Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is all therapy about blaming your parents?

44 replies

Giveupnow · 29/02/2024 13:31

interested in heating from any one with any knowledge of counselling/ therapy with different types. I’m burnt out and have anxiety and probably PTSD from medical trauma and a tough last few years. I’ve tried personal integrative, and now transactional analysis and both therapists seem intent on focusing on my childhood. There is a lot to unpick there but I’m not sure how much more unusual than strict 80s blame/ critical style type parenting that I’m sure lots of us had. I don’t know… my parents weren’t great in that they were very busy, stressed and strict and didn’t really care about the impact it might have on us but I feel guilty about questioning my upbringing so much, when in reality they tried their best. There just wasn’t the emphasis then on child well being or how parents need to nurture their childrens self esteem and emotions?

OP posts:
Giveupnow · 29/02/2024 16:21

@BallaiLuimni wpyld you mind telling what type of therapy your husband had please?

OP posts:
Leonarda89 · 29/02/2024 15:46

As pp has said, EMDR or CBT are possibly more helpful therapies based on what you have described.

In terms of thinking about parenting in general, I would highly recommend reading "The book you wish your parents read".

DyslexicPoster · 29/02/2024 15:44

CBT never touches on your past from what I have been told with multiple cbt on the nhs

Runningwildish · 29/02/2024 15:40

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/02/2024 14:55

Read the poem, Your Mum and Dad They Fuck You Up. Try hard, read a lot, listen to your children and care about their needs and wants, You'll do better, you won't be perfect.

That was my parenting book as well, I think that poem should be in every parenting book. My kids are grown up now and they've said we didn't do too badly as parents, so I'll take that as a win.

BallaiLuimni · 29/02/2024 15:36

Giveupnow · 29/02/2024 14:52

These are all great responses, thank you. Can I ask - does the average person know/ reflect on this? I’m now a parent and am
trying my absolute hardest but find it extremely difficult and worry I’m causing future issues for my children. Nothing specific, just run of the mill stuff - am I too strict? Am I too lax? Not knowing how to handle big feelings. have no idea what a ‘normal’ parent looks like.

I’ve read all the gentle parenting stuff etc so I’m not asking for those recommendations, I’m just wondering how abnormal I am, compared to the average mid 30s parent of young children, in terms of my own emotional regulation etc.

This is exactly the reason why you should be examining your childhood - it will definitely help you to get more of a handle on your own parenting and to get some clarity on how you want to raise your children.

I had a fairly shit childhood but had addressed it to a certain extent in therapy which helped. My DH had a run of the mill childhood and always believed his parents were great, there was nothing wrong with how he was brought up etc. We were on the verge of divorce because he was turning into his dad (grumpy, lazy, disconnected) and it was only when he examined his childhood that he woke up and recognised the coping mechanisms he'd developed that were destroying his relationship with me and with the kids. The change in him was genuinely hard to believe - we went from being on the brink of splitting up to a very strong, loving relationship and I can say hand on heart that he is the best dad I've ever come across - fun, engaged, loving, without being too lenient.

You will make mistakes as a parent, it's inevitable. IME what makes the difference is the ability to recognise those mistakes and rectify them. Apologising makes an absolutely massive difference - if you get things wrong, acknowledge that and say sorry. Your child will see that you're a human, you're not perfect but you know that and you can see when you've hurt them.

Bkjahshue · 29/02/2024 15:00

You sound very much like me; I think I became a bit more understanding about my parents when I became a parent and realised that they were just trying their best. I accept that with my own children I won’t get everything right and I’ll make different mistakes to my own parents but I’ll keep on doing my best.

ListerMummy · 29/02/2024 14:59

It you have PTSD from medical trauma, you should probably look into something targeted specifically for that. EMDR and trauma-focused CBT are the two major therapies used for trauma. Neither of those would involve blaming your parents unless they were directly involved in some way (which seems unlikely).

NothingVenturedAndAllThat · 29/02/2024 14:57

Giveupnow · 29/02/2024 14:52

These are all great responses, thank you. Can I ask - does the average person know/ reflect on this? I’m now a parent and am
trying my absolute hardest but find it extremely difficult and worry I’m causing future issues for my children. Nothing specific, just run of the mill stuff - am I too strict? Am I too lax? Not knowing how to handle big feelings. have no idea what a ‘normal’ parent looks like.

I’ve read all the gentle parenting stuff etc so I’m not asking for those recommendations, I’m just wondering how abnormal I am, compared to the average mid 30s parent of young children, in terms of my own emotional regulation etc.

Parents mess their kids up. That's just a reality. It's also a product of the fact that every generation typically develops more awareness than the one before them. So, in comparison to your parents, you'll do a better job. And then the next generation will identify things in the parenting we're accustomed to that aren't so great and they'll get therapy for those things. You can only do as well as you know how to do. Read, learn, do the best you can, but know that no parent is perfect and there will be issues they have to work through.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 29/02/2024 14:56

Giveupnow · 29/02/2024 14:52

These are all great responses, thank you. Can I ask - does the average person know/ reflect on this? I’m now a parent and am
trying my absolute hardest but find it extremely difficult and worry I’m causing future issues for my children. Nothing specific, just run of the mill stuff - am I too strict? Am I too lax? Not knowing how to handle big feelings. have no idea what a ‘normal’ parent looks like.

I’ve read all the gentle parenting stuff etc so I’m not asking for those recommendations, I’m just wondering how abnormal I am, compared to the average mid 30s parent of young children, in terms of my own emotional regulation etc.

These are exactly the things that brought me to therapy, OP. Best thing I ever did for myself.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 29/02/2024 14:56

Amber2384 · 29/02/2024 13:48

I wouldn’t see it as blaming your parents - the majority do the best with what they know at the time. For me, it’s been really helpful for me to look at how my childhood shaped me and led me to develop behaviours which are not serving me as an adult and causing me undue anxiety in my own parenting. I don’t blame my parents at all but by breaking it all down I can now recognise when unhelpful thought processes and behaviours start and stop them in their tracks. This has led to a great reduction in my own anxiety and, I think, led to me being a more patient and understanding parent.

This

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/02/2024 14:55

Read the poem, Your Mum and Dad They Fuck You Up. Try hard, read a lot, listen to your children and care about their needs and wants, You'll do better, you won't be perfect.

Giveupnow · 29/02/2024 14:52

These are all great responses, thank you. Can I ask - does the average person know/ reflect on this? I’m now a parent and am
trying my absolute hardest but find it extremely difficult and worry I’m causing future issues for my children. Nothing specific, just run of the mill stuff - am I too strict? Am I too lax? Not knowing how to handle big feelings. have no idea what a ‘normal’ parent looks like.

I’ve read all the gentle parenting stuff etc so I’m not asking for those recommendations, I’m just wondering how abnormal I am, compared to the average mid 30s parent of young children, in terms of my own emotional regulation etc.

OP posts:
Eyesopenwideawake · 29/02/2024 14:04

I should have just agreed with the excellent post from @Amber2384 😁

Whatsthesecret · 29/02/2024 14:03

Your childhood gives insight into how your coping mechanisms formed and why you are the way you are.

Eyesopenwideawake · 29/02/2024 14:02

It's not (generally) about blaming parents, it's about understanding how your childhood shaped you.

Why is this important? Between the ages of about 18m and 10yrs you learn at a faster rate than at any other time in your life. You watch, you hear, you experience and you absorb at a prodigious rate. However what you can't do in that period is think logically and rationally about what you learn - you simply don't have the ability.

So ideas become facts and you develop your core beliefs; the deeply held 'truths' about who you are, what the world is like and how you fit in. Core beliefs can be both negative "I am not good enough" or positive "I am a natural sportsperson" - negative ones aren't a sign of abusive or neglectful parenting - they can just be mistaken notions that you developed about yourself.

That's why therapists often want to delve into your childhood - that's where the story started.

Amber2384 · 29/02/2024 13:48

I wouldn’t see it as blaming your parents - the majority do the best with what they know at the time. For me, it’s been really helpful for me to look at how my childhood shaped me and led me to develop behaviours which are not serving me as an adult and causing me undue anxiety in my own parenting. I don’t blame my parents at all but by breaking it all down I can now recognise when unhelpful thought processes and behaviours start and stop them in their tracks. This has led to a great reduction in my own anxiety and, I think, led to me being a more patient and understanding parent.

haveyougotamin · 29/02/2024 13:45

Can't agree with above poster more. It's about understanding how your environment affected you growing up (not solely parents) and how this contributes to your responses/perspectives/etc etc. if you aren't aware and don't understand it, it's more difficult to change

KreedKafer · 29/02/2024 13:43

It's not about 'blaming' your parents, but everyone is shaped by their childhood so it's useful for the therapist to be able to unpick what experiences might affected/influenced the way you think about things and react to situations.

For instance, my parents were fab parents and I completely adore them. They were in no way abusive or neglectful and there is nothing about my upbringing I could 'blame' them for - I had a broadly happy childhood and was safe and loved in a stable, non-chaotic household. But both my parents are very much people who will joke their way through the most awful situations, and that's definitely affected the way I use humour as a coping mechanism (not always in a way that's healthy). Neither I nor a therapist would 'blame' my parents for that, but it does help a therapist to unpick why I've got a dark sense of humour about the worst things that have happened to me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread