Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fund this particular child’s school trip?

115 replies

Oxpenswife · 29/02/2024 14:18

I need some objective advice on whether I’m being petty here.

I have 2 children, my DD is at a local independent school, when my son reached schooling age he started at the same school but due to his SEN it wasn’t a good fit, our local primary however has an amazing SEN set up, and he has flourished there since starting in year 1. He has been there for 1.5 years now.

Since he started I’ve always made sure to spend what I would have spent on his school fees to help support his current school. Although it’s a nice school, like many they’re underfunded so I contribute financially in various areas, the head teacher usually sends me each class teacher’s ’Amazon wish list’ at the start of each term and I will usually buy all the items needed (craft supplies mainly or spares for stationary) last year I arranged new laptops for the class library as many children do their homework there instead of at home etc. and last summer I covered the cost for their Forrest school area to be redone. I have no issue with supporting in this way as it benefits my son at the end of the day.

Now onto my AIBU

DS is due to go on his first school trip in 6 weeks time, I’ve been asked by the deputy head if I am able to fund the kitty that’s used to pay for children who can’t afford the trip to go. I was more than happy to say yes until I overheard when picking DS up yesterday that one of the boys from the year above would also be joining this trip if the kitty could be covered, he is not allowed to go on trips with his year group due to concerns around supervision (and he has been violent before on trips according to playground gossip)

I emailed the head straight after leaving and asked for clarification around what the kitty would be used for, she admitted it would be for those whose parents can’t afford the cost plus the cost for an extra TA so this older child could attend.

AIBU to say no to funding the additional resource so a child from another class can gatecrash this trip?

OP posts:
Ledl54 · 29/02/2024 15:02

But there’s no precedent for donating to help only kids in her son’s year that has been established?

caringcarer · 29/02/2024 15:02

You say the SEN DC who is 1 year older than your sons class could not go the year before because there was no TA to support him. If you really want all DC to feel included you'd not refuse the general kitty so several DC in your DS's class and the 1 older DC can not go. I'm assuming the older boys parents will find his place it's just the TA you will fund. I think it's really odd you pay for so much at your DS's school but as you do it's not nice to be discriminatory against the older DC who couldn't attend the year before through no fault of his own other than no TA available to attend. All the other DC will get to experience this trip except one. One day your DC might be the difficult DC who needs a TA and other DC might not want your DS to attend.

NoOrdinaryMorning · 29/02/2024 15:00

I'm with you, OP. That money could fund a child in that year who can’t afford to go

Ledl54 · 29/02/2024 14:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Pheasantsmate · 29/02/2024 14:59

If I were you I wouldn’t fund the kitty and just use the money for a great educational and fun day out for your own children. If the trip gets then your kids still get a great day out. If the few kids in the class don’t go your son gets 2 nice days out.
It also sets a line in the sand for the school that you are happy to donate but they can’t take the piss.
if this was a child in your sons class I agree it would be wrong to exclude him- but it sounds like he is an expensive child to look
after and his own class kitty can’t manage it so the school are changing the parameters to get the resident cash cow to stump up. I think the school have behaved quite improperly here. Knowing you will pay for your son and his peers- essentially moving temporarily a child that needs additional funding so you will end up covering it.

BlusteryLake · 29/02/2024 14:59

You have inadvertently wandered into a highly inappropriate situation where you are buying influence on school policy without being elected to do so by any other parents. Fine to make a one-off donation for a specific thing, but you can't start dictating school policy with your money.

Woodyandbuzz1 · 29/02/2024 14:59

I think your overthinking it op. This child won't be allowed to go on a rampage hurting other kids just because he's on a school trip.

Lifeinlists · 29/02/2024 14:58

Singleandproud · 29/02/2024 14:47

An individual funding a state school like this is nice but entirely inappropriate. Fundraising for items no problem and the children can get involved but using you as a cash cow is not. Nor should a private' investor'be able to dictate to a school how they spend their money on or on which children.

It really isn't appropriate and could lead you unwittingly into very difficult situations. Is this a Local Authority school and do they know this is happening?
You're already being pressured into giving money for something you're not comfortable with. Focus on your son's needs and stop playing Lady Bountiful.

Remona · 29/02/2024 14:58

This is a ridiculous situation. I can’t believe you’re giving the school £15-£20k a year. That’s just crazy. I bet the school can’t believe their luck. Giving you an Amazon wish list and you buy everything on it?!

You either give the school a set amount a year for them to do with as they wish or you don’t give them anything at all. You really can’t start attaching strings to your donations. I think you’ve got yourself into an untenable situation. Personally, I think you should spend that money on extra-curricular activities for your son or even put it aside for his further education.

Mrsttcno1 · 29/02/2024 14:58

Shinyandnew1 · 29/02/2024 14:53

If I say no to funding the kitty unfortunately a few children won’t go this child included

Thats not usually how it works. With school trips, if there is not enough parental contributions and the school cannot cover it, the trip is cancelled-they don’t just leave a few children out.

That’s not true.

In most cases (I think even all now in England at least) parents are told of the trip and the cost e.g. £20, parents either give permission for their child to attend or not, if they do then they pay for THEIR child, they don’t “contribute” more than the cost for their own child to attend. Most schools have a “hardship fund” type situation which is typically money from fundraisers etc and if there are children in a class who’s parents would like them to go on a trip but can’t afford it then they can apply for money from this fund to cover it. That is what’s happening here basically, theres people who want to go but their parents cannot afford to pay it so they are relying on “hardship fund” to cover those children, if OP doesn’t want to pay the “kitty“ then the money isn’t available for those kids to go.

