Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are those 'Acts Of Service'? Or just the basics?

31 replies

moderationincludingmoderation · 29/02/2024 14:37

DH is not particularly physically affectionate. Less so than ever, due to various stressful life events.

I feel I need it more than ever, also due to various stressful life events and Perimenopause/age/having a babies has made me feel insecure in my looks, so I think I need those small signs of affection/attraction.

By affection I don't mean physical intimacy necessarily (This is lacking though),
I mean random hugs, the odd compliment etc. Not a lot.

DH argues that he shows affection/support through acts such as walking the dog, getting things done around the house etc. Making me tea in the morning etc.
He is great around the house and a great co-parent, we absolutely share all the load.
But highlighting those things as signs that you love someone feels lazy to me.
I can see that, yes, being there, doing life with someone shows that you love them and you choose them... but it's not quite the same is it?

I understand that Acts Of Service is some peoples main love language. But do standard shared house hold tasks that serve BOTH parties/the whole household or relationship basics (like making a cuppa) really count as AOS?
Because, I do all those things too.
Aren't those just base level expectations of the human you live with and are in a relationship with?

I manage to do all those things, plus more, PLUS do lots of extra acts of service and be affectionate, and plan nice gifts and dinners etc.

I adore him, we are soul mates, but I think he may be due a bit of gentle kick up the arse? AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PictureFrameWindow · 01/03/2024 16:22

I think you're maybe missing the fact that he's doing these things to respond to your needs. Cooking a big lunch for your family so you wouldn't be stressed out and could enjoy their presence is a great example. Fair enough about the dog! But what he's saying is that he regularly puts himself in your shoes and tries to either anticipate or directly respond to your needs and wants. It does sound like maybe you're not seeing that as an active effort. (But I'm acts of service so maybe I'm incredibly biased 🙈).

moderationincludingmoderation · 01/03/2024 16:10

To add, he is also not good at talking about emotions etc.
He got very good at burying his away.

I think this is another reason why he finds it hard to sympathise sometimes, enough to feel it's time to offer a hug. Because none was afforded to him.

OP posts:
moderationincludingmoderation · 01/03/2024 16:07

He can be affectionate. He is with our DC, the dog, some elderly friends.

And he can be with me. But I think he just goes in phases and sometimes, if his mind is tied up with other things, as a PP said, it just doesn't occur to him!

I haven't asked him directly but we have had many conversations over the years in which the topic of affection, or similar, understanding etc comes up. It doesn't take a genius to understand how being sent away to boarding school in another country at age 10 could affect someone. He was left to essentially fend for himself and when he was crying and missing his mum, there was no-one to give him a hug. He had to toughen up, create a shell and get on with it, alone, quickly.
This is why I try to have a lot of patience and grace for this side of him.

OP posts:
BallaiLuimni · 01/03/2024 13:36

I think the Acts of Service thing is a bit of a red herring and a distraction. He does his fair share, which is great, but you want affection and he doesn't give it to you. In that situation you have three choices:
Suck it up, accept he's not affectionate and live with a lack of affection
Try to find a way to make him more affectionate
Leave

On a personal level, I HATE when I tell someone I'm upset about a particular thing and they say 'But I do this other thing!' To me, it's very dismissive as it deflects the actual point and shuts you down.

A mature, considerate response from your DH would be 'I'm sorry that it upsets you, let's think about how we can fix it,' or even 'Sorry I know it's not great but I don't think I can change.' He should at least take your concerns seriously and realise the effect it's having on you.

I am a very affectionate person and couldn't live without a lot of touch - luckily DH is also very affectionate so there's a good match. Despite how great he is I would really struggle to tolerate a lack of affection for a long time so I do think this is an important issue and not something to be glossed over.

Have you asked your DH why he's not affectionate?

Cordeliacordyline · 01/03/2024 13:08

Findwen · 29/02/2024 21:47

I think there may be more to 'I did the hoovering for you' than is perhaps appreciated. It is a household task of course - but people (regardless of sex) have different standards.

There are 10 specks of dust on the floor.
You are happy when then there is 1 or less.
They are happy when there is 6 or less.
They do the hoovering when there was 3 because they wanted to do it for you.

So DH and I had this issue. He’s happy to live with dirt and chaos. He doesn’t register it. I am much happier in a clean and tidy house. This became a source of conflict, with him not doing a fair share and me getting exhausted. So we did an exercise.

