Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Airbnb host gave us a bad review!

220 replies

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 10:37

This is the first time I have used Airbnb. So perhaps I'm not versed at how to properly use it.

However, we spent up from 3.5 k for a house for a week and I think we had to pay around 200-250 for cleaning.

This was in a southern European country.

We have two young kids and we had a nice time but had to leave early due to a family emergency.

We stripped all the beds and put all towels and sheets in the washroom.

We cleaned the kitchen and sweeped the floors.

Some rubbish was left in the bins outside, because the weekly collection came after we already left.

We apologised for this and they told us not to worry.

We received a bad review - all around the fact that we left all the bedding and towels in the washroom and that they could see children's finger print marks on a lot of surfaces and on windows. They also mentioned that there was some sand on the floor under the beds. Obviously we didn't sweep well enough.

I don't really understand why I need to pay a cleaning fee if I need to clean windows ?

I'm never using Airbnb again.

OP posts:
2catsandhappy · 29/02/2024 13:32

I have read on MN to take photos of how you leave the place.
A tip I will use in future.

PictureFrameWindow · 29/02/2024 13:29

I don't use it much now exactly because of this, some hosts seem to pocket the cleaning fee.

Movinghouseatlast · 29/02/2024 13:26

whiteroseredrose · 29/02/2024 13:22

I use Booking dot Com, who often have the same properties on but without the extras and chores.

It's the host who adds the rules to the property, it doesn't matter what platform you book on.

Movinghouseatlast · 29/02/2024 13:25

AmethystSparkles · 29/02/2024 13:09

I think the reviews are only posted publicly once both have been submitted. If I get a bad feeling about the host in any way, I don’t leave a review.

There’s the problem that if you make any sort of complaint to the host, you then cant risk leaving a review because they’ll be expecting a bad review and will leave you a bad review in retaliation. Mostly we’ve had good experiences but in one house, there were no smoke detectors and the host kept the front door permanently locked so there was no way out except through the kitchen which meant walking though every room. Then when I complained he belittled me and said I was having an ‘episode’!! Airbnb did nothing. Nothing’s regulated so there’s no guarantee that smoke and carbon monoxide detectors will be fitted.

Interlinked Fire alarms in every room is now regulated. (Carbon monoxide alarms are a legal requirement to meet building regs.) Anyone with a holiday let who doesn't have interlinked fire alarms can be closed down. You need to complain to the fire brigade in the area the property is in, they have the authority to close the property down.

Air BnB, booking.com, cottages.com, Sykes etc don't regulate self catering properties they are merely advertising platforms

whiteroseredrose · 29/02/2024 13:22

I use Booking dot Com, who often have the same properties on but without the extras and chores.

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 13:21

PaulGalico1 · 29/02/2024 13:15

I use Airbnb regularly and rely on reviews to help me make an informed decision. Smelly sheets are absolutely unacceptable and I would want to know.

To me it's not great but overall, we had a nice time and I was able to revivify it. The house wasn't dirty overall and it didn't ruin my holiday.

OP posts:
MrsKintner · 29/02/2024 13:19

Sounds like you both left false reviews then Grin

PaulGalico1 · 29/02/2024 13:15

I use Airbnb regularly and rely on reviews to help me make an informed decision. Smelly sheets are absolutely unacceptable and I would want to know.

AmethystSparkles · 29/02/2024 13:09

I think the reviews are only posted publicly once both have been submitted. If I get a bad feeling about the host in any way, I don’t leave a review.

There’s the problem that if you make any sort of complaint to the host, you then cant risk leaving a review because they’ll be expecting a bad review and will leave you a bad review in retaliation. Mostly we’ve had good experiences but in one house, there were no smoke detectors and the host kept the front door permanently locked so there was no way out except through the kitchen which meant walking though every room. Then when I complained he belittled me and said I was having an ‘episode’!! Airbnb did nothing. Nothing’s regulated so there’s no guarantee that smoke and carbon monoxide detectors will be fitted.

