Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband scammed. Change house to my name?

166 replies

Sunnydaysaregreat · 29/02/2024 19:56

It's looking very likely my husband has invested tens of thousands of pounds (turns out most of it is his family's as they thought he knew about money) in a scam investment. Spoke to FCA and Fraud Action already, both brilliant and gave help.

Although I'm shocked, I'm being calm with my husband and intend to talk about how we go forward, and pay back his family (I've been advised we're unlikely to get much money back). I'm trying to keep it together but the red flags were so clearly all over these companies, it's actually worried me so much that he is a liability for our financial safety (we have young children).

AIBU to tell him I want to house transferred into just my name? Obviously there's a huge trust issue in that he was doing all of this investing without telling me, but it's husband judgement I'm most concerned about. I'm going to talk to Citizens Advice tomorrow to ask about how this is done.

Advice appreciated as while I am being sensitive to the fact that he has absolutely been scammed, his judgement makes me feel unsettled.

OP posts:
Coolblur · 01/03/2024 14:31

Surroundyourselfwiththerightpeople · 01/03/2024 13:28

I would check if the house being in your name actually makes any difference. I think you may find that If you are married it doesn’t matter whose name house is in if one of you is pursued for debts. I believe at that point technically you each own 1/2 of everything. I am not an expert but have looked into it.

This is not true. Debt accumulated in one person's name is theirs alone, regardless of marrital status. However, if they have assets in joint names, a house for example, then they could be pursued to pay their debt using those assets. The spouse cannot be pursued to pay their DH/DW's individual debt, nor can their individual assets be seized. So in this case, putting all assets into her name is the best way of protecting them.

In the event of divorce all assets go into the 'pot' to be divided, regardless of whose name they're in. Debt is only shared if it's in joint names.

NewNeighbour007 · 01/03/2024 14:29

My ex DH ran up debts without my knowledge. I only discovered that he had a CCJ (County Court Judgement) against him when we were refused a joint mortgage on our first flat.

He told me his debt was 'none of my business'. I said it absolutely was if it was stopping us getting a place together.

I had to go to my parents, cap in hand, and ask them to be the guarantors for my mortgage, embarrassing at the age of 28 (I was fully solvent, decent job, no debt) as I had to take the mortgage on alone.

He told me it was only a grand, which I was furious about because I could have paid that off immediately - AND he'd been buying designer clothes the week before.

Of course he was lying. It was much more - £8K (but this was the 90s, so much more in real terms). I was furious when I found out he'd lied. Even his mum was when I told her!

My dad said to call the wedding off - so I did, and moved back to theirs, but of course, I was then bombarded with calls and letters. In the end, I thought love could conquer all.

Once married, I found out he was online gambling into the wee small hours. When I approached hm about it, he hissed, "Don't worry I won't gamble YOUR house away" (everything had stayed in my name, despite his daughter moving in with us when she was 11).

Luckily when we divorced the house was in my name and I gave him a lump sum to buy him out of his (tiny) share of it. That was 6 years after the first red flag.

Don't ignore the red flags for years like I did.

The man who hides his finances from you and puts you, his children and his wider family at risk is not to be trusted, whatever his motivations. Any future with him will always be precarious at best.

Idontusuallypostonherebut · 01/03/2024 14:19

Sorry haven't read all of the responses here, but I'm sure that if the house is mortgaged in both names you can't take his name off, unless you can mortgage the property without him (at least what I was told with my ex).

Also just to add it might be worth checking that he hasn't taken any debt against the house already /any other credit in your name.

Sorry you're going through this

Surroundyourselfwiththerightpeople · 01/03/2024 13:28

I would check if the house being in your name actually makes any difference. I think you may find that If you are married it doesn’t matter whose name house is in if one of you is pursued for debts. I believe at that point technically you each own 1/2 of everything. I am not an expert but have looked into it.

Ramalangadingdong · 01/03/2024 13:25

missmollygreen · 29/02/2024 20:08

YABU
Im sure you have never made a mistake. Im sure he feels terrible enough.
What do you hope to gain by taking him off the house deeds?!

I just assumed that she wanted to ensure that they didn’t lose the house (through debts he might have incurred).

Mamaraisedadoughut · 01/03/2024 13:23

It becomes like a gambling addiction, so yes.
I would get him to move his name off the deeds, and I'd remove his access to savings, and I would ensure everything in the house was in my name, not his.

With secret investing comes secret debt, and if he's sneaking about with his investing (I now call it gambling!) Chances are he will continue to sneak about doing it...before you know it, bailiffs are at your door.

Stability for your children should be paramount to both of you, so he should really agree.

Hoping it doesn't continue, maybe the embarrassment will be enough from having lost extended family members money too

LovelyTheresa · 01/03/2024 13:11

missmollygreen · 29/02/2024 20:08

YABU
Im sure you have never made a mistake. Im sure he feels terrible enough.
What do you hope to gain by taking him off the house deeds?!

Don't be absurd. This isn't a simple 'mistake'. The OP's husband has been both duplicitous and stupid. I would actually be considering divorce over this, but if I didn't divorce him, I would most certainly want all assets in my name and to be in complete control of finances from here on in. I wouldn't even let him be buying a coffee for the forseeable future. What a moron.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 01/03/2024 11:38

Well he's a fool isn't he? The trust would be gone from this marriage and I'm afraid I'd have to divorce him.

Geebray · 01/03/2024 11:23

Also, as he has been stupid/greedy enough to fall for this scam, his details will have been sold on to other scammers. And as others have said, being found out as an idiot will make him vulnerable to trying to get it all back somehow. Especially as you say he is "proud", and the shit is about to hit the fan with his family, as well as you.

Geebray · 01/03/2024 11:21

Oh dear OP. I fear that you are just at the beginning of finding out what he has actually done.

@TiredCatLady has given you an excellent To Do list. Keep strong.

hellsBells246 · 01/03/2024 11:18

HelloHappyCampers · 29/02/2024 20:00

I wouldn't just start with the house I would sit down with him and a financial adviser/solicitor and work everything out. All your assets/money/savings/other investments etc. Have a full financial health check and then take control yes absolutely. Once scammed they usually fall for it again one day so you do need to get in control.

Yes, this.

And the trust issue is a massive one. Why didn't he talk to you about this investment? Does he have form for this?

Parentofeanda · 01/03/2024 11:03

Oh and they did divorce, unfortunately she got nothing as they lost the house by then and all savings gone, but i know she's doing better now as she is with someone new and very happy :)

Parentofeanda · 01/03/2024 11:02

this happened to someone i know, timeline went

Husband borrowed 25k from his parents and lost it all on a bitcoin type scam.
He felt like crap so instead of being honest he took his and his wifes savings of 17k and gambled it. With every win he would double his bet and lose it all til it was all gone.
He then remortgaged there house and put it all on an investment scam.

He lost everything, they lost the house and all of their savings and his parents never got the retirement fund back and are now on Benefits in old age instead of enjoying they're time. Was really sad

TiredCatLady · 01/03/2024 10:52

I’m sorry this is happening to you - it’s honestly a betrayal at least as bad as infidelity.

Some steps, because when someone has lost a lot of money, they very seldom want to admit exactly how much straight away.

First, check all bank accounts, statements, credit cards for the entire time period this has been going on and identify the transactions or transfers. That’s his accounts, joint accounts and your accounts too. Make a note of how much, anything identifiable and any patterns. This will help you to work out the scale of the loss and also flag anything that happens going forward.

Second, credit checks for both of you so you can work out if he has put debt in your names.

Third, check for charges against your home and whether that is now at risk directly. If you’re also on the mortgage and he has done so without your knowledge then that’s fraud.

Fourth, the other parties involved. Has he borrowed their money and invested it on their behalf or his own? Or had he simply convinced them to invest in the same thing as him and they did it themselves? That part is quite key when it comes to whether they can sue for the money.

He will likely drip feed or minimise it and it may take some time for you to find out exactly what has gone on. That the police are already involved suggests it’s pretty serious.

Next steps - ringfence your own accounts, hide or cut up credit cards, get him off any joint account. Set up an alert on your property (land registry) so you will know if anyone tries to place a charge against it. Keep on with the regular credit checks. If there is also debt involved, be aware bailiffs may turn up depending on what stage it’s at.

Unfortunately scam victims, much like gamblers, can be in denial and keep throwing money after it convinced it will all come right etc.

