Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think raising school absenteeism fines won’t help much.

212 replies

Boomer55 · 29/02/2024 09:19

Fines for parents taking children out of school without permission will rise across England from September.
The minimum fine will increase from £60 to £80 per parent as part of a government drive to return attendance to pre-pandemic levels.
One school told BBC News one out of every three of its pupils absent without permission had been on a family holiday during term time.
A head teachers' union said fines were needed to avoid "chaos" in schools.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

Teenager sits up on bed looking at phone

School absence fines for parents to rise by £20 in England

Most of the fines in England are for unauthorised term-time holidays, the education secretary says.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

OP posts:
New2024 · 01/03/2024 12:37

Vod · 01/03/2024 12:25

No, it was about the precise aspect of business you mentioned. Regulation.

A specific thing you think prevents regulation and not what my post was about. UK regulation of business protects us - most people want that.

Laiste · 01/03/2024 12:36

Needmorelego · 01/03/2024 12:33

@Laiste just seen your correction.
My point was that many families can't afford any holidays ever. Term time or not.

No that's very true.

EnglishGirlApproximately · 01/03/2024 12:36

Any regulation that means holiday providers can't have seasonal pricing will have one of two results - prices rising year round so those without children are paying more, or holiday providers going bust.

The travel industry works on small margins and there's negligible profit in low season.
Hoteliers and overseas airlines will charge tour operators what they want as they can't be ruled by UK law, so the only option is to increase low season pricing or go out of business.

pizzaHeart · 01/03/2024 12:36

Vod · 29/02/2024 11:32

Fining on Day 1 instead of Day 5 just incentivises people to take a fully term time holiday for maximum savings, instead of nicking a couple of days either side of the holidays as more of a compromise option.

Yes to this^
of course most of ministers are ok financially and don’t care about cheaper holidays plus their kids are in public schools which break up for holidays earlier.

Laiste · 01/03/2024 12:35

''10 x the fine'' would be £1160 per child.

For people with low income that would have to be recouped with a payment plan based on affordability ect ect. Who the hell would vote for taxes spent on all that admin?

40somethingme · 01/03/2024 12:35

If the government is not careful we’re going to soon end up with headlines about record-low birth rates and population crisis like in Japan or South Korea. Why would parents choose to have more children when they have to deal with this nonsense and being told how to parent their own kids? They really need to back off, the record numbers of parents taking their children out of the school system and choosing to home educate should be a warning sign.

Needmorelego · 01/03/2024 12:33

@Laiste just seen your correction.
My point was that many families can't afford any holidays ever. Term time or not.

Needmorelego · 01/03/2024 12:32

@Laiste sorry did you mean you can or can't afford term time holidays?

Laiste · 01/03/2024 12:31

sorry - can't afford a hol during school hols i mean

Laiste · 01/03/2024 12:30

Needmorelego · 01/03/2024 12:25

@Laiste that "x10" comment was about holidays.
Families with "no spare cash" can't afford to go on holiday in the first place.
(I'm not saying I agree with that idea....)

Yes i know. We can't afford to go on holiday during term time, but can get enough together for a week in July.

I don't think you'll find that's something unusual ...

Vod · 01/03/2024 12:25

New2024 · 01/03/2024 12:23

But your reply was about an utterly different aspect of the topic of business.

No, it was about the precise aspect of business you mentioned. Regulation.

Needmorelego · 01/03/2024 12:25

@Laiste that "x10" comment was about holidays.
Families with "no spare cash" can't afford to go on holiday in the first place.
(I'm not saying I agree with that idea....)

Vod · 01/03/2024 12:24

fleurneige · 01/03/2024 12:15

Absentism is a very complex issue, and reasons so so varied. A proper assessment should be made, but there is no system or staff to do this. So raising fine won't help.

As for holidays in term-time, I'd multiply the fine by a minimum of 10. (coat - out).

You'd end up with more people fighting them and also not paying once they'd lost, both of which are expensive. The fining system at the moment benefits from the fact that people have substantial incentives to factor it in and accept it. You may know that the court system is creaking at the moment. It's not immediately obvious where the capacity to deal with this would come from.

It would also be magnificently unpopular. The current system obviously causes widespread resentment too, but £80 per child per holiday isn't enough to make most people change their vote on that basis. It's not a good idea politically to escalate an unpopular but relatively minor policy.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 12:23

Vod · 01/03/2024 12:01

Your post literally begins with your claim that people are saying business is above regulation, and you go on to try and set that up as a comparison. If your post was only about your belief that people shouldn't take their DC out of school, you wouldn't have mentioned business regulation at all.

But your reply was about an utterly different aspect of the topic of business.

Laiste · 01/03/2024 12:20

Good luck with managing to get fine x 10 off a family with no spare cash 🙄

Where's the money going to come from to pay for all the admin involved there?

fleurneige · 01/03/2024 12:15

Absentism is a very complex issue, and reasons so so varied. A proper assessment should be made, but there is no system or staff to do this. So raising fine won't help.

As for holidays in term-time, I'd multiply the fine by a minimum of 10. (coat - out).

Vod · 01/03/2024 12:12

LyndaLaHughes · 01/03/2024 12:09

Also, absolutely the issue is WHY children aren't in school. An overloaded, too-hard curriculum, punitive Ofsted system and burnt out teachers as well as a massive teacher shortage and funding crisis as well as a cost-saving move towards inclusion at all costs regardless of the needs of the child or the impact on other children are part of the problem. Provision for SEN children is woeful now and TAs have been cut to the bone. It was never about the needs of the child- it's always been about money. As proven by the latest move to cut EHCPs by 20%. A target the government had paid a big whack to one of their mates again to oversee. The total collapse of support services and utterly inadequate provision for mental health support and timely assessment for SEN. It's unacceptable. This government have utterly destroyed education over the past 14 years and they would rather blame parents and children than admit they've got it all so wrong.

Exactly this. They're yarning on about fines in the hope that people will be stupid enough not to notice all the systemic issues that have happened on their watch.

LyndaLaHughes · 01/03/2024 12:09

Also, absolutely the issue is WHY children aren't in school. An overloaded, too-hard curriculum, punitive Ofsted system and burnt out teachers as well as a massive teacher shortage and funding crisis as well as a cost-saving move towards inclusion at all costs regardless of the needs of the child or the impact on other children are part of the problem. Provision for SEN children is woeful now and TAs have been cut to the bone. It was never about the needs of the child- it's always been about money. As proven by the latest move to cut EHCPs by 20%. A target the government had paid a big whack to one of their mates again to oversee. The total collapse of support services and utterly inadequate provision for mental health support and timely assessment for SEN. It's unacceptable. This government have utterly destroyed education over the past 14 years and they would rather blame parents and children than admit they've got it all so wrong.

LyndaLaHughes · 01/03/2024 12:03

Overtheatlantic · 29/02/2024 09:26

I think fines are outrageous anyway. The school doesn’t own the children.

We really need to move away from the language of "the schools" etc when getting angry about issues that are government policy. Teachers and schools have been bearing the brunt of the anger around this issue for years. They didn't make the rules and never have. Headteacher discretion is overall a myth. If your school's overall attendance is low, then you are answerable to the local authority and Ofsted for that. As a HT, if you are being scrutinised highly- which is not always consistent between local authorities and schools - then you have no option but to refer for fines.

Vod · 01/03/2024 12:01

New2024 · 01/03/2024 11:26

My post isn’t about that - it’s not about that element of your argument at all in any respect. Read the words.

Kids should be in school and parents should be responsible enough to keep them there. Teachers and institutions fulfil their responsibilities (strikes notwithstanding) the parents also have responsibilities to their child, the state, society. Just keep your child in school, that place that does have regulations.

Edited

Your post literally begins with your claim that people are saying business is above regulation, and you go on to try and set that up as a comparison. If your post was only about your belief that people shouldn't take their DC out of school, you wouldn't have mentioned business regulation at all.

Needmorelego · 01/03/2024 11:56

@firef1y many parents know exactly the reasons their child isn't in school and they are begging for help.
Help that is underfunded and hard to access - or often simply doesn't exist.
They are fighting for the child to get help and support and being handed a fricking 80 quid fine is not going to help them one tiny bit.
Sorry that was for @cerisepanther73 .

Universalsnail · 01/03/2024 11:55

Still significantly cheaper then the hiked cost of a school holiday holiday. I don't know why they think this will make any difference

soupfiend · 01/03/2024 11:54

PuttingDownRoots · 29/02/2024 09:24

Save £500 vs fine of £80. Maths still adds up.

It's per parent per child isn't it? So 80 x 4 if you have 2 kids

Bushmillsbabe · 01/03/2024 11:50

It should always be looked at in context of the child and family. Does the child have high attendance and child and family engaged with school and learning? Is it a one off or a regular occurance? Can it be easily avoided - such as is it a family wedding or funeral where the parent doesn't have a choice when it, or a week at Butlins/disney/Costa del ... where the parebts can choose.
I got really annoyed, we haven't taken our girls out during termtime in 4 years of them being in school, but my husband cousin brought their wedding forward into termtime as his father terminally ill, and it was abroad so we took our girls out for 3 days of school. I was honest and gave a full explanation and received a letter from the headteacher saying was unacceptable considering their 'next steps' (? Fine). I politely replied to say this is probably the last time will see his uncle and we would accept the whatever consequences they saw fit.

But some schools are great - our terminally ill friend took her girls to Disney to make memories and the school just said go for it.

But equally I know of families who take their children out 3 weeks every year for a cheap package holiday - they are the ones the government should be targeting, not those who are making final precious memories with terminally ill family members.

firef1y · 01/03/2024 11:49

cerisepanther73 · 01/03/2024 10:55

@Overtheatlantic

Ok

There's comes a point when people need to know that education is important and if that means raising the fines for lack of attendance,

So be it,

Perhaps that 🤔 give parents the incentive to address their issues of why their child is like that in the first place,

Whether they attend school or not
It's the law they are provided with some kind of education wherever that be,

Obviously school system isn't perfect never has been,

but it's much better its improved nowadays than used to be more awareness around learning difficulties ect

I think lockdowns made some Parents or more aware of the importance of educating their child and how difficulties of it too. Understanding of teachers work...

I can't address the issue that "makes my child like that", he has autism with avoidance disorder and sensory issues. I struggle to get him in school every day, some days he's late and guess what that gets marked as an unauthorised absence. His attendance currently sits at 74% but...of that 26% at least 20% is days where I've got him in eventually.
There are things the school could do to help him (not changing PE days every half term would be a good start), but atm the whole burden falls on me and there are days where I admit I just can't fight him anymore.
I've had neighbours call the police, because of the screaming that goes on, I've been covered in bruises, yes it is that bad. And he's not a small child, he's strong, I can't just pick him up and carry him put the door.

Swipe left for the next trending thread