Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fund this particular child’s school trip?

115 replies

Oxpenswife · 29/02/2024 14:18

I need some objective advice on whether I’m being petty here.

I have 2 children, my DD is at a local independent school, when my son reached schooling age he started at the same school but due to his SEN it wasn’t a good fit, our local primary however has an amazing SEN set up, and he has flourished there since starting in year 1. He has been there for 1.5 years now.

Since he started I’ve always made sure to spend what I would have spent on his school fees to help support his current school. Although it’s a nice school, like many they’re underfunded so I contribute financially in various areas, the head teacher usually sends me each class teacher’s ’Amazon wish list’ at the start of each term and I will usually buy all the items needed (craft supplies mainly or spares for stationary) last year I arranged new laptops for the class library as many children do their homework there instead of at home etc. and last summer I covered the cost for their Forrest school area to be redone. I have no issue with supporting in this way as it benefits my son at the end of the day.

Now onto my AIBU

DS is due to go on his first school trip in 6 weeks time, I’ve been asked by the deputy head if I am able to fund the kitty that’s used to pay for children who can’t afford the trip to go. I was more than happy to say yes until I overheard when picking DS up yesterday that one of the boys from the year above would also be joining this trip if the kitty could be covered, he is not allowed to go on trips with his year group due to concerns around supervision (and he has been violent before on trips according to playground gossip)

I emailed the head straight after leaving and asked for clarification around what the kitty would be used for, she admitted it would be for those whose parents can’t afford the cost plus the cost for an extra TA so this older child could attend.

AIBU to say no to funding the additional resource so a child from another class can gatecrash this trip?

OP posts:
Herdinggoats · 29/02/2024 16:10

Underhisi · 29/02/2024 16:01

The school shouldn't have discussed another child with you.

It's fine to state that you don't want donations to be spent on staffing. It isn't fine to say the donation cannot be used to fund staff for a particular child.

It isn’t fine when it is a class trip for the school to move kids that aren’t in that class into it for the day to benefit from the fact that that particular class kitty is more generous! How about next year when the school moves two kids into the class for the day because they missed out on trips because their own kitties couldn’t cover them. The school have put the OP in an awful position.

”Will you fund the kids in the class who can’t go?”
“Yes”
“great we’ll move another one over so you can pay for them too”

Abysmal, cheeky fuckery by the school

Underhisi · 29/02/2024 16:01

The school shouldn't have discussed another child with you.

It's fine to state that you don't want donations to be spent on staffing. It isn't fine to say the donation cannot be used to fund staff for a particular child.

Timshortforthalia · 29/02/2024 15:56

It’s up to you if want to fund this or not.

A separate issue is whether or not you discuss this particular child’s involvement in the trip with the school.

If you don’t fund it, you’d be wise not to mention why.

If you cross the line and try to discuss this child, the school would be wise to no longer accept your money for any purpose.

ChimneyPot · 29/02/2024 15:47

I have only read the first two pages of replies but I am horrified that a principal spoke to you about a pupil who is not your child.
This sounds highly unprofessional it not illegal,

If I were that child’s parent and I found out my child’s personal information had been discussed with another parent I would be complaining.

TeaAndStrumpets · 29/02/2024 15:47

gamerchick · 29/02/2024 15:14

Like a daydream.

Or one of those hand-wringing "problems" so beloved of The Guardian.

Smells off to me.

kcchiefette · 29/02/2024 15:43

I think you are utterly insane to donate this kind of money. For clarity, this is some people's yearly wage!

You are being far too generous and kind and the school are taking advantage of it.

E.g. if I had the money, I would maybe do a couple of "one-off" projects such as building a SEN area or revamping the playground, but it certainly wouldn't be happening on a recurring basis.

Shinyandnew1 · 29/02/2024 15:42

Mrsttcno1 · 29/02/2024 14:58

That’s not true.

In most cases (I think even all now in England at least) parents are told of the trip and the cost e.g. £20, parents either give permission for their child to attend or not, if they do then they pay for THEIR child, they don’t “contribute” more than the cost for their own child to attend. Most schools have a “hardship fund” type situation which is typically money from fundraisers etc and if there are children in a class who’s parents would like them to go on a trip but can’t afford it then they can apply for money from this fund to cover it. That is what’s happening here basically, theres people who want to go but their parents cannot afford to pay it so they are relying on “hardship fund” to cover those children, if OP doesn’t want to pay the “kitty“ then the money isn’t available for those kids to go.

That’s not the process in any school I’ve ever worked in. Are you a teacher?

GlossyPaper · 29/02/2024 15:41

I wonder if a physically violent child should join older rather than younger kids? It’s a strange decision anyway. Surely his behaviour needs to be managed in his own peer group.

Do other parents know you do this OP? If what you have written is true, it’s unusual enough to be very identifiable to teachers and parents at your school.

Skiphopbump · 29/02/2024 15:40

If there aren’t enough contributions towards the school trip the whole trip will be cancelled. Individual children can’t be excluded due to lack of finances. The school shouldn’t be making you feel that if you don’t pay then some children will miss out.
I think the amount you are contributing is insane. I don’t know how much spare money you have but it would be better spent on private Ed psych/OT/S&LT assessments, therapy as needed, a solicitor to get a really strong EHCP, after school clubs etc.

ApoodlecalledPenny · 29/02/2024 15:35

You’re talking about a year one child when you say he’s a violent bully? Yeesh.

This all sounds extremely unusual.

isthesolution · 29/02/2024 15:35

Do you think what the money is being spent on directly helps YOUR child? If not, is it better to do something that will directly help them? An extra member of staff directly employed for your child? A private tutor? Music lessons etc?

The money you spend on your other child's schooling is directly for that child not just for a teachers Amazon wish list.

CurlewKate · 29/02/2024 15:27

"I would get more involved in the schooling decisions if I was you."

I think the head/governors would be putting themselves in a completely invidious position if they gave a parent that sort of involvement. I am amazed they are happy with it situation as it is, never mind taking it further.

Hotgirlwinter · 29/02/2024 15:22

BlusteryLake · 29/02/2024 14:59

You have inadvertently wandered into a highly inappropriate situation where you are buying influence on school policy without being elected to do so by any other parents. Fine to make a one-off donation for a specific thing, but you can't start dictating school policy with your money.

100% this.

If it were an independent then I would accept nepotism as a fact of life.

But another parent ploughing money into a state school and then using it to personally influence the decisions of staff. Absolutely not. I hope your donations and the way they are spent are clear and transparent for all the parents

Hotgirlwinter · 29/02/2024 15:18

Wow, this sounds very weird and controlling OP. Donating to a charity but then wanting to dictate how the donation is spent, down to input on the garden design? Now you want to exclude children from trips.

You honestly sound off your head.

IntriguingFactJumble · 29/02/2024 15:18

I would NOT pay for that child to go along. Unlikely one TA would make enough difference to ensure no trouble.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 29/02/2024 15:15

So why not pay for an extra TA just to accompany your son, or even better an extra 2 TA's to be with your son, and your son only - then you will have no worries at all regarding this other child being there with his TA because with 3 TA's available they will be able to keep both children very separate.

Then stop listening to playground gossip !

gamerchick · 29/02/2024 15:14

Ledl54 · 29/02/2024 15:12

This just seems too unlikely to me, the amount of money involved, and that a school would get into a situation like this with such an obvious moral hazard.

Like a daydream.

gamerchick · 29/02/2024 15:13

That's the problem with a bit of a god complex, it grows the ego.

Youve got yourself into a weird situation. It needs better handling by the looks of it.

inkblackheart · 29/02/2024 15:12

You're completely mad to do this and it isn't really even benefitting your son. Use the money to pay for tuition for him or clubs or trips he would enjoy and put the rest into a fund for him when he's older and might want to go to university.

Ledl54 · 29/02/2024 15:12

This just seems too unlikely to me, the amount of money involved, and that a school would get into a situation like this with such an obvious moral hazard.

TheHateIsNotGood · 29/02/2024 15:08

YABVU - it's great that your local primary has a "great SEN set up", apparently it is also inclusive for SEN dc other than your DS. Do you really listen to school gossip about other, probably SEN dc? The school probably thought you might more understanding of SEN.

It's still early days OP, be careful, one day it might be your ds that is the subject of schoolgate gossip.

takealettermsjones · 29/02/2024 15:08

So you're helicopter parenting and throwing your money around and they're accepting bribes? 🥴

LipstickLil · 29/02/2024 15:07

LittleMousewithcloggson · 29/02/2024 14:56

Say no
Donate to specific projects that are long term for everyone only eg Forest school, expensive technical equipment, sports equipment etc
That way no one can ever say you are favouring (or discriminating against) anyone and it can’t become personal or make anyone feel you have any control with school decisions
You are buying specific things for the whole school only - as straightforward as that

I agree with this and also with the point that by asking you to fund other specific DC's places on a trip (and thereby giving you a veto on whether those DC get to attend or not), the school has wandered into inappropriate territory.

I think, if I were you, I would tell the school in writing that from now on you wish to make it clear that you will only fund things that benefit the school and the pupils as a whole and not things for individual DC. Hardship funds that pay for disadvantaged DC to go on trips should be raised via school fundraisers/PTA events that are labelled as such and not rely on the generosity of any one parent.

MrsKarlUrban · 29/02/2024 15:06

I see what you're doing and it's lovely of you but I do think it sounds like you are their own personal wallet
I would cut down the amount in future and put the rest aside for things your child would like ??
I do think it's a bit off, older child on the younger children's trip - unless the TA that you would be paying for is very attentive and keeps him on track ??

easylikeasundaymorn · 29/02/2024 15:05

Crunchymum · 29/02/2024 14:34

So you'll be happy to fund the trip if this one child doesn't go?

I'd be absolutely fucking livid if a parent was allowed that sort of control or input at my kids school?

Can you not see how exclusionary this is?

I can certainly see your point but the other POV is that OP was asked to fund one thing (money for the kids in her ds's class to go on a trip) and the school were sneakily planning to use the money for something slightly different (a child in a different class to attend).

In which case I don't think it's U for the OP to want the current arrangement - the school asks for money for specific purposes and she then agrees if it's something she wants to spend money on -to continue and not see this as the start of a slippery slope whereby school thinks its ok to ask her for money for something, she agrees but they then spend the money on something else.

The argument regarding whether the whole thing is morally ethical could be debated for a while - if you took a utilitarianism or "greatest good" philosophy it would be the case that the OP providing this funding positively affects many pupils therefore is better to continue it even with her conditions meaning one child might be treated unfairly than to stop it with the consequence multiple children lose out.

However I suspect if you said "I'll pay for the kids in ds class to go but not for x" then the school would say "Great! We've put your money towards those kids and we've funded x from elsewhere." So if you're adamant you don't want x to go then you'll probably have to refuse funding the trip at all.

The other option is to separate the 2 issues - if you really think x attending will be of detriment to your son (sounds unlikely tbh) then ask the school what their plans are to ensure this won't happen, regardless of how he's funded to attend the trip.