Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think raising school absenteeism fines won’t help much.

212 replies

Boomer55 · 29/02/2024 09:19

Fines for parents taking children out of school without permission will rise across England from September.
The minimum fine will increase from £60 to £80 per parent as part of a government drive to return attendance to pre-pandemic levels.
One school told BBC News one out of every three of its pupils absent without permission had been on a family holiday during term time.
A head teachers' union said fines were needed to avoid "chaos" in schools.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

Teenager sits up on bed looking at phone

School absence fines for parents to rise by £20 in England

Most of the fines in England are for unauthorised term-time holidays, the education secretary says.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

OP posts:
fleurneige · 02/03/2024 11:37

Vod · 02/03/2024 11:33

That's an unworkable proposal. The 'beauty' of the current system is that people don't have much incentive to challenge it, playing along is financially rewarded and it's not significant enough to do more than piss people off. It isn't much of a vote loser.

Whereas making the fines much more expensive also creates an environment where people have no incentive just to cough up for an easy life, and also means people are less likely to be able to pay up. Enforcement of fines is expensive and resource intensive, and our court systems are creaking as it is. It isn't something that a government could implement.

I know- because it has become culturally 'acceptable' and even by some 'expected' - unlike in the past of other cultures.

One effect however, after a short period of messy adjustment, could be that parents realise that it is just not on at all.

Talking to friends all over Europe about this issue, they are aghast that UK parents do this in droves as if quite normal.

Vod · 02/03/2024 11:33

fleurneige · 02/03/2024 10:45

Which is why I said multiply by 10 - so it would cost money rather than save!

That's an unworkable proposal. The 'beauty' of the current system is that people don't have much incentive to challenge it, playing along is financially rewarded and it's not significant enough to do more than piss people off. It isn't much of a vote loser.

Whereas making the fines much more expensive also creates an environment where people have no incentive just to cough up for an easy life, and also means people are less likely to be able to pay up. Enforcement of fines is expensive and resource intensive, and our court systems are creaking as it is. It isn't something that a government could implement.

fleurneige · 02/03/2024 10:45

Notthisone · 02/03/2024 10:13

No its not going to make any huge difference it does nothing to support those where absence is related to school avoidance and its not a significant enough increase to prevent term time holdays as still considerably cheaper than school holiday prices.
Last year it was £1800 cheaper for 4 adults and 2 children to go on holiday the week before half term rather than over half term. So still saving £1480 with the planned increases

Which is why I said multiply by 10 - so it would cost money rather than save!

Notthisone · 02/03/2024 10:13

No its not going to make any huge difference it does nothing to support those where absence is related to school avoidance and its not a significant enough increase to prevent term time holdays as still considerably cheaper than school holiday prices.
Last year it was £1800 cheaper for 4 adults and 2 children to go on holiday the week before half term rather than over half term. So still saving £1480 with the planned increases

Whycantiwinmillionsandsquillions · 02/03/2024 10:12

I suppose there are 2 issues here.
Some parents take children out of school to go on cheaper holidays. Increasing the fine will not deter them. If you are going to save money then those parents will still do it. What is wrong is when these parents expect the teacher to provide homework or do extra work so that their child can catch up. No they have missed it so tough shit.
Secondly those parents who are not forcing their child to go to school. This is a complex issues. Maybe there is a justified reason. Maybe the parents are out at work and not physically in to prevent their child just staying home. Or maybe they actively encourage their child not to go to school.
I’m always puzzled by this as technically, children don’t have to attend school they can be home schooled.
The real issue is how teachers and schooled staff are assessed.
Change that and I can guarantee that school will no longer give a whether your child is there or not.
It all comes down to targets. That is what it’s all about.

Vod · 02/03/2024 10:02

Walkden · 01/03/2024 19:32

During the pandemic much was made that everyday in school counts, missing out was ruining life chances etc.

Ironic most people on the thread are complaining that the government still applies this principle now that it is no longer convenient to them.

'Still' applies? I rather think the point is that it wasn't actually being applied!

But yes of course, interfering with the established social contract about school attendance during the pandemic has had an impact on attitudes. Surely that's not exactly a surprise, though? I know I wasn't the only one who saw it coming miles away!

New2024 · 02/03/2024 09:34

Bushmillsbabe · 01/03/2024 19:24

Yep, I think they are for sickness and essential medical/dental appointments.
Although our school will authorise 1 or 2 days for exceptional circumstances, like a funeral of a close family member. And there was a boy with leukaemia in my oldest year and they authorised a holiday to Disney for a week to make memories for all his siblings

I also can't recall children going out of school in termtime, apart from 1 and all my friends Mums talked about it for weeks, so it must have been a huge deal

I think that may be due to many fewer people going on holiday, I was one of only a few who had a summer holiday abroad every year from about 7 years old, most went to grandparents, camping, seaside for a few days and I was accused of being a 'posho' for going abroad in a caravan in late 80's.

It's interesting that other countries don't have same issue. I wonder if that's a cultural thing, or economic

I can recall a couple of exceptional circumstances over the years our DC at school. The first was when someone went to see a parent get an OBE or something like that. The second, a Yr13 invited to a conference as a speaker. The last of those might not even be deemed an absence, more like a solo school trip.

Walkden · 01/03/2024 19:32

During the pandemic much was made that everyday in school counts, missing out was ruining life chances etc.

Ironic most people on the thread are complaining that the government still applies this principle now that it is no longer convenient to them.

Bushmillsbabe · 01/03/2024 19:24

New2024 · 01/03/2024 19:15

This was how it was here when I was growing up. It’s actually still not something that’s supposed to happen. Authorised absences are not intended to used for holidays.

Yep, I think they are for sickness and essential medical/dental appointments.
Although our school will authorise 1 or 2 days for exceptional circumstances, like a funeral of a close family member. And there was a boy with leukaemia in my oldest year and they authorised a holiday to Disney for a week to make memories for all his siblings

I also can't recall children going out of school in termtime, apart from 1 and all my friends Mums talked about it for weeks, so it must have been a huge deal

I think that may be due to many fewer people going on holiday, I was one of only a few who had a summer holiday abroad every year from about 7 years old, most went to grandparents, camping, seaside for a few days and I was accused of being a 'posho' for going abroad in a caravan in late 80's.

It's interesting that other countries don't have same issue. I wonder if that's a cultural thing, or economic

New2024 · 01/03/2024 19:15

fleurneige · 01/03/2024 19:07

I lived in Germany and Holland for a few years, and have friends who teach in Italy, Switzerland and France. Taking kids on holiday in term-time is just unheard of and would be totally not accepted. Different priorities?

This was how it was here when I was growing up. It’s actually still not something that’s supposed to happen. Authorised absences are not intended to used for holidays.

fleurneige · 01/03/2024 19:07

I lived in Germany and Holland for a few years, and have friends who teach in Italy, Switzerland and France. Taking kids on holiday in term-time is just unheard of and would be totally not accepted. Different priorities?

New2024 · 01/03/2024 18:16

Dontcallmescarface · 01/03/2024 17:03

So your proposal is that the UK ring up the Greek (or wherever), tourist board and say what?

"Excuse me but would you mind awfully lowering your prices for UK visitors in your very busy Summer season? We don't mind what you charge other countries but if you could just do us that favour we'd be terribly grateful"

What do you suppose the answer would be? It would probably translate into 2 words..."fuck" and "off".

So that’s exactly what I neither said nor suggested. Obviously, what we here in Brexit Britain can do not anything else.

Theunamedcat · 01/03/2024 17:15

Why are they lumping sick children in with holidaymakers? My son has had three days off he has diarrhea ffs I cannot send him in Dr's won't want to see him either its obvious we arnt on holiday because my younger child is still going to school but ffs his attendance is poor due to ill health if it was holiday related I would pay a fine

Dragonsandcats · 01/03/2024 17:10

namechangedasashamd · 29/02/2024 12:04

Our school now do home visits for any absence right before or after half term/holidays

What’s the point of that? Surely you’d just say you had to work so you left your kid with their grandparents for childcare while they were ill.

Vod · 01/03/2024 17:09

Dontcallmescarface · 01/03/2024 17:03

So your proposal is that the UK ring up the Greek (or wherever), tourist board and say what?

"Excuse me but would you mind awfully lowering your prices for UK visitors in your very busy Summer season? We don't mind what you charge other countries but if you could just do us that favour we'd be terribly grateful"

What do you suppose the answer would be? It would probably translate into 2 words..."fuck" and "off".

Other countries applying their own laws instead of ours is right wing, it would seem.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/03/2024 17:06

Experts devise the best ways. I’m not one but…

Well, quite.

Dontcallmescarface · 01/03/2024 17:03

New2024 · 01/03/2024 15:54

There are many ways to do this and all industries benefit from regulation. Experts devise the best ways. I’m not one but I do know but recognise something needs doing and can be done. What that is, is not my specialism to debate.

This is discussion is painful to me because it’s really sad that some on this thread are more worried about those taking big profits having to be subject to scrutiny and regulation. Some here would rather be fleeced by businesses and break schooling regulations. If that’s not a right wing position that’s part of what got us into this colossal mess since 2010, what in bleep is it?

So your proposal is that the UK ring up the Greek (or wherever), tourist board and say what?

"Excuse me but would you mind awfully lowering your prices for UK visitors in your very busy Summer season? We don't mind what you charge other countries but if you could just do us that favour we'd be terribly grateful"

What do you suppose the answer would be? It would probably translate into 2 words..."fuck" and "off".

InvestigateWhether · 01/03/2024 16:10

New2024 · 01/03/2024 15:54

There are many ways to do this and all industries benefit from regulation. Experts devise the best ways. I’m not one but I do know but recognise something needs doing and can be done. What that is, is not my specialism to debate.

This is discussion is painful to me because it’s really sad that some on this thread are more worried about those taking big profits having to be subject to scrutiny and regulation. Some here would rather be fleeced by businesses and break schooling regulations. If that’s not a right wing position that’s part of what got us into this colossal mess since 2010, what in bleep is it?

All clever words and noble principles. And of course everybody would like cheaper holidays.

But how can the UK unilaterally tell airlines that they can’t charge x for flights or a hotel in Greece that it can’t charge y for a stay? I am no economist or business person but surely all that would happen if they did that is that tourism abroad would stop trying to attract UK tourists and seek a market elsewhere. How would you address this?

New2024 · 01/03/2024 15:54

InvestigateWhether · 01/03/2024 15:36

You can’t answer the simple question asked. You suggested regulation but can’t even make a vague suggestion of how it would work in practice. It’s been painful to read!

There are many ways to do this and all industries benefit from regulation. Experts devise the best ways. I’m not one but I do know but recognise something needs doing and can be done. What that is, is not my specialism to debate.

This is discussion is painful to me because it’s really sad that some on this thread are more worried about those taking big profits having to be subject to scrutiny and regulation. Some here would rather be fleeced by businesses and break schooling regulations. If that’s not a right wing position that’s part of what got us into this colossal mess since 2010, what in bleep is it?

InvestigateWhether · 01/03/2024 15:36

New2024 · 01/03/2024 13:49

There’s plenty things they could do, but I am not presuming to supply detail. It’s an area to be addressed by government.

The other point is not about morals. Rule breaking is never the way to deal with this. If you can’t link that to democracy, God help us.

Enough now, I must leave this place where we are happy to be shafted by business but not penalised for bunking off school

You can’t answer the simple question asked. You suggested regulation but can’t even make a vague suggestion of how it would work in practice. It’s been painful to read!

EnglishGirlApproximately · 01/03/2024 15:05

New2024 · 01/03/2024 12:43

We just love business holding us all to ransom these days. Thatcher and all the attitudes she promoted have so much to answer for.

Holiday cottages in Cornwall in peak season command over £1000 a week. Liscence to print money

Nobody is holding anyone to ransom, a holiday is a luxury and it's fine that's it's priced as such.

I'm not as familiar with the UK holiday market as I am overseas but assuming £1k per week in high season that's maybe 12-13 weeks a year to make enough profit to see a company through the many weeks of low or zero occupancy.

Bushmillsbabe · 01/03/2024 14:47

Laiste · 01/03/2024 14:26

There's a lot of unnecessary hyperbole in your post @Bushmillsbabe. The entitlement and the flying thousands of miles and the Costa del rubbish and the multiple holidays.

None of that applies to our family for eg.

I believe it's entirely possible for a school to use it's discretion to gauge weather a few days off days off once a year for a family holiday (which would otherwise be un-affordable) is a reasonable scenario. To take into account the child's attendance level and any other family factors such as SEN. Or when the piss is being taken. Or when a family needs support rather than arbitrary fines.

It's how it used to work.

Where is the fine money going anyway? It's not being ploughed back into the school i bet.

It may not apply to your family, but it does apply to some I know

I don't think schools are allowed to use their discretion, they are not legally allowed to authorise termtime holidays I was told
But I agree they should be able to - we did take our girls (both 100% attendance) out of school for a few days to attend a wedding abroad of a close family member, where wedding had been brought forward from the school holidays due to their father being terminally ill. My husband was an usher, my girls were flowergirls, we were going! All explained to school but still received a very snotty letter from 1 of the girls headteacher telling us off and threatening us with a fine. The other headteacher was much more pleasant but still couldn't authorise.
A headteacher friend says when she could authorise she had parents sending threats etc to her if she didn't so is glad she can't. But it is a shame that they can't use discretion in exceptional circumstances

And the fine amount probably barely covers admin costs of administering the fines, so yes the schools won't be seeing the money

Laiste · 01/03/2024 14:38

Vod · 01/03/2024 14:32

It's interesting how often snobbery about the Costas and the like comes up in discussions about term time holidays, particularly from people who clearly imagine themselves to be making some kind of moral point.

Agreed.

Samlewis96 · 01/03/2024 14:38

namechangedasashamd · 29/02/2024 12:04

Our school now do home visits for any absence right before or after half term/holidays

Well youare obligated to answer the door. Imagine if the whole fami,y aredown with notrovirus and someone from school rocks up. Just what you need

Vod · 01/03/2024 14:32

It's interesting how often snobbery about the Costas and the like comes up in discussions about term time holidays, particularly from people who clearly imagine themselves to be making some kind of moral point.