PansyOatZebra · 29/02/2024 13:06

This is why I don’t use air bnb. It’s not a holiday if you have to worry about cleaning etc.

I have used them twice and that was years ago.

I also don’t like the fact that some hosts leave all their belongings there. We booked a cottage in Wales and it was so cluttered with the host’s stuff. We now book through “holiday cottages” for U.K. cottages now.

Justbeenfined · 29/02/2024 13:05

You gave a glowing review because.... Karma?? That's nuts and very unhelpful.

PumpkinPieAlibi · 29/02/2024 13:04

Don't write off all AirBnBs because of one experience OP. It's specific to that host and not the platform as a whole.

I've used it 3 times in the last 2 years and would rate my first 2 experiences as 5/5 stars and my last as 4/5 stars. Thanks to using an AirBnB rather than a hotel, we were able to stay in a lovely apartment in Cap Estate, St Lucia overlooking the Royalton golf course and views of the Atlantic for just under $600USD for the entire week which was a steal! The area was beautiful (celebrities have homes there) and filled with 5-star resorts (Body Holiday, Sandals Royalton, Cap Maison) but totally unaffordable if we didn't book through AirBnB.

So what I'm saying is, don't miss out on huge savings and potentially great vacations in the future because of one experience.

Norahsbooks · 29/02/2024 13:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

LittlePinkLampshade · 29/02/2024 13:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WaitingForSunnyDays · 29/02/2024 13:00

I think the cleaning expected from the guest also depends on the country. In France in chain holiday apartments our experience was that you were expected to leave the place pretty much immaculate. The list of cleaning tasks before you left was a page long, and that appeared to be perfectly standard.

Catza · 29/02/2024 12:59

Don't be put off using AirBnB - it's not like all hosts are part of one large corporation. I have my property on there and I have never left a bad review, nor have I expected the guests to clean after themselves. I have cleaners coming in before every guest. Obviously, I would be pissed off if you trashed the place or had a pet chewing on furniture or something outside of normal holiday mess.
To be honest, guests aren't angels either when it comes to reviews. Someone left me one start review the other day because of bad weather.

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 12:57

@fedupwithbeingcold

No it's not !!

The place was great, yes the sheets smelled bad, but I could rectify it.

Overall the place was really nice and another family will have a good time there.

I looked at the overall picture when I left my review and decided that the hosts had been really really lovely to us and the sheets / internet situation could be lived with and it wasn't worth leaving a bad review for that. So no it was not dishonest !!!!

OP posts:
fedupwithbeingcold · 29/02/2024 12:51

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 11:56

I just feel bad leaving bad reviews. I know it's stupid. But it's someone's livelihood potentially isn't it.

How selfish! Your glowing review might mean that another family spends their hard earned money on booking a place with smelly sheets. All because you couldn't be honest!

It's very dishonest of you

Janehasamane · 29/02/2024 12:51

This is all very extreme. Not to use air b n b again over one bad review, instead of just not using that host, and putting a fake good review up as you’ve unusual and irrational superstitions about reviews.

its very unhealthy way to react over something so minor

rookiemere · 29/02/2024 12:46

The difference between booking.com and Airbnb is that no review is requested of the holiday maker from booking.com unless they wish to reply to someone's review.

I've only used Airbnb a couple of times but have had a less than glowing review from VRBO
as nephew and his family were last to leave our shared rental property and they aren't renowned for their cleanliness and they managed to bungle up key return despite my very explicit instructions.

phoenixrosehere · 29/02/2024 12:46

theresnolimits · 29/02/2024 12:30

I use AirBnb or Vrbo at least six times a year, in the UK and abroad. I’ve never had a bad experience. The reviews are crucial and I wouldn’t choose one that isn’t highly reviewed. I’d be furious if I read a false glowing review for a dump - although I’d cross check with other reviews.

I tidy, wash up, empty bins mainly because I hate to be in a messy place. I tidy in hotel rooms too! It takes me 15-20 mins and is a check I haven’t left stuff in/under the bed etc. I have never hoovered., washed floors, stripped beds. And I have never had less than a 5 star review - ever!

I will say I’ve moved more onto VRBO lately because the prices are completely transparent about n the first page. I also think they have more properties as owners have moved across.

But would I want to spend evenings sitting on my bed in a hotel room rather than relaxing in a lounge with a glass of my own wine? And don’t say ‘go to the bar’ because at £10.50 a glass, I’m not interested in adding £40 onto my bill for a couple of drinks.

Equally, do I want to sit around in a hotel bedroom waiting for DH to get up, or would I rather relax over a coffee in the living room?

We’re all different but long live self catering.

Same.

I’ve never had a bad experience either whether I’ve traveled alone or with family. I’m particular about where I stay and will look through reviews, examine the pictures, the location, read the house rules, check the cleaning fee etc to see what kind of hosts and their expectations.

Saying that, for me and our family, we’re not often in the Airbnb or a hotel for long periods and it’s usually just a place to mainly sleep and have breakfast.

toomuchfaff · 29/02/2024 12:36

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 10:54

So I have never left a bad review for anything in my life. It's just not my style. I feel like it's bad karma.

I left a glowing review. Even though there were some issue. The sheets were sticky and smelled really bad and I washed them before we slept in the beds- same with blankets. It's unacceptable really, but I didn't mention it to the hosts I also didn't write it in the review.

In addition, the intent was rubbish.

Not happy about the situation and will never use it again. I wish I could delete my glowing review. But I can't. I still wouldn't leave a bad review but I shouldn't have left a good one.

Maybe you need to go back and rewrite your review. Facts - not bad mouthing.

The fact you had to wash the bedding - fact
The fact you paid a £250 cleaning fee and got a bad review because you didnt sweep up

You can let others know your experience without it turning to a derogatory review.

I hate AirBnB for this reason. What was the £250 for if they dont clean anything? My cleaners come in, they clean the whole house spotless for £39, admittedly no washing but ffs that is ridiculous.

LittlePinkLampshade · 29/02/2024 12:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Movinghouseatlast · 29/02/2024 12:34

Travelsweat · 29/02/2024 11:57

This happened to us several years ago, also after having cleaned the property, swept/mopped, stripped the beds, etc. It was our first and last time using Airbnb—we were accused not only of leaving it in a state of ‘enormous filth’ (which we absolutely did NOT, even though we had so paid a hefty cleaning fee), but also of crazy things like putting holes in the skirting boards and ruining the sofa; things which were unequivocally false. I am sure the owner used us to as an excuse to make fraudulent insurance claims since we didn’t have a leg to stand on as first-time users. I’m happy to use booking.com for non-hotel properties, but I absolutely loathe Airbnb as a result of our experience and I will never use them again.

That's a terrible experience.

You do know booking.com has mostly the same self catering properties as Air BnB though? Run by exactly the same people? They are just advertising platforms.

I do think the Air BnB 'you are expected to clean' is turning into a bit of an urban myth. I've stayed in loads and never been expected to clean. I've also read thousands of reviews of other properties ( research for my own) and have never seen it mentioned that the hosts expected the guests to clean. And this would be something people would mention in a review.

DoAWheelie · 29/02/2024 12:33

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 10:54

So I have never left a bad review for anything in my life. It's just not my style. I feel like it's bad karma.

I left a glowing review. Even though there were some issue. The sheets were sticky and smelled really bad and I washed them before we slept in the beds- same with blankets. It's unacceptable really, but I didn't mention it to the hosts I also didn't write it in the review.

In addition, the intent was rubbish.

Not happy about the situation and will never use it again. I wish I could delete my glowing review. But I can't. I still wouldn't leave a bad review but I shouldn't have left a good one.

What's the bloody point of giving a review at all if you are going to lie in it. The whole point of them is to find out as a community, what is actually worth doing/buying/going to and what is shite. If everyone just lies and says it's great no matter what the whole thing is useless.