This scale of financial stupidity would be a deal breaker for me - placing your and your children’s home and financial security in jeopardy would be the end. I’d be doing the above checks and then looking to divorce.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 01/03/2024 10:08

Re the house - I think you can have the house just owned by you, so he can’t borrowed against the value/equity, but if you get divorced, it won’t matter it was just in your name when any split of assets was agreed.

you really need him to come clean if he’s already borrowed against the value of the house, and a new agreement that he doesn’t make any investments or gambles without discussing it with you first.

be clear this a betrayal comparable to cheating.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 01/03/2024 10:04

There’s an old saying that you can’t cheat an honest man.

basically he needs to accept he took greedy and reckless actions out of greed. He needs to admit he was scammed and it would have been obvious to someone less greedy.

re family, there is a massive difference between if he borrowed money from them and invested in his name or if he encouraged them to invest in their names, and if the profit was going to come to him or them.

if he borrowed from them, you need to set up plans to repay them. If they were also greedy and no doing basic checks (and they know he’s not an accountant or financial advisor), then while morally you might feel you need to repay it, I’d not prioritise that.

definately you need full checks to make sure he hasn’t taken loans out you don’t know about.

Uricon2 · 01/03/2024 09:50

I would absolutely despise anyone who put my/children's security at risk to basically gamble on a get rich quick scheme through greed, compounded by the fact he didn't tell you about it ( I imagine because he knew you wouldn't agree)

You're trying to get a handle on what's happened but what is he doing to start sorting this out? Do his family know about the lost money yet? I think the chance of him throwing good money after bad to "try to recoup" is very high.

TheRulerofThings · 01/03/2024 09:49

OP you need to watch carefully for recovery scammers. They may contact your husband (or you) and tell him that they can get the money back but will just scam him out of further money. They are a big risk as those who have lost large sums can be desperate and vulnerable to any supposed opportunity to get the funds back. You need to make sure you can see any transactions he is making and possibly even advise friends not to lend him money or make payments on his behalf.

kiwiane · 01/03/2024 09:46

I would divorce him as it’s a form of gambling. You need to ensure that you can secure a home for yourself and your children.

3luckystars · 01/03/2024 09:43

I can’t believe how calm you are being?

Tens of thousands of pounds would take us many many years to accumulate, if ever.

It’s just gone.

Are you extremely wealthy?

Cailin66 · 01/03/2024 09:43

missmollygreen · 29/02/2024 20:08

YABU
Im sure you have never made a mistake. Im sure he feels terrible enough.
What do you hope to gain by taking him off the house deeds?!

Seriously ! This is not a "mistake". He borrowed money in secret to "invest" in dodgy products, wanted to do even more damage until his wife stopped him and kept everything a secret from her. He can't be trusted with money.

Cailin66 · 01/03/2024 09:41

Sunnydaysaregreat · 29/02/2024 21:09

Yes Shoppingshamed it would be drastic but it was such a huge amount invested (he got sucked into a "guaranteed" high return for lump sum investments) and I should add he was going to invest more. It was simply me finding out and contacting FCA that stopped him putting even more money in. I absolutely feel so sorry for him because he is a proud man which is why I'm being very calm with him and talking about ways forward. But to be honest, my protective instinct has gone into overdrive to make sure my children are financial secure.

Not too proud to borrow money from family in some quack get rich scheme.

Why were his family so gullible as to loan him money?

Not too proud to put your and the children's financial future at risk.

Not too proud to share it with his wife that he was risking all your finances. You need to take control of the family finances. And if there is even half a chance he would dare borrow against your home then yes you need to try and get that in your name alone.

Not only is putting money into guaranteed high return investments stupid, it's even worse to borrow to do so. And of course there is no guaranteed high returns anywhere. When he wasn't getting the high returns why did he try and continue to throw away even more money?

Is he a gambler?

Nanny0gg · 01/03/2024 09:39

missmollygreen · 29/02/2024 20:08

YABU
Im sure you have never made a mistake. Im sure he feels terrible enough.
What do you hope to gain by taking him off the house deeds?!

Financial security?

This is one hell of a big 'mistake'!

betterangels · 01/03/2024 09:35

I couldn't trust a man who did that. What if you hadn't found out? He's a reckless liar, basically.

Time to find out how deep it goes.

muggart · 01/03/2024 09:32

Clever scam or not, investing tens of thousands without your wife's knowledge is not acceptable.

This is exactly right.

Solidarity OP. This happened to me except I was aware that my DH makes investments so he wasn't lying or hiding anything, but one did turn out to be a scam and we lost a huge amount. There was no deceit though, it was just poor judgment, so it didn't impact cause a rift in our marriage.

If your DH is effectively lying and stealing from shared funds then yes you should take sole control of the finances.