We each had bits of paper with all of the domestic and household chores on (one bit of paper for each chore and we each had our own bits of paper - an identical set).

Then across the kitchen table we had timings from twice a day, right up to biannually and never. We then, independently, without discussing, put each chore in the zone that reflected how often we each felt it should be done. So that we could get to a middle ground on any where there was a disparity.

There was very little difference in where we put things. Some he felt should be done more often than me.

He hadn’t been socialised to put any effort into these things. I had. And he didn’t care if the standards he wanted weren’t met, but, enjoyed living in a clean organised house more.

What has helped is that now we have a Democratically decided set of standards and whenever the old trope he used use comes out (well I’m only doing this for you, you are the one with the high standards etc) I can remind him that the standards are OUR mutually agreed standards and he needs to do his FAIR share of it.

And now, mostly, he does. Just occasionally he will say ‘but I do all this for you’ no. You do it because it needs to be done and you agreed to these standards.

moderationincludingmoderation · 01/03/2024 08:51

I think the specks of dust example is useful as a concept though and I know what that PP means.
BUT, this is not something necessarily reserved for couples. This type of caring & showing love are also done in plutonic scenarios. Out of love, respect etc.

I agree that the little thoughtful more personal things, like arranging the pillows for you or running the bath with your favourite bubble bath etc, feel more initimate.

fyi all, my DH didn't use the term 'Love Language' & doesnt even know it exists as a concept!
He just pointed out that as I had been stressed and we had a lot to do he had walked the dog, made the bolognese (for a big family lunch involving my family) etc.
Which I do appreciate! And I do see how that was an 'act of service' but throwing in the dog walk was a bit rich I thought.. cos he always walks the dog on that day!

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 29/02/2024 22:02

There are 10 specks of dust on the floor.
You are happy when then there is 1 or less.
They are happy when there is 6 or less.
They do the hoovering when there was 3 because they wanted to do it for you.

Sounds like an unlikely scenario to me.

Findwen · 29/02/2024 21:47

I think there may be more to 'I did the hoovering for you' than is perhaps appreciated. It is a household task of course - but people (regardless of sex) have different standards.

There are 10 specks of dust on the floor.
You are happy when then there is 1 or less.
They are happy when there is 6 or less.
They do the hoovering when there was 3 because they wanted to do it for you.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 29/02/2024 21:40

I think it’s a bit unfair to write things off as “just daily tasks” because there’s lots of things that you could say are a daily task that actually someone does do for you out of love/to show they love you.

For you. That's the point. Doing the hoovering isn't 'for you'. It's just a household task. Running you a bath, arranging your pillows for you, yes.

Nagado · 29/02/2024 21:31

I think the whole idea around love languages is a bit stupid, but putting that to one side, an act of service is supposed to be doing something for someone you love. Things like defrosting the car when he’s not going to be using it, or taking the time to make you a lunch to take to work. He’s not doing the hoovering for you. It’s not your mess. It’s household mess and something you’re both responsible for. So taking away those chores, what is he doing to contribute to your relationship? If he believes in that rubbish enough to have identified his particular way of showing he loves you, what is he doing to ‘serve’ you?

Mrsttcno1 · 29/02/2024 18:55

I think it’s a bit unfair to write things off as “just daily tasks” because there’s lots of things that you could say are a daily task that actually someone does do for you out of love/to show they love you. For example I cook lovely meals for us for dinner, we eat them together, but that doesn’t mean it’s not an “act of service”. At the moment as I’m heavily pregnant my husband often just goes and runs me a bath, takes our dog for a walk, fills my water bottles up and puts them in the fridge for me so there’s always one there waiting for me when I need one, if I’m getting off the sofa to go for a wee (which as you can imagine, 8 months pregnant, is about every 3 minutes) he will stand up and give me a hand up from the sofa, he changes our bed sheets and organises all my pillows into place for me going up to bed so I can just climb straight in, he puts my slippers and dressing gown on the corner of the bed so I can easily slip into them in the morning, brings me a cup of tea or orange juice in the morning, brings me back a bottle of juice and some sweets from the corner shop even though when he asked I said I didn’t need anything, and so so many more…none of these things are particularly romantic and you wouldn’t read about them in a love story or see them in a rom com, but that’s how he is showing me every single day that he loves me, he’s taking care of me, they aren’t grand gestures or particularly a massive effort or special, but they mean the world to me and I wonder if maybe there are lots of little things like that which you’re maybe not seeing for what they are, or are just taking for granted as a given after so long together? I’d rather have the calm, solid and steady kind of love that we have than have the crazy, highest of highs and lowest of lows we see on films and in books! X

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/02/2024 18:38

I remember the days with an ex when I'd stagger in through the door after work absolutely shattered, hungry, tired, stressed and see the utter chaos that was waiting for me to deal with - and not even be offered a drink if he was literally standing in front of the kettle at the time.

The last thing I wanted at that point was for him to start pawing at me for 'a cuddle'. He, naturally, complained that I wasn't affectionate enough towards him, but when I'd be up to my elbows in foetid sink water trying to find a mug and not think about the smell from the stuff he'd dumped on top of the full bin, I really wasn't in the headspace for that.

DP, however, amongst myriad other things, does drinks, cooks, listens to my moaning about work and makes sure I have a nice packed lunch every day. The sheer amount of things he does for my benefit (as he'd not eat anything like as fancy/expensive/healthy as I like, would be fine if he didn't have to hear my venting about a shitty day and doesn't have a lunch himself, so doesn't need to be making one at all) vastly outweighs the fact that I usually need to go up to him if I want a hug, as he doesn't tend towards seeking them out.

It might feel weird, but maybe he could come to see giving you a hug/etc as another positive act like bringing you a cuppa? OK, you would need to request them at least at first, but it could work without it feeling like a criticism.

laclochette · 29/02/2024 18:32

The whole concept of Love Languages was concocted by a conservative American pastor, so the fact that it very easily can be used to justify some pretty regressive things - like men only doing the mere basics for their wives and classing them as "acts of service" - is hardly surprising. It has no research or evidence basis.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 29/02/2024 18:32

I show care in the small things - bringing back a coffee, making sure the house is kept clean and tidy because if it wasn't it would cause them stress

Doing your fair share of looking after your own house is not a favour or an act of service to anyone else. Men (quite rightly) get flamed for saying to their female partners 'I did the hoovering for you'. Surely that applies just as much to women?

HollyKnight · 29/02/2024 18:32

moderationincludingmoderation · 29/02/2024 18:22

Sorry if it didn't come across - I do show him appreciation. We both show each other appreciation. We acknowledge often that we are a great team and feel we have a great balance.

I was just questioning whether those shared tasks fall under 'Acts Of Service' in regards to love languages. I have realised I would like more. It sometimes feels like we're best friends (which is lovely) but nothing more.
In my early 40's, I don't feel ready to say goodbye to romance.
You're right. I need to speak up more and make it clearer.. I have done in the past. Mentioned that I would love a hug, or that I'm sad we arent more intimate. I have been holding back though as I know he has a lot on his mind.

Yes. Just say to him straight what you want from him at that moment. Actually say to him "Can I get a hug". Don't do that vague thing of "I would like you to hug me more often" because if that kind of thing doesn't come naturally to him, he isn't going to know when to do it, and you're just going to feel even more disappointed for getting your hopes up. If he loves you, he will want to please you. But he's not going to suddenly become a mind reader and do these things spontaneously.

moderationincludingmoderation · 29/02/2024 18:28

@pickledandpuzzled

Thanks and you're right, maybe I am taking those things for granted after 20 years.
Though i will argue that the tea in bed is now occasional after being a regular thing which did make me sad and was a bit of a catalyst for this whole train of thought actually!

But I definitely take what you say on board.

p.s I also put a huge amount of effort into meals, good food etc. I guess I would say that is one of my AOS.. and one could argue it's also just a daily household task!

OP posts:
twingiraffes · 29/02/2024 18:26

DH thinks I appreciate all the things he does in the house (a lot, to be fair) because he's doing it for me. I think he still subscribes to the view that all housework is women's work, and that him doing some chores is showing his love for me, because I don't then have to do it.

My view is that since we both live here, him doing the hoovering, taking the bins out or cleaning the toilet is not showing his love for me, it just needed doing and he is equally responsible.

londonloves · 29/02/2024 18:24

Contributing equally to the running of a household you both live in is not an act of service. It's up there with "I did the washing up for you" or "I'll babysit the kids".

moderationincludingmoderation · 29/02/2024 18:22

HollyKnight · 29/02/2024 17:25

Would you say a SAHM shouldn't expect acknowledgment and appreciation for what she does at home for the family because it is "the basics"? I think any time anyone does something that benefits you, even if it benefits them too, it should be appreciated. Because you would really notice it if they stopped doing those things.

You should be able to acknowledge that your DH is showing you that he loves you with his actions, while also wanting him to show you it in a way that means something to you. i.e. affection. Keep talking. Ask for a hug when you want one instead of saying nothing, thinking he should know.

Sorry if it didn't come across - I do show him appreciation. We both show each other appreciation. We acknowledge often that we are a great team and feel we have a great balance.

I was just questioning whether those shared tasks fall under 'Acts Of Service' in regards to love languages. I have realised I would like more. It sometimes feels like we're best friends (which is lovely) but nothing more.
In my early 40's, I don't feel ready to say goodbye to romance.
You're right. I need to speak up more and make it clearer.. I have done in the past. Mentioned that I would love a hug, or that I'm sad we arent more intimate. I have been holding back though as I know he has a lot on his mind.

OP posts:
moderationincludingmoderation · 29/02/2024 18:14

Janehasamane · 29/02/2024 15:42

I don’t think you can force someone to be affectionate. To bully them into complimenting you and being affectionate. If a man wrote this, and that is wife needed a kick up the arse he’d have his arse handed to him. And be branded a sex pest.

you need to sort your own issues around insecurity out. You cannot bully your husband into being a performing seal.

The kick up the arse comment was tongue in cheek...

I would never bully anyone or force them to do something.

I appreciate him a lot. I just find myself missing romance and feeling desired.

I would never force someone to show me that. I want them to want me.

I was just having a laugh, clearly that didn't come across to you.

OP posts:
Tropicalsunshine · 29/02/2024 18:14

My DH and I have talked about this in counselling. I want affection, he doesn't think of it. He just doesn't want it himself. Our counsellor taught me to ask for what I need and him to try and give it. I learned to not criticise what he doesn't do but tell him what I would like. He loves me so he is trying to do some of the things I ask for.
So a kiss before bed, a hand on a knee etc.
People are different and their needs are different.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 29/02/2024 18:06

Not really if that's his share of the housework. For me it's the little extras for example, at. Iggy, after kids in bed, my husband ALWAYS asks me if he can get me something (cuppa, snack, a gin ☺️), if I have had a long day or if I say I am cold he'll make a fire for me or would run me a bath, he knows how much I dread defrosting the car, so sometimes he does that for me.

HollyKnight · 29/02/2024 17:25

Would you say a SAHM shouldn't expect acknowledgment and appreciation for what she does at home for the family because it is "the basics"? I think any time anyone does something that benefits you, even if it benefits them too, it should be appreciated. Because you would really notice it if they stopped doing those things.

You should be able to acknowledge that your DH is showing you that he loves you with his actions, while also wanting him to show you it in a way that means something to you. i.e. affection. Keep talking. Ask for a hug when you want one instead of saying nothing, thinking he should know.

Janehasamane · 29/02/2024 15:42

I don’t think you can force someone to be affectionate. To bully them into complimenting you and being affectionate. If a man wrote this, and that is wife needed a kick up the arse he’d have his arse handed to him. And be branded a sex pest.

you need to sort your own issues around insecurity out. You cannot bully your husband into being a performing seal.

pickledandpuzzled · 29/02/2024 15:41

moderationincludingmoderation · 29/02/2024 15:33

So well put @pickledandpuzzled

To be fair, he does do some of those, like make tea for only me and bring it up etc.

But I guess after 20 years, that doesn't feel 'romantic' and more just 'automatic' if that makes sense?

So I’d say there’s an element of you taking some things for granted. Take it as one who knows, you’d feel sad if he didn’t do it!

One of the things that made me like DH when we first met was him carrying the basket round Tesco for me. It’s really easy to stop seeing this stuff.

Perhaps you both need a chat about being appreciative? I cook every day- nutritious, tailored to us meals that I plan, shop for and cook. I avoid trashing the kitchen. No one says thank you, or ‘that was nice’, anymore.