AffIt · 29/02/2024 14:56

I think a private individual donating this amount of money to a state school sounds incredibly off.

Have you ever seen their accounts, OP? How are these donations reported? What do other parents think?

I'm sure this isn't your intention, but it does look as though you are playing - or at least have the opportunity to play - kingmaker here and I would be wary of how that sits with other, less wealthy parents.

ToasterChic · 29/02/2024 14:56

Crunchymum · 29/02/2024 14:34

So you'll be happy to fund the trip if this one child doesn't go?

I'd be absolutely fucking livid if a parent was allowed that sort of control or input at my kids school?

Can you not see how exclusionary this is?

I agree. If I was found out this was happening, I would report the school to OFSTED and complain in writing to the governors. Even if the excluded child wasn’t mine. What you are doing and what the school is allowing is immoral. You and your child aren’t more important than any other child just because you’ve got money to throw at the school.

LittleMousewithcloggson · 29/02/2024 14:56

Say no
Donate to specific projects that are long term for everyone only eg Forest school, expensive technical equipment, sports equipment etc
That way no one can ever say you are favouring (or discriminating against) anyone and it can’t become personal or make anyone feel you have any control with school decisions
You are buying specific things for the whole school only - as straightforward as that

Oxpenswife · 29/02/2024 14:55

Heronwatcher · 29/02/2024 14:50

I imagine if the OP won’t fund this the school will find the money from somewhere else anyway.

Has your child had any negative interactions with the older child in the time he’s been at school?

No he hasn’t, the school is quite split for reception and year 1 compared to the rest of the school (different playgrounds etc.) but I have heard a lot of bad stories from other parents

And I know it’s just gossip but I’m just a bit scared for DS, it would be his first trip and he will already be a bit out of sorts with the change in routine etc.

OP posts:
PhoenixStarbeamer · 29/02/2024 14:55

You know there are charities the school can apply to who will fund minimum of 70% of the costs of school trips for the children that cannot afford it. Some cover the full cost. They also get pupil premium funding from the government for every child who has parents with a low income, and can use that to cover trips or TAs.

Heronwatcher · 29/02/2024 14:53

I want to help those in DS’s class to attend, but also don’t want to if it means some of the money will be used to get an older child on the trip.

Why not? You do realise that the difference between one school year and the next one down is a matter of 24 hours in some cases? Plus my kids have friends all across the school years. If the school think they’d all be fine together do you really know better?

Shinyandnew1 · 29/02/2024 14:53

If I say no to funding the kitty unfortunately a few children won’t go this child included

Thats not usually how it works. With school trips, if there is not enough parental contributions and the school cannot cover it, the trip is cancelled-they don’t just leave a few children out.

Oxpenswife · 29/02/2024 14:53

Dahlietta · 29/02/2024 14:51

But you are trying to dictate, even if that isn't your intention. You are effectively saying, I will fund it, but only if it doesn't mean that that child comes.
As others have said, it's very murky. What will happen when your child appears to get any special treatment and the other parents find out that you give thousands of pounds to the school?

I’m not though

I would never refuse to just refuse the one aspect of the kitty

As rightfully so I can’t do that

My debate is funding the kitty or not. If not then this child and a few in DS’s class will miss out

OP posts:
UnbeatenMum · 29/02/2024 14:53

One the one hand this is your charitable giving and it's reasonable to pick and choose where your money goes. But in the other hand it's not anonymous and you clearly have a positive relationship with the school that you want to continue. So I think if you decide to say no you need to make it about your principles around giving and not any this specific child. E.g. I prefer to fund resources that benefit larger numbers, benefit DS personally or last a long time.
Personally though I think it sounds like you were going to say yes before the boy was mentioned and it seems like a good use of money. Unless he's been violent towards your DS personally I would go ahead and assume he will be well supervised by his 1:1.

PhoenixStarbeamer · 29/02/2024 14:53

I think it is really rude to ask you to fund a TA for someone in a different year.

Oxpenswife · 29/02/2024 14:52

imnottoofussed · 29/02/2024 14:50

What would you do if they hadn't asked you to fund it but you found out this child and a 1-1 was going on the trip. Would you be happy to let the trip go ahead then when you've got absolutely no control over the matter?

I think the level of your input is quite astounding to be honest.

I’d have raised concerns with the SENco and decided after discussing whether to pull DS from the trip.

OP posts:
Dahlietta · 29/02/2024 14:51

But you are trying to dictate, even if that isn't your intention. You are effectively saying, I will fund it, but only if it doesn't mean that that child comes.
As others have said, it's very murky. What will happen when your child appears to get any special treatment and the other parents find out that you give thousands of pounds to the school?

Oxpenswife · 29/02/2024 14:51

blankittyblank · 29/02/2024 14:49

Agree with this. this agreement you have with the school is bordering on unethical! How can you get to decide who does and doesn't attend a trip? Either the money is there or it isn't. I would feel very uncomfortable with you making decisions for my child.

I don’t get to decide who does and doesn’t go

If I say no to funding the kitty unfortunately a few children won’t go this child included

OP posts:
imnottoofussed · 29/02/2024 14:50

What would you do if they hadn't asked you to fund it but you found out this child and a 1-1 was going on the trip. Would you be happy to let the trip go ahead then when you've got absolutely no control over the matter?

I think the level of your input is quite astounding to be honest.

Heronwatcher · 29/02/2024 14:50

I imagine if the OP won’t fund this the school will find the money from somewhere else anyway.

Has your child had any negative interactions with the older child in the time he’s been at school?