Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think raising school absenteeism fines won’t help much.

212 replies

Boomer55 · 29/02/2024 09:19

Fines for parents taking children out of school without permission will rise across England from September.
The minimum fine will increase from £60 to £80 per parent as part of a government drive to return attendance to pre-pandemic levels.
One school told BBC News one out of every three of its pupils absent without permission had been on a family holiday during term time.
A head teachers' union said fines were needed to avoid "chaos" in schools.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

Teenager sits up on bed looking at phone

School absence fines for parents to rise by £20 in England

Most of the fines in England are for unauthorised term-time holidays, the education secretary says.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

OP posts:
Laiste · 01/03/2024 14:26

There's a lot of unnecessary hyperbole in your post @Bushmillsbabe. The entitlement and the flying thousands of miles and the Costa del rubbish and the multiple holidays.

None of that applies to our family for eg.

I believe it's entirely possible for a school to use it's discretion to gauge weather a few days off days off once a year for a family holiday (which would otherwise be un-affordable) is a reasonable scenario. To take into account the child's attendance level and any other family factors such as SEN. Or when the piss is being taken. Or when a family needs support rather than arbitrary fines.

It's how it used to work.

Where is the fine money going anyway? It's not being ploughed back into the school i bet.

soupfiend · 01/03/2024 14:18

You can't just stay unemployed to be home educating! You have to be actively looking for work or you might be signed off sick in which case it makes no odds whether you home educate or not in terms of the impact on taxation income for the government

Bushmillsbabe · 01/03/2024 14:09

soupfiend · 01/03/2024 13:15

Well we have got record low birth rates and a population crisis and why would government be concerned about home education it's cheaper for the public purse?

Yes and no
If a parent is home educating, then they are likely not working. That could mean they are claiming benefits. But also not paying tax, maybe left a job in a shortage profession like nursing, and then have to employ expensive agency staff.
So home education may be more expensive on public purse

Bushmillsbabe · 01/03/2024 14:03

New2024 · 01/03/2024 13:33

Simply not talking about the same thing I am talking about. Law makers and governments can regulate to help with any business area under their jurisdiction or they can be left to hike prices more and more as they have been. Why am I supposed to say what they might do? You already have a lay persons overview.

The bit of the whole topic that is harder to understand is why parents think they are entitled to break the rules. Yes, prices are a pita but dealing with it by breaking the rules and blaming the schools for taking sanctions is actually anti democratic

You have nailed it with one word 'entitled'
'Entitled to have a holiday' 'entitled to take children out of school' but also 'entitled to an education for their child' 'entitled to moan when teachers strike' and 'entitled to their school not closing as the teachers fancy a cheap break too'. Just imagine if these parents rocked up to school to a sign saying 'sorry, you lot clearly don't respect us enough to send your child in so we are not coming in either' - there would be uproar!

A holiday is lovely but not a human right. People talk about 'quality family time' that can just as easily be at home. We dont have to fly 2000 miles to enjoy spending time with our children.

Access to education is a child's human right. And before I get shot down,I know that many many children don't have access to appropriate educational placements and are missing school due long wait list for special schools, lack of funding, poor mental health support. It's not these ones I am referring to, its the children who are happy and needs met in school but taken out of school multiple times a year in termtime to go to Costa del Brit

Vod · 01/03/2024 13:55

Bushmillsbabe · 01/03/2024 13:52

Lots of comments about holidays being cheaper termtime - true.
But am interested how people then cover school holidays for childcare? School holidays are 14 weeks a year. Annual leave is 5 weeks a year on average. So even if a couple takes it seperate then thats 10 weeks a year
If then take leave during termtime, need to pay for playschemes - where I am thats at least £50 for a full 8am-6pm day per child - so £500 a week for 2 children. If both parents go on holidays thats 2 less weeks covered/2 more weeks childcare at £1000 - so actually doesn't make termtime holidays much cheaper really

Edited

I think a lot of it is because people aren't necessarily in 2 x FT working households and using paid holiday childcare. There will be some households in the position you set out here. But lots of others will have at least one of DC at school who are too old to need holiday childcare, a SAHP, family help, a parent working part time or flexibly or a parent who's a carer to a disabled DC and doesn't work.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/03/2024 13:53

There’s plenty things they could do

Really? Ok, then.

Name 5 things they could do.

Bushmillsbabe · 01/03/2024 13:52

Lots of comments about holidays being cheaper termtime - true.
But am interested how people then cover school holidays for childcare? School holidays are 14 weeks a year. Annual leave is 5 weeks a year on average. So even if a couple takes it seperate then thats 10 weeks a year
If then take leave during termtime, need to pay for playschemes - where I am thats at least £50 for a full 8am-6pm day per child - so £500 a week for 2 children. If both parents go on holidays thats 2 less weeks covered/2 more weeks childcare at £1000 - so actually doesn't make termtime holidays much cheaper really

Vod · 01/03/2024 13:52

New2024 · 01/03/2024 13:49

There’s plenty things they could do, but I am not presuming to supply detail. It’s an area to be addressed by government.

The other point is not about morals. Rule breaking is never the way to deal with this. If you can’t link that to democracy, God help us.

Enough now, I must leave this place where we are happy to be shafted by business but not penalised for bunking off school

Right, so you know enough to confidently state over multiple posts that there are loads of things we could do that would actually make a difference, but not enough to give even a vague hint as to what they are. That sort of bullshitting always speaks for itself.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/03/2024 13:52

It appears that we're back to the concept of trying to regulate holiday pricing again. Please do tell us what you suggest and how it would protect us. You haven't so far.

Its almost like there is no sensible or possible regulation.

England’s government would have no jurisdiction to tell anyone in a different country how they should price their villa/hotel/apartment. If they tried to cap English holiday providers, the providers would either put up the prices the rest of the year or fold completely.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 13:49

Vod · 01/03/2024 13:41

You're supposed to say what they might do because you suggested the idea, claimed we needed to get over the notion that we couldn't do it, said it couldn't hurt to try, that it was defeatist not to and that people who have pointed out the difficulties to you are espousing an ultra right wing stance. You are of course free not to back up any of your claims and you're clearly not going to because they're ridiculous but that does mean it will be clear that you can't.

As for democracy, what manifesto was this in? I'm not interested in people's moral takes on whether parents should take their DC out of school, but I do want to hear more about this.

There’s plenty things they could do, but I am not presuming to supply detail. It’s an area to be addressed by government.

The other point is not about morals. Rule breaking is never the way to deal with this. If you can’t link that to democracy, God help us.

Enough now, I must leave this place where we are happy to be shafted by business but not penalised for bunking off school

Vod · 01/03/2024 13:41

New2024 · 01/03/2024 13:33

Simply not talking about the same thing I am talking about. Law makers and governments can regulate to help with any business area under their jurisdiction or they can be left to hike prices more and more as they have been. Why am I supposed to say what they might do? You already have a lay persons overview.

The bit of the whole topic that is harder to understand is why parents think they are entitled to break the rules. Yes, prices are a pita but dealing with it by breaking the rules and blaming the schools for taking sanctions is actually anti democratic

You're supposed to say what they might do because you suggested the idea, claimed we needed to get over the notion that we couldn't do it, said it couldn't hurt to try, that it was defeatist not to and that people who have pointed out the difficulties to you are espousing an ultra right wing stance. You are of course free not to back up any of your claims and you're clearly not going to because they're ridiculous but that does mean it will be clear that you can't.

As for democracy, what manifesto was this in? I'm not interested in people's moral takes on whether parents should take their DC out of school, but I do want to hear more about this.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 13:33

Vod · 01/03/2024 13:23

Again, you wrote regulation and did not specify further. You then used the concept to make a daft comparison, which means your post was indeed about that aspect of my argument.

It appears that we're back to the concept of trying to regulate holiday pricing again. Please do tell us what you suggest and how it would protect us. You haven't so far.

Simply not talking about the same thing I am talking about. Law makers and governments can regulate to help with any business area under their jurisdiction or they can be left to hike prices more and more as they have been. Why am I supposed to say what they might do? You already have a lay persons overview.

The bit of the whole topic that is harder to understand is why parents think they are entitled to break the rules. Yes, prices are a pita but dealing with it by breaking the rules and blaming the schools for taking sanctions is actually anti democratic

Vod · 01/03/2024 13:26

Needmorelego · 01/03/2024 13:23

@40somethingme yes several schools in South London have recently closed or plan to close.
Schools that just a few years ago that were oversubscribed are now undersubscribed.

It's an interesting point. So far it's been a locally specific thing, as DC who were born around the early 2010s mini boom are still in the school system, and those from the 2020s drop are too young yet. But we're likely to see the impact in a few years.

Needmorelego · 01/03/2024 13:23

@40somethingme yes several schools in South London have recently closed or plan to close.
Schools that just a few years ago that were oversubscribed are now undersubscribed.

Vod · 01/03/2024 13:23

New2024 · 01/03/2024 12:37

A specific thing you think prevents regulation and not what my post was about. UK regulation of business protects us - most people want that.

Again, you wrote regulation and did not specify further. You then used the concept to make a daft comparison, which means your post was indeed about that aspect of my argument.

It appears that we're back to the concept of trying to regulate holiday pricing again. Please do tell us what you suggest and how it would protect us. You haven't so far.

soupfiend · 01/03/2024 13:15

40somethingme · 01/03/2024 12:35

If the government is not careful we’re going to soon end up with headlines about record-low birth rates and population crisis like in Japan or South Korea. Why would parents choose to have more children when they have to deal with this nonsense and being told how to parent their own kids? They really need to back off, the record numbers of parents taking their children out of the school system and choosing to home educate should be a warning sign.

Well we have got record low birth rates and a population crisis and why would government be concerned about home education it's cheaper for the public purse?

soupfiend · 01/03/2024 13:11

LyndaLaHughes · 01/03/2024 12:03

We really need to move away from the language of "the schools" etc when getting angry about issues that are government policy. Teachers and schools have been bearing the brunt of the anger around this issue for years. They didn't make the rules and never have. Headteacher discretion is overall a myth. If your school's overall attendance is low, then you are answerable to the local authority and Ofsted for that. As a HT, if you are being scrutinised highly- which is not always consistent between local authorities and schools - then you have no option but to refer for fines.

I didn't read the full article but the OP mentions the head teacher association? So they are in support I assume?

Laiste · 01/03/2024 13:08

SmokedPaprikaPuffs · 01/03/2024 13:01

My son had awful attendance in reception because it was when the world went back to normal after the pandemic, I believe the first full school year with no lockdowns. He caught everything going, at one point I had covid and he had chicken pox which was not a fun week. He's now year 2 and recently got 100% attendance award which I chucked straight in the bin.
I hope parents won't be fined in cases of children catching one thing after the other. If the school can prove you've been on holiday, fair enough. If social services need to be involved because school suspects something more going on, fair enough. But I resent being told to give my child calpol and send him in so his attendance won't be affected. If he needs calpol he's staying at home.

In my case they don't have to prove it (going on holiday) i tell the school politely and honestly in advance. I wouldn't ask my DC to lie.

I agree with you on the point of 'send them in unless they're dying' advice. IME working in schools we dreaded the poor snotty child coming in day after day feeling ill and spreading germs. I don't imagine anythings actually changed re: attitude of staff. No one wants to try to teach a poorly child.

soupfiend · 01/03/2024 13:06

Universalsnail · 01/03/2024 11:55

Still significantly cheaper then the hiked cost of a school holiday holiday. I don't know why they think this will make any difference

Absolutely, I was just saying that it's not just 80 quid. I don't blame parents for doing it, for me the government and schools broke down any concept of every second counting during covid so I doubt thigs will recover and the respect for education has long gone

SmokedPaprikaPuffs · 01/03/2024 13:01

My son had awful attendance in reception because it was when the world went back to normal after the pandemic, I believe the first full school year with no lockdowns. He caught everything going, at one point I had covid and he had chicken pox which was not a fun week. He's now year 2 and recently got 100% attendance award which I chucked straight in the bin.
I hope parents won't be fined in cases of children catching one thing after the other. If the school can prove you've been on holiday, fair enough. If social services need to be involved because school suspects something more going on, fair enough. But I resent being told to give my child calpol and send him in so his attendance won't be affected. If he needs calpol he's staying at home.

whyayepetal · 01/03/2024 13:00

The whole system needs complete reform.
**
I believe that the reason for the uptick in persistent absences since the pandemic is for several reasons.
**
Firstly, the fact that the government closed the schools to most children during the pandemic and then continued for ages with all the silly "bubble" stuff that made no sense, broke the contract between schools and families and undermined the importance of regular school attendance for a number of people. Before anyone shoots me down, I am not saying they were right or wrong to close schools initially, or that it's OK for parents not to take attendance seriously. I just think it has caused a shift in attitudes for some people in recent years.
**
Secondly, the Tories have overseen the wholesale destruction of mental health and SEND services, as well as the NHS as a whole. This has clearly had a massive impact on the wellbeing of millions of people, some of them school kids. Absenteeism or absence due to persistent illness is one of the ways that this manifests.
**
Thirdly, people in almost every income bracket are feeling the effects of the COL crisis. Taking the kids out of school for many families is the difference between having holidays or not. It's not just about saving £100 nowadays. They simply can't afford to go away in the school holidays. It's beyond unreasonable and unrealistic to expect families to never experience family holidays together. School is important but it's not the only important thing. Life is important. Family time is important. Enrichment is important. Cultural experiences are important. Time away from the daily grind is important.
**
I think the whole school system (and public services in general) is unfit for purpose and needs urgent and radical reform. The curriculum is outdated. SEND children are not adequately supported and able to reach their potential. Resources are stretched beyond belief. The issue of families not being allowed the flexibility to take affordable holidays is really the least of it.
**
It's much easier for the Tories to punish and blame children and their parents than it is to actually analyse the numerous reasons why this situation is occuring and address the root causes, for which the blame lies squarely at their feet. Basically it's just more DARVO from the government. Kids deserve an education and the government is not fulfilling it's obligations to make education and healthcare accessible to all.

Spot on @Fargo79 👏

ilovebreadsauce · 01/03/2024 12:46

Dixiechickonhols · 29/02/2024 16:32

Private schools aren’t fined.
I personally think horse has bolted.

Their fine is paying fir weeks they aren't using

Laiste · 01/03/2024 12:44

Sadly it's true also that holiday companies would try to increase the average price across the year.

I'm wondering how that would work in principal though. No one's going to pay big(er) bucks for a week in Bognor in October. (no offence to Bognor)

I think it's fair to say that it's always going to be more expensive to go away during the school holls.

I think it's also fair to say that fining parents for absence isn't going to work. For all the reasons outlined so far.

It's lazy from the government and putting more pressure on the relationship between parents and schools.

New2024 · 01/03/2024 12:43

EnglishGirlApproximately · 01/03/2024 12:36

Any regulation that means holiday providers can't have seasonal pricing will have one of two results - prices rising year round so those without children are paying more, or holiday providers going bust.

The travel industry works on small margins and there's negligible profit in low season.
Hoteliers and overseas airlines will charge tour operators what they want as they can't be ruled by UK law, so the only option is to increase low season pricing or go out of business.

We just love business holding us all to ransom these days. Thatcher and all the attitudes she promoted have so much to answer for.

Holiday cottages in Cornwall in peak season command over £1000 a week. Liscence to print money

CharliesAngels81 · 01/03/2024 12:41

It's easy money for the local council though as families factor in the fine in holiday cost.

If they truely meant it they would put a fine that would get parents thinking.

But the increase will stop people taking them out for a day off for their birthday etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread