Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Airbnb host gave us a bad review!

220 replies

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 10:37

This is the first time I have used Airbnb. So perhaps I'm not versed at how to properly use it.

However, we spent up from 3.5 k for a house for a week and I think we had to pay around 200-250 for cleaning.

This was in a southern European country.

We have two young kids and we had a nice time but had to leave early due to a family emergency.

We stripped all the beds and put all towels and sheets in the washroom.

We cleaned the kitchen and sweeped the floors.

Some rubbish was left in the bins outside, because the weekly collection came after we already left.

We apologised for this and they told us not to worry.

We received a bad review - all around the fact that we left all the bedding and towels in the washroom and that they could see children's finger print marks on a lot of surfaces and on windows. They also mentioned that there was some sand on the floor under the beds. Obviously we didn't sweep well enough.

I don't really understand why I need to pay a cleaning fee if I need to clean windows ?

I'm never using Airbnb again.

OP posts:
fliptopbin · 29/02/2024 14:24

We had an airbnb specify that the flat was to be fully swept and vacuum cleaned before departure, although they did not provide a vacuum cleaner or even a brush! We tried contacting them, they insisted that they were in the flat, so we were worried we would be accused of stealing them or something.Luckily we got in early with our review stating this, because they replied saying that they had arrived at the flat to realise that they had not left us keys to the utility cupboard with the cleaning utensils in.

AnImaginaryCat · 29/02/2024 14:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Exactly. If the negative issue is something the host can (should) improve it's in their control to improve it so as to not affect their livelihood.

It's not like giving a negative review because it was raining or you got sunburn when you were there.

ohtowinthelottery · 29/02/2024 14:21

Having just spent days looking at properties in Spain for a small group holiday for a special birthday, I'm grateful for all the honest reviews posted - it has made me rule out quite a few properties. That said, even though I've used Airbnb before, I avoided them this time due to the ridiculous cleaning policy some hosts seem to have. If I'm paying a cleaning fee, I expect them to clean. Obviously, we leave rentals tidy with no obvious dirt, but I'm not about to get my duster out when I'm on holiday - nor will I strip beds (although I made an exception during Covid).

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 14:14

Newestname002 · 29/02/2024 14:10

@airbbbnb

But I can't. I still wouldn't leave a bad review but I shouldn't have left a good one

You could have left a polite but factual review though, especially if you'd let the hosts know the problems you had. 🌹

I didn't let them know. So I also thought it wasn't fair.

I just got on with it. I wasn't in the mood to start complaining about something I was easily able to fix. We were busy and just wanted to enjoy our holiday etc. not everyone is the same.

Also the people seemed really really nice and I just wanted to get on with my holiday. There was a lot going on, on a family level too, which is hard to explain here. We were just busy.

OP posts:
Newestname002 · 29/02/2024 14:12

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 11:56

I just feel bad leaving bad reviews. I know it's stupid. But it's someone's livelihood potentially isn't it.

For which you are paying handsomely. 🌹

NotARealWookiie · 29/02/2024 14:11

Airbnb has gone massively down hill. The nightly fees have gone up, the platform fee is high and now so many people charge a cleaning fee but expect you to clean!

Just don’t use it again.

ireallyshouldreadmybook · 29/02/2024 14:10

Airbnb is just a platform that a lot of landlords use so it's not Airbnb's fault. Having said that the first time we used them, the host made a claim against our deposit and said we'd smashed a lamp and had hidden the broken pieces at the bottom of the bin. We definitely didn't and even if we had broken something I would own up and pay for it.

Thankfully just before we left, I happened to take a photo of the room (to send to my mum) and you can clearly see the lamp in the shot. Airbnb accepted that as evidence and we got our deposit back. Just like everywhere else, some landlords are absolutely going to try it on.

Newestname002 · 29/02/2024 14:10

@airbbbnb

But I can't. I still wouldn't leave a bad review but I shouldn't have left a good one

You could have left a polite but factual review though, especially if you'd let the hosts know the problems you had. 🌹

Funkyslippers · 29/02/2024 14:09

MonsteraMama I'd much rather have an apartment or house than a hotel room. OH goes to bed later than me, DD needs her own bedroom & I like to have a kitchen & living room

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 14:06

@Stravaig no one else left any bad reviews for this host. It's a risk we all take when we go on holiday.

For me it wasn't ideal that I needed to wash the sheets, but the place was great apart from that and I would recommend it.

OP posts:
Stravaig · 29/02/2024 14:04

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 11:56

I just feel bad leaving bad reviews. I know it's stupid. But it's someone's livelihood potentially isn't it.

It's also the hard earning savings of every person who books that holiday accommodation based on your inaccurate and dishonest glowing review!!! 🤯

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 14:00

IncompleteSenten · 29/02/2024 13:51

I wonder if the sheets stank because the host doesn't wash them between guests

They smelled like fried food.

Maybe someone fried something in the house and left the doors open so the smell went onto the sheets. That was the smell. It was odd.

The blankets in the cupboards also smelled like that, to the extent that I thought someone had transported fried food in them or something.

It was definitely odd. All the mattresses had clean looking and clean smelling mattress protectors on them and pillow protectors were also clean, as were the pillows inside.

I couldn't make sense of it. But it was strange and not pleasant.

They didn't look dirty, just had a weird smell and felt strange against skin.

OP posts:
Justbeenfined · 29/02/2024 13:51

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 13:21

To me it's not great but overall, we had a nice time and I was able to revivify it. The house wasn't dirty overall and it didn't ruin my holiday.

Dirty sheets are totally unacceptable honest to god your standards must be low

IncompleteSenten · 29/02/2024 13:51

I wonder if the sheets stank because the host doesn't wash them between guests

beAsensible1 · 29/02/2024 13:50

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 11:56

I just feel bad leaving bad reviews. I know it's stupid. But it's someone's livelihood potentially isn't it.

Yes but it’s not great for anyone coming after expecting a decent stay when the place has sticky sheets and duvets.

honesty is fine. There’s no need to be cruel, but matter of fact is good.

i read the reviews for everywhere, it’s super annoying. This has reminded to do the rest of my reviews for my holiday

whitenoisemachine · 29/02/2024 13:49

I think this is quite common with air b&b.

Went on my honeymoon to a beautiful place and blew the budget going there so stayed in a cheap air b&b as we knew we'd go sightseeing most of the week. It wasn't particularly clean and the hot tub we specifically booked it for was out of action so we mentioned this in the review and the host went apeshit. Claimed I was exceptionally rude, left a hair in the fridge (the crime!!), left marks all over the balcony (hadn't even been out there all week, bar to eat a cheese sandwich lol) and we had "trashed the place". For those reasons, she claimed we were not entitled to the partial refund we'd requested.

However, I have the good sense to always photograph a place I'm staying very thoroughly just before I depart. I sent air b&b with the pictures with the early morning time stamp (place obviously very tidy, not "trashed") and she had to send me the partial refund plus have her review taken off.

Moral of the story: always^^ take pictures before you check out of a place.

IncompleteSenten · 29/02/2024 13:49

I guess it comes down to how you view omitting information that you could reasonably think others might find useful

Some would view that as dishonest or 'lying by omission', others wouldn't and would like you say, go down the if you can't say anything nice route.

I think on balance a truthful pros and cons is most helpful.

mimbleandlittlemy · 29/02/2024 13:48

Why didn't you complain about the sheets there and then? On the rare occasions I've had a problem either at an AirBnB or a Booking.com property, I've immediately messaged the host and asked that if it could be sorted and it usually is in a matter of a couple of hours, just as you would complain at a hotel and expect it sorted ASAP.

It's always worth looking for a "super host" on AirBnB - they do not want that status ruined and they are usually genuinely great hosts too.

shearwater2 · 29/02/2024 13:45

I've used AirBnb several times, UK and overseas, and have never had a bad review myself nor have left one, and the host has never asked us to do any cleaning. As a courtesy I'm always stripped beds, left towels in the bath, washed dishes, emptied bins and left surfaces clean.

Did you not read the reviews before you booked it? Surely others would have had the same issue? I only use superhosts and those who have the accommodation advertised on several sites, so are professionals doing it as a proper business. Also surely you leave them a bad review if they have been unfair.

I do stay in hotels too but don't want to stay in one with my large dog, even if it is dog friendly, nor did I want to when DDs were small - was much nicer for them and us to have their own bedroom. It's a fantastic website to use and much easier to search for and filter requirements such as looking at only pet friendly places, than most other holiday cottage and accommodation websites, so I will definitely be continuing to use them.

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 13:41

IncompleteSenten · 29/02/2024 13:38

It could equally be considered bad 'karma' to leave dishonest reviews that may lead to others booking a shit place.

But my review wasn't dishonest. I decided on balance that we had a good experience.

Yes it's not acceptable to have smelly sheets, but it wasn't something I couldn't fix.

Everyone has different standards.

The sheets and the internet wouldn't have stopped me from going back again.

I never leave ' fake ' good reviews.
If I genuinely have a bad experience, I usually just don't leave a review. It doesn't make me dishonest or a coward.

OP posts:
headstone · 29/02/2024 13:40

I had one bad review from an Airbnb in France, I think as previous posters said the French are very fussy. It did put me off so I use booking.com instead now so I don’t have to worry about being slagged off when returning from my holidays.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 29/02/2024 13:39

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 11:56

I just feel bad leaving bad reviews. I know it's stupid. But it's someone's livelihood potentially isn't it.

Yes it is stupid. You've undermined the process entirely and will actually contribute to the loss of people's livelihood because reviews from either side, are inauthentic.

DrNo007 · 29/02/2024 13:39

We rented an Airbnb and the owners’ horrible dog harassed, chased, growled at and finally bit me. (I love most dogs and they mostly love me.) Then the owners left us a vile review, accusing us of various things that were not our fault including not following the checkout procedure, which they had not described anywhere (we treble checked). They did not mention the dog bite!

Needless to say in the absence of written or verbal guidance on checkout procedure we left the place clean and tidy, took the rubbish to bins, and left the key exactly where they had left it for us.

There was no option to respond publicly to their negative review, only to post one of our own prior to their posting their review of us (so we could not respond to their review), though maybe that has changed since judging from an PP, and there was no route to ask Airbnb to remove it. I will never use Airbnb again.

Having said that however, after decades of both DH and I staying in hotels across the world without trouble, last year a hotel that we stayed in for one night before leaving for holiday called us while on holiday and accused us of stealing their bloody hairdryer and iron from our room!! In fact we had not even noticed that there were, or were meant to be, those items in the room as we had no need for either. They threatened to set the police on us! They never apologised. We won’t be going back there.

IncompleteSenten · 29/02/2024 13:38

It could equally be considered bad 'karma' to leave dishonest reviews that may lead to others booking a shit place.

Brexile · 29/02/2024 13:35

WaitingForSunnyDays · 29/02/2024 13:00

I think the cleaning expected from the guest also depends on the country. In France in chain holiday apartments our experience was that you were expected to leave the place pretty much immaculate. The list of cleaning tasks before you left was a page long, and that appeared to be perfectly standard.

I was going to say this! I wonder if that's why so many people have camper vans? There aren't really any other good accommodation offers in France apart from relatively expensive hotels (Campanile upwards). Budget hotels (FI for example) are unspeakably grim and tent camping isn't for everybody.