursive and critical thinking skills necessary to do it respectfully. This teacher didn’t attempt to do so. Given her own appalling grasp of the issues she was clearly ill prepared on the specific subject matter, but that doesn’t mean she shouldn’t have been able to model the skills she wanted to see from the kids instead of trying to shame them (which was spectacularly unsuccessful given she couldn’t string a coherent sentence about the ideas together) and threatening them about their place in the school.

This approach would make being a teacher quite difficult, and the classroom the Lord of the Flies. I agree, though, these types of skills are essential for students to develop - in the appropriate environments and when the teacher determines. In a classroom, students shouldn't speak whenever they feel like it.

We don’t know what happened in the classroom. The recording is the discussion where they were held back after class and told off - not for speaking out of turn but for saying something the teacher disagreed with.

Arbor · 01/03/2024 05:16

@NumberTheory

That doesn’t make what the kids were doing “just mucking about” as you claim. They are being introduced to ideas that they find unbelievable - which isn’t surprising, since vast majority of people find the idea of being cat gender unbelievable - they challenged that. That’s not “just mucking around”, it’s engaging in learning. Questioning what you don’t understand is essential to gaining understanding They may not have the best skills to do so well, and a good teacher would hopefully be able to help the whole class develop the sort of discursive and critical thinking skills necessary to do it respectfully. This teacher didn’t attempt to do so. Given her own appalling grasp of the issues she was clearly ill prepared on the specific subject matter, but that doesn’t mean she shouldn’t have been able to model the skills she wanted to see from the kids instead of trying to shame them (which was spectacularly unsuccessful given she couldn’t string a coherent sentence about the ideas together) and threatening them about their place in the school.

This approach would make being a teacher quite difficult, and the classroom the Lord of the Flies. I agree, though, these types of skills are essential for students to develop - in the appropriate environments and when the teacher determines. In a classroom, students shouldn't speak whenever they feel like it.

Loulou599 · 01/03/2024 03:53

Urgh, kids in the UK...

How about just get on with learning stuff instead of trying to "platform your personality"

Swipe left for the next trending thread