Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Airbnb host gave us a bad review!

220 replies

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 10:37

This is the first time I have used Airbnb. So perhaps I'm not versed at how to properly use it.

However, we spent up from 3.5 k for a house for a week and I think we had to pay around 200-250 for cleaning.

This was in a southern European country.

We have two young kids and we had a nice time but had to leave early due to a family emergency.

We stripped all the beds and put all towels and sheets in the washroom.

We cleaned the kitchen and sweeped the floors.

Some rubbish was left in the bins outside, because the weekly collection came after we already left.

We apologised for this and they told us not to worry.

We received a bad review - all around the fact that we left all the bedding and towels in the washroom and that they could see children's finger print marks on a lot of surfaces and on windows. They also mentioned that there was some sand on the floor under the beds. Obviously we didn't sweep well enough.

I don't really understand why I need to pay a cleaning fee if I need to clean windows ?

I'm never using Airbnb again.

OP posts:
housethatbuiltme · 29/02/2024 16:50

Same.

We went away for a weeks minimoon not far from where we live but in a quirky little flat built at the end of someone garden (near their house but not overlooked and otherwise 'secluded') after getting married and it was nice so we went back for our 1 year anniversary.

Would have made it an annual thing except after the 1 year one stay the host left a passive aggressive review about us being nice but 'untidy' guests.

We tidied everything before leaving (although didn't strip the beds, never done that anywhere and the place didn't even have a washer so what would we do with it) and it looked exactly as it did when we arrived + like you paid a large bloody cleaning fee anyway.

They lost ongoing business by being twatty.

Rubbishconfession · 29/02/2024 16:44

YANBU, I much prefer booking cottages via a company. We pay a cleaning fee and strip beds and do the dishes/tidying but that's it, we don't sweep up or scrub.

Never had any negative correspondence following stays.

My one and only experience with AirBNB was in Spain and it was miserable. Going from the delightful Marriott Playa to the AirBNB flat was a huge let down, we should have done it the other way around.

WildBear · 29/02/2024 16:43

Stayed in a static home due to glowing reviews. The place smelt musty and there was mould. Contacted Airbnb with photographs. They contacted host and we left early. Still had to pay for the night we stayed mind. Worst part of it in my mind was Airbnb continuing to allow the accommodation to be on their site.

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 16:40

ToodlePipSdqueak · 29/02/2024 16:25

So in this case, I think it was a one off, because they didn't have other negative reviews at all. All reviews were really good.

Sooooo that might be because people are like you and don't review?!

That doesn't really bother me.

OP posts:
shearwater2 · 29/02/2024 16:35

mydogisthebest · 29/02/2024 16:34

Me and DH use Airbnb a lot and have done for around 7 years. We have stayed in ones in the UK, France, Belgium, Holland, Sweden, Spain and Venice. We have never ever had any problem.

We don't like hotels or guest houses. Who wants to have to sit and relax in one room? Often you have to sit on the bed because there is only one chair (and it's not usually a comfortable one). We don't want to be told what time we can eat breakfast. We are early risers and hotels often don't start their breakfasts early enough. With Airbnb we can choose to eat at the accommodation or go out and eat.

We also don't like that hotels are so often very noisy late at night/overnight. Inconsiderate guests coming back and slamming doors, shouting etc. Often too there is quite a lot of noise from adjoining rooms whether it is a couple rowing or having noisy sex,

We have stayed in lovely places and all with a separate living room, kitchen, bathroom and at least one bedroom. Lots of them had a garden or, in the case of apartments, a balcony. Almost always cheaper than even budget hotels. How much does a good hotel with at least a comfy sofa or couple of chairs cost?

We have a couple times stayed in hotels which, to us, were pricy (over £400 a night) and although the rooms were a good size and they had comfortable seating, they were still noisy late at night and overnight and, of course, no way of cooking anything (not even a slice of toast). No garden to have a morning coffee in either.

We will stick with Airbnb

Great post.

mydogisthebest · 29/02/2024 16:34

AliceA2021 · 29/02/2024 11:53

I've used Airbnb 3 times and none were great. Hotels and guest houses in future.

Me and DH use Airbnb a lot and have done for around 7 years. We have stayed in ones in the UK, France, Belgium, Holland, Sweden, Spain and Venice. We have never ever had any problem.

We don't like hotels or guest houses. Who wants to have to sit and relax in one room? Often you have to sit on the bed because there is only one chair (and it's not usually a comfortable one). We don't want to be told what time we can eat breakfast. We are early risers and hotels often don't start their breakfasts early enough. With Airbnb we can choose to eat at the accommodation or go out and eat.

We also don't like that hotels are so often very noisy late at night/overnight. Inconsiderate guests coming back and slamming doors, shouting etc. Often too there is quite a lot of noise from adjoining rooms whether it is a couple rowing or having noisy sex,

We have stayed in lovely places and all with a separate living room, kitchen, bathroom and at least one bedroom. Lots of them had a garden or, in the case of apartments, a balcony. Almost always cheaper than even budget hotels. How much does a good hotel with at least a comfy sofa or couple of chairs cost?

We have a couple times stayed in hotels which, to us, were pricy (over £400 a night) and although the rooms were a good size and they had comfortable seating, they were still noisy late at night and overnight and, of course, no way of cooking anything (not even a slice of toast). No garden to have a morning coffee in either.

We will stick with Airbnb

Idontpostmuch · 29/02/2024 16:31

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 10:54

So I have never left a bad review for anything in my life. It's just not my style. I feel like it's bad karma.

I left a glowing review. Even though there were some issue. The sheets were sticky and smelled really bad and I washed them before we slept in the beds- same with blankets. It's unacceptable really, but I didn't mention it to the hosts I also didn't write it in the review.

In addition, the intent was rubbish.

Not happy about the situation and will never use it again. I wish I could delete my glowing review. But I can't. I still wouldn't leave a bad review but I shouldn't have left a good one.

You had a rubbish place and very unfairly got bad review. Of course you shouldn't have had to clean windows! However you shouldn't have left a good review. It's disingenuous. It isn't fair to people coming after you who might book on the strength of the positive feedback received by the host.

ChiaraRimini · 29/02/2024 16:30

From what I hear AirBnB bookings have fallen off a cliff so I don't think hosts will be in a position to be choosy.
Prices have rocketed and it's just not competitive anymore.
Plus many properties are advertised on other sites so it's worth Googling to see if you can book on a different site with lower fees.

takemeawayagain · 29/02/2024 16:26

I love Airbnb, getting a kitchen so we don't have to pay to eat out at every meal is fantastic and there is so much more space than a hotel room. We've stayed in around 20 different places and only had one dud - when we made the mistake of staying somewhere with no previous reviews.

ToodlePipSdqueak · 29/02/2024 16:25

So in this case, I think it was a one off, because they didn't have other negative reviews at all. All reviews were really good.

Sooooo that might be because people are like you and don't review?!

PrincessTeaSet · 29/02/2024 16:14

I find air BnB unprofessional and over priced. It used to be good when it was a cheap way to stay somewhere. Now it's just as expensive as any other accommodation but with the added annoyance that they can cancel last minute for no reason, they can leave you a bad review, and the hosts are often completely unreasonable in their expectations of guests, wanting to come and check up on you and complain about inconsequential things. Basically it's like staying with your fussy in-laws while paying for a decent hotel. Never again!

LaCouleurDeMonCiel · 29/02/2024 16:09

EcstaticMarmalade · 29/02/2024 10:51

We used an Airbnb about eight years ago

Host posted a review of us that complained that we cooked food in the kitchen and that it left a lingering smell.

No extractor fan and window didn’t open. It wasn’t even fish or anything, it was just some grilled chicken, boiled baby potatoes and a salad. Apart from that just things like toast.

There were a few problems with the place so we had just decided not to post a review (on the don’t say anything if you can’t say anything nice type basis). She posted her review at the last possible moment so I think she felt aggrieved we hadn’t posted an immediate glowing review.

First and last time using Airbnb.

There were a few problems with the place so we had just decided not to post a review (on the don’t say anything if you can’t say anything nice type basis)
FFS the whole point of reviews is to give feedback. It is thanks to people thinking like this that we book places with 5* reviews and end up disappointed!

PrincessTeaSet · 29/02/2024 16:01

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 11:56

I just feel bad leaving bad reviews. I know it's stupid. But it's someone's livelihood potentially isn't it.

You don't need to leave a bad review. Leave an honest review mentioning both good and bad things. If it's their livelihood they need to make sure the sheets are clean. It's not rocket science.

Firawla · 29/02/2024 15:54

Why on earth did you leave a “glowing review” for somewhere with problems, and sticky sheets??????? For that yabu

Coyoacan · 29/02/2024 15:53

KrisAkabusi · 29/02/2024 11:03

Yes, because hosts look at guest reviews when deciding who to rent to. If people have bad reviews they might not be able to rent what they want.

Well only hosts who expect their guests to wash the windows would be put off and that is all for the good. My friend runs a Airbnb and would never expect her guests to do the cleaning

whiteroseredrose · 29/02/2024 15:47

@Movinghouseatlast

'It's the host who adds the rules to the property, it doesn't matter what platform you book on'

That isn't my experience. I use apartments several times a year, sometimes when the property is on both AirBNB and Booking. One occasion was in Taormina and Siracusa.

There were some requests about leaving things clean and putting out rubbish or recycling at 6am and back in by 8am on specific days. I washed up and wiped surfaces and left it clean, but I didn't hoover, mop or strip beds.

We didn't manage to put the bins out every single day. No consequences at all because I'm not reviewed.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 29/02/2024 15:38

I had the solitary dishwasher tablet in ‘penthouse’ in Poole! And one loo roll for two loos for a week. Our ‘host’ made it clear that that was it.

Luckily it was in England and we had our car, so we just topped up at Tesco when we were buying breakfast stuff ( but I made sure to take it all with me). I left the solitary tablet though, didn’t want to stretch her budget.

It used to be quite standard in Gîtes that you brought your own towels and sheets, or your could hire them from the owner as an extra. They did tell you this before you arrived though.

justteanbiscuits · 29/02/2024 15:35

I'm another that used to use Air BNB a lot, and now won't due to the cleaning fees. It seems all hosts now expect you to do a full clean when you leave, but then still charge exorbitant cleaning fees. I'm happy to pay a cleaning fee, but not also clean top to toe before I leave.

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 15:35

@Zyq

So in this case, I think it was a one off, because they didn't have other negative reviews at all. All reviews were really good.

Do I feel bad that I didn't say in my review that they had stinky sheets ? Not as bad as I would feel if as the result of a bad review, the person who's making a living from a service - wouldn't be able to do so anymore. I think making a living, trumps the need for a holiday without stinky sheets. (Seeing as you could wash the sheets or complain and get new ones ).

In this particular case, I don't think it's a common occurrence that they have a problem with the sheets though, so I didn't feel the need to point it out. Seeing as I hadn't complained about it to them.

OP posts:
Changeeusername · 29/02/2024 15:25

A few years ago we rented a house in Denmark for a week. When we arrived (self check in) there were no sheets on the bed. When we asked we were told we should have taken our own! We were allowed to use theirs after a conversation.
She had the crockery in 2 large drawers. One marked personal for them and one for us.
Ours was full of plastic garbage which she expected us to eat our meals from! (we didn't)
She left a note asking us to do a basic clean after we left (despite being charged circa £70 (can't remember exactly) for cleaning)

We've just come back from Spain and rented an apartment for a week. There was a handover and the owner explained kitchen utensils etc and said there was a dishwasher and here's a tablet in case you don't want to handwash every night! He left us ONE dishwashing tablet. I was stunned in to silence.

mrsdineen2 · 29/02/2024 15:19

I'm happy to do the cleaning.

I'm happy to pay for a cleaner.

Only a complete mug does both.

I'm old enough to remember Airbnb in its infancy, when it was great. Now it's just full of lazy landlords who don't want to deal with tenancy law or do anything other than collecting payments.

Zyq · 29/02/2024 15:12

airbbbnb · 29/02/2024 11:56

I just feel bad leaving bad reviews. I know it's stupid. But it's someone's livelihood potentially isn't it.

Don't you feel bad about the next guest who is conned by your glowing review only to find the sticky sheets?

Caspianberg · 29/02/2024 14:55

@Fairyliz - cost?space?facilties?
For a family of 4, a self catered rental is no doubt far cheaper for a week holiday. Plus separate bedrooms for kids, outside space if kids go to bed early and adults want to sit outside. We have a rental, many seem to eat whatever at the house for breakfast, eat out wherever they go daytime, then either eat out/ get takeaway/ do a bbq/ easy food in evening. It’s not the Sam was at home. No cleaning required here unless you made a huge pile of mess like spilled cereal everywhere you would probably give a basic dustpan and brush sweep. we live southern Europe, so it’s hot here in Summer. So renting an apartment or villa with family self catered can be cheap as most just drive here also

Fairyliz · 29/02/2024 14:48

I only use hotels on holidays. Why would you go self catering when you have to clean the place along with food shopping and cooking.
I go on holiday to get away from all that!

rustlerwaiter · 29/02/2024 14:35

AirBnB is a complete pain in the arse really. Hit and miss with what you're going to get, hosts pulling bookings at any time because they know they can get more money relisting, AirBnB themselves doing little to moderate the platform.

I've got a couple of places I would use again but I've had just as much go badly with AirBnB and Booking.com as I have go well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread