Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think raising school absenteeism fines won’t help much.

212 replies

Boomer55 · 29/02/2024 09:19

Fines for parents taking children out of school without permission will rise across England from September.
The minimum fine will increase from £60 to £80 per parent as part of a government drive to return attendance to pre-pandemic levels.
One school told BBC News one out of every three of its pupils absent without permission had been on a family holiday during term time.
A head teachers' union said fines were needed to avoid "chaos" in schools.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

Teenager sits up on bed looking at phone

School absence fines for parents to rise by £20 in England

Most of the fines in England are for unauthorised term-time holidays, the education secretary says.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68420275

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Vod · 03/03/2024 11:51

It does nothing to help the situation, it just piles financial pressure on families in lieu of finding out what the problem actually is and fixing it (I was bored)

Exactly. And this is why it's so important we don't pretend adding £20 to fines or whatever other harebrained, pointless ideas people come up with are going to do anything to address the problem. It's a distraction.

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 03/03/2024 11:38

I was a truant. My mum couldn't drive, had my siblings to look after, and lived rurally so I took the train/walked to school and could disappear at any point on that journey. My dad was out of the house working from 6am to 6-9pm every day. What were they supposed to do to make a 14 year old go to school (and stay there) exactly? How is would fining them have made any difference at all?

It does nothing to help the situation, it just piles financial pressure on families in lieu of finding out what the problem actually is and fixing it (I was bored)

Vod · 03/03/2024 11:19

LlynTegid · 03/03/2024 10:07

On the question of regulation of holiday companies, you could make it illegal to offer child discounts in term time. Where they use their own planes, if they won't comply, you could deny them landing slots at airports in the UK.

As for my suggestion about withdrawing passports for serial offenders, it should only ever be after a court appearance.

If you want a carrot not stick approach, first in the queue for university places for those who don't take children out for holidays might work.

None of those are workable or would achieve anything much.

The first suggestion will simply mean companies charging the same but adjusting it so they're no longer advertising it as a child discount, plus fewer package holidays and more separate booking of accommodation.

The second faces the same feasibility issues that any policy relying on courts does, when our court system is creaking and delays of years are commonplace now. Even if workable, it wouldn't prevent travel within the CTA for anyone or outside the UK for people with more than one citizenship.

For the third, where do you think the resources are going to come from to organise and enforce this, bearing in mind it's the student who applies to the university not the parents? You'd need a system that not only identifies two entirely different people but also manages to link fines that could be over a decade old, more for mature students. Good luck with that! And save some for the inevitable legal challenges from applicants.

LlynTegid · 03/03/2024 10:07

On the question of regulation of holiday companies, you could make it illegal to offer child discounts in term time. Where they use their own planes, if they won't comply, you could deny them landing slots at airports in the UK.

As for my suggestion about withdrawing passports for serial offenders, it should only ever be after a court appearance.

If you want a carrot not stick approach, first in the queue for university places for those who don't take children out for holidays might work.

emmylou24 · 03/03/2024 08:59

I'm taking both mine out in June and if I get fined then so be it. They are 10 and nearly 13 and both working at a Yr 1 level so no chance of catching up. Last June the talk of transitions started early and caused so many issues for my son that he was self harming, having panic attacks withe hyperventilating and has now developed an extreme stress disorder where he vomits several times and goes gray which is not great for s child with ketotic hypoglycaemia. So we are having a break to take a breath and start again and hopefully reduce some of the anxiety a little

Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2024 22:18

Vod · 02/03/2024 17:10

So basically, what we're talking about are the views of people who don't actually face this issue and indeed may benefit indirectly from it, because prices in June and early July might be higher if they also had to compete with more English families for holidays then. And one of the groups mentioned are off for almost the whole summer, so practically speaking would barely have chance to remove their DC during the season even if they wanted to. The state's done it for them.

Yeah, not sure they're qualified to speak on this one tbh.

Exactly!

People living in countries who have longer holidays and no fines, being aghast at how parents living under these situation react, isn’t particularly relevant here.

Vod · 02/03/2024 17:10

So basically, what we're talking about are the views of people who don't actually face this issue and indeed may benefit indirectly from it, because prices in June and early July might be higher if they also had to compete with more English families for holidays then. And one of the groups mentioned are off for almost the whole summer, so practically speaking would barely have chance to remove their DC during the season even if they wanted to. The state's done it for them.

Yeah, not sure they're qualified to speak on this one tbh.

fleurneige · 02/03/2024 14:23

Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2024 12:02

Talking to friends all over Europe about this issue, they are aghast that UK parents do this in droves as if quite normal.

How many weeks do they have off for the summer in these countries? If you have 8/10/12 weeks, then I expect you have a lot more leeway to go when you want. More choice to weeks/villas and less competition with people you work with over the same weeks.

6 to 8 weeks. France however staggers the holidays, by splitting the country into 3 regions, to avoid everyone being on hols at the same time.

If a school closes for 1 day, because of an emergency, or staff day- then all children are off, and the programme adjusted to make sure all catch up at the same time. Totally different.

Teachers often have to spend their breaks, lunchtimes or after school helping children who have been away to catch up and not fall behind, do badly in tests and not setted properly. They never mind when it is because of illness or accident, but they do resent it when it is about time off for a holiday.

Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2024 13:59

Google Baker days for the history so you can see that the 5 training days were removed from teacher holiday allowance in 1988. I’m presuming you don’t want them removed from the teacher holiday allowance again…

Skyblue92 · 02/03/2024 13:50

MyLastRoloIsMine · 02/03/2024 13:35

Inset days take place in term time at our local schools.
Last year, schools here were delayed returning to school after the six week holiday due to a teacher training day!
They'd had six bloody weeks to do it, but delayed the start of term instead.
Seems perfectly acceptable to do this, but not take your child out without a fine.
It may not happen in your area, but it certainly happens in mine.

So you’d be happy to tell your boss that you are fine for a mandatory training session to take place during your holiday?

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2024 13:48

Inset days take place in term time at our local schools.

Last year, schools here were delayed returning to school after the six week holiday due to a teacher training day!

They'd had six bloody weeks to do it, but delayed the start of term instead.

Seems perfectly acceptable to do this, but not take your child out without a fine.
It may not happen in your area, but it certainly happens in mine.

Ok let's try again.

Term time is 190 days.

Teacher contracts (and some support staff) are term time + 5 days = 195 days

The 5 days for training are outside term time. It doesn't matter where those 5 days are in the year, the pupils would not have been in school.

If a school has a training day at the start of the school year (which is common sense) then it doesn't matter whether there's a training day or not because your kids would not have been in school that day.

Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2024 13:41

MyLastRoloIsMine · 02/03/2024 13:35

Inset days take place in term time at our local schools.
Last year, schools here were delayed returning to school after the six week holiday due to a teacher training day!
They'd had six bloody weeks to do it, but delayed the start of term instead.
Seems perfectly acceptable to do this, but not take your child out without a fine.
It may not happen in your area, but it certainly happens in mine.

They'd had six bloody weeks to do it

You have misunderstood. The previous poster was pointing out that 5 Inset days were removed from teachers’ holidays, so pupils have never lost any teaching days.

They are obviously held throughout the year whenever the head decides they are best placed. So, yes, they are held in term times (as they couldn’t be held during the staff holidays which is what I presume you were referring to with the above comment) but no teaching time is lost. If all 5 were held during the ‘school holidays’, your children have a 7 week summer holiday and the teachers would have 6 weeks off and then a week training. This is generally not done and the days are peppered throughout the year instead.

Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2024 13:38

MyLastRoloIsMine · 02/03/2024 13:37

I never said it was the schools who implemented the fines.
They're bloody quick enough to dish them out though.

Edited

Schools do not issue fines.

MyLastRoloIsMine · 02/03/2024 13:37

I never said it was the schools who implemented the fines.
They're bloody quick enough to dish them out though.

MyLastRoloIsMine · 02/03/2024 13:35

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2024 13:20

What pisses me off about the fines is that when it suits the school to close on a school day, that's perfectly ok, but take your child out of school for a day and get a fine.
Schools rarely close on a school day unless there's an actual reason eg boiler breakage, gas leak, snow making the site or building unsafe, no heating.

Our local news page on social media is full of smart arse people thinking they're really clever talking about all the time school closes for training days, but school training days come out of the school holidays, not out of term time.

Inset days take place in term time at our local schools.
Last year, schools here were delayed returning to school after the six week holiday due to a teacher training day!
They'd had six bloody weeks to do it, but delayed the start of term instead.
Seems perfectly acceptable to do this, but not take your child out without a fine.
It may not happen in your area, but it certainly happens in mine.

Vod · 02/03/2024 13:32

Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2024 13:19

What pisses me off about the fines is that when it suits the school to close on a school day, that's perfectly ok, but take your child out of school for a day and get a fine.

What do you mean about suiting the school to close? Closing due to water leaks/RAAC/covid is pretty much out of the school’s hands.

It’s not the schools who introduced fines, either.

Yep, I totally understand being fucked off about double standards given the few years we've just had, but let's place the blame for that where it's deserved. Schools didn't cause this.

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2024 13:20

What pisses me off about the fines is that when it suits the school to close on a school day, that's perfectly ok, but take your child out of school for a day and get a fine.
Schools rarely close on a school day unless there's an actual reason eg boiler breakage, gas leak, snow making the site or building unsafe, no heating.

Our local news page on social media is full of smart arse people thinking they're really clever talking about all the time school closes for training days, but school training days come out of the school holidays, not out of term time.

Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2024 13:19

What pisses me off about the fines is that when it suits the school to close on a school day, that's perfectly ok, but take your child out of school for a day and get a fine.

What do you mean about suiting the school to close? Closing due to water leaks/RAAC/covid is pretty much out of the school’s hands.

It’s not the schools who introduced fines, either.

MyLastRoloIsMine · 02/03/2024 13:14

What pisses me off about the fines is that when it suits the school to close on a school day, that's perfectly ok, but take your child out of school for a day and get a fine.
A couple of years ago, my then 12 year old granddaughter missed four months of school, because her mum, my daughter, fled DV and moved almost 80 miles to live with me until she got sorted.
The schools here were full so she couldn't get a place.
We phoned her previous school and asked if they could send some school work over, or do it online. No, because she's not a pupil at the school anymore.
Yet this was acceptable to the LEA!
But god forbid you want to take them out for a few days. Have a nice holiday, here's your fine!!

JustDiscoveredBueno · 02/03/2024 12:27

It's daft. The whole attendance push kind of stinks anyway when they keep ignoring major reason for it - if they genuinely wanted to help attendance, they'd talk about illness occasionally and address ridiculous policies around it - teacher absence has also increased significantly and I don't think tons of them are taking time off for holidays.

MaryHoppins · 02/03/2024 12:25

I think it's good to increase the fine. I'd rather not go on holiday than remove my child from school.

Vod · 02/03/2024 12:09

Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2024 12:02

Talking to friends all over Europe about this issue, they are aghast that UK parents do this in droves as if quite normal.

How many weeks do they have off for the summer in these countries? If you have 8/10/12 weeks, then I expect you have a lot more leeway to go when you want. More choice to weeks/villas and less competition with people you work with over the same weeks.

In Italy, one of the examples given, it's three months!

Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2024 12:02

Talking to friends all over Europe about this issue, they are aghast that UK parents do this in droves as if quite normal.

How many weeks do they have off for the summer in these countries? If you have 8/10/12 weeks, then I expect you have a lot more leeway to go when you want. More choice to weeks/villas and less competition with people you work with over the same weeks.

Vod · 02/03/2024 11:48

fleurneige · 02/03/2024 11:37

I know- because it has become culturally 'acceptable' and even by some 'expected' - unlike in the past of other cultures.

One effect however, after a short period of messy adjustment, could be that parents realise that it is just not on at all.

Talking to friends all over Europe about this issue, they are aghast that UK parents do this in droves as if quite normal.

'Could' be. Doubt it, frankly. There's just no basis to think we'd see change at all.
After all, England has some of the shortest school holidays in Europe. Perhaps these aghast Italians and French we heard about upthread might think differently if they didn't have quite so much time off in summer to work with.

Fwiw, opposition to our school holiday fining system certainly isn't England specific. My relatives in ROI think it's backward as fuck.

fleurneige · 02/03/2024 11:37

in the past OR other cultures, sorry.