Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not remind dh of MIL’s birthday?

167 replies

BirthdayBlitz · 29/02/2024 20:45

Name changed for this one. MIL’s birthday is in the next few weeks. We are not close at all, by her choosing. When together (not often at all, we live far apart) we are cordial but that’s it.

Dh is bad with dates and never remembers her birthday. I on the other hand am good on dates and remember it. We’ve been married 25 years and at the beginning we’d do cards, then that fell off and we’d at least acknowledge birthdays which was fine with me. For the past few years I haven’t gotten even an acknowledgment on my birthday. Dh is remembered (his birthday falls on a holiday so it’s pretty hard to forget) and every year I have to remind him to call his mother, usually multiple times.

WIBU to just skip it this year and not remind dh?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SerafinasGoose · 02/03/2024 17:17

IncompleteSenten · 02/03/2024 15:52

I loved my mum in law dearly.
It still would not have been my job to remind her son of her birthday?

I mean, what kind of useless shite can't remember the birthday of the woman who raised him?

When we cover up for these men we are helping them hide the fact their family is not important enough to them to bother remembering a date. Or programming their phone to set a reminder. Or setting up a Moonpig email reminder.

We're helping them pretend to care when the reality is they clearly don't.

Exactly right.

It works the other way, too. My MiL wasn't above forgetting DH's own birthday when he was merely a child. This is why these days we never let it go by unmarked, and always ensure we do something special. It's out of character for DH - he never likes 'fuss' and big events and we even eloped when we married - so for this reason I asked him about it. I think, from memory, she forgot his tenth birthday - now around the age of our own son - to whom I cannot even imagine doing such a thing.

I think it's very kind of him to notice and send cards for her birthday at all. But in my (admittedly biased) view he is by far the better person, and this in no small part is the reason I fell in love with him in the first place.

FeelingLostTheseDays · 02/03/2024 16:22

Puzzlefactor · 02/03/2024 15:58

Yes I think I have. The real issue is the OP doesn't like her MiL. If she did like her I think she would be more than happy to remind her DH.

No. It’s not a wife’s job to remind her husband of his own mother’s birthday, however nice or awful his mum might be. It’s rarely the either way round. It is more wife work and it’s sexist and unacceptable. If a man can function in other ways, he can remember his own social obligations. It is nothing to do with how much the mil is liked.

I would not want my son’s wife to have to remind him of my birthday. Nope.

sausagepastapot · 02/03/2024 16:21

No, I wouldn't remind him. I don't remind mine.

SouthLondonMum22 · 02/03/2024 16:18

Puzzlefactor · 02/03/2024 16:13

I didn't say it was the wife's responsibility. But in my life a dearly loved MiL would get an acknowledgement of her birthday from me too, not just from her son.

DH sorts her card and gift and writes them from the both of us. I will send her a text wishing her happy birthday and we'll usually go out for a meal too.

I have never and will never remind DH when it is his mums birthday.

IncompleteSenten · 02/03/2024 16:15

Puzzlefactor · 02/03/2024 16:00

So you wouldn't have wanted to send your dearly loved MiL a card then? Why, because she's not part of your family too?

Ok, confession time. She was born in rural Kenya a hundred years ago and always said she only knew the season she was born in.

But that doesn't mean my opinion is different . If she or we knew what her birthday was and my husband couldn't be arsed to remember, no way would I cover up for him. I'd also think a lot less of him for it not mattering.

I'd probably have sent her a card from me and told her her son's being useless again.
And she'd agree with me. That wonderful woman always had my back.

But I remain adamant that we should not collude with our men to hide their lack of interest in their family.

Puzzlefactor · 02/03/2024 16:13

I didn't say it was the wife's responsibility. But in my life a dearly loved MiL would get an acknowledgement of her birthday from me too, not just from her son.

SouthLondonMum22 · 02/03/2024 16:10

Puzzlefactor · 02/03/2024 16:00

So you wouldn't have wanted to send your dearly loved MiL a card then? Why, because she's not part of your family too?

Because it is MIL's sons job to get her a card. Why should it be the wife's responsibility?

Puzzlefactor · 02/03/2024 16:00

IncompleteSenten · 02/03/2024 15:52

I loved my mum in law dearly.
It still would not have been my job to remind her son of her birthday?

I mean, what kind of useless shite can't remember the birthday of the woman who raised him?

When we cover up for these men we are helping them hide the fact their family is not important enough to them to bother remembering a date. Or programming their phone to set a reminder. Or setting up a Moonpig email reminder.

We're helping them pretend to care when the reality is they clearly don't.

So you wouldn't have wanted to send your dearly loved MiL a card then? Why, because she's not part of your family too?

Puzzlefactor · 02/03/2024 15:58

FeelingLostTheseDays · 02/03/2024 15:47

You have not understood the real issue here at all, have you?

Yes I think I have. The real issue is the OP doesn't like her MiL. If she did like her I think she would be more than happy to remind her DH.

IncompleteSenten · 02/03/2024 15:52

I loved my mum in law dearly.
It still would not have been my job to remind her son of her birthday?

I mean, what kind of useless shite can't remember the birthday of the woman who raised him?

When we cover up for these men we are helping them hide the fact their family is not important enough to them to bother remembering a date. Or programming their phone to set a reminder. Or setting up a Moonpig email reminder.

We're helping them pretend to care when the reality is they clearly don't.

FeelingLostTheseDays · 02/03/2024 15:47

Puzzlefactor · 02/03/2024 11:10

It seems more that people dislike their MiLs so will use this to point score. Rather than the actual reminding the husband.

You have not understood the real issue here at all, have you?

Puzzlefactor · 02/03/2024 11:10

It seems more that people dislike their MiLs so will use this to point score. Rather than the actual reminding the husband.

Hopingitsahornyfinger · 02/03/2024 11:03

Well said @SerafinasGoose it's the same for me & my DH.

SerafinasGoose · 02/03/2024 11:03

diddl · 01/03/2024 08:20

Of course!

Same as my parents always sent my husband a birthday card.

Because they cared enough!

I have no idea when my MiL's birthday is. The scant few years she ever acknowleged mine was after DC was born - our birthdays being only days apart - so she could make a point of continually addressing me as Mrs Hisname and DC as Master Hisname. (Broad hint: neither of these are our actual names, and she ignored DH's polite requests to address us correctly).

Even that low trickle has dried up now, and I'm perfectly happy and comfortable with that. In fact, I prefer it. At least it's honest.

SerafinasGoose · 02/03/2024 10:57

Puzzlefactor · 29/02/2024 21:22

it's not wifework to actually be nice to your husband. I often wonder if anyone actually likes their husbands on MN.

I love my husband enough to recognise that he's an exceptionally competent adult, who is perfectly capable of holding down the kind of CEO role that many women are still kept out of, and that he's capable and efficient. He married a wife he views as an equal - his own choice - and he's well able to organize his own life admin.

I don't compute this strange learned helplessness some women seem intent on projecting onto their husbands. Where do they receive these strange impressions that men are seemingly incapable of remembering their mothers' birthdays or doing their own holiday packing?

I have no interest in wifework and I don't do it. If this equates in some people's minds with not being 'nice' to their husbands, then they've inherited a value system based less on equal, loving partnerships than regressive stereotypes. My DH thankfully doesn't buy into this. I'm pleased I have more respect him than this, and he returns that respect with the attitude that he married a wife, not a personal secretary.

TwylaSands · 02/03/2024 08:01

FeelingLostTheseDays · 02/03/2024 07:11

For me, my husband’s brain is fried with work stress

I wonder how many of us full-time working women need reminders?! Or is is just the Man with his Very Important Big Job that can’t remember his own mum’s birthday? Stop excusing this nonsense.

Im a fulltime working mother and need reminders. So i set them on my phone and have a calendar in the kitchen. I dont expect my husband to think for me.

OldBeyondMyYears · 02/03/2024 07:30

OP...your husband could be forgiven for 'forgetting' a birthday once. After that, it's no longer 'forgetting', it's sheer laziness! I bet he doesn't forget when his team are playing away, or when he has work meetings to attend.

This ridiculous idea that 'men forget' birthdays/anniversaries etc is complete bollocks! They don't forget, they simply don't prioritise.

I would have nothing to do with his life admin from here on...as someone upthread has suggested, give him ONE list with all the important dates on, tell him to put them all on his phone calendar, and that this is the last time you'll be supporting his 'memory' 🤦‍♀️

And do it now, in advance of his mother's birthday, so he has to make some sort of effort nearer the time to call her.

FeelingLostTheseDays · 02/03/2024 07:11

Happiestathome · 29/02/2024 23:35

I do remind my husband and in your situation, personally, I would continue to do it for his sake if it was likely to cause issues for him with the family. I completely understand those that choose not to though. For me, my husband’s brain is fried with work stress and we just help each other out where we can.

For me, my husband’s brain is fried with work stress

I wonder how many of us full-time working women need reminders?! Or is is just the Man with his Very Important Big Job that can’t remember his own mum’s birthday? Stop excusing this nonsense.

FeelingLostTheseDays · 02/03/2024 07:05

Foxblue · 29/02/2024 22:49

Ooh I love a thread when grown woman with shitty uncaring husbands say its 'not nice' not to remind someone whose 'bad with dates'.
These men who can drive, work, use a mobile phone, use a laptop, use a TV, ooh they are just so rubbish with dates, so rubbish they are rendered absolutely incapable of writing it on a calendar! It's so weird, this type of selective memory AND long term inability to be able to drive a car or operate machinery or remember when christmas day is or what days of the week the weekends are on, but not use a basic mobile phone app to add a recurring date to (or ask someone to show them how so they learn) they should really study this at length! Are we not concerned about this temporary inability to do basic things? Should these men be driving? Should they be working?

I'm shit with dates. Do you know what I do? I PUT IT IN A FUCKING CALENDAR. Its okay to be shit at something, but you make an active effort to learn? Because it's unreasonable to expect others to do basic things for you? Because it's part of being an adult?

Exactly. These poor souls remember stuff at work somehow.

I am relieved that so many women on this thread think like this. I see that as a tiny bit of progress.

FeelingLostTheseDays · 02/03/2024 07:03

Puzzlefactor · 29/02/2024 21:39

Oh but it does. We don't do petty point scoring in my family. But you do what makes you happy. If saying 'don't forget your mums birthday tomorrow' is too much like wifework for you then that's fair enough. To me it's just being nice.

Many women are doormats without realising. Doing all the emotional labour in a family because that’s what they have always done.

IncompleteSenten · 01/03/2024 23:01

MrsCarson · 01/03/2024 08:16

I have a question.
All of you who don't remind your partner and don't send any cards/texts to the in-laws for birthdays, do you receive cards/texts wishing you a happy birthday from your in-laws?

No.

Catsmere · 01/03/2024 22:36

He "can't" remember his own mother's birthday? Writing it on a calendar is too hard, presumably. He sounds like my father and brother - they'd do Mother's Day because of all the ads, but remembering Mum's birthday was too hard.

No. Let him grow up and mark a date that's more relevant to him than you. You're not a PA.

TwylaSands · 01/03/2024 22:34

He could take seconds out of his life and create a reminder of his phone.

He cannot be arsed and he thinks it is beneath him.

i bet he doesnt need endless reminders about the car service and mot.

Ewock · 01/03/2024 22:31

No I wouldn't remind him. They give you no thought and he is their son not you. If he can't be bothered to put in a diary/on a calendar why should you be the one who has to remember these things?
I don't understand women/men who treat their partners as if they are children. They work, manage to live then they can remember a birthday if they want to

IncompleteSenten · 01/03/2024 15:45

Yes. It'd be interesting to know how many men have to remind their female partners of their (the female partner) family birthdays every year (several times in a short space of time every year for each event. eg 6 reminders it's their mum's birthday coming up. Your mum's birthday is next month, your mum's birthday is in a fortnight, your mum's birthday's in a week, your mum's birthday is the end of this week, your mum's birthday is this weekend, your mum's birthday is tomorrow...) and how that compares to the number of women who remind their male partner of their (male) family birthdays in the same way.

Also how many other things are annual fixtures in their lives that they can't remember and are unable to set reminders for for some unspecified reason and so require repeated external prompting every single year and often physical help to meet the requirements of the annual event eg buying gifts, sending cards etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread