Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think raising school absenteeism fines won’t help much.

212 replies

Boomer55 · 29/02/2024 09:19

Fines for parents taking children out of school without permission will rise across England from September.
The minimum fine will increase from £60 to £80 per parent as part of a government drive to return attendance to pre-pandemic levels.
One school told BBC News one out of every three of its pupils absent without permission had been on a family holiday during term time.
A head teachers' union said fines were needed to avoid "chaos" in schools.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

Teenager sits up on bed looking at phone

School absence fines for parents to rise by £20 in England

Most of the fines in England are for unauthorised term-time holidays, the education secretary says.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

OP posts:
Laiste · 01/03/2024 11:30

Education is important, and we treat it with great importance year round. DDs attendance is as good as we can possibly make it through each year. It's usually up n the 90%s.

But equally our whole family benefits from a week off a year together.

In a choice between DD missing the last week of the school year or us never having a family holiday (in the UK - none of us have passports to confiscate!) i'm choosing the holiday.

The school considers enrichment days (Sports day (they go home early after mostly sitting in the field), whole days buggering about dressed as vikings or umpaloompas) and school trips (a week in term time in Dorset) valid parts of the DCs development. Fair enough. We pay up and we engage - providing DD with costumes or whatever.

In my eyes our single week away together is also valid as part of my kids happiness, development and wellbeing.

Yes, we get the threatening letters. If we got fined it wouldn't change anything.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 11:26

Vod · 01/03/2024 11:18

You think it's ultra right wing to point out that businesses outside UK jurisdiction won't have to follow UK regulation? Mmmkay. Bit insulting to anyone on the left, centre or soft right to think only the far right have noticed that the UK is not in fact in charge of the planet.

Says a lot, though, that you still haven't told us what policy you want to implement and what you think it would achieve. All we've had so far is vibes.

My post isn’t about that - it’s not about that element of your argument at all in any respect. Read the words.

Kids should be in school and parents should be responsible enough to keep them there. Teachers and institutions fulfil their responsibilities (strikes notwithstanding) the parents also have responsibilities to their child, the state, society. Just keep your child in school, that place that does have regulations.

Vod · 01/03/2024 11:18

New2024 · 01/03/2024 11:09

That’s an ultra right wing stance: so business is above regulation; workers must obey rules, students can do what they like.; Government bodies can’t levy sanctions or fines or impose rules.

You think it's ultra right wing to point out that businesses outside UK jurisdiction won't have to follow UK regulation? Mmmkay. Bit insulting to anyone on the left, centre or soft right to think only the far right have noticed that the UK is not in fact in charge of the planet.

Says a lot, though, that you still haven't told us what policy you want to implement and what you think it would achieve. All we've had so far is vibes.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 11:09

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:52

Because your claims are, well, bonkers.

The one about school being the same as work in this respect is particularly hatstand. If DC are to have the same responsibilities as employees, they'd also need the same benefits and rights. Which aren't all financial, as it happens. A situation where there is a contract is not a like a situation where there isn't.

That’s an ultra right wing stance: so business is above regulation; workers must obey rules, students can do what they like.; Government bodies can’t levy sanctions or fines or impose rules.

cerisepanther73 · 01/03/2024 10:55

@Overtheatlantic

Ok

There's comes a point when people need to know that education is important and if that means raising the fines for lack of attendance,

So be it,

Perhaps that 🤔 give parents the incentive to address their issues of why their child is like that in the first place,

Whether they attend school or not
It's the law they are provided with some kind of education wherever that be,

Obviously school system isn't perfect never has been,

but it's much better its improved nowadays than used to be more awareness around learning difficulties ect

I think lockdowns made some Parents or more aware of the importance of educating their child and how difficulties of it too. Understanding of teachers work...

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:52

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:43

Lastly, taking children out of school in term time will only be like bunking off work when DC are paid a wage to be at school and accrue employment rights for being there too

Think about that for a moment, not every responsibility is about money. If your child bunks off they get detention. If you are complicit/take them out for hols you get fined. If you keep them off and it’s actual neglect there are consequences.

Why can’t it be suggested on here that maybe we could help to avoid fines by using law to regulate business without such outrage ? Bonkers

Because your claims are, well, bonkers.

The one about school being the same as work in this respect is particularly hatstand. If DC are to have the same responsibilities as employees, they'd also need the same benefits and rights. Which aren't all financial, as it happens. A situation where there is a contract is not a like a situation where there isn't.

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:50

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:45

I said regulate where we can. Nobody should just give up because the UK law can’t reach every part of the universe.

Ok, then tell us what we can do and how it would be beneficial. You still haven't.

It's not about giving up, it's about explaining why this is worth attempting in the first place. We must do something and this is something is a piss poor justification for any policy. It's a particularly bad one when it would still leave us with much cheaper holidays in term time plus a fine system that doesn't work and frequently makes things worse.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/03/2024 10:45

Why can’t it be suggested on here that maybe we could help to avoid fines by using law to regulate business without such outrage?

How would English laws be able to restrict the prices that eg a villa owner in Majorca, set for renting their property?

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:45

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:35

All things are regulated, yes. Holiday accommodation in, say, Spain, is regulated by bodies that do not include the UK government. So again, tell us what you want to do, what is possible and what it would achieve. All we've had so far is vibes.

The crucial difference between schools in England and holiday accommodation outside the UK is that we're actually in charge of schools in England. We can run them without the current fining system, like we did until a few years back. It's within our control. Creating a system where families don't have access to much cheaper holidays in term time, however, is not.

The problem you have when making your argument isn't business, it's the fact that the UK isn't in charge of the world.

I said regulate where we can. Nobody should just give up because the UK law can’t reach every part of the universe.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:43

Lastly, taking children out of school in term time will only be like bunking off work when DC are paid a wage to be at school and accrue employment rights for being there too

Think about that for a moment, not every responsibility is about money. If your child bunks off they get detention. If you are complicit/take them out for hols you get fined. If you keep them off and it’s actual neglect there are consequences.

Why can’t it be suggested on here that maybe we could help to avoid fines by using law to regulate business without such outrage ? Bonkers

DrCoconut · 01/03/2024 10:40

As long as schools are giving pupils time off for football matches on TV the whole minutes matter bullcrap is an utter joke. Only when it suits the system.

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:35

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:31

All things are regulated and have rules. Adjust rules for business where possible. It can’t hurt to try even if it isn’t possible to reach every price hiker or mode of transport.

In schools there are rules but so many are happy to break them to save money. The second anyone dares to say on here that maybe temptations to pull your kids out of school should be reined in posters reject that 🤷

Bushiness can’t be the problem, it must be schools. I think not

All things are regulated, yes. Holiday accommodation in, say, Spain, is regulated by bodies that do not include the UK government. So again, tell us what you want to do, what is possible and what it would achieve. All we've had so far is vibes.

The crucial difference between schools in England and holiday accommodation outside the UK is that we're actually in charge of schools in England. We can run them without the current fining system, like we did until a few years back. It's within our control. Creating a system where families don't have access to much cheaper holidays in term time, however, is not.

The problem you have when making your argument isn't business, it's the fact that the UK isn't in charge of the world.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:31

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:15

You've yet to explain what use regulation would actually be. If you could make a case, that might be different.

Nobody's 'shoulds' are of any importance here anyway, it's plain fact that a great many holidays are taken in places where the UK wouldn't be in a position to tell accommodation providers what they can charge. It doesn't matter how you or I might personally feel about that. Whereas we very much can have a society where we don't have school attendance fines. Like Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland seem to manage.

All things are regulated and have rules. Adjust rules for business where possible. It can’t hurt to try even if it isn’t possible to reach every price hiker or mode of transport.

In schools there are rules but so many are happy to break them to save money. The second anyone dares to say on here that maybe temptations to pull your kids out of school should be reined in posters reject that 🤷

Bushiness can’t be the problem, it must be schools. I think not

gotmychristmasmiracle · 01/03/2024 10:21

Good little money earner for the government, no wonder they increased the fines!

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:20

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:16

We can at least try. Saying you can’t cover everything/legislate everyone so you won’t bother doing anything is defeatist.

The other thing is to simply stop thinking that taking your kids out of school in term time is acceptable. It’s not different from bunking off work.

So again, please explain how we could try and what impact this would have. I'm ready to hear a case, but nobody ever makes one.

Another alternative is that we could succeed in not being a society that fines parents for children missing school. It's a terrible policy, has failed in improving attendance, damages relationships between parents and schools and blames parents of SN kids for systemic failures.

Lastly, taking children out of school in term time will only be like bunking off work when DC are paid a wage to be at school and accrue employment rights for being there too.

coureur · 01/03/2024 10:18

New2024 · 01/03/2024 09:57

That’s why we need to get over the notion that we can’t regulate businesses. We should not crave a society where greed is the lead.

The UK can regulate business that is located in the UK - because it needs to be as it is selling a physical product. If the government brought in price capping on holiday companies, every single one of the handful of remaining UK-based holiday companies would re-locate abroad overnight.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/03/2024 10:18

What sort of legislations against holiday companies do you think would work? Both in England and across the globe?

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:16

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:02

But how does this fit with the fact that lots of holidays are taken in other societies who won't be subject to UK legislation? Even if we think we could in theory prevent eg airlines and companies doing packages from charging more in school holidays, that still leaves a huge amount of room for people to be charged more. Let's say you get your price controlled flight out of the UK, or you drive yourself, then what? I just can't see how people think this is going to work.

We can at least try. Saying you can’t cover everything/legislate everyone so you won’t bother doing anything is defeatist.

The other thing is to simply stop thinking that taking your kids out of school in term time is acceptable. It’s not different from bunking off work.

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:15

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:08

Some regulation would not go amiss.

Why do families rail against schools trying to get them to abide by the rules but think companies should be allowed to do what they like?

You've yet to explain what use regulation would actually be. If you could make a case, that might be different.

Nobody's 'shoulds' are of any importance here anyway, it's plain fact that a great many holidays are taken in places where the UK wouldn't be in a position to tell accommodation providers what they can charge. It doesn't matter how you or I might personally feel about that. Whereas we very much can have a society where we don't have school attendance fines. Like Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland seem to manage.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 10:08

Vod · 01/03/2024 09:36

I don't see how it would be workable anyway, not least because people living in the UK don't necessarily book with companies subject to UK regulations for their holidays. If you book travel and accommodation separately, as a significant number of people do, how is the British government going to stop people and companies elsewhere from charging more for their properties when they know it's school holidays?

Some regulation would not go amiss.

Why do families rail against schools trying to get them to abide by the rules but think companies should be allowed to do what they like?

Fargo79 · 01/03/2024 10:03

The whole system needs complete reform.

I believe that the reason for the uptick in persistent absences since the pandemic is for several reasons.

Firstly, the fact that the government closed the schools to most children during the pandemic and then continued for ages with all the silly "bubble" stuff that made no sense, broke the contract between schools and families and undermined the importance of regular school attendance for a number of people. Before anyone shoots me down, I am not saying they were right or wrong to close schools initially, or that it's OK for parents not to take attendance seriously. I just think it has caused a shift in attitudes for some people in recent years.

Secondly, the Tories have overseen the wholesale destruction of mental health and SEND services, as well as the NHS as a whole. This has clearly had a massive impact on the wellbeing of millions of people, some of them school kids. Absenteeism or absence due to persistent illness is one of the ways that this manifests.

Thirdly, people in almost every income bracket are feeling the effects of the COL crisis. Taking the kids out of school for many families is the difference between having holidays or not. It's not just about saving £100 nowadays. They simply can't afford to go away in the school holidays. It's beyond unreasonable and unrealistic to expect families to never experience family holidays together. School is important but it's not the only important thing. Life is important. Family time is important. Enrichment is important. Cultural experiences are important. Time away from the daily grind is important.

I think the whole school system (and public services in general) is unfit for purpose and needs urgent and radical reform. The curriculum is outdated. SEND children are not adequately supported and able to reach their potential. Resources are stretched beyond belief. The issue of families not being allowed the flexibility to take affordable holidays is really the least of it.

It's much easier for the Tories to punish and blame children and their parents than it is to actually analyse the numerous reasons why this situation is occuring and address the root causes, for which the blame lies squarely at their feet. Basically it's just more DARVO from the government. Kids deserve an education and the government is not fulfilling it's obligations to make education and healthcare accessible to all.

RoseAndRose · 01/03/2024 10:03

I didn't think it was meant to help, as such.

Just stick roughly in line with inflation so the effect remains much the same

Vod · 01/03/2024 10:02

New2024 · 01/03/2024 09:57

That’s why we need to get over the notion that we can’t regulate businesses. We should not crave a society where greed is the lead.

But how does this fit with the fact that lots of holidays are taken in other societies who won't be subject to UK legislation? Even if we think we could in theory prevent eg airlines and companies doing packages from charging more in school holidays, that still leaves a huge amount of room for people to be charged more. Let's say you get your price controlled flight out of the UK, or you drive yourself, then what? I just can't see how people think this is going to work.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 09:57

Shinyandnew1 · 01/03/2024 09:30

Regulation of the holiday companies is what is needed.

As has been pointed out-this will not be happening. They are businesses and can do what they want.

That’s why we need to get over the notion that we can’t regulate businesses. We should not crave a society where greed is the lead.

Vod · 01/03/2024 09:45

Tatonka · 01/03/2024 09:38

People are so privileged on here. The fines aren't to target rich people taking their kids on holiday 🤦🏼‍♀️

I don't know about rich, but the government reckon 89% of fines are issued for unauthorised holidays.

https://educationhub.blog.gov.uk/2024/02/29/fines-for-parents-for-taking-children-out-of-school-what-you-need-to-know/

I don't trust them myself, but it's no great surprise that people pick up on the messaging they're putting out.

Fines for parents for taking children out of school: What you need to know - The Education Hub

The Education Hub is a site for parents, pupils, education professionals and the media that captures all you need to know about the education system. You’ll find accessible, straightforward information on popular topics, Q&As, interviews, case studies,...

https://educationhub.blog.gov.uk/2024/02/29/fines-for-parents-for-taking-children-out-of-school-what-you-need-to-know